BAR · Business Analysis · 9 practice questions
Special Orders With Idle Capacity: Relevant Costs Only
Accept a special order using idle capacity when incremental revenue covers all incremental costs and regular sales are unaffected. Below, follow an accept-or-reject example that separates costs caused by the order from costs that stay unchanged.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on which costs will change if the order is accepted and whether spare capacity exists.
Answer B. Shelby has idle capacity (10,000 − 7,000 = 3,000 units available) and fixed manufacturing overhead is committed in the short term, so the relevant costs are incremental/variable. The special order price ($45) exceeds the variable cost ($30) by $15 per unit, producing a $15 × 2,000 = $30,000 positive contribution to operating income. Allocated fixed overhead per unit is not relevant to this short-term accept/reject decision.
Why not A: This distractor tempts because external costing allocates fixed overhead to unit cost, suggesting the full unit cost should matter. It fails because the $60,000 fixed overhead is committed and will not change if the order is accepted, so allocated fixed overhead is not an incremental/avoidable cost for the decision.
Why not C: This choice is tempting as full absorption cost is a familiar pricing benchmark and ensures long-run cost recovery. It is wrong here because insisting on covering allocated fixed overhead would reject profitable incremental business when capacity is idle and fixed costs are already committed; the correct short-term test is whether price exceeds variable/avoidable costs.
Why not D: This distractor tempts by invoking a simple comparison to the regular price, which seems intuitively persuasive. It fails because with spare capacity a lower-than-regular price can still increase operating income if it covers variable costs; the relevant measure is incremental contribution, not whether the price matches or exceeds the regular selling price.
Step by step
- Confirm truly idle capacity
Northline receives a one-time order for 5,000 units at $23 each and has enough idle capacity to fill it without affecting regular sales. Ignore qualitative factors.
- Identify variable manufacturing costs
Direct materials are $8, direct labor is $5, and variable manufacturing overhead is $2 per unit. These incremental manufacturing costs total $15 per unit.
- Add order-specific costs
The order requires labeling of $1 per unit and a one-time setup costing $10,000. Both costs occur only if Northline accepts the order.
- Remove costs that do not change
Exclude allocated fixed manufacturing overhead of $6 per unit because total fixed overhead will not change. Also exclude the regular $3 per-unit variable selling cost because this order will not incur it.
- Compare incremental totals
Revenue is 5,000 × $23 = $115,000. Incremental costs are 5,000 × ($15 + $1) + $10,000 = $90,000.
- Make the decision
Accept: operating income increases by $115,000 − $90,000 = $25,000. The decision turns on the change in profit, not full absorption cost.
- Check the minimum price
Setup adds $10,000 ÷ 5,000 = $2 per unit, making the minimum price $15 + $1 + $2 = $18. The $23 offer exceeds that minimum by $5, confirming a $25,000 gain across 5,000 units.
Key points
- Remember: Ask what changes if you accept the order, not what costs are allocated to each unit.
- A one-time setup cost matters even though it does not vary with each unit.
- A cost labeled variable is irrelevant if the special order will not incur it.
- At the minimum acceptable price, the order leaves operating income unchanged.
How the exam traps you
- Including allocated fixed overhead produces a $5,000 loss. Exclude the unchanged $6 per unit; the order actually adds $25,000.
- Subtracting only variable manufacturing costs produces a $40,000 increase. Also subtract $5,000 for labeling and $10,000 for setup.
- Including regular variable selling costs produces only a $10,000 increase. Exclude the $3 per unit because this order incurs no variable selling cost.
Question 2
| Cost Element | Per Unit | Total | Behavior |
|---|---|---|---|
| Direct materials | $5 | Variable | |
| Direct labor | $3 | Variable | |
| Allocated fixed manufacturing overhead | $2 | Fixed (will not change if order is accepted) | |
| Incremental packaging and shipping | $1 | Variable (incurred only for special order) | |
| Additional electricity for the order | $4,000 | Incremental | |
| Supervisor’s salary | $20,000/yr | Fixed (paid regardless unless line is closed) | |
| Depreciation on factory equipment | $12,000/yr | Fixed (straight-line; incurred regardless) |
Hint
Which costs increase when producing the extra 10,000 units? Exclude allocations, sunk costs, and any expenses that will continue unchanged whether the order is accepted or not.
Answer D. Only costs that will change because of the special order are relevant. Direct materials and direct labor vary with each unit; packaging and shipping are incurred only for this order; and the additional electricity ($4,000) is an incremental cost. Allocated fixed overhead, the supervisor's salary (paid regardless unless the line is closed), and depreciation are fixed or sunk for this decision and therefore not avoidable.
Why not A: This option is tempting because the supervisor's salary is an operating cash outlay, which can make it seem relevant. The stem, however, states the supervisor will be paid regardless unless the entire line is closed, so the salary is not avoidable for this single order and is not an incremental cost.
Why not B: This distractor tempts because allocated fixed overhead appears in per-unit product cost under absorption costing. It fails because the allocation is based on normal capacity and will not change when the one-time order is accepted, so it is not an incremental/avoidable cost.
Why not C: Candidates may be drawn to include depreciation and allocated overhead since both are product costs for reporting. However, depreciation here is a sunk/fixed expense and will be incurred regardless of the order; allocated overhead likewise does not change with the special order, so neither is relevant to the accept/reject decision.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on which costs and benefits change if the order is accepted. Then look for the extra condition that turns a positive contribution into a loss.
Answer D. The relevant unit cost is the variable manufacturing cost: $8 + $6 + $4 = $18 per unit. Contribution per unit = $20 - $18 = $2, so total contribution = $2 × 5,000 = $10,000. A one-time setup cost of $15,000 exceeds that contribution, so accepting the order would reduce short-term operating income and should be rejected.
Why not A: Being a first-time customer may be operationally notable but does not by itself affect short-term incremental profit. Unless the first order creates additional relevant costs or changes future demand, it doesn't justify rejecting a profitable special order.
Why not B: This distractor tempts candidates who compare the special-order price to the regular list price. Because the order is outside Lark's normal market and will not affect regular sales, the decision depends on incremental revenue versus incremental costs, not the usual selling price.
Why not C: Absorption cost includes fixed manufacturing overhead, which is already being incurred and is irrelevant to a one-time special-order decision with idle capacity unless the fixed cost would change. The correct decision uses incremental (relevant) costs, not full absorption cost.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on relevant costs only: which revenues and costs change if Ridge accepts the one-time order?
Answer D. Only incremental revenues and costs are relevant. Incremental revenue = 5,000 × $22 = $110,000. Incremental costs = 5,000 × $18 = $90,000 (variable manufacturing) + $6,000 setup = $96,000. Fixed manufacturing overhead does not change and the $4 variable selling cost is not incurred, so the order increases profit by $14,000.
Why not A: This distractor adds the usual variable selling cost without verifying applicability. The stem explicitly says the $4 variable selling cost would not be incurred on this special order, so it should not be included.
Why not B: This reflects full-cost thinking. Fixed manufacturing overhead is unavoidable here and does not change if the order is accepted, so it is not relevant to the decision.
Why not C: Managers may resist undercutting normal prices, but with idle capacity and a one-time order (no lost regular sales), the question is whether incremental profit increases, not whether the price equals the normal price.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on costs that change only if the special order is accepted, then compare that amount to the special-order price.
Answer B. With idle capacity and no effect on regular sales, only costs that change if the order is accepted are relevant. Per-unit relevant costs = $10 (DM) + $5 (DL) + $4 (variable MOH) = $19, plus the one-time setup cost of $4,000 spread over 2,000 units = $2 per unit, for a total relevant cost of $21 per unit. Since the special-order price of $23 exceeds $21, Pine should accept the order; operating income increases by $2 × 2,000 = $4,000.
Why not A: This distractor is tempting because variable costs are the usual starting point, but it ignores the one-time $4,000 setup cost which is relevant. Although the decision remains to accept, the reasoning is incomplete, so it's not the best-supported conclusion.
Why not C: This appeals to absorption-cost thinking by including allocated fixed manufacturing overhead, but that $6 per unit is not relevant here because fixed overhead will not change with the order. Using full cost overstates the incremental cost and leads to the wrong decision.
Why not D: This is a common business shortcut but is not the correct managerial-accounting rule in this fact pattern. When capacity is available and regular sales are unaffected, the normal selling price is not controlling; the special-order price only needs to cover relevant incremental costs.
Question 6
Hint
Compare incremental revenue to incremental costs only: include variable costs (with the overtime premium for units above unused capacity) and the one-time setup; exclude fixed manufacturing overhead that will not change.
Answer B. Incremental revenue = 2,500 × $30 = $75,000. Incremental costs = (2,000 × $25) + (500 × ($25 + $4 overtime)) + $4,000 setup = $50,000 + $14,500 + $4,000 = $68,500. Net incremental income = $75,000 − $68,500 = $6,500. The $24,000 fixed manufacturing overhead is not avoidable this month and therefore is not relevant to the special-order decision.
Why not A: Tempting because some candidates allocate fixed MOH (implicit $24,000 ÷ 6,000 = $4 per unit) and treat that allocation as incremental (2,500 × $4 = $10,000), then add the $4,000 setup, producing a small loss. Wrong because the fixed MOH is not avoidable and therefore not an incremental cost for this one-time order.
Why not C: Tempting because a simple contribution-margin check (30 − 25 = $5 × 2,500) yields $12,500. Wrong because this ignores the one-time setup cost and the $4 overtime premium for the 500 units beyond idle capacity, both of which reduce the incremental gain.
Why not D: Tempting because including an allocated fixed overhead charge (e.g., 2,500 × $4 = $10,000) but omitting the setup and/or overtime costs can produce this smaller gain. Wrong because allocated fixed overhead is not incremental; the correct incremental analysis includes only additional variable costs, the overtime premium for units above unused capacity, and the one-time setup cost.
Question 7
Hint
Start with incremental cash costs of the order, then ask two separate questions: how many units fit in idle capacity, and does the order size cross any step-cost threshold?
Answer A. Apex has 10,000 units of idle capacity, so 10,000 of the 20,000 special-order units will displace regular sales. Incremental explicit costs = variable manufacturing (20,000 × $28 = $560,000) + tooling $60,000 + supervisor step cost $36,000 = $656,000. Opportunity cost = lost contribution on 10,000 displaced units = 10,000 × ($50 − $28 − $4) = $180,000. Required revenue = $656,000 + $180,000 = $836,000.
Why not B: This includes variable manufacturing cost, tooling, and the lost contribution margin on displaced units but omits the $36,000 step cost that is triggered because the order exceeds 15,000 units.
Why not C: This result reflects incorrectly adding the $4 selling commission on all 20,000 special-order units (20,000 × $4 = $80,000). The stem states there is no selling commission on the special order, so that amount should not be added to the special-order cost.
Why not D: This number arises if someone adds allocated fixed manufacturing overhead (e.g., $9 × 20,000 = $180,000). Allocated fixed overhead that will be incurred regardless of the order is not a relevant incremental cost; only the $36,000 step cost is relevant.
Question 8
Hint
Focus only on costs that will change if the special order is accepted.
Answer D. Use only the incremental costs for the decision. Relevant costs are direct materials ($9) + direct labor ($5) + variable manufacturing overhead ($4) + special handling ($2) = $20 per unit. Fixed manufacturing overhead is allocated and will not change, and the variable selling expense is avoided, so both are irrelevant.
Why not A: This equals the normal variable production costs (9 + 5 + 4 = 18) but omits the $2 per-unit special handling required for the special order, so it understates the minimum acceptable price.
Why not B: This includes the allocated fixed manufacturing overhead ($6). Allocated fixed overhead does not change for the special order and is therefore irrelevant to the minimum acceptable price.
Why not C: This adds the $3 variable selling expense to the relevant variable costs plus special handling. The problem states the special order requires no selling effort, so the normal variable selling expense is avoided and should not be included.
Question 9
Hint
Focus on which revenues and costs change only because of the special order. Ignore amounts that are allocated but unchanged.
Answer C. Revenue = 1,000 × $18 = $18,000. Relevant incremental costs are variable manufacturing (1,000 × $11 = $11,000) and special packaging (1,000 × $1 = $1,000), totaling $12,000. Fixed overhead and regular variable selling costs are not incremental for this order, so operating income increases by $18,000 − $12,000 = $6,000.
Why not A: This is a trap for candidates who treat the allocated fixed manufacturing overhead ($4 × 1,000 = $4,000) as an incremental cost and subtract it from the true contribution. Because fixed overhead does not change with the order, it is irrelevant, so this answer understates the increase.
Why not B: This arises if a candidate deducts the normal variable selling cost of $2 per unit for the special order. The stem explicitly states the special order would not require any variable selling costs, so that $2 per unit should not be included.
Why not D: Choosing no change reflects ignoring the contribution from the special order or incorrectly netting in all allocated overhead. Since Hale has unused capacity and the order yields positive contribution after relevant costs, operating income increases.
Common questions
Are allocated fixed overhead costs relevant to a special order?
Not when total fixed overhead stays unchanged. Northline excludes its $6 per-unit allocation because accepting the order does not change that cost.
How do you calculate the minimum special-order price?
Divide all incremental costs by the order quantity. Northline's minimum is $18 per unit: $15 manufacturing, $1 labeling, and $2 setup.
Do variable selling costs belong in special-order analysis?
Include them only if the order causes them. Northline excludes its regular $3 per-unit selling cost because the special order will not incur it.
Watch it solved
A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Managerial and cost accounting, worked step by step.
Activity-Based Costing & Standard Cost Variances | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Managerial and cost accounting
- Special-Order Minimum Price With a Machine-Hour Bottleneck
- Make or Buy: Avoidable Fixed Costs and Freed Capacity
- Absorption vs Variable Costing: Operating Income Difference
- ABC vs. ABM: Cost Pools, Drivers, and Management Decisions
- Process Costing Equivalent Units: Weighted-Average vs FIFO
- Direct Materials Price Variance: Net Favorable and Unfavorable
- Direct Labor Rate Variance: Formula and Calculation
- CVP Break-Even Units and Sales Dollars: Contribution Margin
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.