BAR · Business Analysis · 8 practice questions
Special-Order Minimum Price With a Machine-Hour Bottleneck
When capacity is scarce, a special order must cover the contribution it displaces as well as its incremental costs. Below, follow the order from machine hours used to the minimum acceptable price.
Try one first
Hint
Identify the bottleneck resource and compare profit contribution relative to that resource rather than per unit or as a percentage of sales.
Answer C. When machine hours are the bottleneck, management should prioritize contribution margin per unit of the constrained resource. Both products have a $40 contribution margin per unit, but Product A uses 2 machine hours (40 ÷ 2 = $20 per machine hour) while Product B uses 4 hours (40 ÷ 4 = $10 per machine hour). Therefore contribution margin per machine hour is the appropriate governing factor.
Why not A: Contribution margin per unit is a common profitability measure but ignores the constrained resource. Since both products yield the same $40 per unit, per-unit margin doesn't indicate which product makes better use of scarce machine hours.
Why not B: Contribution margin percentage measures profitability per sales dollar but ignores the bottleneck. A higher percentage does not guarantee a higher contribution per machine hour, which is the relevant metric under capacity limits.
Why not D: Selecting the product with the lowest variable cost ignores selling price and the constrained resource. Low variable cost alone does not ensure the highest contribution per machine hour, so it is not the correct governing factor here.
Step by step
- Identify the scarce machine hours
Marston's machining center is fully used, and every Omega unit can be sold. The proposed order is for 1,000 Delta units requiring 1.5 hours each, versus 1.25 hours per Omega unit.
- Find regular contribution
Omega sells for $130 and incurs $70 of variable manufacturing cost plus $15 of variable selling cost per unit. Its contribution margin is $130 minus $70 minus $15 = $45 per unit.
- Value each bottleneck hour
Divide Omega's $45 contribution by its 1.25 machine hours: $36 per hour. This is the contribution Marston gives up for each hour diverted to Delta.
- Calculate displaced contribution
Delta needs 1,000 × 1.5 = 1,500 hours, displacing 1,500 ÷ 1.25 = 1,200 Omega units. Lost contribution is 1,500 × $36 = $54,000, or $54 per Delta unit.
- Calculate incremental variable costs
Delta requires $26 of materials, $20 of labor, and $10 of variable manufacturing overhead per unit, totaling $56. No selling commission is paid on Delta, so total incremental variable cost is $56,000.
- Separate setup from allocated overhead
Include Delta's $12,000 one-time setup cost because accepting the order causes it. Exclude the $8 per-unit fixed manufacturing overhead allocation because that overhead continues regardless.
- Set the minimum price
Required revenue is $56,000 + $12,000 + $54,000 = $122,000. Divide by 1,000 Delta units to get a minimum acceptable price of $122 per unit.
Key points
- Remember: A special-order unit replaces machine hours, not necessarily one regular unit.
- Opportunity cost is lost contribution, even though it requires no cash payment.
- The minimum price leaves operating income unchanged; it does not add profit.
How the exam traps you
- Adding Omega's $45 unit contribution gives a $113 minimum price. Convert contribution to $36 per machine hour, then multiply by Delta's 1.5 hours.
- Omitting the one-time setup cost gives a $110 minimum price. Include the $12,000 setup cost, or $12 per Delta unit.
- Including allocated fixed overhead gives a $130 minimum price. Exclude the $8 allocation because total fixed overhead does not change.
Question 2
| Omega (Regular Product) | Delta (Special Order) | |
|---|---|---|
| Selling price per unit | $130 | ? |
| Direct materials per unit | , | $26 |
| Direct labor per unit | , | $20 |
| Variable manufacturing overhead per unit | , | $10 |
| Variable manufacturing cost per unit | $70 | $56 |
| Variable selling cost per unit | $15 | $0 |
| Machining-center time per unit | 1.25 hours | 1.5 hours |
| One-time setup cost | , | $12,000 total |
| Allocated fixed manufacturing overhead per unit | , | $8 (continues regardless) |
Hint
First compute the regular product's contribution margin per unit of the bottleneck resource, then apply that rate to the special order's resource usage before adding any order-specific costs.
Answer A. Compute Delta's incremental costs plus the opportunity cost of lost Omega contribution. Delta's variable manufacturing cost = 26 + 20 + 10 = $56; setup cost per unit = 12,000/1,000 = $12. Omega's contribution margin = 130 - 70 - 15 = $45 per unit, or $45/1.25 = $36 per machining hour. Delta uses 1.5 hours, so opportunity cost = 36 * 1.5 = $54. Total minimum price = 56 + 12 + 54 = $122.
Why not B: This reflects incorrectly using Omega's unit contribution of $45 (instead of converting to contribution per machining hour) plus Delta's variable costs and setup: 45 + 56 + 12 = 113. Because the machining center is the bottleneck, the displaced contribution must be calculated on a per-hour basis (45/1.25 * 1.5 = 54).
Why not C: This sums Delta's variable manufacturing cost ($56) and the opportunity cost of lost Omega contribution ($54) but omits the one-time setup cost allocated per unit ($12), so it understates the required price.
Why not D: This comes from adding the nonincremental allocated fixed manufacturing overhead ($8) to the relevant-cost total (122 + 8 = 130). The stem specifies that the fixed overhead will continue regardless of the order, so it is not an incremental cost and should not affect the minimum acceptable price.
Question 3
Hint
Hold assets constant and trace how a higher internal price shifts reported profit between the seller and the buyer.
Answer D. A higher transfer price raises the selling division's reported revenue and operating income while reducing the buying division's operating income by the same amount. Because invested assets are unchanged, ROI moves in the same direction as operating income. Therefore, Components' ROI increases and Assembly's ROI decreases.
Why not A: This treats the transfer price increase as creating profit for the company as a whole. It only reallocates profit between divisions, so one division's reported income rises while the other's falls.
Why not B: This assumes the higher transfer price hurts both sides. The buying division is hurt, but the selling division benefits because its internal sales revenue and operating income increase.
Why not C: This reverses the income effect of the transfer price change. The selling division records more internal revenue, not less, while the buying division records higher input cost, not lower.
Question 4
Hint
Identify the true bottleneck first, then separate incremental outlay costs from any opportunity cost caused by displaced regular sales.
Answer D. Incremental outlay per special unit is $24 + $16 + $8 + $2 = $50, so for 4,000 units the outlay is $200,000 plus $10,000 export documentation = $210,000. Heat-treatment capacity (33,000) is the bottleneck: with 31,000 regular units, only 2,000 special units can be added without displacing regular sales. The other 2,000 special units displace regular sales, costing lost contribution of $92 − (24+16+8+6) = $38 per unit, or $76,000. Minimum acceptable price = $210,000 + $76,000 = $286,000.
Why not A: $210,000 equals the special order's incremental outlays (4,000×$50 + $10,000). It's tempting because fixed overhead and normal variable selling cost are excluded correctly, but it ignores the heat-treatment bottleneck that forces displacement of profitable regular sales.
Why not B: This reflects adding fixed manufacturing overhead to the special order (full-cost pricing). It's wrong because the problem states fixed manufacturing costs would not change, so fixed overhead allocation is irrelevant to the minimum acceptable price.
Why not C: This is plausible if a candidate recognizes displacement but miscomputes the lost contribution as $44 per displaced unit (92 − 24 − 16 − 8) by forgetting to subtract the regular variable selling cost of $6. The correct lost contribution per displaced unit is $38, so this overstates the opportunity cost.
Question 5
Hint
Start with the outside selling price, then remove only the costs that disappear on an internal transfer.
Answer C. A market-based transfer price begins with the external selling price and adjusts for costs avoided on an internal transfer. North avoids both the $6 commission and the $4 shipping cost. Therefore, the appropriate internal price is $80 minus $10, or $70 per unit.
Why not A: This treats the internal transfer the same as an external sale. That fails because North does not incur the external commission or shipping cost when transferring internally.
Why not B: This comes from subtracting only the $6 commission from the external price. That fails because shipping is also avoided on an internal transfer, so both avoided selling costs must be removed.
Why not D: This comes from subtracting only the $4 shipping cost from the external price. That fails because the sales commission is also not incurred internally, so the adjustment is incomplete.
Question 6
Hint
When capacity is full, focus on what the selling division gives up by transferring one unit internally.
Answer A. At full capacity, an internal transfer replaces an outside sale. The minimum acceptable transfer price equals variable cost plus opportunity cost. Here, the opportunity cost is the lost contribution margin on the outside sale, so $31 + ($48 - $31) = $48.
Why not B: This answer adds allocated fixed cost to variable cost and ignores the forgone outside sale. Fixed manufacturing cost is not an incremental sacrifice on the transferred unit, while the lost contribution margin is.
Why not C: This answer adds full cost to the lost contribution margin. That double counts fixed cost, because the minimum acceptable transfer price is based on variable cost plus opportunity cost, not full cost plus opportunity cost.
Why not D: This answer treats variable manufacturing cost as the only relevant amount. That approach works when the selling division has idle capacity, but it fails here because Alpha would give up an outside sale.
Question 7
Hint
For a one-time special order, start with incremental revenue versus incremental cost, then ask whether any scarce resource or regular business would be affected.
Answer A. With idle capacity and a one-time order, decisions are based on incremental revenue versus incremental and opportunity costs. Because the special-order price ($62) exceeds variable cost ($54), the order is profitable if it does not displace regular sales. If accepting the order forces Ridge to give up regular sales that generate positive contribution margin, the lost contribution is an opportunity cost that can make the order unattractive despite covering variable costs.
Why not B: This is tempting because students often focus on full (absorption) cost. However, fixed manufacturing overhead allocated based on normal capacity is a sunk cost for this incremental decision when capacity is idle, so a price below full absorption cost can still be acceptable if it covers variable costs and does not displace profitable regular sales.
Why not C: Candidates may assume any price below the regular selling price should be rejected, but the normal selling price is not the decision criterion for a one-time order with idle capacity. The key is whether incremental revenue exceeds incremental and opportunity costs, not whether the price equals the usual list price.
Why not D: This sounds technical and plausible because allocations affect reported unit costs, but changes in allocated fixed overhead do not create real incremental cash flows. Allocation shifts are not relevant unless they reflect a real change in capacity use or incremental cost.
Question 8
Hint
Identify only costs that change if Orion outsources: include variable costs, any avoidable fixed overhead, and any forgone contribution from alternative uses of freed capacity; ignore prior sunk tooling costs.
Answer A. Compute the relevant incremental cost to make: variable cost $12.00 per unit, plus avoidable fixed overhead of $90,000/25,000 = $3.60 per unit, plus the opportunity cost from the freed capacity (each A frees 0.5 machine-hour → 0.5/2.5 = 0.2 unit of B forgone at $6.00 CM = $1.20). Total relevant cost = $16.80 per unit, which exceeds the $15.00 purchase price, so Orion should buy. The $10,000 tooling cost is a prior sunk cost and is irrelevant to the decision.
Why not B: Tempting because variable costs are often the most visible incremental costs; wrong because this ignores other relevant changes, the avoidable portion of fixed overhead and the forgone contribution from alternative use of the freed capacity both increase the true incremental cost to make above the purchase price.
Why not C: Tempting because including full fixed overhead makes in-house production look expensive and supports buying; wrong because only the avoidable portion of fixed overhead is relevant to the outsourcing choice, unavoidable allocated fixed overhead should not drive the incremental decision.
Why not D: Tempting because tooling is a product-specific cost and feels like it must be recouped; wrong because the $10,000 was incurred in a prior period and is a sunk cost that does not change with the outsourcing decision (its $0.40 per-unit effect is not an incremental cost and does not justify continuing production).
Common questions
How do you calculate a special order's minimum acceptable price at full capacity?
Add incremental order costs and the contribution lost from displaced regular sales. For Marston, $56 of variable cost, $12 of setup cost, and $54 of lost contribution produce a $122 minimum per Delta unit.
How do machine hours affect special-order opportunity cost?
Delta uses 1.5 hours per unit, while Omega uses 1.25 hours. Each Delta unit therefore displaces 1.2 Omega units, making opportunity cost $54 rather than Omega's $45 unit contribution.
Does allocated fixed overhead belong in a special-order minimum price?
Not when total fixed overhead stays unchanged. Marston excludes Delta's $8 allocation but includes the $12,000 setup cost because accepting the order causes that cost.
Watch it solved
A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Managerial and cost accounting, worked step by step.
Activity-Based Costing & Standard Cost Variances | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Managerial and cost accounting
- Special Orders With Idle Capacity: Relevant Costs Only
- Make or Buy: Avoidable Fixed Costs and Freed Capacity
- Absorption vs Variable Costing: Operating Income Difference
- ABC vs. ABM: Cost Pools, Drivers, and Management Decisions
- Process Costing Equivalent Units: Weighted-Average vs FIFO
- Direct Materials Price Variance: Net Favorable and Unfavorable
- Direct Labor Rate Variance: Formula and Calculation
- CVP Break-Even Units and Sales Dollars: Contribution Margin
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.