TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 6 practice questions
1031 Exchanges After TCJA: Equipment and Inventory Boot
Only qualifying real property receives Section 1031 deferral; equipment, inventory, and cash received are boot. Below, a worked exchange shows how to separate total realized gain from gain taxable now.
Try one first
Hint
First decide which items received qualify as like-kind property under current Sec. 1031 rules, then compare total boot to the realized gain.
Answer C. Lark realized a gain of $240,000 (FMV $760,000 less basis $520,000). Under current Sec. 1031 rules, only real property qualifies for like-kind treatment, so the $35,000 office furniture and the $25,000 cash are boot (non-like-kind). Total boot is $60,000, and recognized gain is the lesser of realized gain or boot received, so Lark recognizes $60,000.
Why not A: Tempting if one focuses only on business/investment use, but after the TCJA Sec. 1031 nonrecognition applies only to exchanges of real property. The office furniture is personal property and thus constitutes boot that can trigger recognition.
Why not B: This reflects spotting cash as boot but overlooking that non-like-kind personal property received (the furniture) is also boot. Both the $25,000 cash and the $35,000 furniture count as boot.
Why not D: While the furniture is non-like-kind property, cash received in a like-kind exchange is also boot. The correct total boot is $35,000 + $25,000 = $60,000, not $35,000.
Worked example
Cedar LLC exchanges U.S. investment land with a $320,000 adjusted basis and $600,000 fair market value. It receives U.S. investment land worth $480,000, movable equipment worth $60,000, inventory worth $40,000, and $20,000 cash. The real property exchange otherwise qualifies under Section 1031. The equipment is personal property. There are no liabilities or exchange expenses.
| 1 | Total fair market value received$480,000 + $60,000 + $40,000 + $20,000 | $600,000 |
| 2 | Realized gain$600,000 received - $320,000 adjusted basis | $280,000 |
| 3 | Boot received$60,000 equipment + $40,000 inventory + $20,000 cash | $120,000 |
| 4 | Recognized gainLesser of $280,000 realized gain or $120,000 boot | $120,000 |
| 5 | Deferred gain$280,000 realized gain - $120,000 recognized gain | $160,000 |
Cedar recognizes $120,000 of gain in the exchange year and defers the remaining $160,000.
Check: Shortcut here: replacement land of $480,000 minus old basis of $320,000 leaves $160,000 deferred, so $280,000 total gain minus $160,000 equals $120,000 taxable now.
Key points
- Business use does not make movable equipment qualifying real property.
- Inventory triggers recognition in the exchange year, not when the inventory is later sold.
- Receiving boot does not automatically make the entire real property exchange taxable.
How the exam traps you
- Count only cash as boot and recognize $20,000. Include the equipment and inventory at fair market value, bringing total boot to $120,000.
- Recognize the entire $280,000 gain because nonqualifying assets were received. The real property portion still qualifies. Recognition is limited to $120,000 of boot.
- Defer all gain because the replacement assets will be used in the business. Business use does not extend Section 1031 to equipment or inventory.
Question 2
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Warehouse (real property): adjusted basis $180,000; FMV $260,000 | |
| Delivery equipment: adjusted basis $40,000; FMV $50,000 | |
| Mason transfers the warehouse for an office building to be used in Mason's business (FMV $240,000) and receives $20,000 cash | |
| Mason transfers the delivery equipment for replacement delivery equipment (FMV $50,000) to be used in Mason's business | |
Hint
Analyze each exchange separately. First decide whether current §1031 applies to that type of property, then determine whether any boot causes gain recognition.
Answer C. Section 1031 nonrecognition applies to qualifying real property exchanges under current law. The warehouse exchange realizes $80,000 of gain (240,000 + 20,000 − 180,000), but Mason recognizes only the $20,000 of cash boot. The equipment exchange involves personal property and does not qualify for §1031, so Mason recognizes the full $10,000 gain (50,000 − 40,000).
Why not A: This correctly treats the equipment exchange as taxable but overlooks the $20,000 cash boot received on the warehouse exchange. Even when a like‑kind real property exchange occurs, gain is recognized to the extent of boot received (limited by realized gain).
Why not B: Tempting if a student believes any business-use asset exchange can be like‑kind. However, after the TCJA, §1031 nonrecognition is limited to real property, so the equipment-for-equipment trade is taxable and triggers a $10,000 recognized gain.
Why not D: This computes the warehouse realized gain correctly but ignores §1031 nonrecognition for qualifying real property exchanges. Only the boot ($20,000), not the entire $80,000 realized gain, is recognized on the warehouse exchange.
Question 3
Hint
First classify which received asset qualifies as like-kind real property and which is boot; compute realized gain, then apply boot recognition rules before determining the replacement property's basis.
Answer A. Realized gain = total FMV received (290,000 + 40,000 = 330,000) − adjusted basis of the old land (240,000) = $90,000. Because the forklift is nonlike-kind boot, recognized gain is limited to the boot ($40,000), deferring $50,000 of gain. Basis in the replacement real property = FMV of the like-kind property ($290,000) − deferred gain ($50,000) = $240,000 (equivalently: old basis + recognized gain − boot = 240,000 + 40,000 − 40,000 = 240,000).
Why not B: Tempting because a candidate might treat the entire exchange as like-kind nonrecognition and carry over the old basis. That fails here because the forklift is nonqualifying personal property (boot) and forces recognition of gain up to its $40,000 value, so recognized gain cannot be $0.
Why not C: Tempting because adding the recognized gain to the old basis (240,000 + 40,000 = 280,000) is a common error. It fails because the basis of the replacement like-kind property must reflect the deferred gain (or be computed as old basis + recognized gain − boot); the boot received reduces the carried-over basis, so the correct basis is $240,000, not $280,000.
Why not D: Tempting if a candidate thinks any receipt of nonqualifying property causes recognition of the entire realized gain. That is incorrect: only gain up to the boot ($40,000) is recognized. The remainder is deferred and reduces the basis in the replacement real property, so the full $90,000 is not recognized and the basis is not simply the FMV.
Question 4
Hint
Focus first on which asset class can still receive Section 1031 treatment under current law, and then consider whether receiving cash changes the result.
Answer C. Under current law Section 1031 nonrecognition is limited to exchanges of real property held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment. The warehouse can qualify for deferral if properly exchanged for replacement business real property (using a qualified intermediary for a deferred exchange). The equipment is personal/business tangible property and does not qualify for Section 1031 treatment, so its gain cannot be deferred through a like-kind exchange.
Why not A: A voluntary sale for cash followed by a later purchase does not create a Section 1031 like-kind exchange, so gain is generally recognized. The 180-day timing rule applies to certain deferred-exchange procedures, not to turning a sale into nonrecognition simply by reinvesting the proceeds.
Why not B: This reflects an outdated broader view of like-kind exchanges. After the 2017 tax law changes, Section 1031 nonrecognition generally applies only to real property; personal property such as equipment no longer qualifies. Relying on a combined exchange to defer the equipment gain would be incorrect.
Why not D: Receiving cash (boot) in a Section 1031 exchange generally triggers recognition to the extent of realized gain up to the amount of boot. Using the received cash to buy other business property afterward does not nullify the boot, the cash portion is taxable to the extent of realized gain.
Question 5
Hint
Separate the transaction by asset type first; apply §1031 only to the real‑property portion and treat cash allocated to nonqualifying property as a separate taxable receipt.
Answer A. Post‑TCJA §1031 nonrecognition applies only to qualifying real property, so treat the assets separately. Land realized gain = $400,000 − $250,000 = $150,000, but recognized gain on the land exchange is limited to the $30,000 boot allocated to that exchange. Equipment realized gain = $30,000 − $20,000 = $10,000 and is fully recognized because equipment is nonqualifying. Total recognized gain = $30,000 + $10,000 = $40,000. Basis in the replacement land = basis_old + recognized_gain_on_exchange − boot_received_on_exchange = $250,000 + $30,000 − $30,000 = $250,000.
Why not B: Tempting because it correctly applies the §1031 limitation to the land portion and some candidates stop there. It fails because the written agreement allocates $30,000 to the equipment, which produces a separate taxable disposition with a $10,000 recognized gain (30,000 − 20,000).
Why not C: Tempting because treating all cash received as boot is a common shortcut that yields a single recognized amount. It fails because the facts provide an express allocation: only $30,000 constitutes boot on the qualifying land exchange; the other $30,000 is consideration for the nonqualifying equipment and is taxed separately.
Why not D: Tempting because one might overgeneralize that nonqualifying property invalidates §1031 for the entire transaction. It fails because qualifying real property can still receive §1031 treatment when assets are separately identified and valued; only the equipment's $10,000 gain is taxed separately. The replacement land basis would not default to FMV when the land portion qualifies for nonrecognition.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the property received into qualifying replacement property and nonqualifying property, then ask what Sec. 1031 does with each piece.
Answer C. Mara realized $80,000 of gain (total FMV received $260,000 less basis $180,000). The office building is qualifying like-kind replacement property, but the inventory is nonqualifying property and is treated as boot. Under Sec. 1031, recognized gain in the exchange year equals boot received, limited by realized gain, so $30,000 is recognized now and the remaining $50,000 is deferred and reflected in the basis of the replacement property.
Why not A: This distractor misses the fact that Mara also received inventory, which is nonqualifying property (boot). Receipt of boot triggers current recognition to the extent of the boot's value.
Why not B: This overstates the rule. Receiving nonqualifying property does not automatically disqualify the entire exchange; it normally causes partial recognition equal to the boot received, not recognition of the full realized gain.
Why not D: This is incorrect because boot is taxed in the year of the exchange when received. Deferred recognition applies to the portion tied to qualifying replacement property, not to boot received in the exchange.
Common questions
Does equipment qualify for a 1031 exchange after TCJA?
No. The movable equipment in this exchange is personal property, not qualifying real property. Its $60,000 fair market value counts as boot received.
Is inventory received in a 1031 exchange taxable immediately?
Inventory received is boot in the exchange year. Here, its $40,000 value joins the equipment and cash in determining recognized gain, limited by total realized gain.
Does receiving boot make the whole 1031 exchange taxable?
No. Here, $120,000 is recognized and $160,000 is deferred because boot is less than realized gain and the real property portion otherwise qualifies.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Nontaxable disposition of assets
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.