PracticeTCPFree practice exam

TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 6 practice questions

What Property Qualifies for a Like-Kind Exchange After TCJA?

Section 1031 requires both properties to be like-kind real property held for business or investment, not personal use or primarily for sale. Below, change one fact in Rowan’s exchange and test whether both properties remain eligible.

The ruleSection 1031 applies to exchanges of like-kind real property held for business or investment on both sides. Personal property, personal-use property, and property held primarily for sale do not qualify.

Try one first

Under current federal income tax law (as limited by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 to exchanges of real property), which transaction is properly classified as eligible for like-kind nonrecognition treatment under §1031, assuming each exchange is a direct swap, no cash is paid or received, and no liabilities are assumed or relieved?
Hint

First determine whether §1031 applies to the types of property (real vs. personal) under current law; then check whether each property is held for investment or productive business use rather than as inventory or for personal use.

Sort it

Eligible

Both properties are like-kind real property held for business or investment, and the other exchange requirements are satisfied.

Not eligible

Either property fails the real-property or holding-purpose requirement, or the properties are not like-kind.

ItemGoes to
Rowan directly exchanges a U.S. office building held for investment for U.S. vacant land to hold for investment. No cash, other property, or liabilities are involved. All other Section 1031 requirements are satisfied. Is the exchange eligible?EligibleAn office building and vacant land can be like-kind. Both satisfy the investment-purpose requirement. Holding vacant land for appreciation qualifies even without current rental income.
Same facts, except Rowan held the office building primarily for sale to customers. Is the exchange eligible?Not eligibleThe relinquished building is dealer property. Qualifying replacement land does not cure its disqualifying holding purpose.
Same facts, except Rowan will use the replacement land in its business rather than hold it for investment. Is the exchange eligible?EligibleBusiness use also qualifies. The properties do not need identical uses.
Same facts, except Rowan receives machinery to hold for investment instead of the investment land. Is the exchange eligible?Not eligibleThe replacement machinery is personal property, so it does not qualify under Section 1031 even though Rowan holds it for investment.
Same facts, except Rowan acquires the replacement land intending to subdivide and sell lots to customers. Is the exchange eligible?Not eligibleThe intended resale to customers makes the replacement land dealer property rather than investment property.
Same facts, except the replacement investment land is in Canada. Is the exchange eligible?Not eligibleU.S. real property and foreign real property are not like-kind, even when both are held for investment.
Same facts, except the relinquished office building is fully depreciated for tax purposes. Is the exchange eligible?EligibleFull depreciation does not change eligibility. The building remains investment real property; zero basis is not the holding-purpose test.
Same facts, except Rowan intends to use the replacement land solely for personal recreation. Is the exchange eligible?Not eligibleThe land is real property, but its intended personal use fails the replacement property's holding-purpose requirement.
Same facts, except Rowan receives a membership interest in an LLC taxed as a partnership that owns the land. Is the exchange eligible?Not eligibleA partnership interest is not qualifying real property. The LLC's ownership of land does not change that result.
Same facts, except Rowan held the relinquished office building solely for personal use rather than investment. Is the exchange eligible?Not eligiblePersonal-use property given up fails the holding-purpose requirement even when the replacement land will be held for investment.

Key points

  • Remember: Check both properties for real-property status and business or investment purpose.
  • Different uses can qualify: an investment property can be exchanged for business-use real property.
  • U.S. real property and foreign real property are not like-kind.
  • A partnership interest is not qualifying real property, even when the partnership owns real estate.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating investment machinery as eligible because its holding purpose qualifies. Check property type first. Machinery is personal property and fails the real-property requirement.
  • Assuming qualifying replacement land cures dealer status on the property given up. Test both sides. Property held primarily for sale fails even if the replacement property qualifies.
  • Assuming all real estate qualifies regardless of intended use. Personal use fails the holding-purpose requirement, even when the asset is real property.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

In Year 1, Rowan owns an office building used in its trade or business. Rowan plans to exchange the building for vacant land of similar value. Assume both properties are U.S. real property, the exchange otherwise satisfies Section 1031 identification and timing rules, and Rowan will not receive cash or other non-like-kind property. Which factor will govern whether Rowan may defer gain under Section 1031?
Hint

Property type and procedural requirements are already satisfied, focus on the remaining substantive requirement Section 1031 imposes about the replacement property's intended use.

Question 3

In Year 1, Orion, an individual taxpayer, completes a properly structured deferred exchange using a qualified intermediary. Orion transfers a U.S. warehouse held for investment and, within the applicable statutory deadlines, receives replacement U.S. real property intended to replace it. Assume there are no related‑party issues and no facts exist other than those described in the answer choices. Which additional fact would make Section 1031 nonrecognition treatment unavailable for the exchange?
Hint

Focus on the intended use of the replacement property, investment versus inventory/dealer use, and whether cash or prior depreciation affect eligibility or only the amount of recognized gain.

Question 4

In Year 1, Pine Co. exchanged a warehouse it had used in its business for several acres of unimproved U.S. land that it will hold for investment. In a separate transaction, Reed LLC, a real estate developer, exchanged a U.S. residential lot that it had held primarily for sale to customers for an office building that Reed will lease to third parties. Assume in both transactions that only U.S. real property was exchanged, no cash or other boot was involved, liabilities do not affect the result, and all exchange mechanics and timing requirements were otherwise satisfied. Which statement best reflects the governing factor in determining whether nonrecognition treatment is available under Sec. 1031?
Hint

For Sec. 1031, first test whether the relinquished property falls within the eligible category before worrying about physical differences between the properties.

Question 5

In Year 1, Parker plans to exchange raw land held for investment for an office building that Parker will also hold for investment. The properties are in different states and have different fair values, so Parker may receive some cash at closing. Ignoring timing and intermediary issues, which factor primarily governs whether this disposition is the type that can qualify for nonrecognition under current Sec. 1031 rules?
Hint

Start by identifying what kinds of property current Sec. 1031 still covers before worrying about value differences.

Question 6

In Year 1, Lark exchanged unimproved land held for investment (adjusted basis $120,000; FMV $170,000) and paid $10,000 cash in exchange for a warehouse held for investment with an FMV of $180,000. Assume the exchange satisfied all Section 1031 requirements, neither party assumed liabilities, and Lark received no cash or other non-like-kind property. How should Lark classify this disposition for federal income tax purposes?
Hint

Focus on two points: whether both properties are qualifying real property under current Section 1031 rules, and whether the taxpayer paid boot or received boot.

Drill all 130 Nontaxable disposition of assets questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does equipment qualify for a like-kind exchange after TCJA?

No. Section 1031 now applies only to real property. Replacement machinery fails even if Rowan intends to hold it for investment.

Can an office building be exchanged for vacant investment land?

Yes, if both properties meet the holding-purpose requirement and the other exchange requirements are satisfied. Vacant land held for appreciation qualifies without current rental income.

Does property held for sale qualify for a Section 1031 exchange?

No. Property held primarily for sale does not qualify on either side. Acquiring the replacement land with the intent to subdivide and sell lots to customers fails the holding-purpose requirement.

Practice TCP like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Nontaxable disposition of assets

All Nontaxable disposition of assets practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.