TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 9 practice questions
1031 Replacement Property Basis With No Debt
In a qualifying 1031 exchange with no debt, replacement basis equals old basis plus recognized gain and cash paid, minus cash received. Below: a worked loss example showing why replacement basis can exceed fair market value.
Try one first
Hint
First compute amount realized and the realized gain or loss (property FMV plus cash received minus adjusted basis), then apply Sec. 1031 recognition and the basis carryover adjustment (new basis = old basis + recognized gain - boot received).
Answer B. Amount realized = FMV of Parcel B ($250,000) + cash ($30,000) = $280,000. Realized loss = $280,000 - $310,000 = ($30,000). Under Sec. 1031, realized losses in qualifying like-kind exchanges are not recognized, so no loss is reported. Basis in the replacement property = old basis + recognized gain - boot received; here no gain is recognized, so basis = $310,000 - $30,000 = $280,000.
Why not A: Tempting because the realized amount is $30,000 less than basis, so a student might think the loss is recognized and the new basis equals the replacement property's FMV. It's wrong because Sec. 1031 disallows recognition of realized losses in qualifying exchanges, and the basis is not simply reset to the replacement property's FMV.
Why not C: Tempting because Sec. 1031 defers recognition and some students assume the replacement property's FMV becomes the new basis. It's wrong because the carryover basis rule applies and must be adjusted for boot received: new basis = old basis + recognized gain - boot received (here $310,000 - $30,000 = $280,000).
Why not D: Tempting because students often remember that receipt of cash (boot) can trigger recognition of gain up to the amount of boot. That rule only applies when there is a realized gain; here the realized amount is a loss, so no gain is recognized despite the cash received.
Worked example
Cedar Co. exchanges U.S. investment land with a $400,000 adjusted basis and $350,000 fair market value for U.S. investment land worth $300,000 plus $50,000 cash. Cedar pays no cash. The exchange qualifies under Section 1031. There are no liabilities or exchange expenses. Find Cedar's recognized gain or loss and replacement basis.
| 1 | Amount realized$300,000 replacement land FMV + $50,000 cash received = $350,000 | $350,000 |
| 2 | Realized loss$350,000 amount realized - $400,000 adjusted basis = -$50,000 | $50,000 loss |
| 3 | Recognized gain or loss$50,000 realized loss is not recognized under Section 1031. | $0 |
| 4 | Replacement land basis$400,000 old basis + $0 recognized gain + $0 cash paid - $50,000 cash received = $350,000 | $350,000 |
Cedar recognizes no gain or loss and takes a $350,000 basis in the replacement land.
Check: Replacement FMV plus unrecognized loss gives the same basis: $300,000 + $50,000 = $350,000.
Key points
- Start with adjusted basis, not the old property's fair market value.
- Cash received reduces replacement basis even when no gain or loss is recognized.
- Receiving cash does not create recognized gain when the exchange produces a realized loss.
- The unrecognized loss remains in the replacement property's basis.
How the exam traps you
- Using the replacement land's $300,000 fair market value as its basis. Preserve the $50,000 unrecognized loss: replacement basis is $350,000.
- Leaving basis at $400,000 because the loss is not recognized. Subtract the $50,000 cash received even though no gain or loss is recognized.
Question 2
Hint
First decide whether Maple received or paid boot. Then use the replacement-property basis rule for a qualifying like-kind exchange.
Answer B. For a qualifying Sec. 1031 exchange, the basis of the replacement property is generally the adjusted basis of the relinquished property plus any cash paid and plus any gain recognized. Maple paid $20,000 cash (boot) and recognized no gain, so basis = $180,000 + $20,000 + $0 = $200,000. Therefore Maple's basis in the replacement warehouse is $200,000.
Why not A: This reflects a simple carryover of the old basis but ignores that Maple paid $20,000 cash; cash paid increases the replacement property's basis.
Why not C: This equals the FMV of the relinquished property, but in a qualifying like-kind exchange the basis does not automatically step up to FMV.
Why not D: This equals the implied FMV of the replacement property (250,000 + 20,000), but the replacement basis is the old basis plus boot paid (and any recognized gain), not the replacement property's FMV unless gain is recognized.
Question 3
Hint
First determine how much gain is recognized because of the cash received, then apply the replacement-property basis formula.
Answer A. Tanner's realized gain is $26,000 ($110,000 amount realized less $84,000 basis). Because Tanner received $10,000 cash boot, Tanner recognizes $10,000 of gain. The basis of the replacement land equals the old basis ($84,000) minus cash received ($10,000) plus gain recognized ($10,000), which results in $84,000.
Why not B: This results from subtracting the $10,000 cash received from the old basis but failing to add back the gain recognized; that understates the replacement basis.
Why not C: This reflects incorrectly adding the cash boot to the old basis. Cash received reduces the carryover basis (and recognized gain is added back), so simply adding the boot is wrong.
Why not D: This uses the fair market value of the replacement land as basis. In a qualifying like-kind exchange, basis is generally carried over (adjusted) rather than reset to the replacement property's FMV.
Question 4
Hint
Decide first whether the exchange qualifies for current like-kind treatment, and then ask whether receiving cash can ever turn a realized loss into a recognized loss.
Answer D. This exchange qualifies as a §1031 like-kind exchange because both items are U.S. real property held for productive use or investment. River's amount realized is $390,000 (land) + $30,000 (cash) = $420,000, producing a realized loss of $80,000 ($420,000 − $500,000), but losses are not recognized under §1031. The basis in the replacement land is the carryover basis: $500,000 (old basis) minus $30,000 cash received = $470,000.
Why not A: This option treats the exchange as fully taxable, recognizing the entire economic loss and using FMV as the new basis. Because the exchange qualifies under §1031, the loss is deferred and the replacement basis reflects the carryover (higher than the FMV in this case).
Why not B: This answer assumes the replacement property takes a fair market value basis when no loss is recognized. Under §1031, the basis generally carries over from the relinquished property (adjusted for boot and any recognized gain), so the basis is not set to the $390,000 FMV.
Why not C: This distractor wrongly treats cash (boot) as creating a recognized loss equal to the boot. In reality, boot can force recognition of gain (to the extent of realized gain), but it does not convert a realized loss into a recognized loss. Here the realized $80,000 loss remains unrecognized.
Question 5
Hint
Compute realized gain before applying the boot rule, and then adjust the old basis for both the recognized gain and the cash received.
Answer A. Realized gain = amount realized (FMV received of $200,000 plus $60,000 cash = $260,000) minus basis surrendered ($240,000) = $20,000. Recognized gain is the lesser of realized gain ($20,000) or boot received ($60,000), so $20,000 is recognized. Basis in the replacement property = old basis ($240,000) + recognized gain ($20,000) - boot received ($60,000) = $200,000.
Why not B: This overgeneralizes full nonrecognition for like-kind exchanges and ignores the cash boot received. Because Lark realized a $20,000 gain and received cash, some gain must be recognized to the extent of the realized gain.
Why not C: This treats all boot as automatically recognized without comparing it to the realized gain. Recognized gain is limited to the lesser of boot or realized gain; here realized gain is only $20,000, so recognizing $60,000 would exceed the actual gain.
Why not D: This gets the recognized gain right but fails to adjust the basis for cash boot received. The replacement basis must subtract the boot received after adding the recognized gain, yielding $200,000, not $240,000.
Question 6
Hint
First determine whether the exchange qualifies for Sec. 1031 treatment, then keep realized loss separate from recognized loss before computing the replacement property's substituted basis.
Answer C. This is a qualifying like-kind exchange of real property under Sec. 1031. Doran's realized loss is $40,000 (total value received $180,000 versus basis $220,000), but realized losses are not recognized in a qualifying 1031 exchange, so no loss is recognized now. The replacement property's basis is the carryover basis reduced by cash boot received: $220,000 - $20,000 = $200,000.
Why not A: This incorrectly treats boot as producing a recognized loss and resets basis to the FMV of the replacement property. In a qualifying Sec. 1031 exchange, losses are deferred and the basis generally carries over, adjusted for cash received.
Why not B: Although it correctly defers recognition of the loss, it incorrectly sets the replacement basis equal to the replacement property's FMV. The basis carries over from the old property and is reduced by any cash boot received, giving $200,000 here.
Why not D: This computes the realized loss and the substituted basis correctly, but it wrongly treats the realized loss as currently deductible. Under Sec. 1031 the loss is deferred, so no loss is recognized now.
Question 7
Hint
First decide whether the exchange qualifies for Section 1031 under current law, then separately determine the effect of the cash received.
Answer C. The exchange qualifies under §1031 because both the relinquished land and the replacement warehouse are real property held for investment or productive use in a trade or business. Realized gain is $160,000 (370,000 FMV − 210,000 basis), but recognition is limited to the $30,000 cash boot received. The warehouse's basis is the substituted basis: 210,000 (old basis) + 30,000 recognized gain − 30,000 boot = 210,000.
Why not A: This reflects the common mistake that the properties must have identical uses to be like-kind. Under current law, most real property held for investment or for productive use in a trade or business is like-kind to other real property for §1031 purposes, so full recognition of the $160,000 realized gain is not required.
Why not B: This is tempting because a real-property-for-real-property exchange can qualify for nonrecognition. However, the taxpayer received $30,000 cash (boot), so gain must be recognized to the extent of the boot. Ignoring the boot gives the wrong recognized gain and the wrong replacement basis.
Why not D: This choice correctly limits recognition to the $30,000 cash boot but incorrectly sets the replacement basis equal to the replacement property's fair market value. In a §1031 exchange the replacement generally takes a substituted basis adjusted for recognized gain and boot, not a fresh FMV basis; here that adjusted basis remains $210,000.
Question 8
Hint
Compute the overall realized gain or loss after qualifying exchange expenses before deciding what the cash boot can do.
Answer D. Amount realized = $445,000 (property received) + $15,000 cash - $10,000 exchange expenses = $450,000. Compared with Lee's $530,000 adjusted basis, the exchange produces an $80,000 realized loss. Under a qualifying Sec. 1031 like-kind exchange, realized losses are not recognized; boot cannot create recognized gain when there is no realized gain. Replacement basis = carryover basis adjusted for the exchange = $530,000 + $10,000 exchange expenses - $15,000 cash = $525,000.
Why not A: Economically an $80,000 loss exists, but Sec. 1031 generally defers (disallows recognition of) losses in a qualifying like-kind exchange. Also, the replacement basis is not reset to its FMV; the deferred loss is preserved through the carryover-style basis calculation.
Why not B: Tempting because candidates often net the $15,000 cash boot against the $10,000 exchange expenses and treat the $5,000 difference as recognized gain. That shortcut skips the required first step: there is an overall $80,000 realized loss, so there is no realized gain for the boot to recognize.
Why not C: This reflects correctly concluding no recognition but forgetting that exchange expenses affect basis. Simply doing old basis minus cash (530,000 - 15,000) gives $515,000, but the $10,000 exchange expenses increase the replacement basis to $525,000.
Question 9
Hint
First decide whether the two real properties are eligible for Sec. 1031 treatment under current law. Then separate realized gain from recognized gain, and remember how cash paid affects basis.
Answer B. This is a qualifying §1031 exchange because both properties are real property held for investment or for productive use in a trade or business. Dana realized a $120,000 gain ($300,000 FMV − $180,000 basis) but recognized no gain because no boot was received (Dana paid $25,000 rather than received cash). Dana's basis in the warehouse is the carryover basis plus the cash paid: $180,000 + $25,000 = $205,000.
Why not A: Tempting because of the carryover-basis idea, but it ignores that when a taxpayer pays additional cash in a §1031 exchange, that cash increases the basis of the replacement property.
Why not C: Reflects the common mistake of treating any cash involved as boot that triggers gain. Here Dana paid cash (boot paid), so no boot was received and no gain is recognized; the basis amount shown is correct, which makes this distractor appealing.
Why not D: Appealing if a candidate incorrectly believes the transaction is taxable or that like-kind treatment doesn't apply between investment and business-use real property. Because the exchange qualifies under §1031, the realized gain is deferred and the basis is not stepped up to the replacement property's FMV.
Common questions
What is the basis formula for a 1031 exchange with no debt?
With no exchange expenses, use old adjusted basis plus recognized gain plus cash paid minus cash received. Here, $400,000 + $0 + $0 - $50,000 = $350,000.
Can replacement property basis exceed fair market value in a 1031 exchange?
Yes. Here, the $350,000 basis exceeds the replacement land's $300,000 fair market value by the $50,000 unrecognized loss.
Does receiving cash make a 1031 exchange loss deductible?
No. The $50,000 realized loss is not recognized, even though cash is received. The cash reduces replacement basis instead.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Nontaxable disposition of assets
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.