PracticeTCPFree practice exam

TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 6 practice questions

Section 1231 Netting: Net Gain vs. Net Loss

Net current-year Section 1231 gains and losses before deciding their tax character. Below, follow a business land example and see how a larger loss flips the result from long-term capital gain to ordinary loss.

The ruleNet current-year Section 1231 gains and losses after removing ordinary depreciation recapture. A net gain is long-term capital gain, subject to the five-year lookback; a net loss is ordinary.

Try one first

During Year 2, a sole proprietor sold two parcels of land used in the business, each held for more than 1 year. Parcel A produced a $40,000 gain, and Parcel B produced a $10,000 loss. Assume neither parcel is inventory, neither involves depreciation recapture, and the taxpayer has no nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses from the prior 5 years. What amount and character should the taxpayer report from these sales for Year 2?
Hint

First decide whether both assets are Section 1231 property, then net the gain and loss before deciding the final character.

Step by step

  1. Identify the Section 1231 items

    A sole proprietor sells two parcels of business-use land held more than one year, producing a $40,000 gain and a $10,000 loss. Neither is inventory; these are the year's only dispositions, with no recapture, casualty or theft items, or nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses from the prior five years.

  2. Net the year's gains and losses

    Both parcels qualify as Section 1231 property, so combine their results: $40,000 gain minus $10,000 loss equals a $30,000 net Section 1231 gain. Do not assign separate capital-gain and ordinary-loss treatment to the two sales.

  3. Apply the net gain rule

    The five-year lookback makes a net gain ordinary to the extent of prior nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses. Because the proprietor has none, the entire $30,000 net gain is long-term capital gain.

  4. Flip the result to a loss

    Same facts, except the second parcel produces a $50,000 loss: $40,000 minus $50,000 equals a $10,000 net Section 1231 loss. That net loss is ordinary, not capital; the lookback does not apply to a net loss.

Key points

  • Remember: The annual net result determines character, not each sale by itself.
  • Business use does not automatically make a net gain ordinary.
  • The five-year lookback can recharacterize a net gain, but it does not change a net loss into capital.

How the exam traps you

  • Report the $40,000 gain as capital and the $10,000 loss as ordinary. Net both Section 1231 items first, producing one $30,000 net gain.
  • Call the $30,000 net gain ordinary because the land was used in business. With no prior nonrecaptured Section 1231 losses, the net gain is long-term capital gain.
  • Call the revised $10,000 net loss a long-term capital loss. A net Section 1231 loss is ordinary, even though the property was held more than one year.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Alex, an individual, had the following recognized Year 1 dispositions. All assets were held more than one year. The equipment and building were used in Alex's sole proprietorship. None of the depreciable business property is subject to depreciation recapture.
ItemAmount
Equipment used in the business$18,000 gain
Building used in the business$30,000 loss
Land held for investment$8,000 gain
Stock held for investment$12,000 loss
After applying the required federal income tax netting rules, which result is correct?
Hint

Separate the business-use assets from the investment assets, and remember that §1231 treatment depends on whether the net result is a gain or a loss.

Question 3

In Year 2, Lane, a sole proprietor, disposed of two assets used in the business, each of which had been held for more than one year. A machine was sold for $18,000 when its adjusted basis was $10,000, and a delivery truck was sold for $9,000 when its adjusted basis was $14,000. Assume no depreciation recapture applies, Lane had no other Sec. 1231 gains or losses in Year 2, and Lane had no nonrecaptured net Sec. 1231 losses from the prior five years. How should Lane classify the overall Year 2 result from these dispositions?
Hint

First determine whether each asset falls under Sec. 1231, then net the gain and loss before deciding the character of the final amount.

Question 4

In Year 1, Nora, a calendar-year sole proprietor, disposed of two assets used in her trade or business. She recognized a $70,000 gain on the sale of a warehouse and a $22,000 loss on the sale of machinery. She held both assets for more than 1 year. Assume both assets are Section 1231 property, no depreciation recapture applies, and Nora has no nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses from the prior 5 years. What is the effect on Nora's Year 1 tax return?
Hint

First determine the net Section 1231 result for the year, then decide its character based on the assumptions given.

Question 5

In Year 2, Alder Co. disposed of three assets used in its trade or business, each held for more than one year. The dispositions produced a $30,000 gain, a $12,000 gain, and a $25,000 loss. Assume all three assets are Section 1231 property, none are inventory or capital assets, no Section 1245 or Section 1250 recapture applies, and Alder has no nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses from prior years. How should Alder characterize the Year 2 net result from these dispositions?
Hint

For Section 1231 property, do not classify each gain or loss too early. First determine the overall net result for the year.

Question 6

In Year 1, Kim, an individual taxpayer, had the following asset dispositions and no others: (1) land used in Kim's business, held 4 years, sold at a $15,000 gain; (2) a warehouse used in Kim's business, held 6 years, sold at a $25,000 loss; (3) investment stock, held 2 years, sold at an $8,000 gain; and (4) investment land, held 3 years, sold at a $5,000 loss. Assume none of the assets is inventory, none of the dispositions is subject to depreciation recapture, and Kim has no nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses from prior years. Which of the following is the best action for Kim to take in determining the Year 1 tax character of these items?
Hint

Separate the business-use assets from the investment assets first. Then decide what the net result of the Section 1231 bucket is before applying capital gain and loss treatment.

Drill all 171 Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Do Section 1231 gains and losses have to be netted?

Yes. Combine the year's Section 1231 items before assigning final character. In the example, the $40,000 gain and $10,000 loss become a $30,000 net gain.

When is a net Section 1231 gain ordinary income?

The five-year lookback makes the net gain ordinary to the extent of nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses from the prior five years. The example has none, so its $30,000 net gain is long-term capital gain.

Is a net Section 1231 loss ordinary or capital?

It is ordinary. Increasing the example's parcel loss to $50,000 produces a $10,000 net Section 1231 loss, treated as an ordinary loss.

Watch it solved

A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process, worked step by step.

Section 1231 Netting & Section 1245 Recapture | CPA TCP TBS on YouTube

Practice TCP like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process

All Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.