BAR · Business Analysis · 10 practice questions
Absorption vs Variable Costing: Operating Income Difference
Absorption costing holds fixed manufacturing overhead in inventory until sale; variable costing expenses it when incurred. Below: one scenario with changed sales facts shows how inventory changes flip the operating income difference.
Try one first
Hint
Compute fixed overhead per unit (fixed overhead ÷ units produced) and then decide whether each method assigns fixed overhead to product (deferred in inventory) or treats it as a period expense.
Answer A. Absorption costing allocates fixed manufacturing overhead to units produced ($100 per unit), so the overhead attached to sold units (700 × $100 = $70,000) becomes COGS and the remainder ($30,000) remains in ending inventory. Variable costing treats fixed manufacturing overhead as a period cost, so the full $100,000 is expensed in Year 1.
Why not B: Tempting because it reverses the common labels (thinking absorption means immediate expensing), but it's wrong: absorption allocates fixed overhead to units produced (deferring the portion in ending inventory), whereas variable costing treats fixed overhead as a period expense and would expense the entire $100,000.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the mistaken belief that absorption defers all fixed overhead until sale. It's wrong because absorption only defers the portion allocated to unsold units; the portion allocated to sold units (700 × $100 = $70,000) is recognized as COGS in Year 1.
Why not D: Tempting because it assumes both methods treat fixed overhead the same, but it's incorrect: variable costing expenses fixed manufacturing overhead as a period cost (the full $100,000), so it would not defer $30,000 to inventory.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Wright begins Year 2 with 300 units carrying $20 variable manufacturing cost and $100 fixed manufacturing overhead per unit. It produces 1,000 units at normal capacity, incurs $100,000 fixed manufacturing overhead and $20 variable manufacturing cost per unit, and sells 900 units. Selling and administrative expense is $10,000. All other costs receive identical treatment under both methods.
Answer: Absorption-costing operating income is $10,000 higher than variable-costing operating income.
Current fixed overhead is $100,000 ÷ 1,000 = $100 per unit. Ending inventory is 300 + 1,000 − 900 = 400 units. Its $40,000 fixed overhead exceeds beginning inventory's $30,000 by $10,000. Selling and administrative expense does not affect the difference.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Units sold decrease from 900 to 700.
Answer: Absorption-costing operating income is $30,000 higher.
Ending inventory is 600 units carrying $60,000 fixed overhead. Subtract beginning inventory's $30,000: absorption income is $30,000 higher.
Change 2Units sold increase from 900 to 1,000.
Answer: Operating income is the same under both methods.
Ending inventory remains 300 units. Beginning and ending inventory each carry $30,000 fixed overhead, so the income difference is zero.
Change 3Units sold increase from 900 to 1,300.
Answer: Absorption-costing operating income is $30,000 lower.
Ending inventory is zero. Absorption expenses current fixed overhead plus the $30,000 previously deferred in beginning inventory; variable costing expenses only current fixed overhead.
Key points
- Remember: absorption income minus variable income equals ending inventory's fixed overhead minus beginning inventory's fixed overhead.
- Assign fixed manufacturing overhead using units produced, not units sold.
- Beginning inventory carries the fixed overhead rate assigned when those units were produced.
- Selling and administrative expense stays outside inventory under both methods.
How the exam traps you
- With 700 sold, dividing $100,000 by 700 and multiplying by 300 gives about $42,857. Divide by 1,000 produced: $100 per unit. The income difference is 300 × $100 = $30,000.
- Adding the entire $100,000 of fixed manufacturing overhead to variable-costing income. Compare fixed overhead in ending and beginning inventory. Only the net deferral changes the income difference.
- With 700 sold, adding $10,000 selling and administrative expense yields $110 per unit and a false $33,000 difference. Selling and administrative expense is a period cost under both methods. The correct difference is 300 × $100 = $30,000.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer A. Correct. Ending inventory carries $40,000 fixed overhead versus $30,000 in beginning inventory.
Why not B: Incorrect. $30,000 is beginning inventory's fixed overhead, not the net increase.
Why not C: Incorrect. Inventory increases, so absorption income is higher, not lower.
Why not D: Incorrect. Only the net overhead deferred in inventory creates the difference.
Question 2
Answer A. Correct. Inventory increases by 300 units carrying $100 fixed overhead each.
Why not B: Incorrect. This uses units sold instead of units produced to calculate the overhead rate.
Why not C: Incorrect. This improperly includes selling and administrative expense in the manufacturing overhead rate.
Why not D: Incorrect. Increased inventory defers expense, making absorption income higher.
Question 3
Answer C. Correct. Beginning and ending inventory carry equal fixed overhead.
Why not A: Incorrect. Ending inventory's $30,000 fixed overhead is offset by the same beginning balance.
Why not B: Incorrect. Current fixed overhead is ultimately expensed under both methods here.
Why not D: Incorrect. There is no net release of fixed overhead from inventory.
Question 4
Answer C. Correct. Absorption expenses the $30,000 beginning overhead balance in addition to current overhead.
Why not A: Incorrect. Zero ending inventory does not erase the release of beginning inventory's fixed overhead.
Why not B: Incorrect. Releasing deferred overhead lowers absorption income rather than raising it.
Why not D: Incorrect. Both methods expense current fixed overhead; only beginning inventory's $30,000 creates the difference.
Question 2
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Fixed manufacturing overhead incurred | $300,000 |
| Units produced | 30,000 |
| Units sold | 25,000 |
| Beginning inventory (units) | 0 |
Hint
Compare units produced versus units sold and think about where fixed manufacturing overhead is recognized under absorption versus variable costing (is it expensed immediately or deferred in inventory?).
Answer D. The $50,000 difference equals 5,000 unsold units × ($300,000 ÷ 30,000 units) = $50,000 of fixed manufacturing overhead deferred in ending inventory under absorption costing. Absorption costing capitalizes fixed manufacturing overhead into inventory, so when production exceeds sales some fixed overhead is included in inventory rather than expensed, increasing reported net income for the period. The primary issue is the overproduction incentive/deferral effect created by absorption costing that can artificially inflate current-period income.
Why not A: This option is incorrect and overly prescriptive. Generally accepted accounting principles require absorption (product) costing for inventory valuation on external financial statements. Variable costing is useful for internal decision-making but is not permitted for external inventory valuation, so switching external reports to variable costing is not an appropriate remedy.
Why not B: This is tempting because product-vs-period cost confusion is common, but selling and administrative costs are period costs and are expensed as incurred. The stem's numbers point to fixed manufacturing overhead being deferred in inventory (production > sales), not misclassified S&A costs.
Why not C: Underapplied/overapplied overhead refers to the difference between actual overhead incurred and overhead applied using the predetermined rate. The scenario describes a timing/production-versus-sales effect that defers fixed MOH into inventory, not evidence that the application rate was set incorrectly.
Question 3
Hint
Classify the cost based on where it is incurred first: manufacturing versus selling/admin. Then decide whether it is direct or indirect.
Answer A. Under absorption costing, all manufacturing costs are inventoriable product costs, whether direct or indirect and whether fixed or variable. A factory production supervisor's salary supports the manufacturing process and therefore is recorded as manufacturing overhead, included in inventory, and expensed as cost of goods sold when the related goods are sold.
Why not B: This confuses cost behavior with product-vs-period classification. Being fixed does not make a cost a period cost. Because the salary is incurred in the factory to support production, it is a manufacturing (product) cost under absorption costing.
Why not C: Direct labor must be directly traceable to specific units produced. A production supervisor oversees operations but cannot be traced to individual units, so the salary is indirect manufacturing labor included in overhead, not direct labor.
Why not D: Lack of traceability makes the cost indirect, not nonmanufacturing. Because the salary relates only to factory operations, it is manufacturing overhead rather than a selling or administrative expense.
Question 4
Hint
Start by recalling what makes up product cost under absorption costing, then compare that with the components of conversion cost.
Answer C. Factory rent is a manufacturing overhead cost. Under absorption costing product costs include direct materials, direct labor, and manufacturing overhead; conversion costs are direct labor plus manufacturing overhead. Therefore, factory rent (manufacturing overhead) is both a product cost and a conversion cost.
Why not A: Direct materials are a product cost under absorption costing but are not part of conversion costs, which consist only of direct labor and manufacturing overhead. Thus direct materials are product costs but not conversion costs.
Why not B: Sales commissions are selling expenses and therefore period costs, not product costs; they are not included in conversion costs either. They relate to selling activity, not manufacturing.
Why not D: The corporate controller's salary is an administrative (period) expense, not a manufacturing overhead tied to production. Administrative salaries are not product costs and are not part of conversion costs.
Question 5
Hint
Ask whether each cost is incurred to convert materials and get the goods to their current location and condition (product cost) or whether it arises after production or from an unusual event (period cost).
Answer D. Inventoriable product costs under U.S. GAAP (absorption costing) are direct materials, direct labor, and manufacturing overhead incurred to bring inventory to its present location and condition. Items 1 (factory machinery depreciation), 2 (production supervisor salary), and 3 (freight-in on purchased raw materials) are manufacturing costs capitalized into inventory. Items 4 (post-production storage), 5 (post-sale warranty obligations), and 6 (abnormal spoilage) are period costs and are expensed when incurred.
Why not A: This is tempting because depreciation and the supervisor's salary are manufacturing overhead and spoilage occurs during production. However, abnormal (unexpected or excess) spoilage is treated as a period loss and is not capitalized; only normal, expected spoilage is allocated to product cost.
Why not B: This choice mixes two product costs with an item that is clearly a post-sale obligation. Estimated warranty costs are recognized as an expense and liability in the period of sale and are not capitalized into inventory.
Why not C: Tempting because depreciation and freight-in are product costs. Yet costs to store finished goods after production are post-production carrying or selling/distribution costs and are expensed as period costs, not included in inventory.
Question 6
Hint
First find full manufacturing cost per unit, then apply the stated percentage to that complete cost base.
Answer D. Full manufacturing cost per unit is $24.00, made up of $16.00 variable cost plus $8.00 fixed overhead allocated over 10,000 units. A cost-based transfer price of 120% means multiplying full cost by 1.20, which gives $28.80 per unit.
Why not A: This results from adding fixed overhead to cost but applying the 20% markup only to variable cost. It fails because the markup applies to full manufacturing cost under the policy.
Why not B: This comes from applying the 120% rate to variable cost alone. That fails because the stated policy uses full manufacturing cost, which includes allocated fixed manufacturing overhead.
Why not C: This is the full manufacturing cost per unit before any markup. It fails because the policy sets the transfer price at 120% of cost, not at cost itself.
Common questions
Why is absorption-costing income higher when production exceeds sales?
Some current fixed manufacturing overhead remains in inventory instead of becoming expense. With 700 units sold, Wright adds 300 inventory units carrying $100 each, so absorption income is $30,000 higher.
When do absorption and variable costing report the same operating income?
They report the same income when fixed manufacturing overhead in ending inventory equals that in beginning inventory. For Wright, selling 1,000 units leaves the same 300 units and $30,000 of fixed overhead in inventory.
Why is absorption income lower when sales exceed production?
Absorption costing releases previously deferred fixed overhead from beginning inventory into expense. Selling all 1,300 available units releases Wright's $30,000 beginning balance, making absorption income $30,000 lower.
Watch it solved
A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Managerial and cost accounting, worked step by step.
Activity-Based Costing & Standard Cost Variances | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Managerial and cost accounting
- Special Orders With Idle Capacity: Relevant Costs Only
- Special-Order Minimum Price With a Machine-Hour Bottleneck
- Make or Buy: Avoidable Fixed Costs and Freed Capacity
- ABC vs. ABM: Cost Pools, Drivers, and Management Decisions
- Process Costing Equivalent Units: Weighted-Average vs FIFO
- Direct Materials Price Variance: Net Favorable and Unfavorable
- Direct Labor Rate Variance: Formula and Calculation
- CVP Break-Even Units and Sales Dollars: Contribution Margin
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.