PracticeBARFree practice exam

BAR · Business Analysis · 6 practice questions

WACC and Optimal Capital Structure Calculation

The optimal capital structure minimizes WACC, not maximizes debt. Below: compare financing mixes using after-tax debt costs and see when higher required returns outweigh the tax benefit.

The ruleWACC = equity weight × cost of equity + debt weight × pretax cost of debt × (1 − tax rate). Use market-value weights and each structure's required returns; choose the lowest WACC.

Try one first

Company X is evaluating three capital-structure alternatives. Management's estimates (market-value weights) and required returns are: Unlevered (D/V = 0%, E/V = 100%): Re = 12%. Moderate leverage (D/V = 30%, E/V = 70%): Rd = 6%, Re = 14%. High leverage (D/V = 60%, E/V = 40%): Rd = 8%, Re = 20%. The corporate tax rate is 21%. Which capital structure should management choose to minimize the firm's weighted average cost of capital (WACC) and thereby maximize firm value?
Hint

Calculate the after-tax cost of debt component and compute WACC for each structure; compare the resulting WACCs while remembering the trade-off between the tax shield and rising required returns on equity.

Worked example

Atlas compares three financing plans using market-value weights. Plan A: 100% equity at 10%. Plan B: 40% debt at 6% and 60% equity at 12%. Plan C: 60% debt at 8% and 40% equity at 18%. Assume a 25% corporate tax rate. Operating risk and operating cash flows are unchanged. Which plan minimizes WACC?

1Plan B after-tax debt cost6% × (1 − 25%)4.50%
2Plan C after-tax debt cost8% × (1 − 25%)6.00%
3Plan A WACC100% × 10%10.00%
4Plan B WACC(60% × 12%) + (40% × 4.50%) = 7.20% + 1.80%9.00%
5Plan C WACC(40% × 18%) + (60% × 6.00%) = 7.20% + 3.60%10.80%

Choose Plan B, with 40% debt and a 9.00% WACC. Increasing debt to 60% raises WACC to 10.80%.

Check: For Plan B, start at the 12% equity cost and subtract the debt savings: 12% − 40% × (12% − 4.50%) = 9.00%.

Key points

  • Apply the tax adjustment only to debt, not equity.
  • Use each plan's stated required returns. Higher leverage can raise both debt and equity costs.
  • A rise in WACC after adding debt signals that the lower-debt alternative is better.

How the exam traps you

  • Using pretax debt cost gives Plan B a 9.60% WACC. Reduce its 6% debt cost to 4.50% before weighting.
  • Keeping Plan B's 12% equity cost for Plan C gives an incorrect 8.40% WACC. Use Plan C's higher 18% equity cost.
  • Choosing Plan C because it has the most debt and the largest debt weight. Compare total WACC: Plan C's 10.80% exceeds Plan B's 9.00%.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

SteelCo is a mature steel manufacturer with five years of stable, predictable operating income and low earnings volatility. Its assets are predominantly tangible (heavy machinery and inventory) that can be readily used as collateral. SteelCo has consistently positive taxable income, ready access to debt markets, and faces only modest, mostly administrative bankruptcy costs because customers have many alternative suppliers. Management is considering increasing leverage to lower the firm's tax burden. Given these facts, which factor should most govern SteelCo's target capital structure?
Hint

Focus on earnings stability, asset tangibility, and the size of expected bankruptcy costs, which capital-structure theory directly links those features to an optimal amount of debt?

Question 3

Lake Manufacturing is financed entirely with common equity. Management is considering issuing a moderate amount of long-term debt and using the proceeds to repurchase common shares. Assume Lake's operating income is stable, the after-tax cost of the new debt is lower than Lake's cost of equity, and the company would remain comfortably below any financial-distress range. Lake's weighted average cost of capital would likely change in which way, and with what accompanying effect?
Hint

Focus on two separate questions: what debt does to leverage, and what moderate low-cost debt does to WACC when distress effects are assumed away.

Question 4

Blue Co. has gradually increased debt in its capital structure. At 30% debt, Blue's weighted average cost of capital (WACC) was 9.4%; at 40% debt, WACC was 9.0%; and at 50% debt, WACC increased to 9.3%. Earnings per share also increased after the latest borrowing. Assuming these estimates are reliable, which fact is the clearest trigger that Blue may have moved beyond its optimal capital structure?
Hint

Focus on the signal used to identify an optimal capital structure, not just on whether debt has a tax benefit or boosts EPS.

Question 5

Company R has EBIT of $10,000,000, 1,000,000 shares outstanding trading at $80 per share, no debt, and a 21% corporate tax rate. The firm plans to issue $30,000,000 of debt at a 6% interest rate and use the proceeds to repurchase shares; operating income will be unchanged and there are no bankruptcy costs. Which of the following is the most likely effect or consequence of this capital structure change?
Hint

Compute net income after interest and the new share count, then recall that corporate taxes make interest payments partially tax-deductible (a tax shield that affects WACC).

Question 6

Company R is currently unlevered with an enterprise (firm) value based on operations of V_U = $100 million. The corporate tax rate is 21%. Management will immediately adopt one of four permanent debt levels (perpetual bonds): A) remain unlevered (no debt); B) issue $20 million of perpetual debt (coupon 4%), expected present value (PV) of bankruptcy costs at this debt level = $1.5 million; C) issue $40 million of perpetual debt (coupon 6%), expected PV of bankruptcy costs = $6.0 million; D) issue $60 million of perpetual debt (coupon 9%), expected PV of bankruptcy costs = $15.0 million. Assume the debt will be maintained permanently and that the tax shield on perpetual debt is valued at T_c × D. Ignore other agency effects and market frictions. Which capital-structure option maximizes the firm's enterprise value (V_L) immediately after the recapitalization?
Hint

For each option compute V_L = V_U + (T_c × D) − (provided PV of bankruptcy costs) and compare the resulting enterprise values; the highest number is the best choice.

Drill all 113 Capital structure questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

How do you calculate the after-tax cost of debt in WACC?

Multiply the pretax debt cost by one minus the tax rate. For Plan B, 6% × (1 − 25%) = 4.50%.

How do you find the optimal capital structure using WACC?

Calculate WACC for each alternative using its market-value weights and required returns. Plan B is best among the alternatives because its 9.00% WACC is lowest.

Why can more debt increase WACC despite the tax shield?

Higher leverage can raise the returns lenders and shareholders require. Plan C's higher debt and equity costs push WACC to 10.80%, above Plan B's 9.00%.

Practice BAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Capital structure

All Capital structure practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.