PracticeBARFree practice exam

BAR · Business Analysis · 13 practice questions

Make or Buy: Avoidable Fixed Costs and Freed Capacity

Compare avoidable manufacturing costs with the purchase price minus the benefit from freed capacity. Below: one scenario and one-fact changes that show when making, buying, or financial indifference is the answer.

The ruleRelevant make cost equals variable costs plus avoidable fixed costs. Net buy cost equals purchase cost minus the benefit from the best alternative use of freed capacity; choose the lower cost and exclude unavoidable fixed costs.

Try one first

Marlow Co. makes Part X for use in its production process. The unit cost to make Part X is: direct materials $8, direct labor $5, variable overhead $5, and fixed overhead allocated $6. Of the fixed overhead, $2 per unit would be avoided if Marlow stops making Part X; the remaining $4 would continue regardless. An outside supplier has offered to sell Part X to Marlow for $21 per unit. Assume Marlow has no alternative use for the released capacity. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Separate avoidable costs from unavoidable costs before comparing the make and buy alternatives.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

Marlow Co. needs 10,000 units of Part X annually. Unit manufacturing costs are materials $8, labor $5, variable overhead $5, and allocated fixed overhead $6. Outsourcing avoids $2 of fixed overhead per unit; $4 continues. A supplier offers identical quality and delivery for $21 per unit. No other costs change. Freed capacity can generate $10,000 of annual incremental contribution.

Answer: Be financially indifferent: relevant make cost and net buy cost are both $200,000 annually.

Make: 10,000 × ($8 + $5 + $5 + $2) = $200,000. Buy: 10,000 × $21 − $10,000 = $200,000. The capacity benefit exactly offsets the supplier's premium.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1Freed capacity has no alternative use instead of generating $10,000 annually.

Answer: Continue making Part X; making saves $10,000 annually.

Make remains $200,000. Buying costs $210,000 with no capacity benefit, so making is cheaper.

Change 2Freed capacity generates $30,000 of annual incremental contribution instead of $10,000.

Answer: Buy Part X and use the freed capacity; buying saves $20,000 annually.

Net buy cost becomes $210,000 − $30,000 = $180,000, below the unchanged $200,000 relevant make cost.

Change 3The supplier charges $20 per unit instead of $21.

Answer: Buy Part X and use the freed capacity; buying saves $10,000 annually.

Net buy cost becomes $200,000 − $10,000 = $190,000. The capacity benefit favors buying even when the supplier price equals avoidable make cost.

Key points

  • Remember: Freed capacity can make buying worthwhile even when the supplier charges more than the avoidable manufacturing cost.
  • Divide annual capacity benefits by the component's annual volume before comparing per-unit amounts.
  • Fixed overhead matters only to the extent that outsourcing eliminates it.
  • Equal relevant costs mean financial indifference, not equal full manufacturing and purchase costs.

How the exam traps you

  • Compare the supplier's price with the full $24 manufacturing cost. Exclude the $4 of fixed overhead that continues; relevant make cost is $20.
  • Ignore all fixed overhead and use an $18 make cost. Include the $2 of fixed overhead that outsourcing would eliminate.
  • Compare $20 to $21 and stop. Subtract the freed-capacity contribution from buying before choosing.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

Marlow Co. needs 10,000 units of Part X annually. Unit costs are materials $8, labor $5, variable overhead $5, and fixed overhead $6. Outsourcing avoids $2 of fixed overhead; $4 continues. A supplier offers identical quality and delivery for $21 per unit. No other costs change. Freed capacity can generate $10,000 of annual incremental contribution. Which conclusion is best?

Question 2

Same facts, except freed capacity has no alternative use. Which decision minimizes annual relevant cost?

Question 3

Same facts, except freed capacity can generate $30,000 of annual incremental contribution. Which decision minimizes annual relevant cost?

Question 4

Same facts, except the supplier charges $20 per unit. Which decision minimizes annual relevant cost?

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

A manufacturer sells three product lines (A, B, and C). Monthly data for each line are shown below. Company-wide common fixed costs of $120,000 are allocated to the lines but will remain if any line is discontinued. If a product line is discontinued, all of that line's traceable fixed costs can be eliminated and there is no expected effect on the sales of the remaining lines. Which action would increase the company's overall monthly operating income?
Product AProduct BProduct C
Sales$400,000$300,000$200,000
Variable costs$250,000$210,000$120,000
Traceable fixed costs$100,000$100,000$50,000
Hint

Calculate contribution margin for each line (sales − variable costs) and then subtract traceable fixed costs to get segment margin; only avoidable (traceable) fixed costs matter for a discontinuation decision.

Question 3

Meridian Company produces two products, Alpha and Beta, at a single plant. For Year 1 Product Beta sold 2,500 units at a selling price of $80 per unit and a variable cost of $55 per unit. Meridian currently assigns $55,000 of fixed overhead to Beta, but company analysis shows $30,000 of that is traceable to Beta and would be eliminated if Beta were discontinued; the remaining $25,000 is common corporate overhead that would remain after discontinuation. The plant has idle capacity, so discontinuing Beta would not increase Alpha's sales or otherwise avoid additional fixed costs. Based on these facts, what is the best-supported conclusion?
Hint

Compare the contribution margin that would be lost with only the fixed costs that would actually be eliminated; ignore common overhead that will remain.

Question 4

Nolan Co. manufactures Component K internally and is considering buying it from an outside supplier beginning in Year 2. Assume the supplier's quality is acceptable, Nolan needs the same number of units either way, and any cost not specifically described as avoidable will continue. The following Year 2 cost information relates to Component K: direct materials and direct labor would be eliminated if K is purchased; a K-specific machine maintenance contract can be canceled if K is purchased; the K production supervisor would be reassigned to another understaffed area at the same salary if K is purchased; depreciation on the K-specific machine will continue and the machine has no resale value; 30% of the floor space currently used for K could be subleased if K is purchased; and allocated plant insurance will continue regardless. For the make-or-buy decision, which classification of relevant costs is most appropriate?
Hint

Do not classify costs by whether they are manufacturing or traceable. Classify them by whether the cash flow changes if the company switches alternatives, and remember to consider opportunity effects.

Question 5

Hart Co. currently buys a precision bracket for $19 per unit. Management is evaluating whether to make the bracket internally for the entire annual requirement. If Hart makes the bracket, variable manufacturing cost would be $15 per unit and Hart would incur $100,000 of annual avoidable setup and supervision costs. Hart has enough otherwise idle capacity to produce up to 20,000 brackets with no opportunity cost. Any production above 20,000 brackets would displace another product and cause a lost contribution margin of $3 per bracket produced above that level. Unavoidable allocated plant overhead would continue regardless of the decision. Ignore taxes, inventory effects, and qualitative factors. At what annual requirement would making internally become at least as cost-effective as buying?
Hint

Separate the analysis into two volume ranges: up to idle capacity and above idle capacity. Compare relevant costs in each range rather than using one per-unit savings amount for all units.

Question 6

Baker Co. manufactures product P. Annual sales are 10,000 units at $20 per unit. Variable manufacturing cost per unit is $12. Fixed costs currently allocated to product P include a traceable advertising expense of $30,000 that would be eliminated if P were discontinued, and a corporate-level fixed overhead allocation of $50,000 that would continue even if P were discontinued (unavoidable). If P is discontinued, Baker can use the freed capacity to make product Q, which would yield an additional contribution margin of $20,000. Which of the following is the best conclusion regarding discontinuing product P?
Hint

Compare the incremental (avoidable) costs and incremental benefits: include lost contribution margin and any opportunity gains, but exclude common/unavoidable fixed allocations.

Question 7

Company T currently produces 10,000 units per year of a component used in its product. Variable manufacturing cost is $7 per unit. Allocated fixed manufacturing overhead related to the component is $120,000 per year; if production of the component ceases, $80,000 of those fixed costs would be eliminated and the remaining $40,000 would still be incurred. An outside supplier offers to sell the same component for $9 per unit. Selling and administrative costs and product sales would be unaffected by the decision. Based only on relevant costs, what is the most supportable amount of annual cost savings (a positive number = savings; a negative number = increased cost) if Company T outsources this component?
Hint

Identify which costs would actually be eliminated if production stops (variable costs and only the avoidable fixed overhead), then compare that total avoidable cost to the total cost of buying the part. Focus on net change, not just one side of the comparison.

Question 8

Year 1: Management is evaluating whether to discontinue Product Gamma. Annual financials for Gamma are: Sales $500,000; Variable manufacturing costs $300,000; Variable selling & administrative costs $20,000. Traceable (direct) fixed costs assigned to Gamma are $140,000; corporate common fixed costs allocated to Gamma are $60,000. Management expects that if Gamma is discontinued the $140,000 of traceable fixed costs would be eliminated but the $60,000 of corporate common fixed costs would remain. Freed capacity could be used to produce additional units of Product Alpha, which would increase Alpha's contribution margin by $75,000 per year. All other company sales and costs would be unchanged. What should management do to maximize company operating income?
Hint

Focus on avoidable (traceable) costs and incremental contribution from alternative uses of capacity; ignore allocated corporate common fixed costs when evaluating whether to discontinue a product.

Question 9

Harbor Co. manufactures Part M for use in its finished product. Harbor needs 50,000 units of M each year. The current per-unit manufacturing cost of M is: direct materials $7, direct labor $5, variable manufacturing overhead $4, and fixed manufacturing overhead $6. Of the annual fixed manufacturing overhead assigned to M, $90,000 is the salary of a supervisor that would be eliminated if M were outsourced; the rest would continue regardless. An outside supplier has offered to sell Part M to Harbor for $18.20 per unit. If Harbor outsources M, 70% of the released machine capacity could be used to produce an accessory that would generate annual contribution margin of $85,000, and Harbor can sell all such accessory units produced. The remaining 30% of released capacity would be idle. Assume no quality, timing, or inventory differences. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Separate assigned costs from avoidable costs, then ask whether freeing capacity creates a real economic benefit.

Drill all 252 Managerial and cost accounting questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Are fixed costs relevant in a make-or-buy decision?

Avoidable fixed costs are relevant. Marlow includes $2 per unit that outsourcing eliminates and excludes the $4 that continues.

How does freed capacity affect a make-or-buy decision?

Subtract its incremental contribution from the cost to buy. Marlow's $10,000 annual contribution offsets the supplier's $10,000 premium over avoidable manufacturing costs.

When is a company indifferent between making and buying?

Financial indifference occurs when relevant make cost equals net buy cost. For Marlow, both equal $200,000 after crediting the $10,000 capacity benefit.

Watch it solved

A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Managerial and cost accounting, worked step by step.

Activity-Based Costing & Standard Cost Variances | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube

Practice BAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Managerial and cost accounting

All Managerial and cost accounting practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.