TCP · Entity Tax Compliance · 6 practice questions
Late S-Election Relief Timeline
Late S-election relief generally must be requested within 3 years and 75 days of the intended effective date, with reasonable cause and consistent reporting. Follow Redwood from its missed election through discovery and its relief request.
Try one first
Hint
Apply the filing-timing rule separately to a newly formed corporation and to an already existing calendar-year corporation.
Answer D. A newly formed corporation may make an S election effective for its initial short tax year if Form 2553 is filed on or before the 15th day of the third month of that tax year. Alder's first tax year began March 1, Year 1, so a May 10 filing is timely for that short Year 1 tax year. An existing calendar-year corporation generally must file by March 15 of that tax year to have the election effective for that same year; Birch's May 10 filing (without late-election relief) would instead be effective for the following tax year beginning January 1, Year 2.
Why not A: This reflects the common misconception that an S election simply takes effect on the filing date. In general a timely election is effective for the entire tax year (or the corporation's initial short tax year), not just from the filing date; late filings without relief do not produce a midyear effective date.
Why not B: This treats both filings as only becoming effective the following year. It is wrong because Alder's filing was within the timely window for its initial short tax year (filed before the 15th day of the third month), so Alder can be effective for Year 1.
Why not C: This mixes a correct result for Alder with an incorrect retroactive effectiveness for Birch. Birch, as an existing calendar-year corporation, generally needed to file by March 15 to have S status effective for Year 1; a May 10 filing is too late without relief.
The timeline
- January 1, 20X5Redwood forms and intends S status from inception.
Redwood has eligible shareholders and one class of stock. January 1 is the intended effective date and starts the general relief clock.
- March 15, 20X5The ordinary election deadline passes without Form 2553.
An administrative oversight causes the missed filing. Redwood otherwise qualifies for S status.
- 20X6 filing seasonRedwood and its shareholders report 20X5 consistently with S status.
Redwood timely files Form 1120-S and issues Schedules K-1. Each shareholder timely reports the items consistently.
- August 20, 20X6A new adviser discovers the missing election before IRS contact.
Redwood can establish reasonable cause and has no other disqualifying facts. It should promptly pursue the late-election relief procedure.
- August 20, 20X6, after discoveryRedwood submits Form 2553 requesting relief effective January 1, 20X5.
Include required shareholder consents, a reasonable-cause explanation, and the other required statements. The request falls within the general relief window.
- Intended effective date + 3 years and 75 daysThe general request window ends.
Measure this window from January 1, 20X5. Discovery does not restart it, and filing within it does not replace the other relief requirements.
Key points
- Remember: The relief clock starts on the intended effective date, not when the missing election is discovered.
- Consistent reporting includes both the corporation's Form 1120-S and its shareholders' returns.
- Filing Form 1120-S does not replace the missing Form 2553.
- The relief request needs required shareholder consents and supporting statements.
How the exam traps you
- Starting the relief window when Redwood discovers the omission. Measure from January 1, 20X5, the intended effective date.
- Treating Redwood's timely Form 1120-S as a valid S election. File the missing Form 2553 and request late-election relief.
- Assuming consistent reporting alone guarantees relief. Redwood also needs reasonable cause, required consents, and the procedure's supporting statements.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on whether pass-through status eliminates the entity's return filing requirement.
Answer D. An S corporation must file Form 1120-S to report its income, losses, deductions, and to prepare Schedule K-1s for shareholders. For a calendar-year S corporation the return is generally due on the 15th day of the third month after year-end (March 15) unless a valid extension is filed. The filing obligation exists even if the corporation has a loss or no entity-level tax due.
Why not A: While shareholders do receive Schedule K-1s, those K-1s are supplied as part of the corporation's Form 1120-S filing. The requirement to furnish K-1s does not replace the S corporation's obligation to file its own return.
Why not B: This is tempting because S corporations are pass-through entities for income tax, but they still must file Form 1120-S to report the entity's tax items and provide Schedule K-1s to shareholders. Pass-through status does not eliminate the entity's filing requirement.
Why not C: This distractor leverages familiarity with Form 1120 and the April 15 deadline for many filers, but a corporation with a valid S election files Form 1120-S (not Form 1120), and a calendar-year S corporation's normal due date is March 15 rather than April 15.
Question 3
Hint
Separate the original due date of Form 1120-S from the later date the return is due if an automatic extension is properly filed.
Answer D. A calendar-year S corporation files Form 1120-S by the 15th day of the third month after year-end, which is March 15 of the following year. An automatic extension request must be filed by that original due date (not the extended due date). For a calendar-year S corporation, a timely extension typically extends the filing deadline to September 15.
Why not A: October 15 is a common extended deadline for individual returns when those returns are extended; it does not apply to Form 1120-S, so it is not the correct extension-request deadline.
Why not B: April 15 is the familiar due date for many individual returns, which makes it tempting, but Form 1120-S for a calendar-year S corporation is due March 15, so the extension request must be filed by March 15.
Why not C: September 15 is the extended filing deadline for a calendar-year S corporation after a timely extension is filed, so it is the extended due date, not the deadline to file the extension request itself.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on whether the facts meet the IRS automatic late S-election relief conditions and what procedural steps that relief requires, not on whether the original filing deadline was missed.
Answer B. Redwood meets the typical criteria for automatic late S-election relief under the IRS relief procedure: the corporation intended S status from inception, is otherwise qualified, timely filed and reported as an S (Form 1120-S and consistent K-1s), and the omission was discovered before IRS contact. The appropriate remedial step is to file Form 2553 now with the required shareholder consents and the explanatory statements described in the IRS relief procedure (e.g., Rev. Proc. guidance) requesting relief to the intended effective date. A private-letter ruling or an entity-classification election is unnecessary when automatic relief conditions are satisfied.
Why not A: This answer assumes the missed deadline is irreparable; however, when a corporation intended S status, reported consistently as an S, and can show reasonable cause discovered before IRS contact, the IRS relief procedure provides for retroactive relief rather than forcing a C-election and return amendments.
Why not C: Form 8832 governs entity classification for eligible noncorporate entities and is not an appropriate step to cure a missed S election for a domestic corporation; this approach also abandons the available retroactive relief for 20X5.
Why not D: A private letter ruling is costly and unnecessary where the facts fit the automatic-relief criteria; filing Form 1120-S with consistent shareholder reporting ordinarily supports eligibility for relief rather than disqualifying it.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on the general filing window for an S election to be effective for the corporation's current tax year, not the tax return due date.
Answer D. An S election is effective for a tax year if Form 2553 is filed no later than 2 months and 15 days after the beginning of that tax year. For a tax year beginning July 1, 20X6, that deadline falls on September 15, 20X6. The question excludes late-election relief, so the normal 2 months and 15 days rule controls.
Why not A: Some post-formation filings have short deadlines, but the S-election deadline is specifically 2 months and 15 days after the beginning of the tax year, not 30 days.
Why not B: This choice assumes filing sometime during the calendar year is sufficient, but the general rule requires filing much earlier, within 2 months and 15 days after the start of the tax year.
Why not C: Tying elections to the return due date is a common shortcut, but the S-election deadline is generally earlier than the return due date. The return due date may be relevant only when late-election relief is sought.
Question 6
Hint
Count the regular filing window from the first day of the tax year the corporation wants S status to begin.
Answer A. Form 2553 must generally be filed no later than 2 months and 15 days after the beginning of the tax year to be effective for that tax year (or any time during the preceding tax year). For a calendar-year corporation seeking effectiveness for 20X6, the regular filing deadline is in mid‑March 20X6 (the typical March 15 deadline). Because Lark filed on March 20, 20X6 and did not obtain late-election relief, the election cannot be effective until the start of the next tax year, January 1, 20X7.
Why not B: A common mistake is to assume the election takes effect on the filing date. Absent special relief, a late-filed Form 2553 does not create a midyear S effective date for the current tax year.
Why not C: This option presumes a delayed in-year effective date after a late filing, which the general rules do not provide for. Without timely filing or relief, the first effective date is the next tax year.
Why not D: This assumes the S election applies retroactively to the start of 20X6; that is only possible if Form 2553 was filed timely (by the 2 months and 15 days deadline) or relief was granted. Lark missed the deadline and did not obtain relief.
Common questions
How long do you have to request late S-election relief?
The general window under Rev. Proc. 2013-30 is 3 years and 75 days from the intended effective date. Redwood measures from January 1, 20X5, not its August 20, 20X6 discovery.
Does filing Form 1120-S fix a missing Form 2553?
No. Redwood's timely Form 1120-S and consistent shareholder reporting support its relief request, but Redwood must still submit Form 2553 under the relief procedure.
What does Redwood submit for late S-election relief?
Redwood submits Form 2553 requesting relief effective January 1, 20X5, with required shareholder consents and supporting statements. It must explain reasonable cause and satisfy the procedure's consistent-reporting requirements.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on S corporations, worked step by step.
Built-In Gains Tax & AAA Ordering | CPA TCP Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on S corporations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.