TCP · Entity Tax Planning · 6 practice questions
S Corporation Built-In Gains Tax: The 5-Year Period
The built-in gains tax can apply during the five-year period beginning on the S election's effective date. Below, Oak's timeline compares a late-fifth-year sale with an alternative sale just after the period ends.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on two steps: first decide whether each sale date falls inside the 5-year recognition period, then determine how much of the gain existed on the S election date.
Answer D. The section 1374 built-in gains tax can apply to appreciated C-corporation assets sold during the 5-year recognition period beginning on the first day of the first S year (here, Jan 1, 20X2 through Dec 31, 20X6). A sale on December 30, 20X6 is inside that period, and the tax applies only to the gain that existed on the S election date: FMV $700,000 less basis $300,000 = $400,000. The additional $60,000 of appreciation after the election is not subject to the built-in gains tax; a January 3, 20X7 sale is outside the recognition period and therefore would not trigger the tax.
Why not A: This reverses the rule. Section 1374 targets appreciation that existed on the S election date (pre-election built-in gain), not appreciation that accrued after the election; the $60,000 post-election increase is not subject to the built-in gains tax.
Why not B: This is tempting because the asset was owned at conversion, but section 1374 limits the built-in gains tax to the gain that was built in on the S election date (here $400,000). Later appreciation (the $60,000) is excluded from built-in gain, and the recognition period expires after five years.
Why not C: While S corporations generally pass through income, the built-in gains tax is a statutory exception that can impose corporate-level tax on dispositions of appreciated C-corp assets sold during the recognition period. A sale inside the period can therefore trigger entity-level tax on built-in gain.
The timeline
- January 1, 20X2Oak's S election becomes effective; the five-year clock starts.
Oak is a calendar-year former C corporation holding appreciated land. Assume no other built-in gain or loss items, no carryovers, and no taxable income limitation reducing the BIG tax.
- December 30, 20X6Oak's earlier proposed closing date.
This date is inside the recognition period, so the sale can trigger corporate-level built-in gains tax.
- December 31, 20X6The fifth S year and recognition period end.
This is the final day inside the period. A sale on this date would still be inside.
- January 3, 20X7Oak's alternative proposed closing date.
This sale replaces, rather than follows, the December sale. It falls outside the recognition period and does not trigger BIG tax.
Key points
- Remember: The fifth S year is still inside the period; the sixth S year is outside for Oak's calendar-year election.
- Start the clock on the S election's effective date, not the sale date.
- Compare the sale date with the recognition period's final day.
How the exam traps you
- Treating the fifth S year as outside the recognition period. Oak's period includes all of 20X6 and ends December 31, 20X6.
- Assuming ownership on the election date makes every later sale subject to BIG tax. Oak's January 3, 20X7 sale is outside the period and does not trigger BIG tax.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on the special corporate-level exception that can apply after a C corporation becomes an S corporation, and ask what timing matters most.
Answer C. Under current law (IRC §1374), an S corporation may be subject to a corporate-level built-in gains tax on gain recognized during the five-year recognition period following a C-to-S conversion to the extent that the gain was built in on the election date. The most reliable way to avoid that tax on pre-election appreciation is to wait until after the five-year recognition period to recognize the gain. A sale on February 1, Year 6 clearly occurs after the recognition period that began January 1, Year 1.
Why not A: This is tempting because S corporations normally pass income through to shareholders, but the built-in gains tax is a specific corporate-level exception for appreciation that existed on the S election date and is triggered if the corporation recognizes that built-in gain during the five-year recognition period. A sale on December 31, Year 3 is still within that period and could produce corporate-level tax.
Why not B: This distractor appeals to the idea that pushing cash out to shareholders shifts the tax burden, but the built-in gains tax is triggered when the corporation recognizes the gain on the sale. Selling in Year 2 would cause the corporation to recognize built-in gain during the recognition period; distributing the cash afterward does not eliminate that corporate-level tax exposure.
Why not D: This traps candidates who overgeneralize that distributions avoid corporate recognition. In fact, a distribution of appreciated property generally causes the corporation to recognize gain (as if sold at fair market value) under the tax rules; if that recognition occurs during the recognition period, it can give rise to the built-in gains tax.
Question 3
Hint
Separate the total gain on sale from the amount of gain that already existed on the S-election date, then ask whether the sale year falls inside the recognition period.
Answer B. On the S-election date Orchid had a built-in gain of $400,000 (fair value $900,000 minus tax basis $500,000). Because the prospective 20X5 sale would occur during the recognition period after the S election, corporate-level built-in gains tax could apply to that pre-election $400,000. The remaining $200,000 of post-election appreciation is not part of the built-in gain subject to corporate-level tax.
Why not A: This is tempting because former C corporations can face corporate-level tax on certain gains after conversion, but the built-in gains tax applies only to the gain that existed on the conversion (the $400,000 built-in gain). Post-election appreciation ($200,000 here) is not part of the built-in gain subject to that tax.
Why not C: This distractor relies on the general pass-through rule for S corporations. The exception is the built-in gains tax, which can create a corporate-level tax on pre-election appreciation recognized during the recognition period, so timing can matter even though Orchid is now an S corporation.
Why not D: This mixes in another former‑C issue (tax consequences tied to passive investment income), but built-in gains tax is a separate rule that does not require passive investment income or accumulated E&P; it focuses on pre-election built-in gain and whether it is recognized during the recognition period.
Question 4
Hint
Compute total gain first, then separate the appreciation that existed on the S election date from the appreciation that arose afterward.
Answer B. The total recognized gain is $560,000 ($760,000 sale price − $200,000 basis). Built-in gain for a former C corporation is the appreciation that existed on the S election date, here $700,000 − $200,000 = $500,000, and that amount is subject to corporate-level built-in gains tax if recognized during the recognition period. The remaining $60,000 of appreciation occurred after the S election and is not built-in gain (it passes through under S treatment).
Why not A: This is tempting because an S election generally avoids C-level tax on later income, but it overlooks the built-in gains rule: pre-election appreciation recognized during the recognition period can still trigger corporate-level tax.
Why not C: This distractor mistakes the rule's scope: built-in gains tax applies only to the appreciation that existed on the S election date (the $500,000), not to post-election appreciation.
Why not D: This reverses the rule: the built-in gains tax targets pre-election appreciation recognized in the recognition period, not appreciation accruing after the S election, which is taxed through the S pass-through.
Question 5
Hint
Count five years from January 1, 20X1, and remember that distributions or liquidations can themselves create corporate recognition of appreciated property.
Answer A. The Sec. 1374 recognition period runs five years from the first day the S election is effective (here, January 1, 20X1 through December 31, 20X5). A sale on January 15, 20X6 occurs after that five‑year period, so pre‑election built‑in gain recognized on that sale generally would not be subject to the corporate‑level built‑in gains tax.
Why not B: This misapplies distribution rules. Corporations generally recognize gain on the distribution of appreciated property (so a distribution can be a recognition event); if that recognition is attributable to pre‑election appreciation and occurs during the recognition period, Sec. 1374 can apply.
Why not C: Tempting because candidates may think the fifth S year is outside the five‑year window. It is incorrect: the five‑year recognition period runs from 1/1/20X1 through 12/31/20X5, so a sale on 12/15/20X5 is inside the period and could trigger Sec. 1374.
Why not D: Some may think liquidation avoids corporate tax, but a complete liquidation typically causes the corporation to recognize gain on distributed assets. Because the liquidation date here is within the recognition period, any recognized pre‑election built‑in gain could still be subject to Sec. 1374.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the analysis into two steps: first decide whether the sale date falls inside the built-in gains recognition period, then determine how much of the gain was already built in on the S-election date.
Answer C. A sale on December 31, Year 4 occurs within the 5-year built-in gains recognition period, so corporate-level built-in gains tax can apply. The realized gain would be $900,000 - $300,000 = $600,000, but the built-in-gains tax is limited to the pre-election built-in gain, which is $800,000 - $300,000 = $500,000. A sale on January 2, Year 6 is outside the recognition period, so the corporate-level built-in gains tax would not apply.
Why not A: This choice both uses the total gain rather than the pre-election built-in gain for the inside-period sale and incorrectly asserts that the pre-election built-in gain remains subject to tax after the recognition period; the built-in-gains tax only applies to gains recognized within the recognition period and is capped at the pre-election appreciation.
Why not B: Tempting because $600,000 is the total recognized gain on the Year 4 sale, but the built-in-gains tax is capped at the net unrealized built-in gain that existed on the S-election date ($800,000 - $300,000 = $500,000), not the full post-election appreciation.
Why not D: Incorrect because while S corporations are generally pass-throughs, a former C corporation that held appreciated assets at conversion can face a corporate-level built-in-gains tax if those assets are sold during the recognition period.
Common questions
When does the S corporation built-in gains recognition period start?
It starts on the S election's effective date. Oak's election takes effect January 1, 20X2, so its five-year period ends December 31, 20X6.
Is a sale in the fifth S year subject to built-in gains tax?
It can be. Oak's December 30, 20X6 sale is in its fifth S year and remains inside the recognition period.
Does selling after the five-year period avoid built-in gains tax?
Yes, for Oak's sale. Its alternative January 3, 20X7 sale falls after the period ends and does not trigger corporate-level built-in gains tax.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Tax planning for S corporations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.