PracticeBARFree practice exam

BAR · Business Analysis · 8 practice questions

Special-Order Minimum Price With a Machine-Hour Bottleneck

When capacity is scarce, a special order must cover the contribution it displaces as well as its incremental costs. Below, follow the order from machine hours used to the minimum acceptable price.

The ruleWhen a special order displaces regular sales, its minimum acceptable price covers incremental order costs plus the contribution lost from those sales. Use bottleneck hours to determine how many regular units are displaced.

Try one first

Ridgeway Manufacturing produces Product A and Product B. Per-unit data are: Product A, selling price $100, variable cost $60, requires 2 machine hours; Product B, selling price $160, variable cost $120, requires 4 machine hours. Machine hours are the constrained (bottleneck) resource for the relevant period. Fixed costs are sunk for this short-term decision and should be ignored. Which of the following factors should govern management's product-mix decision while capacity is constrained?
Hint

Identify the bottleneck resource and compare profit contribution relative to that resource rather than per unit or as a percentage of sales.

Step by step

  1. Identify the scarce machine hours

    Marston's machining center is fully used, and every Omega unit can be sold. The proposed order is for 1,000 Delta units requiring 1.5 hours each, versus 1.25 hours per Omega unit.

  2. Find regular contribution

    Omega sells for $130 and incurs $70 of variable manufacturing cost plus $15 of variable selling cost per unit. Its contribution margin is $130 minus $70 minus $15 = $45 per unit.

  3. Value each bottleneck hour

    Divide Omega's $45 contribution by its 1.25 machine hours: $36 per hour. This is the contribution Marston gives up for each hour diverted to Delta.

  4. Calculate displaced contribution

    Delta needs 1,000 × 1.5 = 1,500 hours, displacing 1,500 ÷ 1.25 = 1,200 Omega units. Lost contribution is 1,500 × $36 = $54,000, or $54 per Delta unit.

  5. Calculate incremental variable costs

    Delta requires $26 of materials, $20 of labor, and $10 of variable manufacturing overhead per unit, totaling $56. No selling commission is paid on Delta, so total incremental variable cost is $56,000.

  6. Separate setup from allocated overhead

    Include Delta's $12,000 one-time setup cost because accepting the order causes it. Exclude the $8 per-unit fixed manufacturing overhead allocation because that overhead continues regardless.

  7. Set the minimum price

    Required revenue is $56,000 + $12,000 + $54,000 = $122,000. Divide by 1,000 Delta units to get a minimum acceptable price of $122 per unit.

Key points

  • Remember: A special-order unit replaces machine hours, not necessarily one regular unit.
  • Opportunity cost is lost contribution, even though it requires no cash payment.
  • The minimum price leaves operating income unchanged; it does not add profit.

How the exam traps you

  • Adding Omega's $45 unit contribution gives a $113 minimum price. Convert contribution to $36 per machine hour, then multiply by Delta's 1.5 hours.
  • Omitting the one-time setup cost gives a $110 minimum price. Include the $12,000 setup cost, or $12 per Delta unit.
  • Including allocated fixed overhead gives a $130 minimum price. Exclude the $8 allocation because total fixed overhead does not change.

7 more, each from a different angle

0 of 7 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Marston Co. produces Omega, which uses a machining center that is currently at full capacity. Marston can sell all Omega units it produces at the current price. Marston is considering a one-time special order for 1,000 units of Delta. No selling commission would be paid on Delta, and no costs other than those listed would change.
Omega
(Regular Product)
Delta
(Special Order)
Selling price per unit$130?
Direct materials per unit, $26
Direct labor per unit, $20
Variable manufacturing overhead per unit, $10
Variable manufacturing cost per unit$70$56
Variable selling cost per unit$15$0
Machining-center time per unit1.25 hours1.5 hours
One-time setup cost, $12,000 total
Allocated fixed manufacturing overhead per unit, $8 (continues regardless)
Assuming the special order would displace Omega production because of the machining-center bottleneck, what is the minimum acceptable price per Delta unit that would leave Marston's operating income unchanged?
Hint

First compute the regular product's contribution margin per unit of the bottleneck resource, then apply that rate to the special order's resource usage before adding any order-specific costs.

Question 3

In Year 1, Components Division transfers 8,000 units to Assembly Division. The transfer price is increased from $40 to $46 per unit. Assume the number of units transferred, Assembly's external selling price, all other costs, and each division's invested assets remain unchanged. What is the effect on the divisions' reported ROI for Year 1?
Hint

Hold assets constant and trace how a higher internal price shifts reported profit between the seller and the buyer.

Question 4

Pine Co. manufactures a single product. For regular sales, Pine's per-unit amounts are: selling price $92, direct materials $24, direct labor $16, variable manufacturing overhead $8, fixed manufacturing overhead $14, and variable selling cost $6. Next quarter, Pine expects regular demand of 31,000 units. Total production capacity is 35,000 units, but all units must pass through a heat-treatment step that can process only 33,000 units next quarter. A foreign customer offers a one-time special order for 4,000 units. The special order would not incur Pine's normal variable selling cost, but it would require reinforced packaging costing $2 per unit and export documentation costing $10,000 total. No fixed manufacturing costs would change, and any regular sales displaced by the heat-treatment constraint would be permanently lost. What is the minimum total contract price Pine should accept for the special order?
Hint

Identify the true bottleneck first, then separate incremental outlay costs from any opportunity cost caused by displaced regular sales.

Question 5

North Division sells a component externally for $80 per unit. For external sales, North pays a $6 sales commission and $4 shipping cost per unit. Those two costs are not incurred when units are transferred internally to South Division. If management wants a transfer price that preserves the economics of an outside sale, what per-unit price should North charge South?
Hint

Start with the outside selling price, then remove only the costs that disappear on an internal transfer.

Question 6

Alpha Division produces a component at variable manufacturing cost of $31 per unit and fixed manufacturing cost of $8 per unit. Alpha is operating at full capacity and can sell every unit externally for $48. What is Alpha's minimum acceptable transfer price per unit?
Hint

When capacity is full, focus on what the selling division gives up by transferring one unit internally.

Question 7

Ridge Co. normally sells a product for $90 per unit. Variable manufacturing cost is $54 per unit, and fixed manufacturing overhead of $18 per unit is based on normal capacity. Ridge has idle capacity and is evaluating a one-time special order for 2,000 units at $62 per unit. Ignoring qualitative factors, which condition would be the strongest reason to reject the special order even though the order price exceeds variable manufacturing cost?
Hint

For a one-time special order, start with incremental revenue versus incremental cost, then ask whether any scarce resource or regular business would be affected.

Question 8

Orion Co. manufactures 25,000 units of component A in Year 1. Per-unit manufacturing costs are direct materials $6, direct labor $4, and variable manufacturing overhead $2 (total variable cost $12.00 per unit). Total fixed manufacturing overhead allocated to component A is $200,000; of that amount, $90,000 would be eliminated if Orion outsourced production of the component and the remaining $110,000 would be unavoidable. Each unit of component A requires 0.5 machine-hour. Orion has an offer to purchase all 25,000 units from an outside supplier at $15.00 per unit. If Orion outsources production, the freed capacity could be used to produce product B; product B requires 2.5 machine-hours per unit and yields a contribution margin of $6.00 per unit. Orion also incurred a $10,000 tooling cost specifically for component A in a prior period. Based on relevant-cost analysis, how should Orion respond to the supplier's offer?
Hint

Identify only costs that change if Orion outsources: include variable costs, any avoidable fixed overhead, and any forgone contribution from alternative uses of freed capacity; ignore prior sunk tooling costs.

Drill all 252 Managerial and cost accounting questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

How do you calculate a special order's minimum acceptable price at full capacity?

Add incremental order costs and the contribution lost from displaced regular sales. For Marston, $56 of variable cost, $12 of setup cost, and $54 of lost contribution produce a $122 minimum per Delta unit.

How do machine hours affect special-order opportunity cost?

Delta uses 1.5 hours per unit, while Omega uses 1.25 hours. Each Delta unit therefore displaces 1.2 Omega units, making opportunity cost $54 rather than Omega's $45 unit contribution.

Does allocated fixed overhead belong in a special-order minimum price?

Not when total fixed overhead stays unchanged. Marston excludes Delta's $8 allocation but includes the $12,000 setup cost because accepting the order causes that cost.

Watch it solved

A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Managerial and cost accounting, worked step by step.

Activity-Based Costing & Standard Cost Variances | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube

Practice BAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Managerial and cost accounting

All Managerial and cost accounting practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.