PracticeTCPFree practice exam

TCP · Entity Tax Planning · 6 practice questions

S Corporation Passive Income: 25% Rule and S Election Termination

Passive-income termination requires three consecutive years with both year-end accumulated earnings and profits (AE&P) and passive investment income above 25% of gross receipts. Below: follow Cedar through a decision tree to see whether eliminating AE&P prevents termination.

The ruleAn S election terminates the first day after three consecutive taxable years with year-end AE&P and passive investment income exceeding 25% of gross receipts. Validly eliminating AE&P by the third year-end breaks that streak.

Try one first

Cedar, Inc., a calendar-year S corporation and former C corporation, had accumulated earnings and profits at the close of each of the years 20X3 and 20X4 (totaling $180,000 as of January 1, 20X5). Cedar's passive investment income equaled 30% of gross receipts in 20X3, 28% in 20X4, and is projected to equal 27% in 20X5. On or before December 31, 20X5, Cedar can make a cash distribution large enough to eliminate all accumulated earnings and profits. Assume the distribution is otherwise valid, no other changes to earnings and profits occur, Cedar continues to satisfy all other S corporation eligibility rules, and no relief provisions are sought. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Consider whether the statutory tests for termination and the §1375 tax are evaluated with reference to the presence of accumulated earnings and profits at the close of each year and whether eliminating E&P by year-end changes those outcomes.

Decide it in order

  1. T1Cedar is a calendar-year S corporation. Assume no other termination event or relief. After applying the distribution-ordering rules and any valid election, does Cedar have accumulated C corporation earnings and profits (AE&P) at December 31 of Year 3?

    NoYear 3 breaks the streak. Cedar's S election does not terminate under the passive-income rule, even if Year 3 passive investment income exceeds 25%.
  2. T2Does Cedar's Year 3 passive investment income exceed 25% of total gross receipts? With $1,000,000 of gross receipts, $300,000 passes this test; $250,000 is exactly 25% and does not.

    NoYear 3 breaks the streak. Cedar's S election does not terminate under the passive-income rule because Year 3 passive investment income does not exceed 25%.
  3. T3Did Cedar also have both year-end AE&P and passive investment income exceeding 25% of gross receipts in each of Years 1 and 2?

    YesBoth conditions existed in each of three consecutive years. Cedar's S election terminates on January 1 of Year 4.
    NoYear 3 qualifies, but the required three-year streak is incomplete. Cedar's S election does not terminate on January 1 of Year 4 under this rule.

Key points

  • Remember: No AE&P at the third year-end means no completed three-year streak, even if passive investment income exceeds 25%.
  • Divide passive investment income by total gross receipts, not just operating receipts.
  • A year at exactly 25% breaks the streak.
  • Eliminating AE&P must be valid under the distribution-ordering rules; paying cash alone does not establish that AE&P is gone.

How the exam traps you

  • Counting three years above 25% without checking AE&P. Both conditions must exist in each of the three consecutive years.
  • Treating exactly 25% as a qualifying year. The percentage must exceed 25%; equality breaks the streak.
  • Terminating S status during the third qualifying year. Termination begins on the first day of the following taxable year.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Alder, Inc., a calendar-year corporation, was a C corporation through Year 1 and made a valid S election effective Year 2. It began Year 2 with accumulated earnings and profits (E&P) from its C-corporation years. Assume Alder has no S-corporation eligibility defect other than the passive-income rules, and assume all of the interest and royalties below are passive investment income for this purpose. Alder's only gross receipts were:
PeriodConsulting RevenueInterestRoyalties
Year 2$720,000$80,000$200,000
Year 3$890,000$60,000$250,000
Year 4$930,000$70,000$260,000
During Year 4 Alder distributed its accumulated E&P; by 12/31/Year 4 its accumulated E&P had been reduced to zero. (Termination, if triggered, is effective on the first day of the following taxable year.) How should Alder be classified for federal income tax purposes on 1/1/Year 5?
Hint

Compute the passive‑income percentage for each year, then separately confirm whether accumulated E&P existed at the close of each of those year‑ends; recall when termination becomes effective.

Question 3

Maple, Inc. elected S corporation status after operating for years as a C corporation and still has accumulated earnings and profits from its C corporation years. In Year 1, 30% of Maple's gross receipts are passive investment income. Assume Maple has no other S corporation eligibility problems. Which statement best describes the limiting condition on whether Maple's S election terminates because of this passive income issue?
Hint

Focus on what additional facts must exist before passive investment income can actually end S status, not just trigger concern in one year.

Question 4

Harbor, Inc., a calendar-year corporation, has a valid S election and retained accumulated earnings and profits from years it was previously a C corporation. At the close of Years 1 and 2, Harbor had accumulated C-corporation earnings and profits, and in each of those years more than 25% of its gross receipts consisted of interest and dividend income. In Year 3, more than 25% of Harbor's gross receipts again consisted of interest and dividend income. Before 12/31/Year 3, Harbor made a distribution that, under the S‑corporation ordering rules, reduced its accumulated C‑corporation earnings and profits to zero by the close of Year 3. Assume all other S‑corporation eligibility requirements are satisfied. What is the most likely effect on Harbor's S election under the three‑year excess passive‑income rule?
Hint

Identify every statutory condition of the three‑year excess passive‑income rule, both the passive‑income percentage and the presence of accumulated C‑corp E&P at each year's close.

Question 5

Lakeview, Inc. is a valid S corporation that has accumulated earnings and profits (AE&P) from prior C corporation years. In Year 1 and Year 2, passive investment income exceeded 25% of gross receipts. Management projects that passive investment income will again exceed 25% of gross receipts in Year 3. At the beginning of Year 3, Lakeview has an accumulated adjustments account (AAA) balance of $180,000 and AE&P of $70,000. Assume shareholder stock basis is sufficient, the corporation wants to preserve its S election, and no relief provision applies. Which action taken before the close of Year 3 is the most appropriate tax-planning step to avoid automatic termination under the passive-investment-income rules?
Hint

Remember both prongs of the passive‑income termination rule (three consecutive years above the 25% threshold plus AE&P at year‑end) and that distributions ordinarily reduce AAA before AE&P; consider whether an election or required consents can change that ordering.

Question 6

Redwood, Inc., a calendar-year corporation, made a valid S election effective January 1, Year 1 after previously operating as a C corporation. Redwood had accumulated C corporation earnings and profits (E&P) on January 1, Year 1. Redwood's passive investment income exceeded 25% of its gross receipts in each of Years 1 through 4. On December 20, Year 2, Redwood distributed enough cash to eliminate all accumulated C corporation E&P; it had no accumulated C corporation E&P at the close of Years 2, 3, or 4. Assume all other S corporation requirements are satisfied and no relief provisions apply. Under the passive-investment-income termination rules, when, if at all, does Redwood's S election terminate?
Hint

Remember both (1) passive investment income >25% of gross receipts and (2) accumulated C corporation E&P at the close of the year must exist for three consecutive taxable years; if met, termination is effective the first day of the taxable year following the third such year.

Drill all 115 Tax planning for S corporations questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does passive investment income of exactly 25% terminate an S election?

No. Passive investment income must exceed 25% of gross receipts. A year at exactly 25% interrupts the required three-year streak.

Can an S corporation avoid passive-income termination by distributing AE&P?

Yes. Validly eliminating all AE&P by the third year-end prevents that year from completing the required streak, even if passive investment income exceeds 25%.

When does an S election terminate after three years of excess passive income?

Termination begins on the first day of the following taxable year if both conditions existed in all three consecutive years. For Cedar, a calendar-year corporation, a qualifying Years 1 through 3 streak means termination on January 1 of Year 4.

Practice TCP like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Tax planning for S corporations

All Tax planning for S corporations practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.