TCP · Entity Tax Compliance · 6 practice questions
S Corporation Distributions: AAA, AE&P, and Stock Basis
Without an AE&P-first election, S corporation distributions use AAA before AE&P, but stock basis limits tax-free treatment. Below: follow one cash distribution through basis recovery, dividend income, and capital gain.
Try one first
Hint
Work through the distribution ordering step by step when an S corporation has both AAA and accumulated earnings and profits.
Answer A. Because no election was made to treat distributions as coming from accumulated E&P first, apply the ordering: first AAA, then accumulated E&P, then return of capital. The $18,000 from AAA is tax-free to the extent of basis and reduces Reed's basis from $25,000 to $7,000. The next $12,000 is a dividend (taxable) from accumulated E&P and does not reduce basis; the remaining $10,000 reduces the $7,000 basis to zero and the excess $3,000 is capital gain.
Why not B: This treats more of the distribution as dividends and ignores the priority that AAA distributions are tax-free to the extent of basis when no election is made to treat E&P first.
Why not C: This incorrectly applies basis recovery to the full distribution before respecting the special ordering for an S corporation with both AAA and accumulated E&P; the AAA portion must be applied first and part of the distribution is a dividend before the remaining return of capital.
Why not D: This overgeneralizes that S-corporation distributions are always nontaxable until basis is exhausted; accumulated earnings and profits create a dividend layer that is taxable.
Step by step
- Identify the balances
Pine, an S corporation, distributes $40,000 cash to its sole shareholder, Reed, whose stock basis is $25,000; Pine has $18,000 AAA and $12,000 AE&P from prior C corporation years. There are no current-year income or loss items, contributions, or loans, and Pine makes no AE&P-first election.
- Apply AAA first
The first $18,000 comes from AAA and is tax-free because Reed has enough stock basis. Stock basis falls from $25,000 to $7,000, leaving $22,000 of cash to classify.
- Apply AE&P next
The next $12,000 is dividend income from AE&P and does not reduce stock basis. Reed still has $7,000 of basis, and $10,000 of cash remains to classify.
- Use the remaining stock basis
Of the remaining $10,000, $7,000 is tax-free basis recovery. Reed's stock basis is now zero.
- Recognize the excess as gain
The final $3,000 exceeds Reed's remaining stock basis and is capital gain. Do not classify it as a dividend because the AE&P layer is exhausted.
- Confirm the complete treatment
The $40,000 distribution consists of $25,000 tax-free basis recovery, $12,000 dividend income, and $3,000 capital gain. The $25,000 basis recovery includes both the $18,000 AAA portion and $7,000 distributed after AE&P.
Key points
- Remember: AAA determines the distribution's source; stock basis determines how much of the nondividend portion is tax-free.
- AAA belongs to the corporation; stock basis belongs to the shareholder.
- Total tax-free distributions can exceed AAA when basis remains after the AE&P layer.
How the exam traps you
- Recovering all $25,000 of basis first and calling the remaining $15,000 a dividend. Apply AAA first, then AE&P. Only $12,000 is a dividend; the final $3,000 is capital gain.
- Reducing Reed's remaining $7,000 basis for the $12,000 dividend. Dividends do not reduce stock basis. Keep the $7,000 available for the distribution after AE&P.
- Calling the entire $10,000 remaining after AE&P capital gain. Use the remaining $7,000 stock basis first. Only $3,000 is capital gain.
Question 2
Hint
Work through the distribution in layers: first determine the ordering between AAA and accumulated earnings and profits, then apply Lee's stock basis to the AAA portion.
Answer B. Because Delta has accumulated earnings and profits and made no election to treat distributions as coming first from accumulated earnings and profits, distributions are applied first to the AAA and then to accumulated E&P. The $40,000 AAA portion is reached first; Lee can absorb only $25,000 of that with stock basis, so the $15,000 excess of the AAA portion is treated as gain on the sale/exchange of the stock (capital gain). The remaining $20,000 of the distribution is within accumulated earnings and profits and is treated as dividend income.
Why not A: This assumes the entire AAA portion can be received tax-free, but Lee's stock basis is only $25,000. Any AAA distributed in excess of basis is not a further basis recovery but is treated as gain.
Why not C: This reflects the mistake of treating all amounts above basis as gain. Because Delta has accumulated earnings and profits, after the AAA layer is applied the next layer (to the extent of accumulated E&P) is dividend income, not capital gain.
Why not D: This would be the result if distributions were treated as coming from accumulated E&P first (or if the ordering were misapplied). Here, AAA must be applied before accumulated E&P (absent an election), which produces a $15,000 capital gain from the AAA excess and only $20,000 of dividend income.
Question 3
Hint
Separate the analysis into layers: first determine which corporate account the distribution comes from, then apply shareholder stock basis only to the portion governed by the S corporation distribution rule.
Answer D. Because Raven has accumulated earnings and profits and made no election to distribute E&P first, the distribution is treated first as coming from AAA. The first $50,000 is therefore governed by the S corporation distribution rules: $30,000 reduces Dana's stock basis to zero, and the excess $20,000 of that AAA-layer distribution is capital gain. The remaining $20,000 of the $70,000 distribution is treated as coming from accumulated earnings and profits and is dividend income.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates sometimes add AAA and stock basis together and treat that sum as sheltering the distribution. That is incorrect: AAA determines the corporate layer from which the distribution is allocated first, but shareholder stock basis limits how much of that AAA-layer distribution can be received tax free. Once Dana's $30,000 basis is exhausted within the AAA layer, the remaining AAA amount produces capital gain rather than additional tax-free recovery.
Why not B: This choice captures the capital gain from the AAA layer but ignores the leftover corporate-level E&P. After the $50,000 AAA portion is applied (producing $20,000 capital gain when basis is exhausted), the remaining $20,000 of the $70,000 distribution is treated as coming from accumulated C‑year earnings and profits and is dividend income.
Why not C: This distractor relies on treating E&P as the source before AAA. Under the facts (no election to treat distributions as from E&P first), the AAA layer is applied before accumulated E&P. Excess within the AAA layer (after exhausting basis) is capital gain; only amounts remaining after the AAA layer are dividends to the extent of accumulated E&P.
Question 4
Hint
Remember the ordering: AAA before E&P, and that tax-free treatment of AAA is limited by the shareholder's stock basis.
Answer D. Distributions are applied to AAA first. The $30,000 AAA portion is tax-free only to the extent of the shareholder's $25,000 basis (reducing basis to zero); the $5,000 excess AAA is capital gain. The remaining $20,000 of the $50,000 comes from accumulated E&P and is dividend income.
Why not A: Tempts by reversing the ordering to treat E&P before AAA, but absent an election distributions come from AAA first; applying E&P-first would yield $10,000 basis reduction and $40,000 dividend only if an E&P-first election were made, so this option misapplies the ordering.
Why not B: Tempts by treating the full AAA balance as tax-free, but it ignores the shareholder's basis limit, only $25,000 of the AAA portion can be tax-free and the $5,000 excess is capital gain.
Why not C: Tempts by applying the basis limit correctly but then misclassifies the next $5,000 as dividend; in fact excess AAA after basis is exhausted is capital gain, not dividend.
Question 5
Hint
Work in order: first update current-year AAA and stock basis, then decide whether any part of the distribution reaches accumulated earnings and profits.
Answer D. Current-year ordinary business income increases both the AAA and the shareholder's stock basis before a year-end distribution. Maple's AAA becomes $50,000 ($20,000 beginning AAA + $30,000 current-year income), and the shareholder's basis becomes $45,000 ($15,000 + $30,000). Because the $40,000 distribution is less than both AAA and the shareholder's basis, it is a nondividend distribution that reduces stock basis, not a dividend.
Why not A: This reflects the error of using only the beginning AAA and ignoring current-year income. AAA is increased by Year 2 ordinary income before the year-end distribution, so AAA is $50,000 and the distribution does not reach earnings and profits.
Why not B: While accumulated earnings and profits can make distributions taxable as dividends, distributions are treated as coming first from the AAA (unless an election applies). Because AAA after current-year income is $50,000, the distribution does not reach the accumulated earnings and profits and is not a dividend.
Why not C: This distractor freezes basis at the beginning-of-year amount. For S corporations, current-year pass-through income increases stock basis before nondividend distributions are applied; here the basis is $45,000 immediately before the distribution so the full $40,000 is covered.
Question 6
Hint
Do not apply the usual basis-first rule in isolation. First determine whether prior C corporation earnings and profits create an ordering layer in the middle of the distribution.
Answer A. Because Lark has AE&P from prior C corporation years and no election was made, the distribution is applied first to the AAA, then to AE&P, and any remaining amount is treated under the normal S-corporation distribution sequencing (return of capital to the extent of basis, then capital gain). The first $40,000 comes from AAA and reduces basis; the next $25,000 is a dividend taxable as income; the final $5,000 reduces basis (no tax) because the shareholder still has $15,000 of basis remaining after the AAA layer. Thus $45,000 reduces basis and $25,000 is dividend income.
Why not B: This is tempting if a student assumes any amount remaining after the AE&P layer must be gain. In fact, after applying AAA and AE&P, any further distribution is a return of capital to the extent of the shareholder's remaining basis; since basis remains, the $5,000 is not gain.
Why not C: This reflects treating the full distribution against basis first and then labeling the excess as a dividend. That ignores the required ordering when AE&P exists, the AAA layer is applied before the AE&P dividend layer.
Why not D: This applies the simpler rule used when no AE&P exists. Because Lark has AE&P from prior C years, a dividend layer occurs and cannot be ignored.
Common questions
What is the distribution order when an S corporation has AAA and AE&P?
Without an AE&P-first election, use AAA first, then AE&P, then remaining stock basis, then capital gain. The AAA portion is tax-free only to the extent of stock basis.
Does an S corporation's AE&P dividend reduce stock basis?
No. Pine's $12,000 dividend leaves Reed's remaining $7,000 stock basis unchanged.
Is an S corporation distribution above AAA and AE&P always capital gain?
No. Any remaining stock basis still provides tax-free recovery. Pine's final $10,000 uses Reed's remaining $7,000 basis before producing $3,000 of capital gain.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on S corporations, worked step by step.
Built-In Gains Tax & AAA Ordering | CPA TCP Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on S corporations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.