TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 6 practice questions
QSBS Section 1202 Holding Periods After OBBBA
QSBS acquisition dates determine whether a four-year holding period permits a Section 1202 exclusion. Below: compare Hampton's four-year sale across acquisition dates, assuming all other QSBS requirements are met and gain is below the applicable limit.
Try one first
Hint
§1202 100% exclusion for QSBS acquired AFTER 9/27/2010 and held >5 years. Per-issuer cap: greater of $10M or 10× basis. AMT-free for post-9/27/2010 acquisitions. Applies to individuals + pass-throughs investing in qualifying domestic C corps.
Answer A. §1202 EXCLUSION PERCENTAGE depends on the ACQUISITION DATE: (1) Acquired ON OR BEFORE Feb 17, 2009: 50% exclusion. (2) Acquired Feb 18, 2009, Sep 27, 2010: 75% exclusion. (3) Acquired AFTER Sep 27, 2010: 100% exclusion. DRUMMOND'S CALCULATION: Acquisition: August 1, Year 1, AFTER Sep 27, 2010 → 100% exclusion tier. Sale: October 1, Year 8, more than 5 years later → meets §1202's 5-year holding requirement. ✓ Gain: $2,000,000 − $400,000 = $1,600,000. PER-ISSUER CAP under §1202(b)(1): greater of (a) $10M cumulative or (b) 10× basis. (a) = $10,000,000. (b) = $400,000 × 10 = $4,000,000. Greater = $10,000,000. Gain ($1.6M) is well below the cap → fully excludable. RECOGNIZED GAIN: $0. AMT TREATMENT: post-9/27/2010 QSBS is also AMT-FREE (the 7% AMT preference under §57(a)(7) was eliminated by 2015 amendments for the 100% exclusion tier). Pre-9/27/2010 QSBS still has the 7% AMT preference. ALL §1202 BENEFITS for Drummond: $1,600,000 of gain fully excluded, saves at LTCG rates of 15%/20% (typical: $240,000 to $320,000 of federal tax). Plus state-tax effect (most states conform to §1202 for state purposes; NY, PA, MA, DC are notable non-conformers). KEY §1202 REQUIREMENTS (all met by Drummond): (1) Original issuance directly from a §1202-qualifying corporation. ✓ (2) Stock acquired in exchange for money or property (not for services). ✓ (3) Corporation is a domestic C corporation. ✓ (4) Aggregate gross assets ≤ $50M at issuance. ✓ (5) Active business test (≥80% assets in active business). ✓ (6) Held more than 5 years. ✓ Answer B is incorrect: 50% exclusion is for pre-2/18/2009 acquisitions, not post-9/27/2010. Answer C is incorrect: §1202 applies to QSBS GAIN, not 'future gains beyond original investment.' The whole gain qualifies for exclusion. Answer D is incorrect: §1202 SPECIFICALLY APPLIES to individual taxpayers (and pass-through entities). The provision is designed for individuals investing in small business C corporations.
Side by side
| Acquired September 28, 2010, through July 4, 2025 | Acquired after July 4, 2025 | |
|---|---|---|
| Holding-period rule | More than five years: 100% exclusion | Three years: 50%; four years: 75%; five years: 100% |
| Hampton's acquisition date | July 3, 2025 | July 5, 2025 |
| Stock cost and basis | $200,000 | $200,000 |
| Holding period at sale | Exactly four years | Exactly four years |
| Sale proceeds | $1,200,000 | $1,200,000 |
| Realized gain | $1,200,000 minus $200,000 = $1,000,000 | $1,200,000 minus $200,000 = $1,000,000 |
| Exclusion percentage at sale | 0%: holding period is too short | 75%: four-year tier is met |
| Gain excluded | $0 | $1,000,000 × 75% = $750,000 |
| Recognized gain | $1,000,000 | $1,000,000 minus $750,000 = $250,000 |
Key points
- Remember: A four-year hold gives no exclusion under the older regime but a 75% exclusion under the new regime.
- Use the acquisition date, not the sale date, to select the holding-period rules.
- The new percentages are fixed tiers, not a fraction calculated by dividing years held by five.
How the exam traps you
- Denying Hampton any exclusion after four years under both acquisition dates. For stock acquired after July 4, 2025, a four-year hold permits a 75% exclusion.
- Excluding 80% because Hampton held the stock for four of five years. Use the statutory tier: 75%, not four divided by five.
Question 2
Hint
§1244 ordinary loss = ORIGINAL HOLDER ONLY. Transferred §1244 stock (gift, sale, inheritance, divorce) → transferee gets capital loss only. No tacking like §1202. §1244 vs §1202 contrast: 1244 = strict original-holder rule; 1202 = gift/inheritance tacking allowed.
Answer D. §1244 has a STRICT 'ORIGINAL HOLDER' requirement, the favorable ordinary loss treatment is available ONLY to the person who acquired the stock DIRECTLY FROM THE CORPORATION in exchange for money or property. KEY §1244 RULES: (1) §1244 ordinary loss available ONLY to original shareholder. (2) Transferred stock (via gift, sale, inheritance, divorce) LOSES §1244 ordinary loss eligibility for the transferee. (3) The corporation must have been a QUALIFYING SMALL BUSINESS at the time of original issuance. (4) Stock retains §1244 'character' but only for the ORIGINAL HOLDER's loss. Compare with §1202 (QSBS): §1202 has SPECIAL TACKING RULES for gifts and inheritance under §1202(h), gifted/inherited QSBS retains QSBS status for the recipient. §1244 has NO SUCH TACKING RULES. §1244 is original-holder-only, period. MARIN'S TAX OUTCOME: $80,000 long-term capital loss (holding period tacks from Vela under §1015 gift basis rules, Marin's holding period includes Vela's years). $3,000 deductible against Marin's ordinary income for Year 6. $77,000 LTCL carries forward indefinitely. PLANNING IMPLICATIONS: (1) §1244 stock should generally be HELD by the original holder for loss recognition; gifting before a loss eliminates the §1244 benefit. (2) The original holder should claim the loss, not the recipient. (3) For LIFETIME GIFTING, the donor loses §1244 protection on the stock; donee gets none. This is significant for failing businesses, original holder should consider claiming the loss themselves before transferring. (4) §1244 vs §1202 contrast: 1244 has NO transfer-friendly rules; §1202 has gift/inheritance tacking. Answer A is incorrect: 'step into shoes' applies to BASIS and HOLDING PERIOD under §1015, but NOT to §1244 status. §1244 explicitly requires the original holder. Answer B is incorrect: there is no §1244(b)(3) gift-tacking provision for donees; the §1244 treatment dies with the original holder upon transfer. Answer C is incorrect: §1244 stock CAN be transferred, the stock itself remains valid; the donee just doesn't get the §1244 ordinary loss benefit.
Question 3
Hint
§1202(c)(2) active business test: AT LEAST 80% of assets used in active conduct of qualified business during substantially all of holding period. Working capital reasonably expected for active deployment within 2 years can count; passive investments don't.
Answer C. §1202(c)(2) requires that AT LEAST 80% (by value) of the corporation's assets be used in the ACTIVE CONDUCT of one or more qualified trades or businesses during SUBSTANTIALLY ALL of the taxpayer's holding period. The 80% test is independent of (and additional to) the $50M aggregate gross assets cap. TECHVENTURE'S ACTIVE-BUSINESS ANALYSIS: Active assets: operating cash ($5M, used in operations) + equipment/inventory ($18M, active business use) = $23M. Inactive/passive: working capital invested in T-bills ($4M, passive investment), portfolio stocks ($3M, unrelated investments) = $7M. Total assets: $30M. Active percentage: $23M / $30M = 76.7%, BELOW the 80% threshold. TechVenture FAILS the active business test; its stock is NOT QSBS for §1202 purposes. WORKING CAPITAL TREATMENT under §1202(e)(6): working capital REASONABLY EXPECTED to be used within 2 years for active business needs CAN count as active. However, working capital invested in PASSIVE investments (T-bills) may not qualify if held long-term without an active business plan to deploy it. Aggressive working-capital characterization is a frequent gray area in §1202 planning. PORTFOLIO INVESTMENTS in unrelated stocks are clearly passive. KEY POINT: §1202 has multiple gating tests (asset cap, active business, qualifying trade/business, etc.); failure of any disqualifies the stock. Active business test failure can be subtle: a company might pass the $50M cap but still fail because of asset composition. PLANNING: corporations should monitor asset composition; investment of excess cash in T-bills should be paired with an active business deployment plan to maintain working capital characterization. Answer A is incorrect: §1202 has multiple tests; the $50M cap is necessary but NOT sufficient. The active business test must also be met. Answer B is incorrect: working capital and operating cash do NOT 'always' count as active. The treatment depends on facts: working capital reasonably expected to be used in active business within 2 years can count; passive long-term investment may not. Answer D is incorrect: the §1202 active business threshold is 80%, NOT 60%.
Question 4
Hint
§1244 worthless stock: $50K single / $100K MFJ ordinary loss cap; excess = capital loss (long-term if held >1 yr). Capital loss = $3K/yr against ordinary, rest carries forward. Original holder only. Triggered automatically (no election).
Answer A. §1244 applies to BOTH SALES AND WORTHLESSNESS of qualifying small business stock. The annual ordinary-loss cap is $50,000 single / $100,000 MFJ; excess is treated as capital loss. ROTH'S CALCULATION: Total loss: $80,000 (worthless stock = sale for $0; basis − $0 = $80,000 loss). §1244 ORDINARY LOSS: $50,000 (single-filer cap), fully deductible against ordinary income with no annual limit. CAPITAL LOSS: $80,000 − $50,000 = $30,000 long-term capital loss (since holding period exceeded 1 year). CAPITAL LOSS USAGE: $3,000/year against ordinary income; remainder ($27,000) carries forward indefinitely as capital loss. ROTH'S YEAR OF WORTHLESSNESS TAX BENEFIT: $50,000 ordinary + $3,000 capital = $53,000 reducing taxable income. KEY §1244 RULES: (1) Annual cap: $50K single / $100K MFJ. (2) Excess = capital loss (long-term or short-term per holding period). (3) Original holder only, transferees don't get §1244 treatment. (4) Applies to worthless stock as well as sold stock. (5) Corporation must have been a QUALIFYING small business at issuance (≤$1M aggregate equity contributions). PLANNING NOTE: §1244 is triggered without any election, automatic if the qualification tests are met. Compare with §1244 on a sale: same rules apply. WORTHLESSNESS TIMING under §165(g): stock becomes 'worthless' when it has no current value AND no reasonable prospect of recovery, generally evidenced by bankruptcy filing, dissolution, or sustained no-trading. Documenting worthlessness can be challenging in practice; the IRS may dispute the year of worthlessness. Answer B is incorrect: §1244 applies to worthlessness as well as sales. The provision specifically encompasses both. Answer C is incorrect: §1244 is CAPPED at $50K single / $100K MFJ; excess is capital loss. There is no 'fully covers all losses' framework. Answer D is incorrect: stock worthlessness is recognized in the year the stock becomes worthless under §165(g), not when the corporation is formally dissolved.
Question 5
Hint
§1202(d)(1) $50M cap: must hold at AND BEFORE issuance AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER. Either fails → stock not QSBS. Permanent, no cure for post-issuance reductions. Subsidiaries (50%+ owned) aggregate.
Answer B. §1202(d)(1) AGGREGATE GROSS ASSETS TEST: Pioneer's aggregate gross assets must NOT EXCEED $50 MILLION at any time AT OR BEFORE THE ISSUANCE AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER the issuance. Both checkpoints matter. PIONEER'S ANALYSIS: Pre-issuance: $48,000,000 ≤ $50M ✓ (passes). Post-issuance: $52,000,000 > $50M ✗ (fails). Reyes's stock FAILS §1202 qualification, the post-issuance test isn't met. Reyes's gain on a future sale would be fully recognized as long-term capital gain (no §1202 exclusion). PERMANENT DISQUALIFICATION: once a corporation crosses the $50M threshold at the time of an issuance, that issuance is permanently disqualified. There is NO 12-MONTH CURE provision allowing post-issuance asset reductions to retroactively qualify stock. Pre-cap-breach issuances (when gross assets were ≤$50M post-issuance) retain QSBS status if they otherwise qualified. PLANNING IMPLICATION: corporations approaching the $50M threshold should issue all anticipated investor stock BEFORE crossing the cap. After crossing, future investors lose the §1202 benefit. WHY THE TWO-POINT TEST: Congress wanted §1202 to target genuinely small businesses. Just measuring at issuance creates a loophole (issue stock, then immediately bring in $50M of additional capital). The post-issuance test prevents this. AGGREGATE GROSS ASSETS measurement: cash + property at ADJUSTED BASIS (with FMV substituted for property contributed in tax-free exchanges). Includes subsidiary aggregation: controlled subsidiaries' assets aggregate with the parent. SUBSIDIARY AGGREGATION: per §1202(d)(3), if Pioneer owns 50%+ of a subsidiary's stock by vote or value, the subsidiary's assets aggregate with Pioneer's for the $50M test. This prevents structuring around the cap by using subsidiaries. Answer A is incorrect: pre-issuance pass alone is insufficient; post-issuance test must also pass. Answer C is incorrect: the test applies at TWO points (before AND immediately after), not just the issuance date. Answer D is incorrect: there is NO 12-month cure provision; once crossed, the issuance is permanently disqualified.
Question 6
Hint
§1244 ordinary loss cap: $50K single / $100K MFJ per year. Excess = capital loss (LTCL if held >1 yr). Capital losses offset gains, then $3,000/yr against ordinary; rest carries forward. §1244 = LOSS; §1202 = GAIN.
Answer B. §1244 ('SMALL BUSINESS STOCK') provides ORDINARY LOSS treatment on a LIMITED amount of loss when stock of a qualifying small business corporation becomes worthless or is sold at a loss, up to $50,000 (single) / $100,000 (MFJ) per year. Excess loss is treated as CAPITAL LOSS. HARTWELL'S CALCULATION: Total loss = $200,000. §1244 ordinary loss limit (single) = $50,000. Ordinary loss recognized = $50,000 (deductible against ordinary income with no $3,000 cap, ordinary losses can offset any income type). Capital loss = $200,000 − $50,000 = $150,000 long-term capital loss (holding period from Year 1 to Year 5 > 1 year). CAPITAL LOSS USAGE: Capital losses can offset capital gains in full, then up to $3,000 against ordinary income per year ($1,500 MFS); excess carries forward indefinitely. HARTWELL HAS NO CAPITAL GAINS for Year 5 → $3,000 of the $150,000 LTCL offsets ordinary income. REMAINING CAPITAL LOSS CARRYOVER: $150,000 − $3,000 = $147,000, carries forward indefinitely. HARTWELL'S YEAR 5 OUTCOME: $50,000 §1244 ordinary loss + $3,000 capital loss against ordinary income = $53,000 reducing taxable income from $300,000 to $247,000. STRATEGIC NOTE: §1244 is most valuable when loss exceeds the cap, converts $50K (single) of capital loss to ordinary, freeing up the full ordinary-rate offset rather than the $3,000/year capital-loss cap. §1244 vs §1202: §1244 = LOSS provision (ordinary, capped); §1202 = GAIN provision (exclusion). Same stock can qualify for both; §1244 applies if sold/worthless at loss; §1202 applies if held >5 years and sold at gain. Answer A is incorrect: this ignores §1244 entirely; it would be the treatment for non-§1244 stock. Answer C is incorrect: §1244 has a strict annual cap ($50K single / $100K MFJ); the cap applies whether the loss is from sale or worthlessness. Answer D is incorrect: the single-filer cap is $50,000, not $100,000. The $100,000 cap is for MFJ.
Common questions
Can I exclude QSBS gain after holding the stock for four years?
For QSBS acquired after July 4, 2025, four years permits a 75% exclusion. Hampton excludes $750,000 of the $1,000,000 gain.
Does stock acquired before July 5, 2025, qualify after four years?
Not under the acquisition window compared here. Stock acquired after September 27, 2010, through July 4, 2025, requires more than five years, so Hampton recognizes the full $1,000,000 gain.
Does Section 1202 require five years or more than five years?
The older acquisition window requires more than five years. Stock acquired after July 4, 2025, reaches the 100% exclusion tier after five years.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process, worked step by step.
Section 1231 Netting & Section 1245 Recapture | CPA TCP TBS on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process
- Section 1231 Netting: Net Gain vs. Net Loss
- Section 1245 Recapture: Ordinary Income vs. Section 1231 Gain
- Section 1231 Five-Year Lookback Rule and Example
- Section 1231 Five-Year Lookback: When Gains Become Ordinary
- Section 121 Partial Exclusion: The 2-Out-of-5-Year Rule
All Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.