TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 6 practice questions
What Property Qualifies for a Like-Kind Exchange After TCJA?
Section 1031 requires both properties to be like-kind real property held for business or investment, not personal use or primarily for sale. Below, change one fact in Rowan’s exchange and test whether both properties remain eligible.
Try one first
Hint
First determine whether §1031 applies to the types of property (real vs. personal) under current law; then check whether each property is held for investment or productive business use rather than as inventory or for personal use.
Answer B. Option B is correct because, under current law (as limited by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017), §1031 nonrecognition applies only to exchanges of real property held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment. Different qualifying U.S. real properties, such as a rental office building and investment farmland, are generally treated as like-kind, so a direct swap meeting the other §1031 requirements would be eligible for nonrecognition.
Why not A: This is tempting because both assets are used in a business and older rules allowed exchanges of business personal property. However, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act narrowed §1031 so that, under current law, machinery and other personal property are not qualifying like-kind property; §1031 now applies to real property only.
Why not C: At first glance both are real property, but §1031 requires that both the relinquished and replacement properties be held for investment or for productive use in a trade or business. A vacation condominium held primarily for personal use does not meet the 'held for investment or trade/business use' requirement, so the exchange is ineligible.
Why not D: This appears attractive because both are real property, but property held primarily for sale to customers (dealer inventory) is excluded from §1031. Because the relinquished lots are held as inventory by a developer, the exchange fails the qualifying-use requirement and is not eligible for nonrecognition.
Sort it
Both properties are like-kind real property held for business or investment, and the other exchange requirements are satisfied.
Either property fails the real-property or holding-purpose requirement, or the properties are not like-kind.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Rowan directly exchanges a U.S. office building held for investment for U.S. vacant land to hold for investment. No cash, other property, or liabilities are involved. All other Section 1031 requirements are satisfied. Is the exchange eligible? | EligibleAn office building and vacant land can be like-kind. Both satisfy the investment-purpose requirement. Holding vacant land for appreciation qualifies even without current rental income. |
| Same facts, except Rowan held the office building primarily for sale to customers. Is the exchange eligible? | Not eligibleThe relinquished building is dealer property. Qualifying replacement land does not cure its disqualifying holding purpose. |
| Same facts, except Rowan will use the replacement land in its business rather than hold it for investment. Is the exchange eligible? | EligibleBusiness use also qualifies. The properties do not need identical uses. |
| Same facts, except Rowan receives machinery to hold for investment instead of the investment land. Is the exchange eligible? | Not eligibleThe replacement machinery is personal property, so it does not qualify under Section 1031 even though Rowan holds it for investment. |
| Same facts, except Rowan acquires the replacement land intending to subdivide and sell lots to customers. Is the exchange eligible? | Not eligibleThe intended resale to customers makes the replacement land dealer property rather than investment property. |
| Same facts, except the replacement investment land is in Canada. Is the exchange eligible? | Not eligibleU.S. real property and foreign real property are not like-kind, even when both are held for investment. |
| Same facts, except the relinquished office building is fully depreciated for tax purposes. Is the exchange eligible? | EligibleFull depreciation does not change eligibility. The building remains investment real property; zero basis is not the holding-purpose test. |
| Same facts, except Rowan intends to use the replacement land solely for personal recreation. Is the exchange eligible? | Not eligibleThe land is real property, but its intended personal use fails the replacement property's holding-purpose requirement. |
| Same facts, except Rowan receives a membership interest in an LLC taxed as a partnership that owns the land. Is the exchange eligible? | Not eligibleA partnership interest is not qualifying real property. The LLC's ownership of land does not change that result. |
| Same facts, except Rowan held the relinquished office building solely for personal use rather than investment. Is the exchange eligible? | Not eligiblePersonal-use property given up fails the holding-purpose requirement even when the replacement land will be held for investment. |
Key points
- Remember: Check both properties for real-property status and business or investment purpose.
- Different uses can qualify: an investment property can be exchanged for business-use real property.
- U.S. real property and foreign real property are not like-kind.
- A partnership interest is not qualifying real property, even when the partnership owns real estate.
How the exam traps you
- Treating investment machinery as eligible because its holding purpose qualifies. Check property type first. Machinery is personal property and fails the real-property requirement.
- Assuming qualifying replacement land cures dealer status on the property given up. Test both sides. Property held primarily for sale fails even if the replacement property qualifies.
- Assuming all real estate qualifies regardless of intended use. Personal use fails the holding-purpose requirement, even when the asset is real property.
Question 2
Hint
Property type and procedural requirements are already satisfied, focus on the remaining substantive requirement Section 1031 imposes about the replacement property's intended use.
Answer A. Section 1031 nonrecognition is limited to like-kind property held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment. The stem already establishes qualifying real property and that procedural (identification/timing and no-boot) requirements are met, so the controlling issue is the intended use of the replacement land, land acquired primarily for resale to customers (inventory) would not qualify.
Why not B: This tempts because depreciation lowers basis and can increase realized gain, but basis/amount of gain affects tax calculation, not whether the exchange qualifies under Section 1031. Eligibility turns on property type and how the replacement property is used.
Why not C: Candidates are tempted because equal values and no boot affect recognized gain, yet equal FMVs by themselves do not satisfy Section 1031's holding-use requirement. The replacement property still must be held for investment or business use to qualify for deferral.
Why not D: This distracts because students often conflate the mechanics of simultaneous versus deferred exchanges with substantive eligibility, but Section 1031 permits deferred exchanges so long as the identification/timing rules are met; the stem already assumes those procedural requirements are satisfied, so transfer timing is not the governing factor.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on the intended use of the replacement property, investment versus inventory/dealer use, and whether cash or prior depreciation affect eligibility or only the amount of recognized gain.
Answer D. Section 1031 applies only to like‑kind exchanges of real property held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment. Property held primarily for sale to customers (inventory or dealer property) is not qualifying replacement property, so an intent to subdivide and sell lots in the ordinary course of business disqualifies the exchange. By contrast, receiving cash is treated as boot (causing recognition to the extent of the boot), and prior depreciation affects gain/recapture and basis but does not by itself make a like‑kind exchange ineligible.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates sometimes think any cash destroys 1031 treatment; however, cash received is generally treated as boot and typically causes recognition only to the extent of the boot while the remainder of the exchange can still qualify under Section 1031.
Why not B: Tempting if a candidate confuses ''land'' with ''property held for sale,'' but unimproved land held for investment is qualifying like‑kind real property and does not prevent nonrecognition treatment.
Why not C: Tempting because prior depreciation raises recapture and basis issues, but being fully depreciated does not disqualify an otherwise valid Section 1031 exchange; it affects the amount of taxable gain, potential recapture, and the replacement property's basis, not eligibility for nonrecognition.
Question 4
Hint
For Sec. 1031, first test whether the relinquished property falls within the eligible category before worrying about physical differences between the properties.
Answer B. Section 1031 nonrecognition applies to exchanges of property held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment; real property that is inventory (held primarily for sale to customers) is excluded. Pine exchanged business-use property for investment land, so the transaction can meet Sec. 1031 requirements. Reed gave up dealer property (a lot held for sale), which generally disqualifies that exchange even though the replacement will be rented.
Why not A: Tempting because most U.S. real property is like-kind regardless of improvement, but like-kind status alone is insufficient; property held primarily for sale to customers (dealer/inventory) is not eligible under Sec. 1031.
Why not C: This distractor relies on the mistaken belief that the properties must have identical uses. For real property, like-kind exchanges may cross different business or investment uses so long as the property given up was held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment.
Why not D: This focuses only on the replacement property's future use. Eligibility is determined chiefly by the nature of the relinquished property; because Reed's lot was dealer property held for sale, the exchange is generally excluded from Sec. 1031 even if the replacement will be leased.
Question 5
Hint
Start by identifying what kinds of property current Sec. 1031 still covers before worrying about value differences.
Answer C. Section 1031 nonrecognition is currently limited to exchanges of qualifying real property held for investment or for productive use in a trade or business. Thus the primary eligibility question is whether both the relinquished and replacement properties are qualifying real property held for the proper purpose. Differences in location or in fair market value do not themselves prevent 1031 treatment; any cash received is treated as 'boot' and may cause partial recognition of gain but does not determine initial eligibility.
Why not A: For real property, 'like-kind' is broadly interpreted, properties can be in different states and used for different business activities and still qualify so long as both are qualifying real property held for investment or business use. Location or identical line-of-business use is not the controlling factor.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates often associate 'like-kind' with equal value, but equal FMV is not required. Value differences can create boot (and partial gain recognition), but they do not decide whether the exchange qualifies under Section 1031.
Why not D: This reflects an overbroad view: being depreciable or merely used in a business does not make property eligible. Raw land is not depreciable yet can qualify; after the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, Section 1031 generally applies only to real property, not to depreciable personal property.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on two points: whether both properties are qualifying real property under current Section 1031 rules, and whether the taxpayer paid boot or received boot.
Answer B. Under IRC Section 1031, like-kind exchanges of real property held for investment generally qualify for nonrecognition of gain or loss. Unimproved land and an investment warehouse are both real property and are treated as like-kind. Recognition of gain is triggered when a taxpayer receives boot (money or other non-like-kind property); here Lark paid cash and received only like-kind property, so no gain is recognized.
Why not A: This distractor plays on the rule that 'boot' can cause recognition. The trap is reversing the direction: gain is recognized when boot is received, not when boot is given. Because Lark paid $10,000 and did not receive boot, the exchange remains nonrecognition.
Why not C: This reflects the common mistaken belief that properties must be similar in physical form. For Section 1031 purposes after the TCJA, different types of U.S. real property held for investment or business use are generally like-kind to one another, so land can be like-kind to improved property such as a warehouse.
Why not D: This overgeneralizes 'like-kind' to mean identical. Section 1031 does not require identical property; because the facts state the exchange met Section 1031 requirements and involved qualifying real property, it is not treated as a taxable sale and purchase.
Common questions
Does equipment qualify for a like-kind exchange after TCJA?
No. Section 1031 now applies only to real property. Replacement machinery fails even if Rowan intends to hold it for investment.
Can an office building be exchanged for vacant investment land?
Yes, if both properties meet the holding-purpose requirement and the other exchange requirements are satisfied. Vacant land held for appreciation qualifies without current rental income.
Does property held for sale qualify for a Section 1031 exchange?
No. Property held primarily for sale does not qualify on either side. Acquiring the replacement land with the intent to subdivide and sell lots to customers fails the holding-purpose requirement.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Nontaxable disposition of assets
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.