TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 13 practice questions
1031 Exchange Boot: Debt Assumed vs. Debt Relieved
Debt assumed offsets debt relieved in a qualifying Section 1031 exchange, but it cannot offset cash received. Below: compare the same exchange as one cash or mortgage fact changes, then practice spotting the difference.
Try one first
Hint
Do not stop once you decide the exchange qualifies under Section 1031. Consider whether the mortgage changes create something treated like cash.
Answer A. The exchange otherwise qualifies for nonrecognition under Section 1031, but net debt relief is treated as boot received. Tate was relieved of a $90,000 mortgage and assumed a $40,000 mortgage, so the net boot is $50,000. Tate's realized gain is $150,000 ($400,000 FMV less $250,000 basis), so the recognized gain is the lesser of realized gain or boot: $50,000.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates often stop after identifying a qualifying like-kind exchange and remember the general nonrecognition rule. However, Section 1031 treats net mortgage relief as boot. Tate's liabilities decreased overall by $50,000, which triggers recognition to that extent.
Why not C: This choice reflects the common mistake of treating only the liability relieved as boot and ignoring liabilities assumed on the replacement property. Boot from liabilities is the net reduction in the taxpayer's liabilities (90,000 relieved minus 40,000 assumed = 50,000), not the full $90,000.
Why not D: This distractor overstates the effect of liabilities. Liabilities do not automatically force full recognition; the taxpayer recognizes gain only to the extent of boot received, and that recognized amount cannot exceed the realized gain (here, $150,000), so only $50,000 is recognized.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Tate exchanges U.S. investment land in a qualifying Section 1031 exchange. The old land has a $250,000 adjusted basis and a $90,000 mortgage that the other party assumes. Tate receives replacement investment land worth $350,000, assumes its $90,000 mortgage, and receives $20,000 cash. There are no exchange expenses or other property.
Answer: Tate recognizes $20,000 of gain.
Realized gain is $350,000 + $20,000 + $90,000 − $90,000 − $250,000 = $120,000. The equal mortgages create no liability boot. Only the $20,000 cash is boot, so Tate recognizes $20,000.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Debt assumed falls from $90,000 to $40,000.
Answer: Tate recognizes $70,000 of gain.
Realized gain is $170,000. Net debt relief is $90,000 − $40,000 = $50,000. Add $20,000 cash for $70,000 of boot.
Change 2Debt assumed rises from $90,000 to $120,000.
Answer: Tate still recognizes $20,000 of gain.
Realized gain is $90,000. Liability boot is zero. The excess $30,000 debt assumed cannot offset cash, so the unchanged $20,000 recognition is the key test.
Change 3Cash received falls from $20,000 to zero.
Answer: Tate recognizes no gain.
Realized gain is $100,000. Equal mortgages create no liability boot, and Tate receives no cash. With no boot, no gain is recognized.
Key points
- Remember: Net the mortgages separately, then add cash received; a negative mortgage difference cannot erase cash boot.
- Use zero for liability boot when debt assumed equals or exceeds debt relieved.
- Equal mortgages eliminate liability boot, not cash boot.
How the exam traps you
- Counting the entire mortgage relieved as boot. Subtract the mortgage assumed before adding cash received.
- Using excess debt assumed to reduce cash boot. Stop liability boot at zero. Keep cash received in boot.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer B. Correct. Net debt relief is zero, leaving $20,000 of cash boot.
Why not A: Incorrect. Equal mortgages eliminate liability boot, but the cash remains boot.
Why not C: Incorrect. This adds gross mortgage relief to cash without subtracting debt assumed.
Why not D: Incorrect. This is realized gain, not recognized gain.
Question 2
Answer C. Correct. Boot is $20,000 cash plus $50,000 net debt relief.
Why not A: Incorrect. This counts cash but ignores $50,000 of net debt relief.
Why not B: Incorrect. This counts net debt relief but omits the $20,000 cash.
Why not D: Incorrect. This counts the full $90,000 relieved without offsetting the $40,000 assumed.
Question 3
Answer B. Correct. Liability boot is zero, but the $20,000 cash remains boot.
Why not A: Incorrect. Excess debt assumed cannot erase the $20,000 cash boot.
Why not C: Incorrect. This is realized gain, which exceeds the boot received.
Why not D: Incorrect. This adds gross debt relief to cash and ignores debt assumed.
Question 4
Answer A. Correct. Equal mortgages and no cash mean no boot.
Why not B: Incorrect. Tate no longer receives the base scenario's $20,000 cash.
Why not C: Incorrect. The $90,000 debt assumed fully offsets the $90,000 debt relieved.
Why not D: Incorrect. This is realized gain, but no boot requires current recognition.
Question 2
Hint
First decide whether the exchanged properties qualify for current like-kind treatment. Then determine what effect, if any, the cash received has on gain recognition.
Answer C. Both properties are U.S. real property held for investment, so the exchange can qualify under like-kind exchange rules. Liam's realized gain is $80,000 (FMV received $260,000 less basis $180,000), but he received $15,000 of cash (boot). Gain recognition in a qualifying like-kind exchange is limited to the boot received, so Liam recognizes $15,000 and defers the remaining $65,000.
Why not A: Many candidates mistakenly think land and improved real estate are not like-kind. Under current law, most U.S. real property used in business or held for investment is like-kind to other U.S. real property, so the exchange can qualify and is not automatically fully taxable for that reason.
Why not B: This confuses the general nonrecognition principle for like-kind exchanges with the boot rule. Because Liam received $15,000 of cash, he must recognize gain up to the amount of boot, so he cannot defer all gain.
Why not D: Receiving boot does not destroy like-kind exchange treatment; it only triggers recognition of gain to the extent of the boot received (or the realized gain, if smaller). Only the portion equal to boot is recognized, not the entire realized gain.
Question 3
Hint
First compute realized gain, then ask how much of that gain must be recognized when like-kind real property is received along with cash.
Answer A. Lane realized a gain of $90,000 (amount realized $230,000 minus adjusted basis $140,000). Under Sec. 1031, realized gain is recognized only to the extent of boot received. Because Lane received $20,000 in cash boot, the recognized gain in 20X5 is $20,000 (the remaining $70,000 is deferred).
Why not B: Tempting because Sec. 1031 often defers gain, but nonrecognition is limited when boot is received. The $20,000 cash forces recognition up to that amount.
Why not C: This equals the deferred portion of the realized $90,000 gain (realized $90,000 minus recognized $20,000), not the amount recognized in the current year.
Why not D: This is the total realized gain (FMV received minus basis) and reflects a common error of recognizing the full realized gain. Under a qualifying like-kind exchange, recognition is limited to the boot received.
Question 4
Hint
Separate realized gain from recognized gain, and treat liabilities relieved and liabilities assumed as net boot.
Answer B. Vera's realized gain equals $900,000 − $540,000 = $360,000. Under Sec. 1031, recognized gain is limited to boot received; Vera's net debt relief (boot) is $150,000 relieved − $90,000 assumed = $60,000. Therefore, Vera recognizes $60,000 of gain in Year 1 and defers the remainder.
Why not A: Tempting because like-kind real property exchanges are often nonrecognition transactions, but complete nonrecognition applies only when no boot is received. Vera received net boot through debt relief, so some gain must be recognized.
Why not C: This reflects the mistake of treating only the liability relieved as boot without netting liabilities. Liabilities relieved and liabilities assumed are netted for boot, giving $150,000 − $90,000 = $60,000, not $150,000.
Why not D: This is the realized gain amount, but realized gain is not automatically recognized in a qualifying Sec. 1031 exchange. Recognized gain is limited to boot, which here is $60,000.
Question 5
Hint
First decide whether the real-property exchange qualifies for Sec. 1031 at all; then separately determine what the cash does to gain recognition and replacement basis.
Answer B. Park realized a $70,000 gain (FMV $210,000 less adjusted basis $140,000). Under Sec. 1031, gain is recognized only to the extent of boot received, so Park recognizes $18,000 of gain. The basis in the replacement land is the old basis increased by any recognized gain and reduced by cash received: $140,000 + $18,000 - $18,000 = $140,000.
Why not A: Tempting because like-kind exchanges are generally nonrecognition transactions, but Park received $18,000 of cash (boot). Boot triggers recognition of gain to the extent of the boot, so some gain must be reported.
Why not C: This relies on an outdated misconception. For Sec. 1031, domestic real property is generally like-kind to other domestic real property regardless of whether one parcel is improved and the other is raw land; because the exchange otherwise qualifies, only the boot portion is recognized.
Why not D: This correctly identifies the recognized gain but misapplies the replacement-basis formula by adding the recognized gain to the old basis without reducing basis for cash received. The proper formula yields a $140,000 basis.
Question 6
Hint
First decide whether the properties qualify for Sec. 1031 treatment. Then separately determine what effect, if any, the cash received has on the amount of gain recognized.
Answer A. The exchange qualifies under Sec. 1031 because Alder exchanged investment real estate for other real property to be held for rental. Alder's amount realized is $120,000 (warehouse $110,000 + $10,000 cash), so realized gain is $50,000 ($120,000 - $70,000 basis). Because Alder received $10,000 cash (boot), recognized gain is limited to the lesser of realized gain or boot received, so Alder recognizes $10,000.
Why not B: This distractor plays on the misconception that the properties must be identical in use or physical character. Under Sec. 1031, real property used for investment or held for productive use in a trade or business is generally like-kind to other real property; the exchange therefore qualifies and is not fully taxable.
Why not C: While both properties qualify for Sec. 1031 treatment, this choice ignores the cash received. Receipt of cash (boot) causes partial recognition of gain up to the amount of boot (or the realized gain, if smaller).
Why not D: This answer overstates the effect of boot: receiving boot does not eliminate nonrecognition treatment for the remainder of the exchange; it only forces recognition to the extent of boot (subject to the realized gain limit). Alder recognizes $10,000, not the full $50,000.
Question 7
Hint
First compute the realized gain, then ask whether the taxpayer received any boot.
Answer B. Maya realized a $50,000 gain (FMV of property given up $170,000 minus adjusted basis $120,000). Because the exchange qualifies under Sec. 1031, gain is deferred except to the extent of boot received; Maya received $20,000 cash, so she must recognize $20,000.
Why not A: This is tempting because like-kind exchanges generally defer gain. However, when the taxpayer receives boot (cash), gain is recognized up to the amount of the boot; here Maya received $20,000, so $0 is incorrect.
Why not C: A candidate might mistakenly compute gain as the replacement property's FMV minus the original adjusted basis (150,000 - 120,000 = 30,000). Recognition is not based on the replacement property's increase; it's limited to realized gain or boot, whichever is less.
Why not D: This equals the total realized gain (170,000 - 120,000 = 50,000) and is a trap for forgetting the Sec. 1031 deferral. In a qualifying like-kind exchange, realized gain is not fully recognized unless the boot equals or exceeds the realized gain; here only $20,000 is recognized.
Question 8
Hint
Compute realized gain first, then identify all boot received. Do not overlook net mortgage relief when determining both recognition and basis.
Answer A. Pine's realized gain is $120,000: amount realized of $260,000 ($220,000 replacement land + $10,000 cash + $30,000 liability relief) minus adjusted basis of $140,000. In a qualifying §1031 exchange, recognized gain is limited to boot received, which here is $40,000 ($10,000 cash plus $30,000 net liability relief). Pine's basis in the replacement land is $140,000, computed as old basis $140,000 + recognized gain $40,000 - cash received $10,000 - liability relief $30,000.
Why not B: This option ignores the $30,000 mortgage relief as boot and counts only the $10,000 cash as boot; because Pine was relieved of the $30,000 mortgage and assumed no replacement liability, total boot is $40,000, not $10,000.
Why not C: This gets the recognized gain correct but miscomputes basis by simply adding recognized gain to the old basis (140,000 + 40,000 = 180,000) and failing to subtract the boot received (cash and liability relief), which reduces the basis.
Why not D: This treats the transaction like a fully taxable sale (recognizing all realized gain) and uses the replacement property's FMV as basis; but in a qualifying §1031 exchange gain in excess of boot is deferred and reduces the basis calculation.
Question 9
Hint
Work in two steps: compute realized gain (FMV relinquished − basis) and compute total boot (cash received plus net debt relief). Recognized gain is the smaller of the two; then adjust basis for the deferred gain.
Answer C. Realized gain = $700,000 FMV of relinquished land − $400,000 adjusted basis = $300,000. Total boot = $18,000 cash + net mortgage relief of $50,000 ($150,000 relieved − $100,000 assumed) = $68,000, so recognized gain is the lesser ($68,000). Deferred gain = $300,000 − $68,000 = $232,000; basis in the replacement property = $632,000 FMV − $232,000 deferred gain = $400,000 (equivalently here, basis_old + recognized − total_boot = $400,000 + $68,000 − $68,000 = $400,000).
Why not A: Tempting because it correctly limits recognition to total boot but then miscomputes basis (for example, by improperly adding net debt relief to the old basis). It fails because basis is FMV of replacement minus deferred gain (or, in this exchange where no additional money was paid, basis_old + recognized − total_boot), which yields $400,000, not $450,000.
Why not B: Tempting because it counts only the $18,000 cash as boot. It fails because mortgage relief ($150,000 relieved − $100,000 assumed = $50,000) is also boot, making total boot $68,000 and increasing recognized gain to $68,000; the correct basis is $400,000, not $350,000.
Why not D: Tempting because it treats the transaction as a taxable sale and recognizes the full realized gain. It fails because a qualifying Sec. 1031 exchange defers gain to the extent of like‑kind consideration; Maple only received $68,000 of boot, so only $68,000 is recognized and most of the $300,000 is deferred.
Common questions
How do you calculate mortgage boot in a 1031 exchange?
Subtract debt assumed from debt relieved. A positive difference is liability boot; add it to cash received.
Can debt assumed offset cash received in a 1031 exchange?
No. Assuming $120,000 while being relieved of $90,000 creates no liability boot, but the $20,000 cash received remains boot.
Is there boot if both properties have equal mortgages?
Equal mortgages create no liability boot. Tate still has $20,000 of boot if cash is received, but no boot if no cash is received.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Nontaxable disposition of assets
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.