TCP · Entity Tax Planning · 6 practice questions
How Much to Lend an S Corporation to Deduct Its Loss
An S corporation shareholder needs enough stock and direct debt basis to deduct a loss. Below: a worked calculation of the year-end funding gap, with loan and capital contribution alternatives.
Try one first
Hint
First determine how much additional basis Maya needs, then separate actions that create shareholder basis from actions that only help the corporation borrow money.
Answer C. Maya needs an additional $24,000 of shareholder basis (42,000 loss − 18,000 stock basis = 24,000). A bona fide loan from the shareholder to the S corporation before year-end creates shareholder debt basis that can be used to deduct the full loss. If properly documented as debt, later repayment in Year 3 is treated as loan repayment rather than a distribution.
Why not A: A guarantee alone does not create shareholder basis because the shareholder has not made an economic outlay. Basis arises when the shareholder actually lends money or otherwise pays the creditor; a mere guarantee is insufficient to support the loss deduction.
Why not B: A capital contribution would increase Maya's stock basis and permit the loss deduction, but it does not meet her repayment objective: subsequent cash returned to her would generally be analyzed as a distribution (return of capital or dividend rules) rather than repayment of a bona fide loan.
Why not D: Basis for Year 2 must exist by the end of Year 2. A corporate borrowing after year-end cannot retroactively create shareholder basis for the prior year; and corporate debt does not equal shareholder debt basis unless the shareholder directly lends or pays the obligation.
Worked example
Ava owns all of Cedar, a calendar-year S corporation with no accumulated C corporation earnings and profits. Her beginning stock basis is $30,000 and direct debt basis is $10,000. Cedar distributes $10,000 and expects an $80,000 ordinary loss. Ava wants to fund the exact basis shortfall by December 31. There are no other basis adjustments, and only the basis limitation applies.
| 1 | Reduce stock basis for the distribution$30,000 beginning stock basis - $10,000 distribution | $20,000 stock basis |
| 2 | Add existing debt basis$20,000 stock basis + $10,000 existing debt basis | $30,000 available basis |
| 3 | Find the funding gap$80,000 expected loss - $30,000 available basis | $50,000 required funding |
| 4 | Fund a direct shareholder loanAva lends $50,000 directly to Cedar under a bona fide note by December 31, outstanding at year-end: $10,000 existing debt basis + $50,000 new loan. | $60,000 debt basis |
| 5 | Apply the loss limitation$20,000 stock basis + $60,000 debt basis = $80,000 available for the $80,000 loss. | $80,000 deductible loss |
| 6 | Alternative: contribute cash capitalInstead of lending, Ava contributes $50,000 cash by December 31: $30,000 + $50,000 - $10,000 distribution = $70,000 stock basis. Add $10,000 existing debt basis. | $80,000 deductible loss |
| 7 | Contrast: merely guarantee a bank loanIf Cedar instead borrows $50,000 from a bank and Ava guarantees it without payment, she gains no basis: $20,000 stock + $10,000 existing debt = $30,000. Suspended loss: $80,000 - $30,000. | $30,000 deductible; $50,000 suspended |
Ava must provide $50,000 by December 31 through either a bona fide direct loan outstanding at year-end or a cash capital contribution to deduct the full $80,000 loss.
Check: Basis must cover the loss and distribution: $80,000 + $10,000 - $30,000 beginning stock basis - $10,000 existing debt basis = $50,000 of new funding.
Key points
- A cash capital contribution increases stock basis; a direct shareholder loan creates debt basis.
- Distributions reduce stock basis before the year's loss is applied.
- For a calendar-year corporation, fund the contribution or loan by December 31, not the return filing date.
How the exam traps you
- Ignoring the distribution and calculating only $40,000 of required funding. Subtract the $10,000 distribution from stock basis first. The funding gap is $50,000.
- Treating a guaranteed bank loan as shareholder debt basis. A guarantee without payment adds no basis. Ava's deductible loss remains $30,000.
Question 2
Hint
First determine how much additional basis Ria needs, then identify which funding methods actually create shareholder basis in an S corporation.
Answer A. Ria needs $60,000 of additional basis to reach $85,000 of basis and fully deduct the $85,000 loss (85,000 − 25,000 = 60,000). A bona fide loan from the shareholder to the S corporation creates shareholder debt basis (and increases the at‑risk amount), which permits deduction of the full loss. A guarantee or a third‑party bank loan by itself does not create shareholder basis; an equity contribution would also work but the shareholder prefers to avoid adding capital.
Why not B: A guarantee alone does not create shareholder debt basis for S‑corporation loss purposes; basis is only created if the shareholder actually advances funds (for example, by lending directly or by paying under the guarantee). Therefore the guarantee by itself would not give Ria the $60,000 of basis needed in Year 1.
Why not C: A capital contribution would increase Ria's stock basis by $60,000 and allow the full loss deduction, but the fact pattern states Ria prefers not to make an additional equity contribution if another method will accomplish the same result.
Why not D: Debt owed by the S corporation to an unrelated third‑party lender does not create shareholder basis. Without a direct shareholder loan or additional stock basis, Ria's deductible loss remains limited to her existing $25,000 basis.
Question 3
Hint
Track shareholder basis in order: first increase stock basis for contributions and income items, then reduce stock basis for the distribution, and only then test how much loss can be absorbed by remaining stock basis and debt basis.
Answer D. Begin with Nora's $18,000 opening stock basis. Stock basis is increased by the $7,000 contribution and the $6,000 separately stated long-term capital gain (18,000 + 7,000 + 6,000 = 31,000). The $20,000 nonliquidating distribution reduces stock basis to $11,000, and Nora also has $10,000 of debt basis from her bona fide loan, so she may deduct $11,000 + $10,000 = $21,000 of the $30,000 ordinary loss.
Why not A: Tempting if the candidate correctly reduces stock basis for the distribution but forgets that the shareholder loan creates debt basis. After distribution, Nora has $11,000 of stock basis but also $10,000 of debt basis that can be used for loss deduction, raising deductible loss to $21,000.
Why not B: Tempting if the candidate ignores the effect of the $20,000 nonliquidating distribution (or treats contributions and income as available after applying the distribution). The distribution reduces stock basis before applying losses, so Nora does not have sufficient combined stock and debt basis to deduct the full $30,000 loss.
Why not C: Tempting if the candidate nets the $6,000 capital gain against the $30,000 ordinary loss to get $24,000, but separately stated gains increase stock basis rather than being netted for the purpose of the loss limitation. Proper ordering yields only $21,000 of basis available for the ordinary loss.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on two things: what creates direct shareholder basis in an S corporation, and when that basis must exist for the loss year.
Answer C. Lending $50,000 directly to Oak on a bona fide shareholder note creates $50,000 of shareholder debt basis before the end of Year 2. Combined with Reed's $20,000 stock basis, Reed would have $70,000 of total basis and could deduct the full $70,000 Year 2 loss (assuming no other limitations). The essential point is that the corporation must be indebted to the shareholder to generate shareholder debt basis; indirect economic exposure to bank debt does not suffice.
Why not A: This is tempting because Reed is economically exposed, but a guarantee of corporate debt does not by itself create shareholder debt basis. Basis generally arises only if the shareholder becomes the creditor (for example, by paying on the guarantee and stepping into the creditor role).
Why not B: Pledging personal assets to secure a bank loan increases Reed's economic risk but does not create debt owed to Reed. The corporation remains indebted to the bank, so the pledge does not give Reed shareholder debt basis.
Why not D: Creating basis after the end of the loss year does not retroactively increase the basis available to deduct that year's loss. A Year 3 contribution may allow previously suspended Year 2 losses to be deducted in Year 3, but it will not permit those losses to be deducted currently in Year 2.
Question 5
Hint
Reduce stock basis for distributions first, then add any bona fide shareholder loan basis to compute the available basis for loss deduction.
Answer B. The $8,000 distribution reduces Elena's stock basis from $18,000 to $10,000. A bona fide direct loan of $25,000 from Elena to Pine creates shareholder debt basis, so total basis available to absorb the loss is $10,000 + $25,000 = $35,000. Therefore $35,000 of the $40,000 loss is currently deductible and $5,000 is suspended.
Why not A: Tempts because guaranteeing a loan creates apparent economic exposure, but a mere guarantee does not create shareholder debt basis until the guarantor actually makes a payment; after the $8,000 distribution Elena still only has $10,000 of stock basis.
Why not C: Tempts by adding the $25,000 loan to the original $18,000 stock basis, but it incorrectly ignores that the $8,000 distribution reduces stock basis to $10,000 before applying the loss; the correct total basis with the loan is $35,000, not $43,000.
Why not D: Tempts because doing nothing leaves only stock basis available; after the $8,000 distribution Elena's stock basis is $10,000, so only $10,000 of the $40,000 loss would be currently deductible.
Question 6
Hint
Separate two questions: what increases Lena's basis for Year 1, and what makes a later cash transfer look like debt repayment instead of a distribution?
Answer C. A direct, bona fide loan from Lena to Maple establishes shareholder debt basis (distinct from stock basis). That debt basis, together with her existing stock basis, increases the amount of Year 1 loss Lena may deduct. If Maple later repays the note, the cash is analyzed as repayment of shareholder debt rather than as an S corporation distribution.
Why not A: Tempting because Lena is economically at risk, but a guarantee alone does not create shareholder debt basis: the indebtedness is to the bank, not to Lena, and Lena's basis only increases if she actually pays the creditor under the guarantee.
Why not B: A capital contribution would increase Lena's stock basis and thereby allow more of the Year 1 loss to be deducted, but a later cash return would generally be analyzed as an S corporation distribution (return of capital), not as repayment of shareholder debt.
Why not D: Although Lena controls the C corporation, a loan from that separate entity creates indebtedness to the C corporation, not to Lena personally; it does not create Lena's shareholder debt basis and a repayment to the C corporation would not be repayment of Lena's personal debt.
Common questions
How much must I lend my S corporation to deduct its loss?
Subtract available stock and debt basis from your allocated loss. Ava needs $50,000 because her $80,000 loss exceeds her $30,000 available basis.
Can a capital contribution increase my S corporation loss deduction?
Yes. Ava's $50,000 cash contribution by December 31 would increase stock basis enough to support the full $80,000 loss together with her existing debt basis.
Does guaranteeing an S corporation bank loan increase my basis?
A guarantee alone does not increase basis. If Ava merely guarantees Cedar's bank loan without paying anything, she can deduct only $30,000, with $50,000 suspended.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Tax planning for S corporations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.