TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 6 practice questions
Section 121 Partial Exclusion: The 2-Out-of-5-Year Rule
A qualifying medical move can allow a reduced home sale exclusion before the two-year ownership and use tests are met. Below: follow one sale from eligibility through the reduced exclusion and taxable gain.
Try one first
Hint
§121 exclusion: $250K single / $500K MFJ on sale of principal residence. Requirements: 2-of-5 year ownership AND use, no §121 in prior 2 years. Excess gain = LTCG. Cap is on GAIN, not sale price.
Answer A. §121 PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE EXCLUSION allows up to $250,000 (single filer) / $500,000 (MFJ) of gain on the sale of a principal residence to be excluded from federal income tax. CABOT'S CALCULATION: Sale price: $450,000. Adjusted basis: $200,000. Realized gain: $250,000. §121 exclusion (single): $250,000. Recognized gain: $250,000 − $250,000 = $0. REQUIREMENTS (all met by Cabot): (1) OWNERSHIP TEST, owned 2 of 5 years before sale (Cabot owned 10 years ✓). (2) USE TEST, used as principal residence 2 of 5 years before sale (continuous use ✓). (3) FREQUENCY RULE, not used §121 in the prior 2 years (Cabot has not ✓). (4) NO NON-QUALIFIED USE issues (continuous personal-residence use ✓). KEY POINTS: (a) Excess gain (above the cap) is LONG-TERM CAPITAL GAIN if the holding period exceeded 1 year. Cabot's gain doesn't exceed the cap, so all is excluded. (b) The $250K/$500K limits are FIXED (not 80% or some percentage of realized gain). (c) Sale price absolute amount is irrelevant; only realized gain matters for the cap. (d) Sales of personal residences generate CAPITAL gain (or loss not deductible); not ordinary income. PARTIAL EXCLUSION under §121(c)(2) for sales failing the 2-year tests due to qualifying reasons (employment change/health/unforeseen circumstances), not relevant to Cabot. NON-QUALIFIED USE under §121(b)(5) for property used as rental for periods after 2008, not relevant to Cabot's continuous personal use. DEPRECIATION RECAPTURE under §121(d)(6), not relevant absent rental periods. Answer B is incorrect: §121 does not impose a percentage limit on gain; the dollar cap is $250K/$500K. The 80% framing is fabricated. Answer C is incorrect: §121 cap is on gain, not sale price. A $5M sale of a residence with $250K basis still allows $250K (single) excluded. Answer D is incorrect: gain on personal residence is CAPITAL gain (LTCG if held > 1 year), not ordinary income. Personal-use property capital gains, capital losses non-deductible.
Step by step
- Start with the sale facts
Roberts, single, owned and used a home as a principal residence for 18 months before selling because a doctor required relocation for a medical condition. Roberts realized $200,000 of gain and had never used a §121 exclusion.
- Test ownership and use separately
The full exclusion generally requires at least two years of ownership and two years of principal-residence use during the five years ending on the sale date. Roberts meets neither test because each period is only 18 months.
- Identify the qualifying reason
A sale primarily because of qualifying health reasons can receive a reduced exclusion. Roberts's doctor-required medical relocation qualifies.
- Find the shortest applicable period
Compare ownership, principal-residence use, and time since the last sale receiving a §121 exclusion. Roberts has no prior excluded sale, so the 18 months of ownership and use control.
- Prorate the exclusion limit
Multiply the $250,000 single-filer limit by 18/24. Roberts's reduced exclusion limit is $187,500, not the full $250,000.
- Subtract the allowable exclusion
Subtract $187,500 from the $200,000 realized gain to get $12,500 of recognized gain. Because Roberts held the home longer than one year, that remainder is long-term capital gain.
Key points
- Remember: Prorate the exclusion limit, not the gain.
- A qualifying medical reason permits a reduced exclusion, not an automatic full exclusion.
- The reduced limit can leave taxable gain even when total gain is below $250,000.
How the exam traps you
- Denying any exclusion because ownership and use lasted less than two years. Check whether the medical reason qualifies the sale for a reduced exclusion.
- Allowing the full $250,000 because a doctor required the move. The medical exception permits proration; it does not remove the reduced-limit calculation.
- Using a flat 50% reduction for every early sale. Use the actual qualifying period: 18 months divided by 24 months equals 75%.
Question 2
Hint
§121(d)(4): principal residence exclusion EXTENDS to stock in cooperative housing corporations (and condominiums). Same $250K/$500K limits, same 2-of-5 ownership/use tests. NY/NJ co-op transactions get standard §121 treatment.
Answer B. §121(d)(4) explicitly extends the principal residence exclusion to STOCK held by a tenant-stockholder in a COOPERATIVE HOUSING CORPORATION. Co-op apartments are §121-eligible despite being technically corporate stock + a proprietary lease (rather than fee-simple real estate). WALLACE'S CALCULATION: Sale price: $900,000. Adjusted basis: $300,000. Realized gain: $600,000. §121 exclusion (single): $250,000. Recognized gain: $600,000 − $250,000 = $350,000 long-term capital gain (held 8 years > 1 year). REQUIREMENTS (all met): (1) OWNERSHIP TEST, owned the co-op shares for 2 of 5 years (8 years ✓). (2) USE TEST, used the apartment as principal residence for 2 of 5 years (8 years ✓). (3) FREQUENCY RULE, not used §121 in prior 2 years (assumed met). (4) THE COOPERATIVE QUALIFICATION, the housing cooperative must be a 'cooperative housing corporation' under §216, which has specific requirements (e.g., shareholders own stock entitled to occupy units; corporation owns/leases the building). Most legitimate co-ops qualify. SAME LIMITS: $250K (single) / $500K (MFJ); same 2-of-5 ownership/use; same frequency rule. Co-ops not penalized vs traditional homes. CONDOMINIUMS: also §121-eligible. Condo owners hold a fee-simple interest in their unit plus an undivided interest in common areas, closer to traditional real estate ownership. PRACTICAL NOTE: NY/NJ co-op transactions involve transfer of stock and lease; this is treated like a real-estate sale for §121. Closing process and documentation differ from fee-simple sales but the §121 treatment is the same. Answer A is incorrect: §121(d)(4) specifically covers co-op stock; technical ownership form doesn't matter. Answer C is incorrect: there is no '20% reduced exclusion' for co-ops; the standard $250K/$500K limits apply. Answer D is incorrect: co-op stock is not classified as personal property for §121; §121(d)(4) explicitly addresses cooperative housing.
Question 3
Hint
§121 applies ONLY to the PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE (where taxpayer primarily lives). Vacation/second homes don't qualify. Determined by facts (majority time, mail, voter registration), not election. Conversion to principal residence requires changing facts + 2-of-5-year qualifying use.
Answer B. §121 EXCLUSION applies ONLY to the sale of the TAXPAYER'S PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE, defined as the home where the taxpayer PRIMARILY LIVES. Vacation homes, second homes, and rental properties do NOT qualify for §121, regardless of how long owned or how much personal use. MASON'S SITUATION: Boston home: Mason lives there 9 of 12 months → PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE. Maine home: 3 of 12 months → SECONDARY/VACATION HOME, not principal residence. The $200,000 gain on the Maine sale is FULLY RECOGNIZED as long-term capital gain (held > 1 year). §121 is unavailable. PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE DETERMINATION (per Treas. Reg. §1.121-1(b)(2)): based on FACTS AND CIRCUMSTANCES, typically the home where the taxpayer: (a) spends the majority of time during the year; (b) maintains primary mailing and voter registration; (c) uses for primary employment / family / community ties; (d) considers the 'home base.' Where multiple homes are used, only ONE qualifies as principal residence in any given period. NO ELECTION mechanism, taxpayers cannot freely choose which home is the 'principal residence' for §121. The IRS looks at facts. Conversion: a vacation home CAN BECOME a principal residence if the taxpayer changes facts (moves there, registers there, spends majority of time there). After 2-of-5-year qualifying use, §121 becomes available on that home. PLANNING IDEAS: (1) sell the principal residence first (Boston), use $250K/$500K §121 exclusion. (2) move to the Maine home (make it principal residence), reside there 2+ years, then sell with §121, but subject to non-qualified-use allocation under §121(b)(5) for prior secondary use. (3) hold the Maine home indefinitely; gain becomes part of estate (basis step-up at death under §1014). Answer A is incorrect: ownership and 'any personal use' aren't the standard; principal residence requires majority of time. Answer C is incorrect: there is no 25% partial exclusion based on month-of-use. Partial exclusion under §121(c)(2) applies for failed-2-year tests due to qualifying reasons, not for non-principal residences. Answer D is incorrect: there is no election mechanism; principal residence is determined by facts.
Question 4
Hint
§1031 = INVESTMENT/BUSINESS real estate ONLY (post-TCJA: real property only). Personal residences are EXCLUDED. Use §121 instead ($250K single / $500K MFJ exclusion). Don't confuse the two.
Answer B. §1031 LIKE-KIND EXCHANGE is available only for property HELD FOR PRODUCTIVE USE IN A TRADE OR BUSINESS OR FOR INVESTMENT. Personal-use property (including a personal residence) is EXPRESSLY EXCLUDED from §1031. KEY §1031 RULES (post-TCJA): (1) Applies ONLY to REAL PROPERTY (TCJA eliminated §1031 for personal property, formerly applicable to equipment, livestock, etc.). (2) Property must be held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment. (3) Like-kind requirement: most real estate is like-kind to most other real estate. (4) Identification: 45-day window to identify replacement property. (5) Acquisition: 180-day window to acquire replacement. (6) Boot received (cash or non-like-kind property) is taxable gain to the extent received. SINGH'S SITUATION: a personal residence is held for personal use, NOT for productive use or investment. §1031 is unavailable. Singh's correct path: §121 PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE EXCLUSION. Excludes up to $250K (single) / $500K (MFJ) of gain on sale of principal residence if 2-of-5-year ownership AND use tests are met. KEY DISTINCTION: §1031 = INVESTMENT/BUSINESS real estate (rentals, commercial property, raw land for investment). §121 = PERSONAL residence. Don't confuse the two; they have very different qualification rules. Note: a CONVERTED rental that was previously a personal residence (or vice versa) has special rules, partial §121 + non-qualified-use limitations + depreciation recapture. Answer A is incorrect: §1031 does NOT apply to all real estate; personal residences are excluded. Personal-use property is categorically outside §1031. Answer C is incorrect: there is no '2-year holding' provision that makes a personal residence §1031-eligible. The 2-year requirement under §121 is unrelated to §1031. Answer D is incorrect: a qualified intermediary doesn't fix the disqualification; §1031 still requires investment/business use property.
Question 5
Hint
§121(b)(2)(C) surviving spouse: MFJ $500K available within 2 YEARS of spouse's death (assuming both met use/ownership tests during marriage). Combined with §1014 basis step-up at death; full step-up in community property states.
Answer B. §121(b)(2)(C) provides a SURVIVING SPOUSE rule: a taxpayer whose spouse died is entitled to use the MFJ $500,000 exclusion if the sale occurs WITHIN 2 YEARS of the deceased spouse's death AND the deceased spouse would have qualified for the MFJ exclusion if the sale had occurred immediately before death. MARGARET'S CALCULATION: Realized gain: $1,200,000 − $400,000 = $800,000. Sale within 2 years of death: ✓ (7 months). Both spouses met use/ownership tests during their joint lifetime: ✓ (lived in home 20 years). MFJ $500,000 exclusion applies. Recognized gain: $800,000 − $500,000 = $300,000 long-term capital gain. ADDITIONAL BENEFIT: §1014 STEP-UP IN BASIS at death typically adjusts the deceased spouse's portion of the home to FMV at death. For COMMUNITY PROPERTY states: the entire community property gets stepped up (full step-up for surviving spouse). For COMMON LAW states: only the deceased's 50% share gets stepped up. The basis step-up substantially reduces realized gain. Margaret's actual recognized gain may be lower depending on basis step-up, the question simplifies by giving a $400K basis. PLANNING IMPLICATIONS: surviving spouses with large home gains should generally sell within 2 years to lock in the MFJ exclusion. Beyond 2 years, only the single $250K applies. Common-law-state surviving spouses may also benefit from understanding step-up implications. Answer A is incorrect: the surviving spouse rule specifically allows MFJ $500K within 2 years of death, regardless of current marital status. Answer C is incorrect: remarriage is not required for the surviving spouse rule. Remarriage might actually trigger different rules (e.g., prior 2-year frequency on the new joint return). Answer D is incorrect: the rule is 2 YEARS (not same calendar year). Sales within 2 years qualify regardless of calendar-year alignment.
Question 6
Hint
§121(c)(2) partial exclusion: qualifying reason (employment 50+ mile move/health/unforeseen) → partial = (months met ÷ 24) × full ($250K single / $500K MFJ). Powerful relief for failed 2-year tests. Document the qualifying reason.
Answer B. §121(c)(2) provides a PARTIAL EXCLUSION when the home sale fails the 2-year ownership/use tests but is due to a 'qualifying' reason: (1) CHANGE IN PLACE OF EMPLOYMENT, (2) HEALTH/MEDICAL reasons, or (3) UNFORESEEN CIRCUMSTANCES (specific safe harbors). Foster's situation: employer-required relocation = qualifying reason under the EMPLOYMENT safe harbor. Treasury Regulations §1.121-3(c) define a safe harbor for employment-based relocations: the new place of employment must be at least 50 miles farther from the residence than the old place of employment was. PARTIAL EXCLUSION CALCULATION: (months of qualifying ownership/use ÷ 24 months) × FULL EXCLUSION ($250K single / $500K MFJ). Foster: 12 months ÷ 24 months × $250,000 = $125,000 partial exclusion. Realized gain: $80,000. Recognized gain: $80,000 − $125,000 = $0 (capped at zero; the partial exclusion exceeds the gain). FOSTER PAYS NO TAX on the $80,000 gain because the partial exclusion is more than enough to absorb it. KEY LESSON: §121(c)(2) is a powerful relief provision for life events that disrupt the 2-year tests. Without a qualifying reason, a 1-year sale would trigger NO §121 (full or partial), and the entire $80,000 would be LTCG. Documentation is critical: Foster should retain employer relocation records and proof of distance. Answer A is incorrect: PARTIAL §121 IS available under §121(c)(2) for qualifying-reason failures. The 2-year tests have express exceptions. Answer C is incorrect: there is no 'automatic full exclusion within 12 months' rule. Sales within 12 months without a qualifying reason get NO §121. Answer D is incorrect: §1031 does NOT apply to personal residences (excluded as personal-use property). §1031 is for business/investment real estate only.
Common questions
Can I use Section 121 if I sell my home before two years?
Yes, if the sale qualifies for a reduced exclusion. Roberts's doctor-required medical move qualifies despite only 18 months of ownership and principal-residence use.
How do I calculate a partial home sale exclusion?
Multiply the full exclusion limit by the shortest applicable period divided by 24 months. Roberts's single-filer limit is $250,000 × 18/24 = $187,500.
Does a medical move make all home sale gain tax-free?
No. The medical reason permits a reduced exclusion, but gain above that limit remains taxable. Roberts recognizes $12,500 of the $200,000 gain.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process, worked step by step.
Section 1231 Netting & Section 1245 Recapture | CPA TCP TBS on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process
- Section 1231 Netting: Net Gain vs. Net Loss
- Section 1245 Recapture: Ordinary Income vs. Section 1231 Gain
- Section 1231 Five-Year Lookback Rule and Example
- Section 1231 Five-Year Lookback: When Gains Become Ordinary
- QSBS Section 1202 Holding Periods After OBBBA
All Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.