TCP · Entity Tax Compliance · 8 practice questions
S Corporation Passive Income: Three-Year Termination
S status ends after three consecutive years meeting both the passive-income and year-end E&P tests. Follow Lark through a broken streak and three consecutive qualifying years to determine when its S election terminates.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the annual consequence from the status consequence: one rule can impose an entity-level tax before a later rule ends the S election.
Answer A. Because Cedar had accumulated earnings and profits and more than 25% of its gross receipts were passive investment income (with excess net passive income) for three consecutive years, it may be subject to the entity-level tax on excess net passive income for each of those years. Under the three-year passive-income rule, the S election terminates after the third consecutive year and is effective on the first day of the following tax year. Therefore Cedar remains an S corporation through Year 3 and loses S status at the start of Year 4.
Why not B: This answer correctly recognizes the possible entity-level tax but overstates the duration required for termination. The termination trigger is three consecutive years above the 25% passive-income threshold (with accumulated earnings and profits), not four years.
Why not C: Some terminations can cause short-year treatment, but the passive-income termination here becomes effective at the start of the fourth year after three consecutive offending years, so the termination is not midyear in Year 3 and Year 3 is not split.
Why not D: This distractor misstates the relevant threshold. The applicable test is more than 25% of gross receipts being passive investment income (when accumulated earnings and profits are present), not a 50% threshold.
The timeline
- January 1, 20X4Lark's valid S election takes effect after its C corporation years.
Lark uses a calendar year. Assume accumulated C corporation E&P remains at every year-end through 20X8, with no relief or other termination event.
- December 31, 20X4Passive investment income is 27% of gross receipts.
Above 25%, with year-end E&P present. Qualifying streak: 1 year.
- December 31, 20X5Passive investment income is exactly 25% of gross receipts.
Exactly 25% does not exceed the threshold. Despite year-end E&P, the streak resets to zero.
- December 31, 20X6Passive investment income is 26% of gross receipts.
Above 25%, with year-end E&P present. A new qualifying streak starts: 1 year.
- December 31, 20X7Passive investment income is 29% of gross receipts.
Above 25%, with year-end E&P present. Qualifying streak: 2 consecutive years.
- December 31, 20X8Passive investment income is 28% of gross receipts.
Above 25%, with year-end E&P present. The streak reaches 3 consecutive years. Lark remains an S corporation through 20X8.
- January 1, 20X9Lark's S election terminates.
Termination begins on the first day of the year following the third consecutive qualifying year. Lark is a C corporation for 20X9.
Key points
- Remember: Count consecutive years that meet both the passive-income and year-end E&P tests.
- Exactly 25% breaks the streak; the next qualifying year starts a new count.
- The third qualifying year remains an S corporation year.
How the exam traps you
- Treating exactly 25% as a qualifying year. The threshold is more than 25%, not 25% or more.
- Adding qualifying years on both sides of a broken streak. Restart the count after a year that fails either test.
- Ending S status during the third qualifying year. Termination begins on the first day of the following taxable year.
Question 2
Hint
First decide whether 20X4 is still inside the recognition period. Then compare the gain built in on the election date with the gain actually recognized on the sale.
Answer B. The sale in 20X4 falls within the 5-year recognition period for built-in gains. The built-in gain on the conversion date was $120,000 (FMV $420,000 less basis $300,000). The actual gain on sale was $150,000 ($450,000 less $300,000), but the built-in gains tax base is limited to the lesser amount ($120,000). At a 21% corporate rate, the built-in gains tax equals $120,000 × 21% = $25,200.
Why not A: Tempting because S corporations generally pass through income, but former C corporations pay an entity-level built-in gains tax on recognition of pre-election built-in gain during the recognition period; therefore $0 is incorrect.
Why not C: This equals 21% of the $30,000 post-election appreciation ($450,000 − $420,000). That is incorrect because the built-in gains tax applies to pre-election built-in gain realized during the recognition period, not solely to post-election appreciation.
Why not D: This equals 21% of the full recognized gain ($150,000). It is incorrect because the built-in gains tax is limited to the pre-election built-in gain ($120,000), not the entire recognized gain when pre-election gain is smaller.
Question 3
Hint
Determine whether accumulated C corporation E&P existed at the close of each taxable year; both the entity-level tax and the three-year termination test look to the year‑end E&P position.
Answer D. Both the entity-level excess net passive income tax (IRC Sec. 1375) and the three-year S-termination rule (IRC Sec. 1362(d)(3)) are triggered only if the S corporation has accumulated C corporation E&P at the close of the taxable year. Because Ridge eliminated its accumulated C E&P by the close of 20X5, 20X5 is not a qualifying year for either consequence; Ridge neither owes the entity-level passive-income tax for 20X5 nor loses S status at the start of 20X6.
Why not A: This is tempting because of the 'three consecutive years over 25%' rule, but that rule also requires accumulated C E&P to exist at the close of each year for a year to count. Ridge had zero C E&P at 12/31/20X5, so 20X5 does not complete the three-year chain.
Why not B: Incorrect because a taxable year counts toward the three-year consecutive test only if the corporation had accumulated C E&P at that year's close. Eliminating C E&P at 12/31/20X5 breaks the consecutive chain.
Why not C: This distractor focuses on when the passive receipts were earned rather than the year-end E&P position. The statute and regulations look to whether C E&P existed at the close of the taxable year; Ridge eliminated C E&P by year-end, so the entity-level tax does not apply for 20X5.
Question 4
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Asset G: basis $300,000; fair market value $500,000 | |
| Asset L: basis $250,000; fair market value $180,000 | |
Hint
First measure each asset's pre-election built-in gain or loss as of the S-election date and net those built-in amounts; then compute Year 3 taxable income as if the corporation remained a C corporation (including the full asset gains/losses and the unrelated $50,000 loss), the Sec. 1374 tax base is the lesser of the net built-in amount and that taxable income.
Answer C. Asset-level built-in amounts are limited to the pre-election appreciation or depreciation measured on the S-election date: Asset G's built-in gain = $500,000 − $300,000 = $200,000 (actual gain $260,000, excess not treated as built-in) and Asset L's built-in loss = $250,000 − $180,000 = $70,000 (actual loss $100,000 but only $70,000 is built-in). Net recognized built-in gain = $200,000 − $70,000 = $130,000. Taxable income computed as if Maple remained a C corporation for Year 3 equals $260,000 − $100,000 − $50,000 = $110,000, and Sec. 1374 tax is imposed on the lesser of $130,000 and $110,000. Tax = $110,000 × 21% = $23,100.
Why not A: This reflects 21% of $100,000, which arises if the candidate incorrectly uses the full $100,000 actual loss on Asset L instead of limiting the recognized built-in loss to the $70,000 pre-election amount.
Why not B: This is 21% of $130,000 (the net recognized built-in gain of $200k − $70k) and ignores the Sec. 1374 taxable-income limitation; taxable income as a C corporation here is only $110,000, which caps the tax base.
Why not D: This numbers taxes the full $200,000 built-in gain on Asset G at 21% and overlooks both the built-in loss on Asset L and the taxable-income limitation under Sec. 1374.
Question 5
Hint
Identify both elements of the involuntary-termination test (passive receipts and year-end C corporation E&P) and confirm when accumulated E&P is measured.
Answer A. Involuntary termination under the passive-investment-income rule requires both (1) more than 25% passive investment income for each of three consecutive taxable years and (2) accumulated C corporation earnings and profits at the close of each of those years; termination, if any, is effective the first day of the year following the third year. Delta lacked accumulated C corporation E&P at the close of Year 3, so the two-part test was not satisfied and the S election did not terminate on January 1 of Year 4. Because Delta had both excess passive receipts and accumulated C corp E&P at the close of Year 1 and Year 2, it nonetheless could have been subject to the excess net passive income tax in those years.
Why not B: This distractor correctly recalls the three-year passive-income element but omits the separate requirement that accumulated C corporation E&P exist at the close of each of those years; because Delta had no year-end E&P for Year 3, the involuntary-termination test is not met.
Why not C: This choice is tempting because repeated passive-income problems threaten S status, but the rule requires three consecutive years (not two) and also requires accumulated C corporation E&P at the close of each of those years; termination on January 1 of Year 3 is not supported by these facts.
Why not D: This plays on the general rule that S corporations pass items through to shareholders, but it overlooks the narrow entity-level excess net passive income tax that can apply when an S corporation has accumulated C corporation E&P and excess passive income in a year; that tax could have applied in Year 1 and Year 2.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the two prongs of the three‑year test: the consecutive‑year 25% passive‑income threshold and the existence of accumulated E&P at each year‑end.
Answer D. The passive‑investment‑income automatic‑termination rule has two required elements: (1) passive investment income in excess of 25% of gross receipts for three consecutive years, and (2) accumulated earnings and profits at the close of each of those years. The facts show the passive‑income percentages exceed 25% for Years 1-3, so the pivotal unresolved issue is whether Harbor had accumulated E&P at each year‑end (particularly given the late Year‑3 distribution). Taxable income or holding appreciated former‑C assets affect other taxes but do not by themselves satisfy the termination test.
Why not A: Attractive because of the 25% threshold, but incomplete here: termination requires both the excessive passive‑income prong for three consecutive years and the presence of accumulated E&P at the close of each of those years. The stem already indicates the passive‑income prong is met, so the remaining determinative fact is year‑end E&P.
Why not B: Tempting because candidates may equate taxable income with E&P; however a taxable loss on the return does not automatically eliminate accumulated earnings and profits at year‑end. The termination test specifically requires E&P to exist at the close of each of the three years, not merely positive taxable income.
Why not C: This distractor plays on confusion with the built‑in gains regime. Holding appreciated former‑C assets can create built‑in gains tax consequences, but it does not determine whether the S election terminates under the passive‑income three‑year test.
Question 7
Hint
Separate the analysis into two parts: what happens during the third consecutive year, and when the election actually ends.
Answer C. When an S corporation has accumulated earnings and profits at year-end and passive investment income exceeds 25% of gross receipts, the corporation can be subject to a corporate-level tax on excess net passive income for that year. If those conditions exist for three consecutive tax years, the S election terminates effective the first day of the fourth year. Thus Grey can be subject to the excess net passive income tax for 20X3, and the S election ends on the first day of 20X4.
Why not A: This choice confuses timing. The statutory rule does not split the third year into short years; the corporation remains an S for the entire third year and the termination is effective on the first day of the following year.
Why not B: This option correctly recognizes the potential excess net passive income tax for 20X3 but misstates the termination trigger. Termination follows three consecutive years meeting the test when accumulated earnings and profits are present, so the election ends at the start of the fourth year rather than requiring a fourth-year repeat.
Why not D: This distractor relies on the incorrect notion that S corporations never face entity-level tax. The excess net passive income rules can impose a corporate-level tax in a year when passive income exceeds 25% of gross receipts and accumulated earnings and profits exist, even while the S election is still in effect.
Question 8
Hint
Distinguish the annual ENPI tax outcome (IRC §1375) from the separate three‑year termination rule (IRC §1362(d)(3)); determine when termination becomes effective.
Answer C. Under IRC §1362(d)(3), if a corporation with accumulated C corporation earnings and profits has passive investment income exceeding 25% of gross receipts for three consecutive taxable years, the S election terminates effective at the beginning of the following taxable year. Birch met those conditions for 20X2-20X4 and did not obtain §1362(f) relief, so the election terminated effective 1/1/20X5 and Birch must file Form 1120 for the entire 20X5 year. Paying ENPI tax under IRC §1375 for earlier years does not prevent termination under §1362(d)(3).
Why not A: Tempting because one might assume termination waits until the third bad year ends; incorrect because §1362(d)(3) makes termination effective at the start of the next taxable year, so Birch was not an S at any point in 20X5.
Why not B: Some status changes produce short periods, but the three-year passive-income termination is effective at the beginning of the following taxable year; here that effective date is 1/1/20X5, so there is no S short period in 20X5.
Why not D: Plausible because paying ENPI tax addresses the annual tax under §1375, but payment of that tax does not cure or prevent termination once the three-year condition of §1362(d)(3) is met.
Common questions
Does exactly 25% passive investment income terminate an S election?
No. Passive investment income must exceed 25% of gross receipts for the year to count. Lark's exactly 25% year breaks its streak.
Do three nonconsecutive years of excess passive income end S status?
No. The qualifying years must be consecutive, with accumulated C corporation E&P at each year-end. Lark cannot combine 20X4 with years after its 20X5 break.
When does S corporation passive income termination take effect?
Termination takes effect on the first day of the taxable year after the third consecutive qualifying year. Lark's streak ends in 20X8, so termination takes effect January 1, 20X9.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on S corporations, worked step by step.
Built-In Gains Tax & AAA Ordering | CPA TCP Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on S corporations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.