TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 6 practice questions
Section 1231 Netting: Net Gain vs. Net Loss
Net current-year Section 1231 gains and losses before deciding their tax character. Below, follow a business land example and see how a larger loss flips the result from long-term capital gain to ordinary loss.
Try one first
Hint
First decide whether both assets are Section 1231 property, then net the gain and loss before deciding the final character.
Answer B. Both parcels are Section 1231 property because they were used in a trade or business and held more than 1 year. Section 1231 gains and losses are netted, producing a $30,000 net Section 1231 gain ($40,000 − $10,000). With no nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses from the prior 5 years, that net gain is treated as long-term capital gain.
Why not A: This is tempting if a student forgets to net Section 1231 items. Both results are Section 1231 items and must be netted first; they do not remain separately characterized as one capital gain and one ordinary loss in the same year.
Why not C: Business use alone doesn't make the net Section 1231 gain ordinary. A net Section 1231 gain is generally long-term capital gain unless recharacterized by the 5-year lookback rule, which the fact pattern negates.
Why not D: Short-term capital gain is incorrect because both parcels were held more than one year and Section 1231 net gains that survive the lookback are treated as long-term capital gains, not short-term.
Step by step
- Identify the Section 1231 items
A sole proprietor sells two parcels of business-use land held more than one year, producing a $40,000 gain and a $10,000 loss. Neither is inventory; these are the year's only dispositions, with no recapture, casualty or theft items, or nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses from the prior five years.
- Net the year's gains and losses
Both parcels qualify as Section 1231 property, so combine their results: $40,000 gain minus $10,000 loss equals a $30,000 net Section 1231 gain. Do not assign separate capital-gain and ordinary-loss treatment to the two sales.
- Apply the net gain rule
The five-year lookback makes a net gain ordinary to the extent of prior nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses. Because the proprietor has none, the entire $30,000 net gain is long-term capital gain.
- Flip the result to a loss
Same facts, except the second parcel produces a $50,000 loss: $40,000 minus $50,000 equals a $10,000 net Section 1231 loss. That net loss is ordinary, not capital; the lookback does not apply to a net loss.
Key points
- Remember: The annual net result determines character, not each sale by itself.
- Business use does not automatically make a net gain ordinary.
- The five-year lookback can recharacterize a net gain, but it does not change a net loss into capital.
How the exam traps you
- Report the $40,000 gain as capital and the $10,000 loss as ordinary. Net both Section 1231 items first, producing one $30,000 net gain.
- Call the $30,000 net gain ordinary because the land was used in business. With no prior nonrecaptured Section 1231 losses, the net gain is long-term capital gain.
- Call the revised $10,000 net loss a long-term capital loss. A net Section 1231 loss is ordinary, even though the property was held more than one year.
Question 2
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Equipment used in the business | $18,000 gain |
| Building used in the business | $30,000 loss |
| Land held for investment | $8,000 gain |
| Stock held for investment | $12,000 loss |
Hint
Separate the business-use assets from the investment assets, and remember that §1231 treatment depends on whether the net result is a gain or a loss.
Answer A. The business equipment and building are §1231 assets and must be netted together first. The $18,000 gain and $30,000 loss net to a $12,000 §1231 loss, and a net §1231 loss is treated as an ordinary loss. The investment land and stock are capital assets; their $8,000 gain and $12,000 loss net to a $4,000 net long-term capital loss.
Why not B: This misapplies the usual outcome for net §1231 gains (which can be long-term capital gains) to §1231 losses. A net §1231 loss is not capital; it is treated as an ordinary loss.
Why not C: This correctly treats the net §1231 loss as ordinary but incorrectly characterizes the investment assets. Land and stock held for investment are capital assets, so their net loss remains a capital loss.
Why not D: This distractor arises from failing to net the §1231 items before final characterization. §1231 gains and losses from business-use property must be netted together; you cannot treat the gain and loss as separate final results here.
Question 3
Hint
First determine whether each asset falls under Sec. 1231, then net the gain and loss before deciding the character of the final amount.
Answer A. Both assets qualify as Sec. 1231 property because they were used in the business and held for more than one year. The machine produces an $8,000 gain and the truck produces a $5,000 loss, for a net Sec. 1231 gain of $3,000. Because Lane has no nonrecaptured net Sec. 1231 losses from the prior five years, the net Sec. 1231 gain is treated as long-term capital gain.
Why not B: Tempting because the assets were business property, but Sec. 1231 has a netting rule: a net Sec. 1231 gain (when no prior lookback recapture applies) receives long-term capital gain treatment, not ordinary treatment.
Why not C: This appeals to those who recall that some business losses are ordinary, but Sec. 1231 requires you to net gains and losses from qualifying property first; you do not report the $8,000 gain and $5,000 loss separately once both are Sec. 1231 items.
Why not D: A net Sec. 1231 gain is treated as long-term capital gain when the underlying property was held more than one year (and there is no five-year lookback recharacterization), so it is not short-term capital gain.
Question 4
Hint
First determine the net Section 1231 result for the year, then decide its character based on the assumptions given.
Answer D. Section 1231 gains and losses are netted for the year. Nora's net Section 1231 gain is $48,000 ($70,000 gain − $22,000 loss). Because there are no prior nonrecaptured Section 1231 losses and no depreciation recapture, the net Section 1231 gain is treated as long-term capital gain.
Why not A: This option confuses business-property treatment with ordinary income. A net Section 1231 gain is treated as long-term capital gain unless the 5-year lookback rule (nonrecaptured losses) converts it to ordinary income, which the facts explicitly rule out.
Why not B: Short-term treatment depends on holding period. Both assets were held more than one year, so the net Section 1231 gain (if it remains a net gain) is long-term capital gain, not short-term.
Why not C: This mistakenly characterizes each sale separately. Section 1231 requires netting all Section 1231 gains and losses for the year; the correct result is a single $48,000 net Section 1231 gain that is long-term capital gain under the facts given.
Question 5
Hint
For Section 1231 property, do not classify each gain or loss too early. First determine the overall net result for the year.
Answer D. Net the Section 1231 gains and losses: $30,000 + $12,000 − $25,000 = $17,000 net Section 1231 gain. Because there are no prior nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses (the 5-year lookback does not apply), a net Section 1231 gain is treated as a long-term capital gain. Therefore, Alder reports a $17,000 long-term capital gain.
Why not A: This is tempting because the assets were used in a business, but Section 1231 items are netted and, absent the lookback recapture, a net Section 1231 gain is capital in nature, not ordinary.
Why not B: This treats only the loss and ignores the gains. After netting all Section 1231 items, the result is a $17,000 net gain, not a net loss.
Why not C: This reflects the error of classifying each item separately rather than netting Section 1231 gains and losses first. Section 1231 items are combined and the net result determines the character.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the business-use assets from the investment assets first. Then decide what the net result of the Section 1231 bucket is before applying capital gain and loss treatment.
Answer D. The business-use land and warehouse are Section 1231 assets because they were used in the business and held more than one year. They must first be netted against each other, producing a $10,000 net Section 1231 loss, and a net Section 1231 loss is treated as ordinary. The investment stock and investment land are capital assets and net separately to a $3,000 net long-term capital gain.
Why not A: This is tempting because the net result from the Section 1231 bucket in this case is an ordinary loss. It is still wrong because business-use property held more than one year is not automatically ordinary item by item. The two business dispositions must first be combined under the Section 1231 netting rules, and only then is the net character determined.
Why not B: This is tempting because Section 1231 gains can receive long-term capital gain treatment and Section 1231 losses can become ordinary. However, that character determination happens only after all current-year Section 1231 gains and losses are netted together. Kim cannot separately label the land gain as capital while also treating the warehouse loss as ordinary before completing the Section 1231 netting process.
Why not C: This is tempting because all four assets were long-term holdings, which can make it seem as if one overall netting process applies. It is wrong because Section 1231 items and capital assets do not begin in the same netting bucket. Kim must first determine the net Section 1231 result separately, and only the capital assets are netted in the capital gain/loss category unless there is a net Section 1231 gain.
Common questions
Do Section 1231 gains and losses have to be netted?
Yes. Combine the year's Section 1231 items before assigning final character. In the example, the $40,000 gain and $10,000 loss become a $30,000 net gain.
When is a net Section 1231 gain ordinary income?
The five-year lookback makes the net gain ordinary to the extent of nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses from the prior five years. The example has none, so its $30,000 net gain is long-term capital gain.
Is a net Section 1231 loss ordinary or capital?
It is ordinary. Increasing the example's parcel loss to $50,000 produces a $10,000 net Section 1231 loss, treated as an ordinary loss.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process, worked step by step.
Section 1231 Netting & Section 1245 Recapture | CPA TCP TBS on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process
- Section 1245 Recapture: Ordinary Income vs. Section 1231 Gain
- Section 1231 Five-Year Lookback Rule and Example
- Section 1231 Five-Year Lookback: When Gains Become Ordinary
- Section 121 Partial Exclusion: The 2-Out-of-5-Year Rule
- QSBS Section 1202 Holding Periods After OBBBA
All Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.