TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 6 practice questions
Section 1033: Calculate Recognized Gain and Replacement Basis
Section 1033 recognizes gain on proceeds not replaced by qualifying property, limited to realized gain. Below, a worked condemnation example shows recognized gain and replacement basis.
Try one first
Hint
Compute the realized gain first, then ask how much of the insurance recovery was actually reinvested in qualifying replacement property.
Answer C. Pine realized a gain of $180,000 (insurance proceeds $580,000 minus basis $400,000). Under Sec. 1033, gain is recognized only to the extent the amount realized exceeds the cost of qualifying replacement property, so Pine recognizes $60,000 ($580,000 − $520,000). The $120,000 of gain deferred reduces the replacement property's basis to $520,000 − $120,000 = $400,000.
Why not A: Tempting because Sec. 1033 allows deferral, but nonrecognition is only to the extent of reinvestment; Pine reinvested $60,000 less than the proceeds, so that $60,000 must be recognized.
Why not B: This gets the recognized gain correct but incorrectly treats the replacement property's basis as its full cost. The $120,000 of gain that was deferred reduces the basis from $520,000 to $400,000.
Why not D: This reflects only the realized gain and ignores the Sec. 1033 election. Because Pine reinvested $520,000, only the $60,000 excess of proceeds over replacement cost is recognized currently; the remainder is deferred.
Worked example
In Year 1, Cedar's investment land is condemned for a $700,000 gross award. Its adjusted basis is $400,000. Of the award, $100,000 goes directly to the lender to pay off the land's mortgage. Cedar timely buys qualifying replacement land for $600,000 and makes a valid §1033 election. All gain is realized in Year 1.
| 1 | Realized gain$700,000 gross award − $400,000 adjusted basis | $300,000 |
| 2 | Recognized gain$700,000 proceeds − $600,000 replacement cost, limited to $300,000 realized gain | $100,000 |
| 3 | Deferred gain$300,000 realized gain − $100,000 recognized gain | $200,000 |
| 4 | Replacement basis$600,000 replacement cost − $200,000 deferred gain | $400,000 |
Cedar recognizes $100,000 of gain in Year 1 and takes a $400,000 basis in the replacement land.
Check: Shortcut: when qualifying replacement cost falls between old basis and proceeds, recognized gain is the unreplaced proceeds and replacement basis stays at the old $400,000 basis.
Key points
- Full deferral requires replacement cost at least equal to gross proceeds, not merely the old adjusted basis.
- A mortgage payoff from the condemnation award does not reduce the proceeds used in the calculation.
- Buying replacement property alone is not enough. The taxpayer must make a valid §1033 election.
How the exam traps you
- Using $600,000 of net cash as proceeds and recognizing no gain. Use the $700,000 gross award, including the $100,000 paid directly to the lender.
- Subtracting old basis from replacement cost and recognizing $200,000. Compare replacement cost with proceeds to find recognized gain, not with old basis.
- Giving the replacement land its full $600,000 cost basis. Subtract the $200,000 deferred gain from cost to get a $400,000 basis.
Question 2
Hint
For Section 1033, first decide whether one asset gets a special condemnation rule, then determine whether the replacement period is measured from the event date or from the close of the year in which gain is realized.
Answer C. Under §1033 the general replacement period ends two years after the close of the first taxable year in which any gain is realized. For real property involuntarily converted by condemnation and held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment, that replacement period is three years after the close of that tax year. Because both gains were realized in 20X5 and Lane is a calendar-year taxpayer, the truck must be replaced by December 31, 20X7 (2 years) and the condemned warehouse by December 31, 20X8 (3 years).
Why not A: This applies the general 2-year rule to both assets. It ignores the special §1033 rule extending the replacement period to three years for condemned real property held for use in a trade or business or for investment, so the warehouse deadline is incorrect.
Why not B: This measures from the conversion event dates (May 15 and Sept 10). Section 1033 measures the statutory replacement period from the close of the first taxable year in which the gain is realized (here 20X5), not from the accident or condemnation event dates.
Why not D: This measures from the dates proceeds were received (July 30 and Oct 5). While receipt dates are practically important, §1033 ties the replacement deadline to the close of the taxable year in which gain is realized (20X5), not to the dates the awards or insurance proceeds were received.
Question 3
Hint
Separate qualification from measurement: assume the replacement property qualifies, then ask whether the 'amount replaced' is measured by total replacement cost or by where the funds came from.
Answer C. Under IRC §1033 the amount-test for nonrecognition compares the cost of qualifying replacement property acquired within the replacement period to the amount realized from the conversion. The source of funds (cash versus borrowed funds) does not change that comparison: borrowed money used to acquire qualifying replacement property is treated as part of the replacement cost. Here the amount realized is $900,000 and replacement cost is $850,000, so $50,000 of the amount realized is not replaced and is recognized as gain (subject to the realized-gain limit).
Why not A: Attractive because adjusted basis is part of the realized-gain calculation, but the amount-test for deferral asks how much of the amount realized is reinvested in qualifying replacement property, not how basis compares to proceeds.
Why not B: Tempting because it focuses on tracing condemnation cash, but §1033 looks to the cost of the qualifying replacement property actually acquired rather than the provenance of funds; financed amounts that buy qualifying property still count as reinvestment.
Why not D: Misleading because debt reflects financing method; however, debt alone is not the controlling comparison, the total cost of the replacement property (including financed portions) is compared to the amount realized.
Question 4
Hint
Compute realized gain, compare proceeds reinvested to amount realized: uninvested proceeds are recognized; deferred gain reduces the replacement basis.
Answer C. Realized gain = $900,000 − $620,000 = $280,000. Maple reinvested $840,000 of the $900,000 proceeds, so $60,000 ($900,000 − $840,000) is recognized and $220,000 is deferred. The deferred $220,000 reduces basis: replacement basis = $840,000 − $220,000 = $620,000.
Why not A: Tempting because §1033 can defer gain when replacement property is purchased. Incorrect because full nonrecognition requires reinvestment of the entire amount realized; Maple left $60,000 uninvested, so that portion is recognized.
Why not B: Tempting because it correctly identifies the recognized portion of gain. Wrong because it ignores that the deferred gain (the portion not recognized) reduces the replacement property's basis; the basis should be $840,000 − $220,000 = $620,000.
Why not D: Tempting if one ignores the Sec. 1033 election or assumes all realized gain is taxable. Incorrect because §1033 allows deferral of the portion of gain reinvested; only the $60,000 of proceeds not reinvested is recognized here.
Question 5
Hint
Compute realized gain first, then compare the condemnation proceeds with the amount reinvested in qualifying replacement property.
Answer D. Ridge realized a $170,000 gain ($470,000 proceeds less $300,000 adjusted basis). Under the involuntary conversion nonrecognition rules, recognized gain equals the portion of proceeds not reinvested, so Ridge recognizes $40,000 ($470,000 less $430,000). The deferred gain is $130,000, so the replacement property's basis is cost $430,000 less deferred gain $130,000 = $300,000.
Why not A: Tempting if a candidate compares replacement cost to the old basis, but recognition depends on proceeds received versus amount reinvested; because Ridge reinvested $40,000 less than the proceeds, $40,000 is recognized.
Why not B: This gets the recognized gain correct but wrongly treats the replacement property as taking a full cost basis. Under the involuntary conversion rules, the deferred gain reduces the basis of the replacement property (basis = cost minus deferred gain).
Why not C: This treats the condemnation as a fully taxable sale and ignores the nonrecognition election and reinvestment; because most proceeds were reinvested, only $40,000 is recognized and the basis is reduced for deferred gain.
Question 6
Hint
Break the task into two parts: (1) compute the amount realized and realized gain, and (2) identify the replacement period that applies to condemned investment real property before comparing replacement cost to the amount realized.
Answer D. For an involuntary conversion under §1033 the amount realized is the gross condemnation award ($900,000); payment of part of the award directly to a mortgagee does not generally reduce the amount realized. Realized gain = $900,000 - $420,000 = $480,000; because Lane reinvested $760,000, Lane recognizes the $140,000 shortfall ($900,000 - $760,000). Condemned real property held for investment is afforded a three-year replacement period after the close of the tax year of the conversion, so an acquisition in November Year 4 is within that period.
Why not A: Tempting because the general involuntary conversion replacement period is two years, but there is a special three-year period for condemned real property held for investment (measured from the close of the conversion year); thus November Year 4 falls within the three-year window.
Why not B: Tempting because candidates equate 'net cash received' with amount realized; however, §1033 treats the gross condemnation award as the amount realized even when part is paid directly to satisfy a mortgage, so Lane's replacement obligation is measured against $900,000, not just the net cash retained.
Why not C: Tempting because $760,000 exceeds the adjusted basis, but deferral under §1033 requires replacement cost at least equal to the amount realized ($900,000) to fully defer gain; exceeding the taxpayer's basis alone is not sufficient.
Common questions
How do I calculate recognized gain under Section 1033?
Subtract qualifying replacement cost from proceeds, but recognize no more than realized gain and no less than zero. Cedar recognizes $100,000 because its $700,000 award exceeds replacement cost by $100,000.
Does a mortgage payoff reduce condemnation proceeds under Section 1033?
No. Cedar uses the full $700,000 award even though $100,000 goes directly to the lender, leaving only $600,000 in cash.
How do I calculate the basis of Section 1033 replacement property?
Subtract deferred gain from replacement cost. Cedar defers $200,000, so its replacement basis is $600,000 minus $200,000, or $400,000.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Nontaxable disposition of assets
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.