TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 9 practice questions
Section 1245 Recapture: Ordinary Income vs. Section 1231 Gain
Section 1245 ordinary recapture equals the lesser of recognized gain or depreciation allowed or allowable. Below, a worked machine sale shows how to separate ordinary recapture from the gain entering Section 1231 netting.
Try one first
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Machine (§1245 property): original cost $90,000, accumulated depreciation $50,000, sold for $70,000 | |
| Warehouse: adjusted basis $300,000, sold for $260,000 | |
| Land: basis $100,000, sold for $150,000 | |
Hint
Work in sequence: compute any §1245 ordinary recapture and remove it from the §1231 pool, net remaining §1231 items, then apply the §1231 five‑year lookback to any net §1231 gain.
Answer D. The machine's gain is $70,000 − ($90,000 − $50,000) = $30,000 and is ordinary under §1245 because §1245 recapture converts realized gain up to accumulated depreciation into ordinary income; that ordinary recapture is determined and removed before §1231 netting. The warehouse loss ($40,000) and land gain ($50,000) are §1231 items and net to a $10,000 §1231 gain. Under the §1231 five‑year lookback, the current net §1231 gain is recharacterized as ordinary to the extent of Dana's $20,000 prior nonrecaptured §1231 losses, so the entire $10,000 becomes ordinary.
Why not A: This plays on the depreciation misconception: land is generally nondepreciable but that does not exclude it from §1231; property used in a trade or business and held more than one year (including land) is a §1231 item and must be included in §1231 netting.
Why not B: Tempting because it describes a single pooling step, but incorrect: §1245 recapture is computed and treated as ordinary before §1231 netting, so the machine's §1245 ordinary component cannot be included in the §1231 pool and then reclassified afterward.
Why not C: Although both assets were long‑term, they are §1231 items and must be netted; the five‑year §1231 lookback converts current net §1231 gains into ordinary income to the extent of prior nonrecaptured §1231 losses, so the $10,000 net §1231 gain does not remain long‑term capital in this fact pattern.
Worked example
Avery, a sole proprietor, sells a business machine classified as Section 1245 property after using it for three years. It cost $80,000. Depreciation allowed or allowable totals $30,000, all properly claimed. Avery receives $100,000 in a fully taxable cash sale with no selling expenses or other basis adjustments.
| 1 | Compute adjusted basis$80,000 cost − $30,000 depreciation | $50,000 |
| 2 | Compute recognized gain$100,000 proceeds − $50,000 adjusted basis | $50,000 |
| 3 | Separate Section 1245 ordinary recaptureLesser of $50,000 gain or $30,000 depreciation | $30,000 ordinary income |
| 4 | Find the gain entering Section 1231 netting$50,000 total gain − $30,000 ordinary recapture | $20,000 Section 1231 gain |
Avery has $30,000 of ordinary income under Section 1245 and $20,000 of gain entering Section 1231 netting.
Check: The sale price exceeds original cost by $20,000, so that appreciation enters Section 1231 netting; the $30,000 recovery of depreciation is ordinary.
Key points
- The machine must be held more than one year for its excess gain to qualify under Section 1231.
- Use depreciation allowed or allowable, not just the amount the taxpayer chose to claim.
- Keep ordinary recapture outside the Section 1231 pool.
How the exam traps you
- Treating the entire $50,000 machine gain as ordinary income. Recapture cannot exceed $30,000 of depreciation. The remaining $20,000 enters Section 1231 netting.
- Putting the entire $50,000 machine gain into Section 1231 netting. Remove the $30,000 ordinary recapture first. Only $20,000 enters the pool.
Question 2
| Asset | Cost | Adj. Basis | Accum. Depr. | Sold For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Machine | $150,000 | $110,000 | $60,000 | |
| Parcel A of business land | $90,000 | $130,000 | ||
| Parcel B of business land | $50,000 | $30,000 |
Hint
Compute each asset's gain or loss separately, then identify whether any part is recharacterized as ordinary before you net the remaining Sec. 1231 items.
Answer A. Compute each asset separately and apply recapture before netting. The machine's adjusted basis is $150,000 - $110,000 = $40,000, so the sale at $60,000 produces a $20,000 gain; as Sec. 1245 property, that $20,000 is ordinary income to the extent of prior depreciation. Parcel A yields a $40,000 gain and Parcel B a $20,000 loss, giving a $20,000 net Sec. 1231 gain, which is long-term capital gain because there are no nonrecaptured net Sec. 1231 losses in the prior five years. Thus Reed reports $20,000 ordinary income and $20,000 long-term capital gain.
Why not B: This treats all three dispositions as Sec. 1231 items and ignores Sec. 1245 depreciation recapture on the machine. The machine's $20,000 gain is ordinary under Sec. 1245 and cannot be classed as Sec. 1231 LTCG.
Why not C: This correctly recaptures the machine gain as ordinary but fails to net the two land transactions. Parcel B's $20,000 loss offsets part of Parcel A's $40,000 gain, leaving only $20,000 net Sec. 1231 gain (LTCG), not $40,000.
Why not D: This overextends depreciation recapture or ordinary-treatment to the land sales. Only the machine's $20,000 gain is ordinary under Sec. 1245; the net of the two land sales is a Sec. 1231 gain treated as long-term capital gain here.
Question 3
Hint
Compute the gain or loss on each asset first, then recharacterize any depreciation recapture before doing the §1231 netting.
Answer B. Equipment: amount realized 210,000 less adjusted basis 80,000 (180,000 cost − 100,000 accumulated depreciation) produces a $130,000 gain. Under §1245 the lesser of gain (130,000) and prior depreciation (100,000) is recaptured as ordinary income, so $100,000 is ordinary and the remaining $30,000 is §1231 gain. Land: adjusted basis 90,000 sold for 40,000 produces a $50,000 §1231 loss. Net §1231 = $30,000 gain − $50,000 loss = $20,000 net §1231 loss, which is treated as an ordinary loss after the §1231 netting process.
Why not A: This treats the entire equipment gain as ordinary recapture. §1245 recapture is limited to prior depreciation (100,000), so only $100,000 is ordinary; the remaining $30,000 is §1231 gain. The land loss is a §1231 loss and becomes ordinary only if netting produces an overall §1231 loss.
Why not C: This correctly applies §1245 recapture but gets the sign wrong on the §1231 net. After recapture there is $30,000 of §1231 gain and a $50,000 §1231 loss from the land, which net to a $20,000 §1231 loss (not a gain).
Why not D: This collapses the final ordinary effect ($100,000 ordinary income offset by a $20,000 ordinary loss yields $80,000 net ordinary income) but ignores the required intermediate characterization steps: identify §1245 recapture and compute the net §1231 result before combining ordinary items elsewhere on the return.
Question 4
Hint
Compute each asset's gain or loss first, then apply any recapture rules before netting the remaining §1231 amounts.
Answer A. Truck: adjusted basis 100,000 − 40,000 = 60,000, so gain = 120,000 − 60,000 = 60,000. Under §1245, the $40,000 of depreciation is recaptured as ordinary income, leaving a $20,000 §1231 gain. Land: loss = 150,000 − 120,000 = $30,000 (§1231). Net §1231 = $20,000 gain − $30,000 loss = $10,000 net §1231 loss, and a net §1231 loss is treated as an ordinary loss. Therefore report $40,000 ordinary income (§1245 recapture) and a $10,000 ordinary loss.
Why not B: Tempting because the overall taxable effect is $40,000 ordinary income minus a $10,000 ordinary loss = $30,000 net ordinary income. It is wrong because it collapses the required characterization steps: the $40,000 is §1245 ordinary recapture and the $10,000 arises from a net §1231 loss that is treated as ordinary, both should be identified.
Why not C: This misstates the character of the land loss. The truck does have a $20,000 remaining §1231 gain, and the land loss is a §1231 loss, not an immediate ordinary loss. The §1231 items net to a $10,000 net §1231 loss, which is treated as an ordinary loss, not a $30,000 ordinary loss.
Why not D: This correctly shows the $40,000 §1245 recapture and the $10,000 netting result among §1231 items, but a net §1231 loss is treated as an ordinary loss in the year realized. Stating it as a 'net §1231 loss' without noting its ordinary treatment is incomplete for final characterization.
Question 5
Hint
First determine whether any gain must be recharacterized as ordinary before you net the remaining section 1231 items.
Answer B. The machine's adjusted basis is 120,000 - 90,000 = 30,000, so the gain is 50,000 - 30,000 = 20,000, and as section 1245 property that $20,000 is recaptured as ordinary income (limited to the gain). The warehouse produces a 30,000 section 1231 loss (140,000 - 110,000) and the land produces a 45,000 section 1231 gain (145,000 - 100,000). Netting those section 1231 items gives a 15,000 net section 1231 gain, which is long-term capital gain because there are no prior 5-year nonrecaptured section 1231 losses.
Why not A: This distractor results from correctly recapturing the machine's $20,000 as ordinary but then incorrectly treating the net section 1231 gain (land gain offset by warehouse loss) as ordinary as well. Absent prior nonrecaptured section 1231 losses, a net section 1231 gain is long-term capital gain, not ordinary income.
Why not C: This is attractive if a candidate forgets that section 1231 gains and losses must be netted (they would not separately report the warehouse loss as ordinary while reporting the land gain as capital). It also ignores that the machine's $20,000 gain is recaptured as ordinary before any section 1231 netting.
Why not D: This arises if a candidate incorrectly includes the machine in the section 1231 netting and overlooks section 1245 recapture. If all three were netted (incorrectly), total gains of 65,000 less the 30,000 loss would give 35,000, but the machine's $20,000 must be recharacterized as ordinary first.
Question 6
Hint
First separate any depreciation recapture from the equipment gain. Then decide what happens to the remaining business-property gain and loss under the §1231 netting rules.
Answer B. The equipment: amount realized $230,000 less adjusted basis $60,000 = $170,000 gain. As §1245 property, the lesser of gain ($170,000) or accumulated depreciation ($140,000) is recaptured as ordinary income, so $140,000 is ordinary and the remaining $30,000 is §1231 gain. The land: $70,000 realized less $120,000 basis = $50,000 §1231 loss. Net §1231 results are $30,000 gain minus $50,000 loss = $20,000 net §1231 loss, which is treated as an ordinary loss. Thus Lee has $140,000 ordinary income (recapture) and a $20,000 ordinary loss (net §1231).
Why not A: This treats the entire equipment gain as ordinary income (over-recapture). Only the depreciation portion is recaptured under §1245; the excess is treated as §1231 gain and must be netted with other §1231 losses.
Why not C: This distractor confuses business-use land with capital assets. A loss on business-use land held over one year is §1231, not a capital loss; a net §1231 loss is treated as ordinary.
Why not D: This correctly isolates the $30,000 §1231 gain but incorrectly treats the land loss as already ordinary. §1231 gains and losses must be netted first; the combined result here is a $20,000 net §1231 loss, which is ordinary.
Question 7
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Machine used in Lane's business for 3 years: cost $220,000, accumulated depreciation $90,000, sold for $180,000 | |
| Land used in Lane's business for 4 years: cost $140,000, sold for $100,000 | |
| Investment stock held for 18 months: basis $48,000, sold for $60,000 | |
Hint
Classify each asset first: depreciable business personal property, business-use land, and investment stock do not all enter the same netting bucket.
Answer D. Machine: amount realized $180,000 less adjusted basis $130,000 gives a $50,000 gain; because the machine is depreciable business personal property (§1245), the $50,000 is recaptured as ordinary income. Land: $100,000 less $140,000 = $40,000 §1231 loss; with no §1231 gains to net, the §1231 loss is ordinary. Stock: $60,000 less $48,000 = $12,000 long-term capital gain. Net ordinary = $50,000 − $40,000 = $10,000; net long-term capital gain = $12,000.
Why not A: Tempting if you treated both business assets as §1231 and pooled them with the stock, but the machine is §1245 property and its $50,000 gain is recaptured as ordinary income, so you cannot report only capital gain.
Why not B: This would result from treating the land loss as a capital loss and netting it against the stock, but land used in a trade or business held over 1 year is §1231 property (not a capital asset), and a Year 1 net §1231 loss is ordinary.
Why not C: Tempting if you correctly recapture the machine gain and treat the land loss as ordinary but then misclassify the stock gain as ordinary or improperly net it away; the stock is an investment capital asset held >1 year, so its $12,000 gain is long-term capital gain.
Question 8
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Equipment used in Jordan's sole proprietorship: cost $100,000, accumulated depreciation $30,000, sold for $115,000 | |
| Land used in the same business: sold | $22,000 loss |
| Stock held for investment: sold | $9,000 gain |
Hint
Separate the transactions into buckets before netting: recapture on depreciable personal property, then §1231 netting, then investment capital gain.
Answer D. The equipment's adjusted basis is $70,000 (100,000 cost − 30,000 accumulated depreciation), producing a $45,000 gain on sale. Under §1245, $30,000 of that gain is recaptured as ordinary income and the remaining $15,000 is a §1231 gain. Net the $15,000 §1231 gain with the $22,000 §1231 loss on the land to get a $7,000 net §1231 loss (treated as ordinary). Net ordinary income is therefore $30,000 − $7,000 = $23,000, plus the separate $9,000 long-term capital gain from the stock.
Why not A: This choice correctly picks up the $30,000 §1245 recapture but incorrectly treats the business loss as a capital loss offset against the stock. A net §1231 loss is treated as an ordinary loss, not a capital loss.
Why not B: This answer recognizes the §1245 recapture and the stock gain but ignores the $22,000 §1231 loss on the land. After netting the $15,000 §1231 gain with the $22,000 land loss, Jordan has a $7,000 ordinary §1231 loss that reduces ordinary income from $30,000 to $23,000.
Why not C: This option improperly offsets the land loss against the §1245 recapture and then treats the remaining gains as capital. The excess $15,000 equipment gain is a §1231 gain that must be netted with the $22,000 land loss, producing a $7,000 ordinary loss.
Question 9
Hint
Classify each asset before you net anything: first apply depreciation recapture, then net the remaining Section 1231 items, and keep the stock in the capital bucket.
Answer B. Equipment: adjusted basis = $90,000 - $50,000 = $40,000, so total gain = $100,000 - $40,000 = $60,000. Under Section 1245, depreciation recapture makes $50,000 of that gain ordinary income and leaves $10,000 as Section 1231 gain. Net the $10,000 Section 1231 gain with the $25,000 Section 1231 loss on the land to get a $15,000 net Section 1231 loss (treated as an ordinary loss). The stock is a capital asset, so its $12,000 gain is a long-term capital gain.
Why not A: Tempting because both equipment and land are business property held >1 year, but the equipment is Section 1245 property and must first recapture depreciation as ordinary income. Only $10,000 of the equipment gain remains for Section 1231 netting.
Why not C: This correctly treats the $50,000 as Section 1245 ordinary income, but land used in a trade or business is Section 1231 property, not a capital asset; the $25,000 land loss is part of the Section 1231 netting and, if netted into a loss, becomes ordinary rather than a capital loss.
Why not D: Incorrect netting: capital gains from investment stock are not netted with Section 1231 items. Also, the arithmetic ignores that $50,000 of the equipment gain is ordinary recapture and the stock gain remains a separate long-term capital gain.
Common questions
How do I calculate Section 1245 depreciation recapture?
Compute recognized gain using adjusted basis, then take the lesser of that gain or depreciation allowed or allowable. Avery's recapture is the lesser of $50,000 or $30,000, which is $30,000.
Is all gain on Section 1245 equipment ordinary income?
No. Avery's $50,000 gain exceeds the $30,000 depreciation limit, so $30,000 is ordinary recapture and $20,000 enters Section 1231 netting.
Does Section 1245 recapture go into Section 1231 netting?
No. Separate ordinary recapture before Section 1231 netting. For Avery's machine, only the $20,000 remaining gain enters that pool.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process, worked step by step.
Section 1231 Netting & Section 1245 Recapture | CPA TCP TBS on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process
- Section 1231 Netting: Net Gain vs. Net Loss
- Section 1231 Five-Year Lookback Rule and Example
- Section 1231 Five-Year Lookback: When Gains Become Ordinary
- Section 121 Partial Exclusion: The 2-Out-of-5-Year Rule
- QSBS Section 1202 Holding Periods After OBBBA
All Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.