TCP · Entity Tax Planning · 6 practice questions
S Corporation Stock and Debt Basis Ordering
S corporation distributions reduce stock basis before losses, so a tax-free distribution can still limit the loss deduction. Below, a worked calculation tracks stock and debt basis separately through the required annual order.
Try one first
Hint
Do not net the year's items informally. Compute S corporation stock basis in the required annual adjustment order.
Answer C. Adjust stock basis in the required annual order: increase for income items, then decrease for distributions, then decrease for nondeductible expenses, and finally decrease for losses. Basis increases from $12,000 to $17,000 for the $4,000 taxable interest income and $1,000 tax-exempt income, then drops to $7,000 after the $10,000 distribution and to $5,000 after the $2,000 nondeductible expenses. Because only $5,000 of basis remains before the ordinary loss, Jordan may deduct $5,000 of the $8,000 loss and must suspend $3,000; the distribution is nontaxable because it did not exceed basis at the distribution step.
Why not A: This choice ignores that nondeductible expenses also reduce stock basis before losses are allowed. After the distribution, Jordan must still reduce basis by the $2,000 nondeductible expenses, leaving only $5,000 of basis for the loss.
Why not B: This is tempting if a candidate reduces basis for the ordinary loss before applying the cash distribution. That ordering is incorrect for annual S corporation stock-basis adjustments. Income items are applied first, then distributions, so the distribution here does not produce gain and the loss is not fully deductible.
Why not D: This reflects failing to include the $1,000 tax-exempt income as a basis increase. Including the tax-exempt income raises basis available for the loss from $4,000 to $5,000, allowing a larger current deduction.
Worked example
Avery's S corporation has no accumulated earnings and profits. Beginning stock basis is $20,000; direct shareholder loan basis is $5,000. Year 1: taxable interest $4,000; tax-exempt interest $2,000; cash distribution $12,000; nondeductible, noncapital expenses $3,000; ordinary loss $18,000. No other adjustments or loan repayments occur. Assume no losses-first election and no other loss limitations.
| 1 | Increase stock basis for income$20,000 + $4,000 + $2,000 = $26,000 | $26,000 stock basis |
| 2 | Subtract the cash distribution$26,000 - $12,000 = $14,000; the distribution does not exceed stock basis. | $14,000 stock basis; no distribution gain |
| 3 | Subtract nondeductible expenses$14,000 - $3,000 = $11,000 | $11,000 stock basis before losses |
| 4 | Apply losses to stock basis first$18,000 loss - $11,000 stock basis = $7,000 remaining loss | $11,000 loss allowed; stock basis $0 |
| 5 | Apply remaining losses to debt basis$7,000 remaining loss - $5,000 debt basis = $2,000 unsupported loss | $5,000 additional loss allowed; debt basis $0 |
| 6 | Total the current loss deduction$11,000 + $5,000 = $16,000 | $16,000 deductible loss |
| 7 | Determine the suspended loss$18,000 - $16,000 = $2,000 | $2,000 basis-suspended loss |
Avery's $12,000 distribution is tax-free, $16,000 of the ordinary loss is deductible, and $2,000 is suspended; ending stock and debt basis are both zero.
Check: Combined basis available for losses is $25,000 beginning basis + $6,000 income - $12,000 distribution - $3,000 nondeductible expenses = $16,000.
Key points
- Tax-exempt interest increases stock basis even though it is not taxable.
- The cash distribution is tax-free because it does not exceed stock basis after income adjustments.
- Keep loan basis separate: it supports losses, not cash distributions.
- The $2,000 basis-suspended loss carries forward until sufficient basis becomes available.
How the exam traps you
- Ignoring the distribution and deducting the full $18,000 loss. Subtract the distribution before testing losses; only $16,000 of combined basis remains.
- Omitting tax-exempt interest and limiting the deduction to $14,000. Add the $2,000 tax-exempt interest to stock basis before subtracting distributions.
- Using only stock basis and deducting $11,000. After exhausting stock basis, use the $5,000 direct shareholder loan basis for additional losses.
Question 2
Hint
For S corporation losses, start by identifying every basis amount the shareholder can use before worrying about the total loss reported.
Answer A. A shareholder's deductible S corporation loss is limited by the shareholder's combined stock basis and eligible debt basis, assuming no other limitation applies. Reed has $18,000 of stock basis and $7,000 of debt basis, for a total of $25,000 available to absorb the Year 1 loss. The remaining $5,000 is suspended until basis is restored.
Why not B: This is tempting if a candidate remembers that stock basis matters but forgets that direct shareholder loan basis can also support loss deductions. Here, the facts specifically state Reed has $7,000 of bona fide direct debt basis, so Reed is not limited to stock basis alone.
Why not C: This choice reflects the common mistake of deducting the full passed-through loss without applying the basis limitation. Even though the S corporation reports a $30,000 ordinary loss, Reed can currently deduct only the amount supported by stock basis plus eligible debt basis.
Why not D: This is tempting if a candidate overfocuses on debt basis and ignores stock basis, or incorrectly thinks the loan basis is the only amount available once losses are involved. In fact, losses are absorbed by stock basis first and then by eligible debt basis, so both amounts matter here.
Question 3
Hint
Work in two steps: (1) allocate the distribution by source (default: AAA first, then accumulated E&P), and (2) within the AAA portion apply the shareholder's stock basis to separate tax‑free return of capital from capital gain.
Answer C. Under the default ordering for S‑corporation distributions, amounts are treated as coming first from the AAA and then from accumulated (pre‑S) E&P absent an election to alter that ordering. Of the $55,000 distribution, $40,000 is treated as from AAA: $18,000 of that is a tax‑free return of capital (reducing Lila's basis to zero) and the remaining $22,000 of AAA is taxable as capital gain. The remaining $15,000 (55,000 − 40,000) is attributable to accumulated E&P and is dividend income.
Why not A: This is tempting because AAA distributions are often nontaxable, but nontaxable treatment is limited by the shareholder's basis. Here AAA ($40,000) exceeds Lila's basis ($18,000), so $22,000 of the AAA portion is taxable as capital gain.
Why not B: This reflects the common error of applying the shareholder's basis to the entire distribution first and then treating the next $25,000 as dividend; it ignores the default sequencing that treats distributions as coming from AAA before accumulated E&P, which causes the AAA excess over basis to be capital gain in this fact pattern.
Why not D: This treats the entire excess over basis as capital gain and ignores pre‑S accumulated E&P. After allocating $40,000 to AAA, $15,000 of the $55,000 distribution remains that is attributable to accumulated E&P and must be treated as dividend income.
Question 4
Hint
Work the S corporation stock basis in the required order for a year that includes both tax-exempt income, a shareholder distribution, and a loss.
Answer B. Begin with $15,000 basis. Tax-exempt interest increases basis by $3,000 to $18,000. The $14,000 nondividend distribution then reduces basis to $4,000, and losses are applied after distributions, so only $4,000 of the $20,000 loss is currently deductible (the remaining $16,000 is suspended). Because the distribution did not exceed basis at the distribution step, no taxable gain arises.
Why not A: This mistakes the ordering of adjustments. Although tax-exempt income raises basis to $18,000, distributions are applied before losses; the $14,000 distribution does not exceed basis at that step (leaving $4,000), so it does not create gain and only $4,000 of the loss is deductible.
Why not C: This reflects an incorrect ordering or omission of the tax-exempt increase (for example, subtracting the distribution from the $15,000 beginning basis before adding the $3,000 tax-exempt item). Tax-exempt income increases basis before the distribution is applied, so the distribution leaves $4,000 of basis, not $1,000.
Why not D: This assumes losses are applied against beginning basis before the distribution. In reality the distribution reduces basis before losses are taken; after the $3,000 increase and the $14,000 distribution only $4,000 of basis remains to absorb the loss.
Question 5
Hint
Track stock basis and debt basis separately, and be careful about which year-end adjustment happens first in an S corporation loss year.
Answer B. Nondividend distributions reduce stock basis before losses and deductions are applied. The $10,000 distribution reduces Omar's stock basis from $15,000 to $5,000 (no gain because there are no earnings and profits and the distribution does not exceed stock basis). The $30,000 ordinary loss is then deductible to the extent of the remaining $5,000 stock basis plus the $20,000 debt basis, so $25,000 is deductible and $5,000 is suspended.
Why not A: Tempting because combined basis (15k + 20k) exceeds the loss, but incorrect because distributions reduce stock basis before loss items are applied. The $10,000 distribution reduces stock basis first, leaving only $25,000 of basis available for the loss.
Why not C: This reflects the common error of applying losses before distributions. Under S-corp basis ordering, the nondividend distribution reduces stock basis first; because there is still stock basis remaining at distribution time, no gain is recognized and more loss (through debt basis) remains deductible.
Why not D: Incorrect, bona fide direct shareholder debt basis can be used to absorb S corp losses once stock basis is exhausted. Here Omar's debt basis of $20,000 is available after stock basis is reduced by the distribution.
Question 6
Hint
First compute Nora's available stock basis immediately before applying the ordinary loss, remember tax-exempt income increases basis and distributions reduce it.
Answer A. Adjust stock basis before applying the loss: beginning basis $22,000 + $3,000 tax-exempt income − $8,000 distribution = $17,000 available stock basis. The $41,000 ordinary loss exceeds that available basis by $24,000; Nora needs $24,000 of debt basis from a bona fide shareholder loan outstanding at year-end to deduct the remaining loss currently.
Why not B: $19,000 comes from simply subtracting beginning stock basis ($22,000) from the $41,000 loss. That is tempting for its simplicity, but it fails to adjust basis for the $3,000 tax-exempt income (which increases basis) and the $8,000 distribution (which decreases basis).
Why not C: $16,000 is tempting because adding the $3,000 tax-exempt income to beginning basis gives $25,000 and $41,000 − $25,000 = $16,000. It's wrong because it ignores the $8,000 cash distribution, which reduces stock basis before applying the loss.
Why not D: $27,000 results if one subtracts the $8,000 distribution from beginning basis (22,000 − 8,000 = 14,000) and then subtracts that from the loss. It's wrong because it omits the $3,000 tax-exempt income, which raises basis and reduces the required loan to $24,000.
Common questions
Do S corporation distributions reduce basis before losses?
Yes. Here, the distribution reduces stock basis to $14,000 before nondeductible expenses reduce it to $11,000; losses come last.
Does tax-exempt income increase S corporation stock basis?
Yes. The $2,000 tax-exempt interest increases stock basis along with the $4,000 taxable interest, bringing stock basis to $26,000 before the distribution.
Can shareholder debt basis support an S corporation loss deduction?
Yes. After the loss uses the remaining $11,000 stock basis, the direct shareholder loan basis supports another $5,000 deduction. The remaining $2,000 loss is suspended.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Tax planning for S corporations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.