TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 10 practice questions
Section 1231 Five-Year Lookback: When Gains Become Ordinary
A net Section 1231 gain becomes ordinary income up to the nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses from the preceding five tax years. Below, the same land sale shows how changing only the prior-loss history changes the gain's character.
Try one first
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Equipment used in the business | $90,000 gain |
| Warehouse used in the business | $35,000 loss |
| Land used in the business | $20,000 gain |
| Investment stock held more than 1 year | $12,000 loss |
Hint
First net only the Section 1231 items for the current year; then apply the five-tax-year lookback (the five years preceding the current tax year) to determine how much, if any, of the net Section 1231 gain is recharacterized as ordinary income.
Answer A. Net the current-year Section 1231 items first: $90,000 + $20,000 − $35,000 = $75,000 net Section 1231 gain. The five-tax-year lookback applies only when there is a current-year net Section 1231 gain and it counts only net Section 1231 losses in the five tax years preceding the current year (for 20X6, the lookback is 20X1-20X5). Only the 20X2 ($18,000) and 20X4 ($22,000) losses fall in that window (total $40,000), so $40,000 of the $75,000 is recharacterized as ordinary income and the remaining $35,000 is long-term capital gain; that residual long-term capital gain then nets with other capital gains and losses (including the $12,000 capital loss) in the usual capital gain/loss computation.
Why not B: This is tempting because it correctly nets 20X6 Section 1231 items first, but it incorrectly includes the 20X0 $10,000 loss in the five-year lookback. For 20X6 the prior five tax years are 20X1-20X5, so the 20X0 loss is outside the lookback and cannot recapture current gain.
Why not C: This distractor reflects the common sequencing error of combining non-Section 1231 capital losses with Section 1231 items before applying the lookback; the $12,000 investment stock loss is a capital loss, not a Section 1231 item, and should not reduce the amount subject to Section 1231 recapture. The correct sequence is to net only the Section 1231 items first and then apply the five-year lookback.
Why not D: This choice is tempting because prior nonrecaptured Section 1231 losses can turn current gains into ordinary income, but recharacterization is limited to the amount of nonrecaptured Section 1231 losses in the five-year lookback, not automatically the entire current-year gain unless prior losses equal or exceed it.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
In 2026, Rowan, a calendar-year sole proprietor, sells business land held for three years for $100,000. Its adjusted basis is $60,000. The sale is fully taxable and qualifies under Section 1231. Rowan has no other current-year Section 1231 items and no prior net Section 1231 losses.
Answer: $0 ordinary income and $40,000 long-term capital gain.
The sale produces a $40,000 gain: $100,000 minus $60,000. With no prior nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses, none of the gain becomes ordinary income.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Prior-loss history changes to a $15,000 net Section 1231 loss from 2024, not previously used for lookback.
Answer: $15,000 ordinary income and $25,000 long-term capital gain.
The 2024 loss is within the five-year window. Recharacterize $15,000 of the $40,000 gain; the remaining $25,000 keeps long-term capital gain character.
Change 2Prior-loss history changes to a $60,000 net Section 1231 loss from 2024, not previously used for lookback.
Answer: $40,000 ordinary income and $0 long-term capital gain.
Eligible prior losses exceed the $40,000 gain. The entire gain becomes ordinary; $20,000 of the prior loss remains unused.
Change 3Prior-loss history changes to a $15,000 net Section 1231 loss from 2020, not previously used for lookback.
Answer: $0 ordinary income and $40,000 long-term capital gain.
The tempting prior loss changes nothing. For 2026, the window is 2021 through 2025, so the 2020 loss is excluded.
Key points
- Remember: The lookback changes the gain's character, not its total amount.
- For 2026, count prior losses from 2021 through 2025 only.
- Nonrecaptured losses are prior net Section 1231 losses not already used to recharacterize later gains.
- Ordinary recharacterization cannot exceed either the current net gain or the eligible prior losses.
How the exam traps you
- Treating any prior loss as enough to make the entire gain ordinary. Use only the eligible prior-loss amount, capped at the current net gain.
- Including the 2020 loss in the 2026 lookback. Count only the five preceding tax years: 2021 through 2025.
- Ignoring prior losses because the land qualifies as Section 1231 property. Section 1231 treatment requires applying the lookback before assigning long-term capital gain character.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer B. Correct. The $40,000 net Section 1231 gain remains entirely long-term capital gain.
Why not A: No prior nonrecaptured losses exist to make the gain ordinary.
Why not C: The lookback does not automatically split a gain equally.
Why not D: Gain is sale proceeds minus adjusted basis, not total proceeds.
Question 2
Answer D. Correct. Recharacterize $15,000 as ordinary; the remaining $25,000 is long-term capital gain.
Why not A: This ignores the eligible 2024 loss.
Why not B: Only $15,000 of eligible prior losses is available to recharacterize the gain.
Why not C: The ordinary amount equals the eligible prior loss, not the remaining gain.
Question 3
Answer A. Correct. Eligible prior losses exceed the gain, so all $40,000 becomes ordinary.
Why not B: This ignores the eligible 2024 loss.
Why not C: Recharacterization cannot exceed the $40,000 current net gain.
Why not D: The $20,000 unused prior loss is not the amount recharacterized.
Question 4
Answer C. Correct. The 2020 loss is excluded, so the full gain remains long-term capital gain.
Why not A: The 2020 loss is outside the 2021 through 2025 lookback window.
Why not B: An expired loss cannot make any of the gain ordinary.
Why not D: This uses an expired loss and reverses the ordinary and capital amounts.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on sequencing: which comes first, netting current‑year §1231 items, applying the §1231 lookback to the five preceding tax years, or netting capital gains/losses?
Answer A. Net the current-year §1231 items first: $170,000 − $50,000 = $120,000 net §1231 gain. The §1231 lookback to the five preceding tax years recharacterizes current-year net §1231 gain as ordinary to the extent of prior nonrecaptured §1231 losses (Year 2 $35,000 + Year 4 $25,000 = $60,000). Thus $60,000 is ordinary and the remaining $60,000 is long-term capital gain, which is then netted with the $20,000 long-term capital loss, leaving a $40,000 net long-term capital gain.
Why not B: Tempting because prior §1231 losses require recapture treatment, but incorrect sequencing: the lookback applies only to a current-year net §1231 gain, so current-year §1231 gains and losses must be netted before applying the five‑preceding‑tax‑years lookback.
Why not C: Tempting if one assumes all items are combined, but incorrect: capital losses are applied after character is determined; you must net §1231 items and apply any §1231 lookback before offsetting capital losses.
Why not D: Tempting because it treats prior losses as fully tainting future gains, but incorrect: the lookback only recharacterizes current-year net §1231 gain up to the amount of prior nonrecaptured §1231 losses, not necessarily the entire current-year net §1231 gain unless prior losses equal or exceed it.
Question 3
| Asset | Cost | Adj. Basis | Accum. Depr. | Sold For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Machine | $140,000 | $90,000 | $100,000 | |
| Land | $120,000 | $84,000 | ||
| Office building | $300,000 | $60,000 | $300,000 |
Hint
Work in sequence: determine each asset's character (apply any §1245 recapture), then net current‑year §1231 items, then apply the five‑year §1231 lookback.
Answer B. Apply recapture rules to each asset first. The machine produces a $50,000 gain (100,000 − 50,000 basis) that is recaptured as ordinary income under §1245. The building yields a $60,000 §1231 gain and the land a $36,000 §1231 loss, netting to a $24,000 §1231 gain; the five‑year §1231 lookback recharacterizes $18,000 of that net §1231 gain as ordinary, leaving $6,000 as long-term capital gain. Total ordinary income = $50,000 + $18,000 = $68,000; long-term capital gain = $6,000.
Why not A: Tempting because it correctly treats the machine's $50,000 as §1245 ordinary income and nets the building and land into a $24,000 §1231 gain. It fails, however, to apply the five‑year §1231 lookback, which recharacterizes $18,000 of that current §1231 gain as ordinary income.
Why not C: Tempting because it lumps the machine's $50,000 gain with the §1231 items to get a $74,000 net §1231 gain, then applies the lookback to leave $56,000 LTCG. It's wrong because §1245 recapture converts the machine's $50,000 to ordinary income before §1231 netting, so that gain cannot remain in the §1231 net.
Why not D: Tempting because it assumes all depreciation‑related gain (including the building) is ordinary, producing $74,000 ordinary after offsetting the land loss. It's incorrect because the building received only straight‑line depreciation, so there is no additional §1250 ordinary recapture, its $60,000 gain is §1231 (subject to the lookback), not ordinary recapture.
Question 4
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Manufacturing equipment used in his sole proprietorship: original cost $300,000, accumulated depreciation $210,000, sold for $170,000 | |
| Nonresidential building used in the business, depreciated only by the straight-line method: original cost $400,000, accumulated depreciation $120,000, sold for $330,000 | |
| Delivery truck used in the business: adjusted basis $40,000, sold for $25,000 | |
| Investment land: basis $90,000, sold for $60,000 | |
Hint
Sort each disposition into the right bucket first: ordinary recapture, Sec. 1231 property, and capital asset. Then apply Sec. 1231 netting and lookback before doing the final capital gain/loss netting.
Answer C. The equipment produces an $80,000 gain (sale $170,000 less basis $90,000) that is ordinary under Sec. 1245 recapture (depreciation taken exceeds the gain). The building produces a $50,000 Sec. 1231 gain and the truck a $15,000 Sec. 1231 loss, for a $35,000 net current-year Sec. 1231 gain. Apply the Sec. 1231 lookback: $20,000 of that current Sec. 1231 gain must be recharacterized as ordinary because of the Year 5 nonrecaptured Sec. 1231 loss, leaving $15,000 as long-term capital gain. That $15,000 is then netted against the $30,000 long-term capital loss on the investment land, yielding a $15,000 net long-term capital loss; total ordinary income is $80,000 + $20,000 = $100,000.
Why not A: Tempting if the solver recognizes the $80,000 Sec. 1245 ordinary recapture and nets the Sec. 1231 pool as capital without applying the Sec. 1231 lookback. It is incorrect because $20,000 of the current Sec. 1231 gain must be recharacterized as ordinary due to the prior-year nonrecaptured Sec. 1231 loss.
Why not B: This reflects treating the current-year Sec. 1231 gain ($35,000) as ordinary in addition to the $80,000 Sec. 1245 recapture (80+35=115). It's incorrect because Sec. 1231 gains are capital if the net Sec. 1231 result is a gain, subject only to the lookback conversion; the truck's $15,000 loss reduces the current-year Sec. 1231 gain rather than creating an independent ordinary loss.
Why not D: This is plausible if the candidate applies Sec. 1245 recapture and the Sec. 1231 lookback correctly (producing $20,000 ordinary and $15,000 capital), but then fails to net the $15,000 Sec. 1231 capital gain against the separate $30,000 long-term capital loss on the investment land. Netting yields a $15,000 long-term capital loss, not a gain.
Question 5
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Machine (depreciable personal property subject to §1245): cost $80,000, accumulated depreciation $50,000, sold for $55,000 | |
| Delivery truck: cost $50,000, accumulated depreciation $30,000, sold for $14,000 | |
| Land used in the business: adjusted basis $40,000, sold for $62,000 | |
Hint
First determine any §1245 recapture (ordinary). Then classify remaining §1231 gains and losses, net them, and apply any §1231 five‑year lookback recharacterization before reporting the final ordinary vs. capital amounts.
Answer D. The machine's adjusted basis is $30,000 (80,000 - 50,000), so the $55,000 sale yields a $25,000 gain. Under §1245, prior depreciation is recaptured as ordinary income; here the entire $25,000 is §1245 ordinary recapture and does not enter the §1231 net in this fact pattern. The truck produces a $6,000 §1231 loss (20,000 basis − 14,000 sales price) and the land produces a $22,000 §1231 gain, netting to a $16,000 net §1231 gain. Because Dana has a $12,000 nonrecaptured net §1231 loss from 20X5, the §1231 five‑year lookback requires recharacterizing $12,000 of the current §1231 gain as ordinary, leaving $4,000 as long‑term capital gain; total ordinary income = $25,000 + $12,000 = $37,000.
Why not A: This traps candidates who treat the truck loss as immediately ordinary; the $6,000 truck loss is a §1231 loss that must be netted with other §1231 items before applying the five‑year lookback and final characterizations.
Why not B: This correctly treats the machine gain as $25,000 §1245 ordinary recapture and nets the truck loss with the land gain to a $16,000 §1231 gain, but it fails to apply the §1231 five‑year lookback: $12,000 of that $16,000 must be recharacterized as ordinary because of the prior nonrecaptured §1231 loss.
Why not C: This option effectively treats part of the machine gain as §1231 capital gain instead of §1245 recapture. The entire $25,000 machine gain here is ordinary §1245 recapture, so it cannot be included in the §1231 net that produces capital gain.
Question 6
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Machine used in the business (section 1245): cost $70,000, accumulated depreciation $24,000, sold for $76,000 | |
| Warehouse building used in the business (section 1250): cost $200,000, straight-line depreciation $50,000, sold for $170,000 | |
| Delivery truck used in the business (section 1245): adjusted basis $30,000, sold for $21,000 | |
| Investment stock held long term: basis $40,000, sold for $35,000 | |
Hint
Sequence matters: determine any section 1245 ordinary recapture first, then net remaining section 1231 gains and losses and apply the section 1231 five-year lookback to any net section 1231 gain; only after that combine any leftover section 1231 capital amount with other capital transactions.
Answer C. Compute 1245 recapture first: the machine has a $30,000 gain (76,000 − 46,000) of which $24,000 (the accumulated depreciation) is ordinary under section 1245 and $6,000 is a section 1231 gain. Section 1231 items are $6,000 (machine), $20,000 (warehouse), and a $9,000 loss (truck), netting to a $17,000 section 1231 gain. Under the section 1231 five-year lookback, current net section 1231 gain is treated as ordinary to the extent of prior nonrecaptured section 1231 losses (Lane has $18,000), so the full $17,000 becomes ordinary. Total ordinary = $24,000 + $17,000 = $41,000; the $5,000 long-term capital loss on the stock remains a separate capital loss.
Why not A: This result arises from mis-sequencing (for example, netting the $5,000 stock loss with the section 1231 items before applying the five-year lookback). Sequencing is crucial: compute 1245 recapture, net section 1231 gains/losses, apply the five-year lookback to any net section 1231 gain, then combine any remaining capital component with other capital items.
Why not B: Tempting because it recognizes the $24,000 1245 recapture, but it incorrectly treats the $17,000 current net section 1231 gain as long-term capital and nets it with the $5,000 stock loss; this ignores the five-year lookback that causes the current net section 1231 gain to be treated as ordinary to the extent of prior nonrecaptured section 1231 losses.
Why not D: This overstates ordinary treatment by treating more of the gains as ordinary than the rules permit (e.g., treating the warehouse gain as ordinary or recapturing more than the lesser of gain or accumulated depreciation). Only the lesser of gain or accumulated depreciation on section 1245 property is ordinary; the remainder is subject to section 1231 netting and the five-year lookback.
Common questions
What is the Section 1231 five-year lookback rule?
It converts a current net Section 1231 gain to ordinary income up to eligible nonrecaptured losses from the preceding five tax years. With a $40,000 gain and $15,000 of eligible losses, $15,000 is ordinary and $25,000 is long-term capital gain.
Which years count for the Section 1231 lookback in 2026?
The window is 2021 through 2025. A 2020 loss is outside the window and does not recharacterize the 2026 gain.
What happens if prior Section 1231 losses exceed the current gain?
The entire current net Section 1231 gain becomes ordinary income. With a $40,000 gain and $60,000 of eligible losses, only $40,000 is used; the remaining $20,000 stays available while within the five-year window.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process, worked step by step.
Section 1231 Netting & Section 1245 Recapture | CPA TCP TBS on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process
- Section 1231 Netting: Net Gain vs. Net Loss
- Section 1245 Recapture: Ordinary Income vs. Section 1231 Gain
- Section 1231 Five-Year Lookback Rule and Example
- Section 121 Partial Exclusion: The 2-Out-of-5-Year Rule
- QSBS Section 1202 Holding Periods After OBBBA
All Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.