BAR · Business Analysis · 13 practice questions
Make or Buy: Avoidable Fixed Costs and Freed Capacity
Compare avoidable manufacturing costs with the purchase price minus the benefit from freed capacity. Below: one scenario and one-fact changes that show when making, buying, or financial indifference is the answer.
Try one first
Hint
Separate avoidable costs from unavoidable costs before comparing the make and buy alternatives.
Answer D. Only costs that differ between alternatives are relevant. Relevant make cost = DM $8 + DL $5 + variable overhead $5 + avoidable fixed overhead $2 = $20 per unit; the $4 of unavoidable fixed overhead is irrelevant. Because $20 < $21, Marlow should continue making Part X.
Why not A: This overgeneralizes that fixed overhead is never relevant. Avoidable fixed overhead is relevant because it changes between alternatives. Also, even if all fixed overhead were ignored, making would cost $18 versus buying at $21, so the options would not be equal.
Why not B: This is tempting because it compares the supplier price to the full absorption cost ($24). However, $4 of that fixed overhead is unavoidable and will be incurred whether Marlow makes or buys, so it should be excluded from the decision.
Why not C: This distractor reflects ignoring all fixed overhead. The problem states $2 per unit of fixed overhead would be avoided if production stops, so that avoidable fixed cost must be included. The relevant make cost is $20, not $18.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Marlow Co. needs 10,000 units of Part X annually. Unit manufacturing costs are materials $8, labor $5, variable overhead $5, and allocated fixed overhead $6. Outsourcing avoids $2 of fixed overhead per unit; $4 continues. A supplier offers identical quality and delivery for $21 per unit. No other costs change. Freed capacity can generate $10,000 of annual incremental contribution.
Answer: Be financially indifferent: relevant make cost and net buy cost are both $200,000 annually.
Make: 10,000 × ($8 + $5 + $5 + $2) = $200,000. Buy: 10,000 × $21 − $10,000 = $200,000. The capacity benefit exactly offsets the supplier's premium.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Freed capacity has no alternative use instead of generating $10,000 annually.
Answer: Continue making Part X; making saves $10,000 annually.
Make remains $200,000. Buying costs $210,000 with no capacity benefit, so making is cheaper.
Change 2Freed capacity generates $30,000 of annual incremental contribution instead of $10,000.
Answer: Buy Part X and use the freed capacity; buying saves $20,000 annually.
Net buy cost becomes $210,000 − $30,000 = $180,000, below the unchanged $200,000 relevant make cost.
Change 3The supplier charges $20 per unit instead of $21.
Answer: Buy Part X and use the freed capacity; buying saves $10,000 annually.
Net buy cost becomes $200,000 − $10,000 = $190,000. The capacity benefit favors buying even when the supplier price equals avoidable make cost.
Key points
- Remember: Freed capacity can make buying worthwhile even when the supplier charges more than the avoidable manufacturing cost.
- Divide annual capacity benefits by the component's annual volume before comparing per-unit amounts.
- Fixed overhead matters only to the extent that outsourcing eliminates it.
- Equal relevant costs mean financial indifference, not equal full manufacturing and purchase costs.
How the exam traps you
- Compare the supplier's price with the full $24 manufacturing cost. Exclude the $4 of fixed overhead that continues; relevant make cost is $20.
- Ignore all fixed overhead and use an $18 make cost. Include the $2 of fixed overhead that outsourcing would eliminate.
- Compare $20 to $21 and stop. Subtract the freed-capacity contribution from buying before choosing.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer D. Right. Make costs $200,000; buying nets $210,000 minus $10,000, also $200,000.
Why not A: Wrong. Avoidable fixed overhead is relevant, and neither relevant alternative costs $180,000.
Why not B: Wrong. Full cost includes $4 per unit of unavoidable fixed overhead.
Why not C: Wrong. The $18 amount omits $2 of avoidable fixed overhead and ignores the capacity benefit.
Question 2
Answer B. Right. Relevant make cost is $200,000 versus $210,000 to buy.
Why not A: Wrong. This compares the $240,000 full manufacturing cost with the $210,000 purchase cost.
Why not C: Wrong. This omits the $20,000 of avoidable fixed overhead from making.
Why not D: Wrong. Without a capacity benefit, net buy cost is $210,000.
Question 3
Answer D. Right. Net buy cost is $180,000 versus $200,000 to make.
Why not A: Wrong. This ignores the $30,000 contribution available only if Marlow buys.
Why not B: Wrong. This treats all allocated fixed overhead as avoidable.
Why not C: Wrong. The $180,000 make cost omits avoidable fixed overhead.
Question 4
Answer A. Right. Net buy cost is $190,000 versus $200,000 to make.
Why not B: Wrong. This ignores the $10,000 contribution from freed capacity.
Why not C: Wrong. This omits avoidable fixed overhead, understating make cost by $20,000.
Why not D: Wrong. This includes $40,000 of unavoidable fixed overhead in the claimed savings.
Question 2
| Product A | Product B | Product C | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales | $400,000 | $300,000 | $200,000 |
| Variable costs | $250,000 | $210,000 | $120,000 |
| Traceable fixed costs | $100,000 | $100,000 | $50,000 |
Hint
Calculate contribution margin for each line (sales − variable costs) and then subtract traceable fixed costs to get segment margin; only avoidable (traceable) fixed costs matter for a discontinuation decision.
Answer B. Calculate each line's contribution margin (sales − variable costs) and then subtract traceable fixed costs to get the segment margin. Product B's contribution margin is $90,000 (300,000 − 210,000) and its traceable fixed costs are $100,000, so its segment margin is −$10,000. Eliminating B removes that $100,000 of avoidable fixed costs but also loses $90,000 of contribution, a net $10,000 increase in overall operating income (common fixed costs are unchanged).
Why not A: Although A has large sales, its contribution margin is $150,000 (400,000 − 250,000) and traceable fixed costs are $100,000, leaving a positive segment margin of $50,000; discontinuing A would reduce overall operating income by $50,000.
Why not C: C's contribution margin is $80,000 (200,000 − 120,000) and traceable fixed costs are $50,000, giving a positive segment margin of $30,000; discontinuing C would therefore decrease overall operating income by $30,000.
Why not D: This is tempting because common fixed costs are large and unavoidable, but discontinuing a line with a negative segment margin can still improve income; product B has a −$10,000 segment margin, so eliminating it increases operating income by $10,000.
Question 3
Hint
Compare the contribution margin that would be lost with only the fixed costs that would actually be eliminated; ignore common overhead that will remain.
Answer C. Beta's contribution margin = (80 - 55) × 2,500 = $62,500. Only $30,000 of Beta's assigned fixed overhead is avoidable; the remaining $25,000 is common and would remain. Discontinuing Beta would eliminate $62,500 of contribution while saving only $30,000 of fixed costs, producing a net $32,500 decrease in operating income. Therefore Meridian should continue producing Beta.
Why not A: Tempting because it focuses on the $30,000 of traceable fixed costs that would be eliminated. It's wrong because it ignores the $62,500 contribution margin that would be lost, lost contribution exceeds the avoidable fixed costs, so income falls rather than rises.
Why not B: Tempting because it treats all $55,000 of fixed overhead assigned to Beta as avoidable. It's wrong because $25,000 of that is common overhead that would remain after discontinuation; only the $30,000 traceable portion is saved, so the correct net decrease is $32,500, not $7,500.
Why not D: Tempting because candidates sometimes treat allocated fixed costs as sunk and irrelevant. It's wrong here because $30,000 of the assigned overhead is traceable and avoidable, discontinuing Beta does change avoidable costs and eliminates Beta's contribution margin, so the decision has a measurable effect.
Question 4
Hint
Do not classify costs by whether they are manufacturing or traceable. Classify them by whether the cash flow changes if the company switches alternatives, and remember to consider opportunity effects.
Answer A. Relevant costs are future amounts that differ between alternatives, including opportunity costs. Direct materials, direct labor, and the cancelable maintenance contract would be avoided if Nolan buys the component, so they are relevant; the sublease income available only if Nolan buys K is an opportunity benefit and therefore relevant. The supervisor's salary continues (the employee is reassigned at the same salary), the machine's depreciation will continue with no resale value, and allocated plant insurance continues regardless, so these do not differ between alternatives and are not relevant.
Why not B: This is tempting because the supervisor salary and depreciation are clearly associated with K, but both continue even if Nolan buys the part and therefore do not differ between alternatives. It also incorrectly excludes the sublease income, an opportunity effect that should be included in the analysis.
Why not C: This choice appeals to candidates who default to labeling manufacturing costs as relevant. Depreciation and allocated insurance continue regardless and thus are not incremental; it also wrongly ignores the sublease income that becomes available only if K is purchased.
Why not D: This distractor rests on the incorrect shortcut that traceable or manufacturing-labeled costs must be relevant and that nonmanufacturing items can be ignored. Relevant-cost analysis depends on whether amounts change between alternatives; opportunity costs such as potential sublease income are relevant even if not a manufacturing cost, while unavoidable costs that continue are not.
Question 5
Hint
Separate the analysis into two volume ranges: up to idle capacity and above idle capacity. Compare relevant costs in each range rather than using one per-unit savings amount for all units.
Answer C. This is a two-range relevant-cost problem. For the first 20,000 units, making saves $4 per unit versus buying ($19 − $15), which recovers $80,000 of the $100,000 avoidable fixed cost. For units above 20,000, each added unit carries a $3 opportunity cost, so net saving falls to $1 per unit and Hart needs 20,000 more units to recover the remaining $20,000. Therefore the switch point is 40,000 units.
Why not A: This confuses the capacity threshold with the break-even switch point. At 20,000 units Hart has recovered only $80,000 of the $100,000 avoidable fixed cost, so making is not yet as cost-effective as buying.
Why not B: This results from dividing the $100,000 avoidable fixed cost by the initial $4 per-unit savings and assuming that $4 saving applies to all units. That ignores the opportunity cost above 20,000 units, where the incremental saving falls to $1 per unit.
Why not D: This comes from incorrectly applying the post-20,000-unit $1 savings rate to every unit. The first 20,000 units save $4 each (no opportunity cost), so a much smaller total volume is required to recover the fixed cost.
Question 6
Hint
Compare the incremental (avoidable) costs and incremental benefits: include lost contribution margin and any opportunity gains, but exclude common/unavoidable fixed allocations.
Answer B. Product P's contribution margin is 10,000 × ($20 − $12) = $80,000 lost if discontinued. Avoidable fixed cost (advertising) saved = $30,000. Additional contribution from product Q = $20,000. Net change = −80,000 + 30,000 + 20,000 = −30,000, so discontinuing P reduces overall operating income by $30,000 and P should be retained.
Why not A: This is incorrect because it implies the lost contribution margin is exactly offset by avoided costs. It errs by treating the $50,000 corporate overhead allocation as avoidable; that $50,000 is common and unavoidable and is not relevant to the discontinuation decision.
Why not C: This lure reflects focusing only on the $20,000 benefit from product Q and ignoring the lost contribution margin of $80,000 and the avoidable advertising cost. When all incremental effects are included, the net is a $30,000 decrease, not an increase.
Why not D: This option reflects computing −$80,000 (lost contribution) + $30,000 (avoided advertising) = −$50,000 but ignores the $20,000 contribution from product Q. Including that $20,000 reduces the net loss to $30,000.
Question 7
Hint
Identify which costs would actually be eliminated if production stops (variable costs and only the avoidable fixed overhead), then compare that total avoidable cost to the total cost of buying the part. Focus on net change, not just one side of the comparison.
Answer A. If production stops, avoidable costs are variable costs (7 × 10,000 = $70,000) plus avoidable fixed overhead of $80,000, totaling $150,000. Buying the parts costs 9 × 10,000 = $90,000 and $40,000 of fixed overhead would remain, so net savings = $150,000 − $90,000 = $60,000.
Why not B: $150,000 equals the sum of avoidable costs (variable costs + avoidable fixed overhead) and is tempting, but it ignores that the company must pay the supplier $90,000; the net effect requires subtracting the purchase cost.
Why not C: $20,000 comes from (9 − 7) × 10,000, the per-unit variable cost difference, which is a common quick check. It is wrong because it ignores the avoidable fixed overhead of $80,000 that also affects net savings.
Why not D: $120,000 is the total allocated fixed manufacturing overhead and is tempting if a student assumes all fixed overhead would be eliminated. It is wrong because only $80,000 of that fixed overhead is avoidable; $40,000 would continue if production stopped.
Question 8
Hint
Focus on avoidable (traceable) costs and incremental contribution from alternative uses of capacity; ignore allocated corporate common fixed costs when evaluating whether to discontinue a product.
Answer D. Gamma's contribution margin is $180,000 (500,000 - 300,000 - 20,000). If Gamma is discontinued, the company would avoid $140,000 of traceable fixed costs, so discontinuing Gamma alone would reduce operating income by $40,000 (lose 180,000 contribution but save 140,000 fixed). Reallocating freed capacity to Alpha adds $75,000 of contribution, so the combined effect is an increase in operating income of $35,000 (75,000 - 40,000). The $60,000 of corporate common fixed costs are unavoidable in this scenario and therefore irrelevant to the discontinuation decision.
Why not A: Tempting because Gamma currently yields a positive segment margin ($180,000 contribution minus $140,000 traceable fixed = $40,000), but this ignores the incremental benefit from reallocating capacity to Alpha. Continuing would forgo a net improvement of $35,000, so it is not the best action.
Why not B: Tempting because it seems conservative to require elimination of allocated corporate fixed costs, but decision analysis should focus on avoidable (traceable) costs and incremental benefits. The $60,000 corporate common fixed cost will remain even if Gamma is discontinued, so it should not be a gating condition.
Why not C: Tempting because full absorption (including allocated corporate fixed costs) makes Gamma look unprofitable, but allocated common fixed costs are not avoidable here and should not drive the discontinuation decision.
Question 9
Hint
Separate assigned costs from avoidable costs, then ask whether freeing capacity creates a real economic benefit.
Answer B. Relevant make cost: variable cost per unit = $7 + $5 + $4 = $16; for 50,000 units = $800,000. Add the $90,000 avoidable supervisor salary for a total relevant make cost of $890,000. Relevant buy cost: $18.20 × 50,000 = $910,000, but outsourcing frees capacity that can generate $85,000 contribution margin, reducing the net buy cost to $825,000. Since $825,000 < $890,000, outsourcing is the better-supported conclusion.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates often start by comparing supplier price to variable cost. However, the make-or-buy decision must also include avoidable fixed costs (the $90,000 supervisor salary) and any opportunity benefits from freed capacity. Including those items shows buying is cheaper overall.
Why not C: This distractor relies on the mistaken idea that opportunity benefits matter only if all capacity is repurposed. In fact, any portion of released capacity that can earn contribution margin is relevant; the 70% that can be redeployed yields an $85,000 benefit that must be included, while the 30% idle portion has no effect.
Why not D: This choice reflects the common error of treating allocated fixed overhead as fully avoidable. Only fixed costs that actually disappear are relevant. Harbor does not need all assigned fixed overhead to be eliminated for outsourcing to be preferable; only the $90,000 avoidable supervisor salary is relevant.
Common questions
Are fixed costs relevant in a make-or-buy decision?
Avoidable fixed costs are relevant. Marlow includes $2 per unit that outsourcing eliminates and excludes the $4 that continues.
How does freed capacity affect a make-or-buy decision?
Subtract its incremental contribution from the cost to buy. Marlow's $10,000 annual contribution offsets the supplier's $10,000 premium over avoidable manufacturing costs.
When is a company indifferent between making and buying?
Financial indifference occurs when relevant make cost equals net buy cost. For Marlow, both equal $200,000 after crediting the $10,000 capacity benefit.
Watch it solved
A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Managerial and cost accounting, worked step by step.
Activity-Based Costing & Standard Cost Variances | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Managerial and cost accounting
- Special Orders With Idle Capacity: Relevant Costs Only
- Special-Order Minimum Price With a Machine-Hour Bottleneck
- Absorption vs Variable Costing: Operating Income Difference
- ABC vs. ABM: Cost Pools, Drivers, and Management Decisions
- Process Costing Equivalent Units: Weighted-Average vs FIFO
- Direct Materials Price Variance: Net Favorable and Unfavorable
- Direct Labor Rate Variance: Formula and Calculation
- CVP Break-Even Units and Sales Dollars: Contribution Margin
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.