PracticeTCPFree practice exam

TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 9 practice questions

Section 1245 Recapture: Ordinary Income vs. Section 1231 Gain

Section 1245 ordinary recapture equals the lesser of recognized gain or depreciation allowed or allowable. Below, a worked machine sale shows how to separate ordinary recapture from the gain entering Section 1231 netting.

The ruleFor Section 1245 property sold at a gain, ordinary recapture is the lesser of recognized gain or depreciation allowed or allowable. For business property held more than one year, only the remaining gain enters Section 1231 netting.

Try one first

In Year 2, Dana, a calendar-year sole proprietor, disposed of the following assets used in her business, all held more than one year:
ItemDetails
Machine (§1245 property): original cost $90,000, accumulated depreciation $50,000, sold for $70,000
Warehouse: adjusted basis $300,000, sold for $260,000
Land: basis $100,000, sold for $150,000
Dana had no other asset dispositions in Year 2. Dana also has $20,000 of nonrecaptured net §1231 losses from the five preceding tax years. Assume no other facts or special tax rules apply. Which of the following correctly describes the proper sequencing and the Year 2 character of these amounts?
Hint

Work in sequence: compute any §1245 ordinary recapture and remove it from the §1231 pool, net remaining §1231 items, then apply the §1231 five‑year lookback to any net §1231 gain.

Worked example

Avery, a sole proprietor, sells a business machine classified as Section 1245 property after using it for three years. It cost $80,000. Depreciation allowed or allowable totals $30,000, all properly claimed. Avery receives $100,000 in a fully taxable cash sale with no selling expenses or other basis adjustments.

1Compute adjusted basis$80,000 cost − $30,000 depreciation$50,000
2Compute recognized gain$100,000 proceeds − $50,000 adjusted basis$50,000
3Separate Section 1245 ordinary recaptureLesser of $50,000 gain or $30,000 depreciation$30,000 ordinary income
4Find the gain entering Section 1231 netting$50,000 total gain − $30,000 ordinary recapture$20,000 Section 1231 gain

Avery has $30,000 of ordinary income under Section 1245 and $20,000 of gain entering Section 1231 netting.

Check: The sale price exceeds original cost by $20,000, so that appreciation enters Section 1231 netting; the $30,000 recovery of depreciation is ordinary.

Key points

  • The machine must be held more than one year for its excess gain to qualify under Section 1231.
  • Use depreciation allowed or allowable, not just the amount the taxpayer chose to claim.
  • Keep ordinary recapture outside the Section 1231 pool.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating the entire $50,000 machine gain as ordinary income. Recapture cannot exceed $30,000 of depreciation. The remaining $20,000 enters Section 1231 netting.
  • Putting the entire $50,000 machine gain into Section 1231 netting. Remove the $30,000 ordinary recapture first. Only $20,000 enters the pool.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

In Year 1, Reed, a sole proprietor, sold three assets used in Reed's trade or business. Each asset had been held for more than one year. Reed has no nonrecaptured net Sec. 1231 losses from the prior five tax years. Assume all sales were fully taxable dispositions and were not part of an installment sale, like-kind exchange, or casualty event.
AssetCostAdj. BasisAccum. Depr.Sold For
Machine$150,000$110,000$60,000
Parcel A of business land$90,000$130,000
Parcel B of business land$50,000$30,000
What amount and character should Reed report from these dispositions for Year 1?
Hint

Compute each asset's gain or loss separately, then identify whether any part is recharacterized as ordinary before you net the remaining Sec. 1231 items.

Question 3

Sol, a calendar-year sole proprietor, disposed of two assets in Year 1. Sol has no prior-year nonrecaptured net §1231 losses. Both assets were used in Sol's business, were held for more than 1 year, were not inventory, and were sold in fully taxable transactions to unrelated parties. - Equipment: cost $180,000, accumulated depreciation $100,000, sold for $210,000. - Land used in the business: adjusted basis $90,000, sold for $40,000. Before offsetting ordinary items against each other elsewhere on the return, which combination of recognized amounts is most accurate?
Hint

Compute the gain or loss on each asset first, then recharacterize any depreciation recapture before doing the §1231 netting.

Question 4

In Year 2, Mason, a sole proprietor, sold two assets used in his business. He had no casualty or theft transactions in Year 2, and both assets were held for more than one year. The sales were as follows: • Delivery truck (§1245 property): cost $100,000, accumulated depreciation $40,000, sold for $120,000. • Land used in the business: adjusted basis $150,000, sold for $120,000. Assume no installment reporting or other special disposition rules apply. How should Mason characterize the recognized amounts from these sales on his Year 2 return?
Hint

Compute each asset's gain or loss first, then apply any recapture rules before netting the remaining §1231 amounts.

Question 5

In Year 3, Harper, a sole proprietor, sold the following assets, all of which were used in Harper's trade or business and held for more than 1 year: (1) a machine that is section 1245 property with original cost of $120,000, accumulated depreciation of $90,000, and a selling price of $50,000; (2) a warehouse with an adjusted basis of $140,000 and a selling price of $110,000; and (3) land used in the business with a basis of $100,000 and a selling price of $145,000. Assume all gains and losses are fully recognized and Harper has no nonrecaptured net section 1231 losses from the prior 5 tax years. What should Harper report from these dispositions for Year 3?
Hint

First determine whether any gain must be recharacterized as ordinary before you net the remaining section 1231 items.

Question 6

Lee, a calendar-year sole proprietor, disposed of the following business-use assets in Year 2. Lee had no other property dispositions, no casualty or condemnation items, and no nonrecaptured §1231 losses from the prior five years. 1. Manufacturing equipment held for 4 years: cost $200,000, accumulated depreciation $140,000, sold for $230,000. 2. Land used in the business held for 3 years: adjusted basis $120,000, sold for $70,000. All depreciation was allowable and properly claimed. What is the proper Year 2 tax classification of these disposition results?
Hint

First separate any depreciation recapture from the equipment gain. Then decide what happens to the remaining business-property gain and loss under the §1231 netting rules.

Question 7

In Year 1, Lane, a sole proprietor, sold three assets. Assume all sales were taxable dispositions, there were no casualty gains or losses, no other asset sales during Year 1, and Lane had no nonrecaptured net §1231 losses from the prior five years.
ItemDetails
Machine used in Lane's business for 3 years: cost $220,000, accumulated depreciation $90,000, sold for $180,000
Land used in Lane's business for 4 years: cost $140,000, sold for $100,000
Investment stock held for 18 months: basis $48,000, sold for $60,000
What is the correct characterization of Lane's Year 1 recognized results?
Hint

Classify each asset first: depreciable business personal property, business-use land, and investment stock do not all enter the same netting bucket.

Question 8

Jordan, an individual calendar-year taxpayer, has no nonrecaptured net §1231 losses from the prior five years and no other asset dispositions in Year 2. During Year 2, Jordan enters into the following fully taxable sales, and each asset had been held for more than one year:
ItemDetails
Equipment used in Jordan's sole proprietorship: cost $100,000, accumulated depreciation $30,000, sold for $115,000
Land used in the same business: sold$22,000 loss
Stock held for investment: sold$9,000 gain
Assume none of the assets is inventory or dealer property, and no installment reporting applies. Which conclusion is best regarding Jordan's Year 2 recognized gain and loss character from these dispositions?
Hint

Separate the transactions into buckets before netting: recapture on depreciable personal property, then §1231 netting, then investment capital gain.

Question 9

In Year 1, Vega, an individual sole proprietor, had only the following asset dispositions: (1) business equipment held more than 1 year, with original cost of $90,000, accumulated depreciation of $50,000, and sales price of $100,000; (2) land used in the business and held more than 1 year, with adjusted basis of $120,000 and sales price of $95,000; and (3) investment stock held more than 1 year, with basis of $30,000 and sales price of $42,000. Assume all dispositions are fully taxable, Vega has no other gains or losses for the year, and Vega has no nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses from prior years. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Classify each asset before you net anything: first apply depreciation recapture, then net the remaining Section 1231 items, and keep the stock in the capital bucket.

Drill all 171 Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

How do I calculate Section 1245 depreciation recapture?

Compute recognized gain using adjusted basis, then take the lesser of that gain or depreciation allowed or allowable. Avery's recapture is the lesser of $50,000 or $30,000, which is $30,000.

Is all gain on Section 1245 equipment ordinary income?

No. Avery's $50,000 gain exceeds the $30,000 depreciation limit, so $30,000 is ordinary recapture and $20,000 enters Section 1231 netting.

Does Section 1245 recapture go into Section 1231 netting?

No. Separate ordinary recapture before Section 1231 netting. For Avery's machine, only the $20,000 remaining gain enters that pool.

Watch it solved

A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process, worked step by step.

Section 1231 Netting & Section 1245 Recapture | CPA TCP TBS on YouTube

Practice TCP like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process

All Amount and character of gains and losses on asset disposition and netting process practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.