PracticeTCPFree practice exam

TCP · Entity Tax Planning · 6 practice questions

How Much to Lend an S Corporation to Deduct Its Loss

An S corporation shareholder needs enough stock and direct debt basis to deduct a loss. Below: a worked calculation of the year-end funding gap, with loan and capital contribution alternatives.

The ruleDeductible S corporation losses cannot exceed stock basis plus direct debt basis after current-year adjustments. Cash capital contributions and bona fide direct shareholder loans funded and outstanding at year-end can close the basis gap.

Try one first

Maya owns 100% of an S corporation. At the start of Year 2, her stock basis is $18,000 and she has no debt basis. The corporation expects an ordinary loss of $42,000 for Year 2. Maya wants to deduct the full Year 2 loss on her individual return if possible. She is willing to provide exactly enough cash before year-end, but if the business improves, she would like the corporation to be able to repay her in Year 3 without treating the repayment as a distribution. Assume any shareholder advance would be properly documented as bona fide debt, and ignore at-risk and passive activity limitations. Which action is the most appropriate tax-planning step?
Hint

First determine how much additional basis Maya needs, then separate actions that create shareholder basis from actions that only help the corporation borrow money.

Worked example

Ava owns all of Cedar, a calendar-year S corporation with no accumulated C corporation earnings and profits. Her beginning stock basis is $30,000 and direct debt basis is $10,000. Cedar distributes $10,000 and expects an $80,000 ordinary loss. Ava wants to fund the exact basis shortfall by December 31. There are no other basis adjustments, and only the basis limitation applies.

1Reduce stock basis for the distribution$30,000 beginning stock basis - $10,000 distribution$20,000 stock basis
2Add existing debt basis$20,000 stock basis + $10,000 existing debt basis$30,000 available basis
3Find the funding gap$80,000 expected loss - $30,000 available basis$50,000 required funding
4Fund a direct shareholder loanAva lends $50,000 directly to Cedar under a bona fide note by December 31, outstanding at year-end: $10,000 existing debt basis + $50,000 new loan.$60,000 debt basis
5Apply the loss limitation$20,000 stock basis + $60,000 debt basis = $80,000 available for the $80,000 loss.$80,000 deductible loss
6Alternative: contribute cash capitalInstead of lending, Ava contributes $50,000 cash by December 31: $30,000 + $50,000 - $10,000 distribution = $70,000 stock basis. Add $10,000 existing debt basis.$80,000 deductible loss
7Contrast: merely guarantee a bank loanIf Cedar instead borrows $50,000 from a bank and Ava guarantees it without payment, she gains no basis: $20,000 stock + $10,000 existing debt = $30,000. Suspended loss: $80,000 - $30,000.$30,000 deductible; $50,000 suspended

Ava must provide $50,000 by December 31 through either a bona fide direct loan outstanding at year-end or a cash capital contribution to deduct the full $80,000 loss.

Check: Basis must cover the loss and distribution: $80,000 + $10,000 - $30,000 beginning stock basis - $10,000 existing debt basis = $50,000 of new funding.

Key points

  • A cash capital contribution increases stock basis; a direct shareholder loan creates debt basis.
  • Distributions reduce stock basis before the year's loss is applied.
  • For a calendar-year corporation, fund the contribution or loan by December 31, not the return filing date.

How the exam traps you

  • Ignoring the distribution and calculating only $40,000 of required funding. Subtract the $10,000 distribution from stock basis first. The funding gap is $50,000.
  • Treating a guaranteed bank loan as shareholder debt basis. A guarantee without payment adds no basis. Ava's deductible loss remains $30,000.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Ria owns 100% of Pine, an S corporation. At the beginning of Year 1, Ria has $25,000 of stock basis and no debt basis. Pine expects an $85,000 ordinary loss for Year 1 and needs an additional $60,000 of cash to continue operations. Ria wants the largest possible current Year 1 loss deduction and would prefer not to make an additional capital contribution if another funding method will accomplish that result. Assume the activity is nonpassive to Ria, Ria is fully at risk, and any shareholder advance would be bona fide debt. Which action is the best tax-planning choice?
Hint

First determine how much additional basis Ria needs, then identify which funding methods actually create shareholder basis in an S corporation.

Question 3

Nora is the sole shareholder of Pine S Corp. At January 1, Year 1, Nora's stock basis was $18,000 and she had no debt basis. During Year 1, she contributed $7,000 cash to Pine and made a bona fide direct loan of $10,000 to Pine that remained outstanding at December 31. Pine's Year 1 items were a separately stated long-term capital gain of $6,000, a $20,000 nonliquidating cash distribution to Nora, and an ordinary business loss of $30,000. Assume Pine had no debt repayment to Nora, no other items, no suspended losses, and Nora is not limited by the at-risk or passive activity rules. What is the most supportable amount of Pine's Year 1 ordinary business loss that Nora may deduct on her Year 1 return?
Hint

Track shareholder basis in order: first increase stock basis for contributions and income items, then reduce stock basis for the distribution, and only then test how much loss can be absorbed by remaining stock basis and debt basis.

Question 4

At the beginning of Year 2, Reed owns 100% of Oak, an S corporation. Reed's stock basis is $20,000, and Reed has no debt basis. Oak expects a $70,000 ordinary loss for Year 2. Reed wants to maximize the amount of that Year 2 loss he can deduct currently. Assume the at-risk and passive activity rules do not limit Reed, all loans mentioned would be bona fide, and the only relevant limitation is the S corporation basis limitation. Which action, if completed before the end of Year 2, would best accomplish Reed's objective?
Hint

Focus on two things: what creates direct shareholder basis in an S corporation, and when that basis must exist for the loss year.

Question 5

At the start of Year 1, Elena owns 100% of Pine, an S corporation. Her stock basis is $18,000 and she has no debt basis. Pine has no accumulated C corporation earnings and profits. During Year 1 Pine makes an $8,000 cash distribution to Elena and incurs a $40,000 ordinary loss. Before year-end Elena wants to maximize the amount of Year 1 S corporation loss she can currently deduct without changing ownership percentages. She will complete only one of the following alternatives before year-end. Assume any shareholder loan described would be a bona fide direct loan from Elena to Pine, Elena materially participates, and the at-risk and passive activity rules do not otherwise limit the deduction. Which alternative produces the greatest currently deductible Year 1 loss for Elena, and what is that deductible amount?
Hint

Reduce stock basis for distributions first, then add any bona fide shareholder loan basis to compute the available basis for loss deduction.

Question 6

Lena owns 100% of Maple, a calendar-year S corporation. Before any Year 1 loss allocation, Lena has $5,000 stock basis and no debt basis in Maple. Maple expects a $35,000 ordinary loss for Year 1, and Lena materially participates. Assume the at-risk and passive activity rules do not otherwise limit her deduction, and any debt described is bona fide indebtedness. On December 28, Year 1, Maple needs $30,000 of additional cash. Lena wants a funding method that is most favorable if her goals are to (1) increase her Year 1 basis so she can deduct more of Maple's Year 1 loss and (2) have any Year 2 cash return analyzed as repayment of debt rather than as an S corporation distribution. Which choice best achieves both goals?
Hint

Separate two questions: what increases Lena's basis for Year 1, and what makes a later cash transfer look like debt repayment instead of a distribution?

Drill all 115 Tax planning for S corporations questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

How much must I lend my S corporation to deduct its loss?

Subtract available stock and debt basis from your allocated loss. Ava needs $50,000 because her $80,000 loss exceeds her $30,000 available basis.

Can a capital contribution increase my S corporation loss deduction?

Yes. Ava's $50,000 cash contribution by December 31 would increase stock basis enough to support the full $80,000 loss together with her existing debt basis.

Does guaranteeing an S corporation bank loan increase my basis?

A guarantee alone does not increase basis. If Ava merely guarantees Cedar's bank loan without paying anything, she can deduct only $30,000, with $50,000 suspended.

Practice TCP like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Tax planning for S corporations

All Tax planning for S corporations practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.