TCP · Entity Tax Planning · 6 practice questions
S Corporation Passive Income: 25% Rule and S Election Termination
Passive-income termination requires three consecutive years with both year-end accumulated earnings and profits (AE&P) and passive investment income above 25% of gross receipts. Below: follow Cedar through a decision tree to see whether eliminating AE&P prevents termination.
Try one first
Hint
Consider whether the statutory tests for termination and the §1375 tax are evaluated with reference to the presence of accumulated earnings and profits at the close of each year and whether eliminating E&P by year-end changes those outcomes.
Answer A. Under IRC 1362(d)(3), termination for excess passive investment income requires both (1) passive investment income in excess of 25% of gross receipts for three consecutive years and (2) accumulated earnings and profits at the close of each of those years. Because Cedar had E&P at the close of 20X3 and 20X4 and is projected to meet the passive-income percentages in 20X5, the third-year close-of-year E&P condition is critical. Eliminating all E&P on or before December 31, 20X5 means the corporation would not have E&P at the close of 20X5, so the statutory condition for termination would not be met; Sec. 1375 likewise applies only if year-end E&P exist, so no excess net passive income tax would be due for 20X5 if E&P are eliminated by year-end.
Why not B: This choice correctly recalls the '25% for three years' trigger but ignores the separate statutory requirement that the corporation have accumulated earnings and profits at the close of each of those years; a year-end elimination of E&P defeats that second condition for the third year.
Why not C: This distractor rests on the incorrect assumption that the test is evaluated at the start of the third year. The statutory inquiry looks to whether E&P existed at the close of each year; eliminating E&P by December 31, 20X5 addresses the close-of-year condition for the third year.
Why not D: This option correctly notes that the §1375 tax depends on year-end E&P but is incorrect to say termination is unaffected; the three-year termination test also requires year-end E&P, so eliminating E&P by year-end can prevent both outcomes.
Decide it in order
T1Cedar is a calendar-year S corporation. Assume no other termination event or relief. After applying the distribution-ordering rules and any valid election, does Cedar have accumulated C corporation earnings and profits (AE&P) at December 31 of Year 3?
YesGo to T2NoYear 3 breaks the streak. Cedar's S election does not terminate under the passive-income rule, even if Year 3 passive investment income exceeds 25%.T2Does Cedar's Year 3 passive investment income exceed 25% of total gross receipts? With $1,000,000 of gross receipts, $300,000 passes this test; $250,000 is exactly 25% and does not.
YesGo to T3NoYear 3 breaks the streak. Cedar's S election does not terminate under the passive-income rule because Year 3 passive investment income does not exceed 25%.T3Did Cedar also have both year-end AE&P and passive investment income exceeding 25% of gross receipts in each of Years 1 and 2?
YesBoth conditions existed in each of three consecutive years. Cedar's S election terminates on January 1 of Year 4.NoYear 3 qualifies, but the required three-year streak is incomplete. Cedar's S election does not terminate on January 1 of Year 4 under this rule.
Key points
- Remember: No AE&P at the third year-end means no completed three-year streak, even if passive investment income exceeds 25%.
- Divide passive investment income by total gross receipts, not just operating receipts.
- A year at exactly 25% breaks the streak.
- Eliminating AE&P must be valid under the distribution-ordering rules; paying cash alone does not establish that AE&P is gone.
How the exam traps you
- Counting three years above 25% without checking AE&P. Both conditions must exist in each of the three consecutive years.
- Treating exactly 25% as a qualifying year. The percentage must exceed 25%; equality breaks the streak.
- Terminating S status during the third qualifying year. Termination begins on the first day of the following taxable year.
Question 2
| Period | Consulting Revenue | Interest | Royalties |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 2 | $720,000 | $80,000 | $200,000 |
| Year 3 | $890,000 | $60,000 | $250,000 |
| Year 4 | $930,000 | $70,000 | $260,000 |
Hint
Compute the passive‑income percentage for each year, then separately confirm whether accumulated E&P existed at the close of each of those year‑ends; recall when termination becomes effective.
Answer B. Alder's passive receipts exceeded 25% of gross receipts in Years 2-4 (Year 2: 280/1,000 = 28.0%; Year 3: 310/1,200 ≈ 25.8%; Year 4: 330/1,260 ≈ 26.2%), so the three-year passive-income criterion was met. However, the termination rule also requires accumulated E&P to be present at the close of each of those three consecutive years; Alder's accumulated E&P was reduced to zero by 12/31/Year 4, so the accumulated‑E&P condition failed. Because termination (if it occurs) is effective on the first day of the following taxable year, Alder did not terminate and remains an S corporation on 1/1/Year 5.
Why not A: This choice correctly notes the three consecutive years of excess passive income and that Alder began Year 2 with C‑E&P, which makes it tempting. It is wrong because the rule also requires accumulated E&P to be present at the close of each of the three years; Alder had no accumulated E&P at 12/31/Year 4.
Why not C: This distractor lures candidates who treat the occurrence of the third excess passive year as decisive. It is incorrect because termination is effective only on the first day of the following taxable year, and in any event Alder lacked accumulated E&P at the close of Year 4.
Why not D: This choice reflects a common sequencing error: the passive‑income termination requires three consecutive taxable years with excess passive receipts (and accumulated E&P at each year‑end), not two; therefore two years cannot cause termination.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on what additional facts must exist before passive investment income can actually end S status, not just trigger concern in one year.
Answer B. An S corporation's election is not terminated merely because passive investment income exceeds 25% of gross receipts in a single year. Under IRC §1362(d)(3), termination occurs only when the corporation has accumulated earnings and profits and passive investment income exceeds 25% of gross receipts for three consecutive taxable years. A single year over the threshold may instead trigger the excess net passive income tax, but it does not by itself end S status.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates recall the 25% threshold, but wrong: termination requires that the 25% threshold be exceeded for three consecutive years while accumulated earnings and profits exist, not a single year.
Why not C: This distractor misstates the numeric threshold. The relevant cutoff is 25%, not 50%; however, exceeding 25% in one year still does not automatically terminate S status without the three-year/E&P condition.
Why not D: This choice confuses distribution mechanics with termination rules. The accumulated adjustments account affects shareholder distribution tax treatment, but failing to distribute AAA does not control whether an S election terminates for excess passive income.
Question 4
Hint
Identify every statutory condition of the three‑year excess passive‑income rule, both the passive‑income percentage and the presence of accumulated C‑corp E&P at each year's close.
Answer A. The statutory three‑year excess passive‑income termination rule requires both (1) more than 25% of gross receipts from passive investment income and (2) positive accumulated C‑corporation earnings and profits at the close of each of three consecutive taxable years (see IRC §1362(d)(3)). Harbor met the passive‑income condition for Years 1-3, but it had no accumulated C‑corp E&P at the close of Year 3 because the E&P were distributed earlier in Year 3. Because the E&P condition for Year 3 is not met, the three‑year test is not satisfied and the S election does not terminate under that rule.
Why not B: Even if the three‑year test were satisfied, termination under that rule is effective at the beginning of the fourth taxable year (1/1/Year 4), not immediately on 12/31 of the third; additionally, Harbor did not have the required E&P at the close of Year 3, so the test fails.
Why not C: This choice appeals to recall of the 'three consecutive years' trigger but omits the second required element: accumulated C‑corp E&P at the close of each year. Harbor lacked E&P at the close of Year 3, so the statutory test was not met.
Why not D: Inadvertent‑termination relief can cure certain terminations, but it applies only if a termination has in fact occurred or is treated as having occurred. On these facts there was no termination under the three‑year passive‑income rule to cure, so relief is not the appropriate remedy.
Question 5
Hint
Remember both prongs of the passive‑income termination rule (three consecutive years above the 25% threshold plus AE&P at year‑end) and that distributions ordinarily reduce AAA before AE&P; consider whether an election or required consents can change that ordering.
Answer B. The S‑status termination rule is triggered if a corporation has AE&P at the close of each of three consecutive years during which passive investment income exceeds 25% of gross receipts. Because Lakeview already had two prior years above the 25% threshold, it must eliminate AE&P before the close of Year 3 to avoid automatic termination. Under the default distribution ordering, distributions reduce AAA before AE&P, so the corporation should make the election provided for in the distribution‑ordering rules (obtain any shareholder consents required by section 1368(e)(3)) to have a Year 3 distribution treated as from AE&P and distribute at least $70,000 before year‑end to purge the AE&P.
Why not A: This matches the AE&P amount, but under the default ordering distributions reduce AAA first; a $70,000 distribution under normal ordering would leave the $70,000 of AE&P intact and would not prevent automatic termination if passive income again exceeds 25% at year‑end.
Why not C: This confuses the mechanics: simply reducing AAA below AE&P does not eliminate AE&P. The termination test looks to whether AE&P exists at the close of the third consecutive passive‑income year, so this step would not necessarily purge AE&P.
Why not D: The applicable threshold is more than 25% of gross receipts, not 50%. Because Lakeview already had two prior years above that threshold, doing nothing in a third such year while AE&P remains risks automatic termination.
Question 6
Hint
Remember both (1) passive investment income >25% of gross receipts and (2) accumulated C corporation E&P at the close of the year must exist for three consecutive taxable years; if met, termination is effective the first day of the taxable year following the third such year.
Answer C. Both conditions for passive-income termination must coexist for three consecutive taxable years: (1) passive investment income in excess of 25% of gross receipts and (2) accumulated C corporation E&P present at the close of each of those years. If both conditions are met for three consecutive years, the S election terminates effective on the first day of the taxable year following the third year. Here, although passive income exceeded 25% in Years 1-4, Redwood eliminated its accumulated C E&P on December 20, Year 2 and had no accumulated C E&P at the close of Years 2, 3, or 4, so the two conditions never coexisted for three consecutive years and the S election does not terminate.
Why not A: This is tempting because Redwood had accumulated E&P at the start of Year 1 and passive income was high in Years 1-2, but termination requires the two conditions to be present for three consecutive taxable years, not just two.
Why not B: This lures candidates who focus on a three-year passive-income streak (Years 1-3). However, the rule also requires accumulated C E&P at the close of each of those years; Redwood eliminated its accumulated E&P before the close of Year 2, so that requirement is not met.
Why not D: This assumes the relevant three-year period was Years 2-4. Even though passive income was high in Years 2-4, Redwood had no accumulated C E&P at the close of those years, so the combined condition required for termination never occurred.
Common questions
Does passive investment income of exactly 25% terminate an S election?
No. Passive investment income must exceed 25% of gross receipts. A year at exactly 25% interrupts the required three-year streak.
Can an S corporation avoid passive-income termination by distributing AE&P?
Yes. Validly eliminating all AE&P by the third year-end prevents that year from completing the required streak, even if passive investment income exceeds 25%.
When does an S election terminate after three years of excess passive income?
Termination begins on the first day of the following taxable year if both conditions existed in all three consecutive years. For Cedar, a calendar-year corporation, a qualifying Years 1 through 3 streak means termination on January 1 of Year 4.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Tax planning for S corporations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.