TCP · Entity Tax Planning · 9 practice questions
S Corporation Debt Basis: Direct Loans vs. Guarantees
S corporation debt basis comes from bona fide debt owed directly to the shareholder, not an unpaid guarantee. Below: sort Pine's funding alternatives by whether they create Leo's Year 1 debt basis, stock basis, or neither.
Try one first
Hint
Separate participation rules from basis rules. Ask whether the shareholder made a direct economic outlay to the S corporation.
Answer A. For S corporation loss limitations, a shareholder generally needs stock basis or direct debt basis (e.g., a loan made by the shareholder to the corporation). A mere personal guarantee of a corporate debt typically does not create basis unless the shareholder makes an actual economic outlay (for example, paying on the guarantee or lending funds directly). Because Leo only guaranteed the bank loan and did not make a payment or lend funds, his deductible loss is generally limited to his $15,000 stock basis.
Why not B: This is tempting because material participation removes passive activity restrictions, but it does not affect the separate basis limitation. Even an active shareholder cannot deduct S corporation losses beyond available stock and debt basis.
Why not C: This reflects a common shortcut error, confusing personal liability for a corporate debt with having basis. A guarantee alone does not increase stock or debt basis; basis typically arises only if the shareholder actually funds the corporation or pays on the guarantee.
Why not D: This confuses distribution rules with loss limitations. Cash distributions are not required before a shareholder may deduct an S corporation loss; the controlling limitation here is basis, not whether a distribution occurred.
Sort it
By Year 1-end, Leo has funded bona fide debt that Pine owes directly to him and that remains outstanding.
Leo transfers cash to Pine as equity before Year 1 ends, rather than establishing a repayment obligation.
Leo makes no qualifying equity contribution or funded direct loan during Year 1.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Leo lends Pine $20,000 cash before Year 1-end under a bona fide note. The loan remains outstanding at year-end. | Creates Year 1 debt basisPine owes Leo directly, and his actual cash advance creates $20,000 of debt basis. |
| A bank lends Pine $20,000 in Year 1. Leo guarantees the loan but makes no payment. | Creates no Year 1 basisPine owes the bank. Leo's contingent obligation is not a funded shareholder loan. |
| Leo contributes $20,000 cash to Pine as additional paid-in capital before Year 1-end. | Creates Year 1 stock basisThe cash is equity, so it increases stock basis rather than debt basis. |
| Leo borrows $20,000 personally and lends it to Pine under bona fide debt outstanding at Year 1-end. His bank loan remains unpaid. | Creates Year 1 debt basisPine owes Leo directly. His unpaid personal bank loan does not prevent debt basis. |
| A bank lends Pine $20,000 in Year 1. Leo pledges personal securities as collateral but pays nothing. | Creates no Year 1 basisCollateral protects the bank; it does not make Leo Pine's creditor. |
| Before Year 1-end, Pine gives Leo a $20,000 note, but Leo advances no cash or property. | Creates no Year 1 basisA paper note without an actual advance does not establish funded shareholder debt. |
| Leo pays $20,000 on Pine's guaranteed bank debt before Year 1-end. Pine owes him bona fide reimbursement debt outstanding at year-end. | Creates Year 1 debt basisActual payment replaces contingent exposure with a funded, direct claim against Pine. |
| Leo's separate C corporation lends Pine $20,000 in Year 1. Pine's note is payable to that corporation. | Creates no Year 1 basisThe separate corporation is Pine's creditor. Common ownership does not make the loan payable to Leo. |
| Leo lends Pine $20,000 on January 2 of Year 2, before filing his Year 1 return. | Creates no Year 1 basisThe advance occurs in Year 2. The return filing date does not move it into Year 1. |
| A supplier extends Pine $20,000 of trade credit before Year 1-end. Leo advances nothing. | Creates no Year 1 basisPine owes the supplier, not Leo. Corporate borrowing does not automatically increase shareholder basis. |
| Leo co-signs Pine's $20,000 bank note in Year 1. The bank remains the lender, and Leo makes no payment. | Creates no Year 1 basisSigning the obligation does not create funded debt from Pine to Leo. |
| Leo borrows $20,000 personally and contributes the proceeds to Pine as equity before Year 1-end. | Creates Year 1 stock basisPersonal borrowing does not dictate the result. Leo's equity contribution increases stock basis, not debt basis. |
Key points
- Remember: Ask whom Pine owes, not who risks paying the bank.
- Borrowing personally can fund either debt or equity; Leo's transfer to Pine determines which basis increases.
- A signed note without an actual advance does not create basis.
- Complete the funding before Year 1 ends; filing the return later does not extend that deadline.
How the exam traps you
- Treating a guarantee, collateral pledge, or co-signature as a shareholder loan. If Pine still owes only the bank and Leo pays nothing, Leo gets no debt basis.
- Rejecting a back-to-back loan because Leo borrowed the money. A genuine personal borrowing followed by a bona fide loan to Pine creates direct shareholder debt basis.
- Using a Year 2 loan to increase the Year 1 deduction. The later loan does not retroactively create Year 1 basis.
Question 2
Hint
Distinguish two issues: which steps create shareholder loss basis (stock basis vs bona fide debt owed by the S corp to the shareholder) and which steps change shareholders' economic rights in a way that can threaten the one-class-of-stock requirement.
Answer C. S-corporation losses are deductible by a shareholder only to the extent of the shareholder's basis, which includes stock basis and bona fide debt owed by the S corporation to the shareholder. A properly structured direct loan, evidenced by a written promissory note with fixed interest, stated maturity, and creditor-like (arm's-length) terms, creates debt basis for Parker without altering shareholders' equity rights, so it supports loss deductions while preserving the one-class-of-stock requirement. A loan that lacks creditor-like terms risks recharacterization as equity and may not provide reliable debt basis.
Why not A: This is tempting because Parker bears economic exposure, but a guaranty alone does not create shareholder debt basis for S-corporation loss purposes; Parker would not have immediate debt basis unless he actually paid the lender (and factual steps then converted that payment into a loan or contribution). Because a guarantee does not provide up-front debt basis, it does not meet the shareholders' objective.
Why not B: Although preferred stock could economically prioritize repayment to Parker, granting priority distribution or liquidation rights creates a second class of stock (different economic rights) and can jeopardize the S election; moreover, preferred stock provides equity rather than shareholder debt basis for loss deductions.
Why not D: This may appear to preserve formal stock certificates, but a binding side agreement that prioritizes distributions effectively changes economic rights among shareholders (functionally creating unequal classes of equity) and therefore risks the one-class-of-stock requirement; it also does not create debt basis for Parker when the funds are advanced.
Question 3
| Alternative | Amount |
|---|---|
| Contribute cash directly to the S corporation as a capital contribution | $70,000 |
| Borrow $70,000 personally from a bank and then lend that $70,000 directly to the S corporation under a bona fide note | $70,000 |
| Have the bank lend $70,000 directly to the S corporation, with Lane only guaranteeing the bank loan | $70,000 |
Hint
First determine how much additional basis Lane needs, then separate funding methods that create shareholder stock or debt basis from methods that only create indirect economic risk.
Answer D. Lane needs an additional $70,000 of basis (95,000 loss − 25,000 stock basis) to deduct the full Year 1 loss. A $70,000 cash contribution increases Lane's stock basis, and a bona fide loan made directly by Lane to the S corporation creates shareholder debt basis. A mere guarantee of a third‑party loan generally does not create shareholder basis unless and until the shareholder actually makes payments on that debt.
Why not A: Tempting because borrowed money can feel different from a cash contribution, but if Lane personally borrows and then makes a bona fide loan to the S corporation, that direct shareholder loan creates debt basis that can be used to support loss deductions.
Why not B: Looks at the corporation's cash position rather than the shareholder's basis. Shareholder basis increases only from stock contributions or bona fide shareholder loans; the corporation receiving funds under a third‑party loan with only a shareholder guarantee does not automatically increase the shareholder's basis.
Why not C: Attractive because it focuses on economic exposure, but S corporation basis rules distinguish direct shareholder indebtedness from a mere guarantee. A guarantee alone does not usually increase shareholder basis unless the guarantor pays the obligation.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on whether the corporation owes the debt directly to the shareholder, not just whether the shareholder is at risk if the corporation cannot pay.
Answer C. A bona fide direct loan from the shareholder to the S corporation creates shareholder debt basis for the amount loaned, which can be used to absorb S corporation losses. Mere economic exposure (a guarantee or collateral) does not create debt basis unless the shareholder becomes the creditor or pays the obligation. Thus Lynn's direct cash loan increases her debt basis; a guarantee or pledge alone does not.
Why not A: A guarantee creates economic risk but does not make the shareholder a creditor of the S corporation. Shareholder basis generally increases only when the shareholder lends funds or otherwise becomes the creditor or pays the guaranteed debt.
Why not B: Partnership liabilities can affect partner basis, but S corporation liabilities do not automatically increase shareholder basis. Only liabilities owed directly to the shareholder (e.g., shareholder loans) produce debt basis.
Why not D: Providing collateral without becoming the lender leaves the bank as the corporation's creditor. A pledge or collateral support alone does not create shareholder debt basis unless the shareholder actually becomes a creditor or makes a payment on the obligation.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on whose basis must increase and whether the transaction creates direct indebtedness from the S corporation to that shareholder.
Answer A. Kim needs an additional $30,000 of basis to fully deduct her $35,000 allocated loss. A bona fide loan from Kim to the S corporation creates shareholder debt basis (a debt owed to Kim), which, when added to her $5,000 stock basis, permits the full deduction. This accomplishes Kim's goal without changing ownership percentages.
Why not B: A guarantee alone does not give Kim shareholder debt basis at year-end because she has not advanced funds or acquired a debt owed to her by the corporation. Without an actual payment or a direct loan from Kim to Sage, Kim remains limited to her $5,000 stock basis.
Why not C: A cash contribution by Rae increases Rae's basis, not Kim's. Because basis is tracked per shareholder, Rae's contribution would not create additional basis for Kim and thus would not allow Kim to deduct her full allocated loss.
Why not D: S corporations must generally allocate items pro rata on a per-share, per-day basis; they do not permit special or contractual allocations among shareholders like a partnership can. Shareholder agreement cannot properly reallocate S-corp losses away from the statutory pro rata rule.
Question 6
Hint
Ask what actually increases an S corporation shareholder's basis for deducting losses, and whether a personal guarantee alone does that.
Answer C. An S corporation shareholder may deduct losses only to the extent of stock basis plus basis from direct indebtedness of the S corporation to the shareholder. Jordan has $8,000 of stock basis and, under the respected back-to-back shareholder loan, would receive $50,000 of debt basis, allowing a current deduction of $58,000 (with $2,000 suspended). A mere guarantee does not create shareholder debt basis, so under the guarantee Jordan would generally remain limited to $8,000 unless he actually pays on the guarantee.
Why not A: This is tempting because both arrangements expose Jordan to the bank, but economic exposure alone does not create S corporation shareholder debt basis; a guarantee generally does not give the shareholder basis unless he makes payments on the guaranteed debt or otherwise becomes a creditor.
Why not B: Incorrect: corporate borrowing does not increase the shareholder's basis. S corporation loss deductions are limited to the shareholder's own basis; only a bona fide loan from the shareholder to the corporation produces debt basis.
Why not D: Incorrect: a bona fide loan from the shareholder to the S corporation generally creates debt basis when the loan is made, not only when it is repaid, so option (2) would create debt basis in Year 1.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on two issues: how much additional basis Rowan needs, and which actions actually create S corporation basis by the end of the tax year.
Answer D. Rowan needs $52,000 of additional basis (70,000 loss − 18,000 stock basis). A bona fide direct loan from a shareholder to the S corporation creates shareholder debt basis if made before the end of the tax year, which can be used to absorb Year 1 losses. A guarantee alone does not create basis, and waiting until Year 2 would not retroactively increase Year 1 basis.
Why not A: Tempting because a guarantee increases the shareholder's economic exposure, but a bare guarantee generally does not create S corporation basis. Basis arises from direct indebtedness to the shareholder or from the shareholder's actual payment on the guaranteed obligation.
Why not B: A capital contribution would increase stock basis and could absorb losses, but the premise is incorrect: bona fide shareholder debt basis (from a direct loan) also supports S corporation loss deductions. Given Rowan's preference for temporary funding, a loan is the preferable method.
Why not C: Some candidates conflate filing-time mechanics with basis timing, but shareholder basis for S corp losses must exist by the end of the loss year; a Year 2 loan cannot retroactively support Year 1 losses.
Question 8
Hint
Focus on whether the corporation's debt runs directly to the shareholder, not just whether the shareholder is exposed to risk.
Answer B. For S corporation shareholders, debt basis arises from bona fide indebtedness of the corporation that runs directly to the shareholder. A direct loan from Lena to the S corporation creates that debtor-creditor relationship and increases Lena's debt basis, allowing her to deduct pass-through losses to the extent of that basis. Mere guarantees, pledges of personal assets, or co-signing (with the bank remaining the lender) do not create shareholder debt basis unless Lena actually pays the third-party debt and becomes a creditor.
Why not A: This is tempting because a guarantee increases Lena's economic exposure, but the corporation (not Lena) remains indebted to the bank. A guarantee does not create debt owed to Lena, so it generally does not increase shareholder debt basis unless Lena actually pays the third-party debt and obtains a right of repayment.
Why not C: Pledging collateral increases Lena's risk but does not change the party that is the lender. Because the indebtedness remains to the bank rather than to Lena, she does not receive shareholder debt basis merely by providing collateral.
Why not D: Co-signing may make Lena secondarily liable to the bank, but it does not create a direct obligation from the corporation to Lena while the bank remains the creditor. Without a direct loan from Lena or an actual payment that converts the obligation into indebtedness to Lena, debt basis is not increased.
Question 9
Hint
Focus on which option gives the shareholder an actual basis-creating investment or loan to the S corporation, rather than only a contingent obligation.
Answer B. A shareholder's mere guarantee of an S corporation's debt does not, by itself, create shareholder basis. Reed therefore keeps only his existing $12,000 stock basis under the guarantee option and may deduct only that amount of loss. If Reed instead makes a direct $30,000 loan to Maple, he generally receives shareholder debt basis, giving him total basis of $42,000 and allowing the full $35,000 loss deduction, assuming no other limitations apply.
Why not A: This is tempting because Reed is economically exposed under both options. However, for S corporation loss limitation purposes, a contingent liability from guaranteeing corporate debt does not create basis merely because the shareholder might have to pay later. A direct shareholder loan can create debt basis, but a guarantee alone does not.
Why not C: This reverses the actual rule and may appeal to candidates who think a bank loan backed by a personal guarantee is more substantial than a shareholder loan. In reality, the direct loan from Reed to the S corporation is the basis-creating event. The guarantee does not create basis unless Reed actually pays on it and the facts support basis from that payment.
Why not D: This distractor confuses repayment with basis creation and current deductibility. Reed already has $12,000 of stock basis at the start of the year, so some deduction is available immediately. If Reed makes a direct loan, that debt basis generally exists when the loan is made, not only after repayment.
Common questions
Does personally guaranteeing an S corporation loan create debt basis?
No. Leo's unpaid guarantee leaves Pine owing the bank, not Leo. Actual payment can create debt basis when Pine then owes Leo a bona fide repayment obligation.
Does a back-to-back loan create S corporation shareholder basis?
Yes, when Leo borrows personally and actually lends the proceeds to Pine under bona fide debt. Leo need not first repay his personal bank loan.
Can a shareholder loan made after year-end support the prior year's S corporation loss?
No. Leo's Year 2 advance cannot create Year 1 basis, even if he advances the money before filing his Year 1 return.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Tax planning for S corporations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.