BAR · Business Analysis · 6 practice questions
WACC and Optimal Capital Structure Calculation
The optimal capital structure minimizes WACC, not maximizes debt. Below: compare financing mixes using after-tax debt costs and see when higher required returns outweigh the tax benefit.
Try one first
Hint
Calculate the after-tax cost of debt component and compute WACC for each structure; compare the resulting WACCs while remembering the trade-off between the tax shield and rising required returns on equity.
Answer A. Compute WACC using after-tax cost of debt. Unlevered WACC = 12.00%. Moderate: WACC = 0.70(14%) + 0.30(6%)(1 − 0.21) ≈ 11.22%. High: WACC = 0.40(20%) + 0.60(8%)(1 − 0.21) ≈ 11.79%. The 30% debt structure yields the lowest WACC, so it maximizes firm value.
Why not B: Tempting because it avoids leverage risk and has a 12% WACC, but it's wrong: the moderate-leverage WACC (~11.22%) is lower, so moderate debt better increases firm value.
Why not C: More debt raises the absolute tax shield but also increases Rd and Re (and bankruptcy costs); here the high-leverage WACC (~11.79%) is higher than the 30% option, so value is not maximized.
Why not D: Leverage can magnify ROE, but magnified ROE does not necessarily mean higher firm value. The decision criterion here is minimizing WACC, and the 60% structure raises WACC versus 30% debt.
Worked example
Atlas compares three financing plans using market-value weights. Plan A: 100% equity at 10%. Plan B: 40% debt at 6% and 60% equity at 12%. Plan C: 60% debt at 8% and 40% equity at 18%. Assume a 25% corporate tax rate. Operating risk and operating cash flows are unchanged. Which plan minimizes WACC?
| 1 | Plan B after-tax debt cost6% × (1 − 25%) | 4.50% |
| 2 | Plan C after-tax debt cost8% × (1 − 25%) | 6.00% |
| 3 | Plan A WACC100% × 10% | 10.00% |
| 4 | Plan B WACC(60% × 12%) + (40% × 4.50%) = 7.20% + 1.80% | 9.00% |
| 5 | Plan C WACC(40% × 18%) + (60% × 6.00%) = 7.20% + 3.60% | 10.80% |
Choose Plan B, with 40% debt and a 9.00% WACC. Increasing debt to 60% raises WACC to 10.80%.
Check: For Plan B, start at the 12% equity cost and subtract the debt savings: 12% − 40% × (12% − 4.50%) = 9.00%.
Key points
- Apply the tax adjustment only to debt, not equity.
- Use each plan's stated required returns. Higher leverage can raise both debt and equity costs.
- A rise in WACC after adding debt signals that the lower-debt alternative is better.
How the exam traps you
- Using pretax debt cost gives Plan B a 9.60% WACC. Reduce its 6% debt cost to 4.50% before weighting.
- Keeping Plan B's 12% equity cost for Plan C gives an incorrect 8.40% WACC. Use Plan C's higher 18% equity cost.
- Choosing Plan C because it has the most debt and the largest debt weight. Compare total WACC: Plan C's 10.80% exceeds Plan B's 9.00%.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on earnings stability, asset tangibility, and the size of expected bankruptcy costs, which capital-structure theory directly links those features to an optimal amount of debt?
Answer D. SteelCo's stable, positive taxable income means it can reliably benefit from interest tax shields, and its tangible assets reduce potential loss severity for lenders, while expected bankruptcy costs are modest. The trade-off theory explicitly balances the marginal tax benefit of additional debt against the marginal expected cost of financial distress to determine optimal leverage, so it best governs SteelCo's target capital structure.
Why not A: Market timing can affect the timing of specific issuances, but it is a tactical, short-term consideration. For a firm whose structural traits (earnings stability, asset tangibility, modest bankruptcy costs) point toward a particular debt level, the trade-off theory is the fundamental long-run determinant.
Why not B: Pecking-order explains issuance sequencing driven by information asymmetry (retained earnings first), but it does not prescribe a target leverage. Given clear tax advantages from debt and low distress costs, the firm's optimal debt level is better determined by the trade-off framework.
Why not C: Using debt to discipline managers is a valid consideration and can support higher leverage, but it is a secondary motive here. SteelCo's dominant concerns, tax shields and low expected distress costs, are the primary determinants of its optimal capital structure.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on two separate questions: what debt does to leverage, and what moderate low-cost debt does to WACC when distress effects are assumed away.
Answer C. Replacing some equity with a moderate amount of lower-cost debt increases financial leverage because the firm takes on fixed payment obligations. Under the stated assumptions, debt is cheaper than equity and the firm stays comfortably below distress, the weighted average cost of capital would typically decline. This is a financing effect and does not change the company's underlying operating (business) risk.
Why not A: While WACC is likely to decrease, this option confuses business risk with financial risk. Business risk arises from operations (sales volatility, margins), which capital-structure changes do not reduce; financing affects financial risk (leverage), not business risk.
Why not B: This reverses the direction of both effects. Issuing debt and repurchasing equity increases financial leverage rather than decreasing it, and when the new debt is cheaper than equity and distress is not a concern, WACC is expected to fall, not rise.
Why not D: This correctly notes the increase in leverage but gets the WACC effect wrong. With moderate, lower-cost debt and no significant distress, adding debt generally lowers WACC rather than raising it.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on the signal used to identify an optimal capital structure, not just on whether debt has a tax benefit or boosts EPS.
Answer C. A firm's optimal capital structure is typically the mix of debt and equity that minimizes WACC. Blue's WACC fell as debt rose to 40% (from 9.4% to 9.0%) but then rose when debt increased to 50% (to 9.3%), which indicates additional leverage may now be increasing the firm's overall cost of capital. An EPS increase does not outweigh the WACC signal because leverage can boost EPS while still raising overall risk and required returns.
Why not A: This is tempting because debt often appears cheaper on a stand-alone basis. However, debt typically remains cheaper than equity both before and after the optimum; the deciding signal is whether adding debt lowers or raises the firm's overall WACC, not the fact that debt's explicit rate is lower.
Why not B: The tax deductibility of interest is a real benefit of debt, but it does not guarantee that more debt improves firm value. If higher leverage raises required returns enough to increase WACC, the firm may be past its optimal debt level despite the tax shield.
Why not D: Leverage can increase EPS by reducing equity outstanding or by shifting the capital mix, but EPS can rise even while the firm's overall cost of capital and financial risk worsen. The WACC movement is the more direct indicator of having passed the optimum.
Question 5
Hint
Compute net income after interest and the new share count, then recall that corporate taxes make interest payments partially tax-deductible (a tax shield that affects WACC).
Answer B. Unlevered net income = $10,000,000*(1-0.21) = $7,900,000 (EPS = $7.90). Interest = $30,000,000*6% = $1,800,000, so levered net income = (10,000,000 - 1,800,000)*(1-0.21) = $6,478,000. Shares repurchased = $30,000,000 / $80 = 375,000 → new shares = 625,000; levered EPS ≈ $6,478,000/625,000 ≈ $10.36 (an increase). Under Modigliani-Miller with corporate taxes and no bankruptcy costs, the interest tax shield lowers the firm's WACC.
Why not A: Although adding debt raises the required return on equity, the presence of corporate taxes and no bankruptcy costs means the interest tax shield typically reduces WACC; in this scenario the tax benefit dominates, so WACC does not increase.
Why not C: This ignores the share repurchase. Even though net income falls after interest, outstanding shares fall by a larger proportion here, so EPS rises despite the lower net income. The WACC part is correct about the tax shield but the EPS direction is wrong.
Why not D: That conclusion matches M&M without taxes. Because a corporate tax rate is given, interest provides a tax-deductible shield that reduces WACC when there are no bankruptcy costs, so WACC does not remain unchanged.
Question 6
Hint
For each option compute V_L = V_U + (T_c × D) − (provided PV of bankruptcy costs) and compare the resulting enterprise values; the highest number is the best choice.
Answer B. Value with permanent debt: V_L = V_U + T_c × D − (PV of bankruptcy costs). Compute each: A = 100.0; B = 100 + 0.21×20 − 1.5 = 102.7; C = 100 + 0.21×40 − 6.0 = 102.4; D = 100 + 0.21×60 − 15.0 = 97.6. Option B yields the highest enterprise value (102.7), so issuing $20 million of perpetual debt maximizes V_L.
Why not A: Tempting because avoiding debt also avoids bankruptcy costs, but the numbers show a modest debt level produces a net positive benefit: the $20 million debt's tax shield (4.2) minus bankruptcy-cost PV (1.5) still raises firm value to 102.7 versus 100 unlevered.
Why not C: Tempting because a larger debt increases the tax shield (8.4) versus $20m (4.2), but the additional bankruptcy-cost PV (6.0 vs 1.5) nearly offsets the extra shield, leaving V_L = 102.4 which is slightly below the $20m option's 102.7.
Why not D: Tempting because this yields the largest absolute tax shield (12.6), but here the expected bankruptcy costs exceed the tax shield at this level, reducing enterprise value to 97.6, well below the best alternative.
Common questions
How do you calculate the after-tax cost of debt in WACC?
Multiply the pretax debt cost by one minus the tax rate. For Plan B, 6% × (1 − 25%) = 4.50%.
How do you find the optimal capital structure using WACC?
Calculate WACC for each alternative using its market-value weights and required returns. Plan B is best among the alternatives because its 9.00% WACC is lowest.
Why can more debt increase WACC despite the tax shield?
Higher leverage can raise the returns lenders and shareholders require. Plan C's higher debt and equity costs push WACC to 10.80%, above Plan B's 9.00%.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Capital structure
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.