TCP · Entity Tax Compliance · 6 practice questions
S Corporation Basis: Cash Distributions Before Losses
Cash distributions use stock basis before losses, while losses can use remaining stock basis plus qualifying debt basis. Below: a worked calculation showing why a shareholder can recognize distribution gain and still deduct a loss.
Try one first
Hint
Track S corporation stock basis in the required order: increases first, then nondividend distributions, then loss and deduction items.
Answer A. Tax-exempt income increases Nina's stock basis from $30,000 to $38,000. Nonliquidating distributions reduce basis next, so the $25,000 distribution lowers basis to $13,000 and is not taxable (Pine has no accumulated E&P). Losses are applied after distributions, so only $13,000 of the $22,000 loss is deductible in Year 1 and the remaining $9,000 is suspended.
Why not B: This assumes losses are deductible against beginning basis plus tax-exempt income without accounting for the required ordering. Distributions reduce basis before loss/deduction items, so after the $25,000 distribution only $13,000 of basis remains to support the loss.
Why not C: This reflects forgetting that tax-exempt income increases stock basis. If the $8,000 tax-exempt interest were ignored, the basis after the $25,000 distribution would appear to be only $5,000; since tax-exempt income does increase basis, the correct available basis for the loss is $13,000.
Why not D: This comes from applying the loss before the distribution (or otherwise misordering items): if one subtracts the $22,000 loss from the $38,000 basis first, basis would be $16,000 and a subsequent $25,000 distribution would appear to exceed basis by $9,000. That ordering is incorrect, S corporation basis is increased first, then distributions, then losses, so the entire $25,000 distribution is absorbed and not taxable.
Worked example
Alex owns Elm, an S corporation with no accumulated earnings and profits. Beginning stock basis is $24,000; unreduced basis in a bona fide direct loan is $10,000. Elm reports $6,000 of tax-exempt interest, distributes $34,000 cash, and passes through a $16,000 ordinary loss. There are no other items or loan repayments. Alex holds the stock as a capital asset; no other loss limits apply.
| 1 | Increase stock basis for tax-exempt interest$24,000 + $6,000 | $30,000 |
| 2 | Find the tax-free distributionLesser of $34,000 cash or $30,000 stock basis | $30,000 |
| 3 | Calculate capital gain on the distribution$34,000 - $30,000 | $4,000 |
| 4 | Find remaining stock basis$30,000 - $30,000 | $0 |
| 5 | Apply the loss limitationLesser of $16,000 loss or ($0 stock basis + $10,000 debt basis) | $10,000 deductible |
| 6 | Calculate the suspended loss$16,000 - $10,000 | $6,000 suspended |
| 7 | Reduce loan basis for the deducted loss$10,000 - $10,000 | $0 ending debt basis |
Alex recognizes $4,000 of capital gain, deducts $10,000 of ordinary loss, and suspends $6,000. Ending stock and debt basis are both zero.
Check: The $34,000 distribution is $10,000 above beginning stock basis, but tax-exempt interest closes $6,000 of that gap; only the $10,000 loan basis remains for losses.
Key points
- Debt basis cannot shelter a cash distribution.
- Deductible losses reduce stock basis first, then debt basis.
- Basis cannot fall below zero; losses exceeding available basis are suspended.
How the exam traps you
- Pooling stock and debt basis to make the entire distribution tax-free. Compare the distribution with stock basis alone. Alex recognizes $4,000 of capital gain.
- Ignoring tax-exempt interest because it is not taxable. Add the $6,000 to stock basis before testing the distribution.
- Deducting the ordinary loss before testing the distribution. Apply the distribution first, then use remaining stock basis and loan basis for the loss.
Question 2
Hint
Separate what increases stock basis from what creates debt basis, and be careful not to treat a loan guarantee the same as a direct shareholder loan.
Answer A. Losses are limited to the shareholder's stock basis plus any qualifying debt basis. Parker's stock basis is $30,000 ($14,000 beginning basis + $16,000 contribution) and his direct $20,000 loan creates debt basis, so he may deduct $50,000 of the $58,000 loss. The bank loan that Parker guaranteed does not give him basis because he made no payments or other economic outlay on that obligation during Year 1.
Why not B: This choice is tempting if a candidate counts only the Year 1 cash flows to the corporation (the $16,000 contribution + the $20,000 direct loan = $36,000) and forgets the $14,000 beginning stock basis that is also available to absorb losses.
Why not C: This answer reflects using only stock basis (beginning basis plus contribution) and ignores Parker's $20,000 direct loan, which does create debt basis available to absorb loss.
Why not D: This answer assumes Parker can use the $30,000 bank debt (which he guaranteed) to increase his basis. A guarantee alone does not create S corporation debt basis unless the shareholder actually pays or otherwise suffers an economic outlay on the debt; Parker made no payments during Year 1.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on whether S corporation operating income is generally taxed at the entity level or passed through, and whether distributions control the timing.
Answer B. An S corporation is generally a pass-through entity for federal income tax; its ordinary business income is allocated to shareholders and reported on their returns in the year earned even if no cash is distributed. The shareholder is taxed on that passed-through income for Year 1, and the shareholder's stock basis is increased by the amount of the income, which affects future loss limitations and distribution tax treatment.
Why not A: This reflects the C corporation model and is tempting for candidates who conflate S and C treatment. But an S corporation generally does not pay federal income tax on ordinary business income; instead the income flows through to shareholders in the year earned, whether or not cash is distributed.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the mistaken idea that tax follows cash. For S corporations, shareholders are generally taxed on allocated income when the corporation earns it, not when distributions are made, so lack of distribution does not defer the tax.
Why not D: Although an S corporation is a separate legal corporation, for federal income tax purposes it generally avoids the double-taxation regime that applies to C corporations. The stem also rules out special corporate-level taxes that might create exceptions.
Question 4
Hint
Compute Lane's stock basis immediately before the December distribution by adding income items (including tax-exempt interest) to beginning basis, then compare the distribution to that computed basis per the stated ordering.
Answer D. Beginning basis $22,000 is increased by ordinary business income $14,000 and tax-exempt interest $6,000, giving a pre-distribution basis of $42,000. Under the stated ordering, the December distribution is tested against that basis, so $42,000 of the $44,000 is a nontaxable return of basis and the $2,000 excess is capital gain. The $4,000 nondeductible penalty is applied only after the distribution by the problem instruction and therefore does not reduce basis available for the distribution.
Why not A: This answer omits the $6,000 of tax-exempt interest that increases S-corporation stock basis; excluding that item understates the basis available to offset the distribution.
Why not B: This reflects subtracting the $4,000 nondeductible penalty from basis before testing the distribution. The stem explicitly instructs that nondeductible expenses are applied after the distribution, so that ordering makes $38,000 incorrect here.
Why not C: This assumes the entire distribution is tax-free. Distributions are nontaxable only to the extent of stock basis, under the stated ordering Lane had only $42,000 of basis available, so the excess $2,000 would be taxable.
Question 5
Hint
Adjust S corporation stock basis in the required annual order before applying the loss, and do not forget to consider direct shareholder debt basis after stock basis is used up.
Answer B. Increase stock basis by the $8,000 long-term capital gain and $2,000 tax-exempt interest (25,000 -> 35,000). Reduce basis by the $20,000 distribution and the $3,000 nondeductible expense (35,000 -> 12,000). Sage may deduct $12,000 of the $30,000 ordinary loss against stock basis and an additional $10,000 against the shareholder loan basis, for a $22,000 current deduction; the loan basis is reduced to $0 and $8,000 of loss is suspended.
Why not A: This answer is appealing if a candidate remembers to include income increases and debt basis but forgets that the $3,000 nondeductible expense reduces stock basis before applying the loss limitation. Skipping that reduction would (incorrectly) allow a $25,000 deduction.
Why not C: This gets the current deduction amount right but incorrectly leaves the loan basis unchanged. After using $12,000 of stock basis, the permitted additional $10,000 of loss must be applied against the shareholder loan basis, reducing it to $0.
Why not D: This reflects applying loss only to stock basis and ignoring shareholder debt basis. Because Sage has a bona fide $10,000 loan basis, that amount can also be used to claim part of the ordinary loss, so the deduction is greater than $12,000.
Question 6
Hint
Track S corporation stock basis in the required order: increases first, then nondividend distributions, then losses and deductions.
Answer A. Lee's stock basis is increased first by the $2,000 of tax-exempt municipal bond interest, raising basis from $20,000 to $22,000. Nondividend distributions reduce stock basis next, so the $22,000 cash distribution reduces basis to zero and is tax-free. Losses are applied after distributions, so the $10,000 ordinary loss cannot be deducted (no stock or debt basis) and is suspended.
Why not B: This reflects the incorrect ordering of basis adjustments (applying the loss before the distribution). If the $10,000 loss were deducted before the distribution (after the $2,000 tax-exempt increase), basis would be $12,000 and only $12,000 of the distribution would be tax-free with $10,000 treated as gain. The correct order is increases, then distributions, then losses, so the loss is suspended.
Why not C: This choice ignores the $2,000 tax-exempt municipal interest that increases stock basis. Including that tax-exempt income raises basis to $22,000, which allows the entire $22,000 distribution to be tax-free; without accounting for the tax-exempt income the math shown here would follow, but it contradicts the given facts.
Why not D: This option incorrectly treats part of the loss as deductible after the distribution. Because distributions reduce basis before losses, the $22,000 distribution exhausts basis and no portion of the ordinary loss can be currently deducted; the entire $10,000 loss is suspended.
Common questions
Does S corporation debt basis make a cash distribution tax-free?
No. Only stock basis shelters the distribution. Alex's $10,000 loan basis supports a loss deduction but does not prevent the $4,000 distribution gain.
Does tax-exempt income increase S corporation stock basis?
Yes. Alex adds the $6,000 of tax-exempt interest before testing the cash distribution, increasing stock basis from $24,000 to $30,000.
Can I deduct an S corporation loss after a distribution uses all my stock basis?
Yes, if qualifying debt basis remains and other loss limits do not apply. Alex deducts $10,000 against direct loan basis and suspends the remaining $6,000.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on S corporations, worked step by step.
Built-In Gains Tax & AAA Ordering | CPA TCP Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on S corporations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.