PracticeBARFree practice exam

BAR · Business Analysis · 6 practice questions

Debt or Equity? Cash Flow Coverage Comes First

Debt capacity depends first on cash flows covering required payments through downturns, not on tax savings or avoiding dilution. Below: evaluate financing responses for an expansion whose debt option fails the downside cash coverage test.

The ruleEvaluate whether projected cash flows can reliably cover existing and added fixed debt payments through downturns. Tax benefits and avoiding dilution do not justify debt that creates excessive financial risk.

Try one first

Blue Ridge Power, a mature regulated utility, and FlashTrend Retail, a highly cyclical apparel company, are each evaluating whether to increase debt in their capital structure. Assume borrowing rates and tax rates are comparable. In deciding how much additional debt a company can prudently use, which factor should receive the greatest weight?
Hint

Focus on what makes debt different from equity: debt requires fixed payments regardless of how strong or weak the business cycle is.

What should you do?

The situation

Lark Co. needs financing for a long-term expansion. Its business is cyclical, and most assets have little resale value. In a downturn, annual cash available for debt service would be $2 million versus $3 million of total required payments under the debt option. Debt would raise projected EPS, provide deductible interest, and avoid ownership dilution. Common equity would fund the expansion without adding debt payments.

  1. Issue common equity because the debt option fails the downside cash coverage test.

    Best Equity avoids added debt payments. The cash shortfall and limited asset resale value make additional leverage imprudent.

  2. Issue debt because it produces higher projected EPS.

    Wrong EPS does not establish payment capacity. Downturn cash would fall $1 million short of required debt payments.

  3. Issue debt because deductible interest makes borrowing the better choice.

    Wrong Tax savings do not eliminate the payment shortfall or outweigh the resulting financial distress risk.

  4. Issue debt because preserving existing owners' voting control should govern the decision.

    Wrong Avoiding dilution is secondary to meeting required payments. Ownership preferences do not close the downside cash shortfall.

Key points

  • Remember: Debt payments stay due even when operating cash flows fall.
  • Test total required payments after financing, not just payments on the new debt.
  • Assets with little resale value increase expected distress costs and strengthen the case for limiting debt.

How the exam traps you

  • Choose debt because projected EPS is higher. Higher EPS does not supply the cash needed to make required payments.
  • Treat deductible interest as enough reason to borrow. Weigh tax savings against the risk and expected cost of financial distress.
  • Reject equity solely because it dilutes ownership. Preserving ownership is secondary to the ability to meet required payments.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

NovaTech Inc., a privately held software company, is setting its long‑term capital structure. Relevant facts: NovaTech spends heavily on R&D and holds mostly intangible assets (≈70% of total assets) with minimal collateralizable tangible assets; projected free cash flow is negative for the next two years and thereafter positive but quite volatile; management anticipates multiple future rounds of equity financing to fund growth; current taxable income is low. Which factor should most appropriately govern NovaTech's choice of capital structure?
Hint

Focus first on NovaTech’s cash‑flow predictability, collateral availability, and need for future external equity financing, then decide which capital‑structure concern dominates.

Question 3

Harbor Co. must fund a long-term plant expansion this quarter. Management wants to obtain permanent financing while minimizing dilution of existing common shareholders' voting control. Harbor expects stable operating cash flows that can cover fixed financing charges. Which response is most appropriate from a capital structure perspective?
Hint

Match the financing source to both the life of the asset being financed and management's stated goal about ownership control.

Question 4

Hart Co. is evaluating whether to finance a major expansion with long-term debt instead of issuing additional common stock. Hart has historically stable cash flows, expects to remain profitable, and current shareholders want to avoid dilution. If Hart issues the debt, however, its projected interest coverage ratio would decline from 7.0 to 1.8. In deciding whether Hart should add the debt, which factor should govern the decision?
Hint

Focus on what debt adds that equity does not: a required fixed payment that must be covered even if results weaken.

Question 5

Delta Co. wants to raise permanent capital for expansion, but its board is concerned that the company is already highly leveraged. Management's stated goal is to strengthen the capital structure by reducing financial risk and improving the debt-to-equity ratio. Which response best meets that goal?
Hint

Focus on which financing choice adds permanent capital while improving, not worsening, leverage.

Question 6

Aquila Manufacturing currently has $50 million of long-term debt at 5% interest and $150 million of equity (market values). The board is considering issuing $100 million of new long-term debt at 6% to repurchase common stock. Current EBIT is $40 million, but the business is highly cyclical and in a severe downturn EBIT can fall to about $3 million. Corporate tax rate is 30%. After the proposed transaction, annual interest expense would increase from $2.5 million to $8.5 million. Which of the following is the primary issue the board should consider when evaluating this capital-structure change?
Hint

Compute post-transaction interest expense and compare interest coverage under normal vs. downturn EBIT; consider whether expected distress costs outweigh tax and agency benefits.

Drill all 113 Capital structure questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What matters most when choosing debt or equity financing?

Start with cash available to cover total required debt payments through downturns. Lark's $2 million cannot cover $3 million, so the debt option fails that test.

Why not choose debt if interest is tax-deductible?

The tax benefit does not eliminate required payments. Lark's downside cash shortfall and assets with little resale value make financial distress the more important concern.

Should a company use debt to avoid ownership dilution?

Only if it can safely support the fixed payments. Lark should accept dilution rather than add debt it cannot reliably service.

Practice BAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Capital structure

All Capital structure practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.