PracticeTCPFree practice exam

TCP · Entity Tax Compliance · 6 practice questions

S Corporation One-Class-of-Stock Test

An S corporation's shares must have identical distribution and liquidation rights, but voting rights may differ. Below, sort stock terms and agreements by whether they pass the one-class-of-stock test.

The ruleAn S corporation may have only one class of stock. All outstanding shares must confer identical rights to distributions and liquidation proceeds; voting differences alone are permitted.

Try one first

Each of the following corporations is a domestic corporation, is not an ineligible corporation under the Internal Revenue Code, and timely files an S election for Year 1 with all required shareholder consents. Which corporation qualifies to be treated as an S corporation for Year 1?
Hint

Check the basic S corporation eligibility rules in a simple order: shareholder count, shareholder type, and whether the corporation has only one class of stock.

Sort it

Passes the stock-class test

The stated terms preserve identical per-share distribution and liquidation rights.

Fails the stock-class test

The stated terms give some shares different distribution or liquidation rights.

ItemGoes to
Pine issues voting and nonvoting common shares with identical distribution and liquidation rights.Passes the stock-class testVoting differences alone do not create a second class.
Pine's charter gives some shares priority over other shares for nonliquidating distributions.Fails the stock-class testThe priority changes those shares' legal rights to distributions.
Pine makes unequal discretionary cash payments, but all governing documents and binding agreements preserve identical per-share distribution and liquidation rights.Passes the stock-class testActual payment differences alone do not change the rights attached to shares.
Pine's shares have equal current distribution rights, but some shares receive liquidation proceeds before others.Fails the stock-class testIdentical current distribution rights cannot cure different liquidation rights. Both must match.
Pine borrows from a shareholder using a bona fide, nonconvertible note with fixed principal, fixed interest, and a stated maturity.Passes the stock-class testThe instrument is bona fide debt, not another class of stock.
Pine's binding shareholder agreement entitles selected shares to larger distributions per share, despite identical rights in its charter.Fails the stock-class testBinding agreements count. Identical charter terms do not override an agreement granting different distribution rights.
Pine gives some shares enhanced voting power to elect most directors, while preserving identical distribution and liquidation rights.Passes the stock-class testGreater board control changes governance, not the economic rights tested here.
Pine issues shares entitled to a fixed preferred distribution before its existing common shares receive distributions.Fails the stock-class testA fixed preferred distribution creates different distribution entitlements, even without a liquidation preference.
Pine's bona fide buy-sell agreement requires departing owners to sell at book value, preserves distribution and liquidation rights, and has no circumvention purpose.Passes the stock-class testThe book-value sale formula does not, by itself, create different distribution or liquidation rights.
Pine's bank loan limits future dividends for all shares without changing their identical distribution and liquidation rights.Passes the stock-class testA company-wide dividend restriction limits payments without giving any shares preferential rights.

Key points

  • Remember: Check what each share is entitled to, not who controls the vote.
  • Read governing documents and binding agreements for distribution or liquidation preferences.
  • Unequal discretionary payments alone do not establish unequal share rights.
  • Bona fide debt does not create a second class of stock.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating voting and nonvoting common shares as two prohibited classes. Compare distribution and liquidation rights, not voting labels.
  • Treating every unequal cash payment as an automatic stock-class violation. Determine whether legal entitlements differ; unequal discretionary payments alone are not enough.
  • Assuming every shareholder agreement creates a second class. Check its terms. Board-control and ordinary buy-sell provisions do not automatically change distribution or liquidation rights.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Pine Corp is a domestic corporation that otherwise meets the requirements to be an S corporation. To help separate control from economics, Pine is considering changes to its share terms. Which change would generally be permitted without creating a prohibited second class of stock, assuming all shares have identical rights to distributions and liquidation proceeds except as stated?
Hint

For S corporation eligibility, separate voting rights from economic rights. The one-class-of-stock rule is mainly about distribution and liquidation rights.

Question 3

Maple, Inc. has a valid S election at the beginning of Year 1. During Year 1, which event would cause Maple's S election to terminate, assuming no inadvertent-termination relief applies?
Hint

Focus on the basic S corporation eligibility rules: who may be a shareholder, and what kinds of stock differences are allowed.

Question 4

Harbor, Inc., a domestic calendar‑year corporation, has had a valid S election for several years. One 30% shareholder, Reed, holds his stock through a revocable trust that is treated as wholly owned by Reed for federal income tax purposes. Reed dies on January 1, 20X5. Under the trust terms, the trust continues to hold the Harbor stock through December 31, 20X7. No QSST election is made, no ESBT election is made, and the stock is not transferred to Reed's estate or to another eligible shareholder. Assume no inadvertent‑termination relief is sought and no other S corporation eligibility issue exists. What is the correct treatment of Harbor's S election?
Hint

Ask whether a trust that was a grantor trust at death loses eligibility immediately or has a limited continuation. Remember that S‑status is tested continuously and specific trust elections (QSST/ESBT) can affect post‑death eligibility.

Question 5

Pine Ridge, Inc. has a valid S election in effect. In Year 2 it had four shareholders, all eligible U.S. individuals, and the articles authorize only common stock. A shareholder agreement gives two shareholders enhanced voting power to elect most of the board, requires departing shareholders to sell shares at a book‑value formula, and the corporation made unequal cash distributions during Year 2 because one shareholder requested extra funds. Assume there are no options, warrants, convertible instruments, or debt treated as equity, and no evidence the agreement was intended to circumvent S‑corporation rules. In determining whether Pine Ridge has created a prohibited second class of stock for S‑corporation purposes, which factor is controlling?
Hint

Ask which item actually defines a class of stock under S‑corporation rules: differences in contractual economic entitlements to distributions and liquidation proceeds, or differences in governance or one‑time payments?

Question 6

Redwood, Inc., a domestic calendar-year corporation, made a valid S election effective Year 1. Assume its charter and binding agreements create no special distribution or liquidation preferences other than the facts below; assume the Apr. 1 note is bona fide debt (written, nonconvertible, bearing a market rate of interest, payable as a sum certain); and assume federal tax law recognizes each stock transfer on the date made. During Year 2, the following occurred: • Feb. 1: Redwood issued nonvoting common shares to E, a U.S. individual. The new shares have the same rights to distributions and liquidation proceeds as the voting common shares. • Apr. 1: Shareholder L, a U.S. individual, loaned Redwood cash in exchange for a written, nonconvertible note bearing a market rate of interest and requiring payment of a sum certain on a stated maturity date. • Jul. 1: Shareholder M transferred 5% of Redwood's stock to MM Partners, a domestic general partnership. • Aug. 15: After discovering the mistake, MM Partners transferred the same shares back to M. Assume no IRS relief has yet been requested or granted. Which conclusion is best supported regarding Redwood's S status?
Hint

Identify which Year 2 event created an ineligible shareholder and whether a later corrective transfer automatically reverses the tax effect absent express IRS relief.

Drill all 143 S corporations questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can an S corporation have voting and nonvoting stock?

Yes. Voting differences alone are permitted if every outstanding share has identical rights to distributions and liquidation proceeds.

Do unequal distributions create a second class of S corporation stock?

Not by themselves. Unequal discretionary payments do not create a second class when governing documents and binding agreements preserve identical distribution and liquidation rights.

Does a book-value buy-sell agreement violate the one-class-of-stock rule?

Not by itself. The book-value agreement shown below leaves distribution and liquidation rights unchanged and is not intended to circumvent the one-class requirement.

Watch it solved

A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on S corporations, worked step by step.

Built-In Gains Tax & AAA Ordering | CPA TCP Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice TCP like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on S corporations

All S corporations practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.