BAR · Business Analysis · 6 practice questions
Debt or Equity? Cash Flow Coverage Comes First
Debt capacity depends first on cash flows covering required payments through downturns, not on tax savings or avoiding dilution. Below: evaluate financing responses for an expansion whose debt option fails the downside cash coverage test.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on what makes debt different from equity: debt requires fixed payments regardless of how strong or weak the business cycle is.
Answer D. Debt creates fixed obligations for interest and principal, so the governing factor is whether the company can reliably generate enough operating cash flow to service those obligations. Firms with stable, predictable cash flows can generally support more debt than highly cyclical firms whose cash flows fluctuate. Thus, cash-flow stability should receive the greatest weight when assessing prudent additional leverage.
Why not A: Market price may affect whether issuing equity seems attractive relative to issuing debt, but it doesn't determine the firm's capacity to meet contractual interest and principal payments. The primary concern for prudent leverage is the predictability of cash flows, not short-term stock price levels.
Why not B: This is tempting because retained earnings reflect accumulated profits and larger retained earnings increase book equity. However, retained earnings are an accounting balance and do not directly indicate the company's ongoing ability to produce cash to meet fixed debt payments.
Why not C: EPS is an accounting performance metric influenced by noncash items, share count changes, and accounting policies, so it doesn't reliably show cash available for debt service. A company can report improving EPS while having volatile or insufficient operating cash flows, making higher debt risky.
What should you do?
The situation
Lark Co. needs financing for a long-term expansion. Its business is cyclical, and most assets have little resale value. In a downturn, annual cash available for debt service would be $2 million versus $3 million of total required payments under the debt option. Debt would raise projected EPS, provide deductible interest, and avoid ownership dilution. Common equity would fund the expansion without adding debt payments.
Issue common equity because the debt option fails the downside cash coverage test.
Best Equity avoids added debt payments. The cash shortfall and limited asset resale value make additional leverage imprudent.
Issue debt because it produces higher projected EPS.
Wrong EPS does not establish payment capacity. Downturn cash would fall $1 million short of required debt payments.
Issue debt because deductible interest makes borrowing the better choice.
Wrong Tax savings do not eliminate the payment shortfall or outweigh the resulting financial distress risk.
Issue debt because preserving existing owners' voting control should govern the decision.
Wrong Avoiding dilution is secondary to meeting required payments. Ownership preferences do not close the downside cash shortfall.
Key points
- Remember: Debt payments stay due even when operating cash flows fall.
- Test total required payments after financing, not just payments on the new debt.
- Assets with little resale value increase expected distress costs and strengthen the case for limiting debt.
How the exam traps you
- Choose debt because projected EPS is higher. Higher EPS does not supply the cash needed to make required payments.
- Treat deductible interest as enough reason to borrow. Weigh tax savings against the risk and expected cost of financial distress.
- Reject equity solely because it dilutes ownership. Preserving ownership is secondary to the ability to meet required payments.
Question 2
Hint
Focus first on NovaTech’s cash‑flow predictability, collateral availability, and need for future external equity financing, then decide which capital‑structure concern dominates.
Answer C. Given NovaTech's negative near‑term and volatile cash flows, low current taxable income, and limited tangible collateral, the benefits of debt (tax shields, avoiding dilution) are small while bankruptcy and financing risks are high. The firm's need for future equity rounds also makes financial flexibility essential. Therefore the capital‑structure decision should be governed primarily by preserving flexibility and limiting leverage.
Why not A: This is tempting because debt can provide tax shields and delay equity dilution, but NovaTech's low taxable income and lack of collateral mean tax benefits are limited and lenders would face higher default risk, making high leverage imprudent.
Why not B: Leverage can discipline managers in firms with stable excess free cash flow; for a high‑growth, cash‑hungry software firm with negative near‑term cash flow, more debt would likely constrain investment and increase default risk rather than improve governance.
Why not D: Maturity matching and secured financing are prudent in some contexts, but NovaTech has few tangible assets to pledge and near‑term cash shortfalls, so overall leverage and preserving flexibility are the more fundamental concerns.
Question 3
Hint
Match the financing source to both the life of the asset being financed and management's stated goal about ownership control.
Answer D. Issue long-term debt. The project is a long-term asset and management wants permanent financing without diluting voting control, so long-term debt matches the asset's life and preserves existing ownership. The company's stable cash flows and ability to cover fixed charges also support using debt.
Why not A: Tempting because equity avoids mandatory interest and strengthens solvency, but issuing common stock would dilute existing shareholders' voting control, which contradicts management's stated objective.
Why not B: Postponing avoids interest and dilution, but the company must fund the expansion this quarter, so delaying does not meet the stated financing need and therefore is not an appropriate response.
Why not C: Short-term borrowing avoids dilution but creates a maturity mismatch with a long-lived asset and increases refinancing and liquidity risk, making it a weaker choice than long-term financing.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on what debt adds that equity does not: a required fixed payment that must be covered even if results weaken.
Answer A. The governing factor in capital-structure decisions is whether the company can safely support the added fixed charges created by debt. Hart's projected drop in interest coverage from 7.0 to 1.8 indicates significantly reduced debt-servicing capacity and greater financial risk. Tax benefits and dilution concerns are relevant but secondary to ensuring the company can reliably meet interest obligations.
Why not B: This is tempting because interest is tax-deductible and creates an after-tax benefit. However, the tax advantage does not justify taking on debt if the required interest payments could jeopardize the company's ability to operate or remain solvent; capacity to service debt comes first.
Why not C: Avoiding dilution is a common motivation for choosing debt over equity, making this distractor attractive. Still, preservation of ownership is not the primary governing factor when increased leverage would materially raise solvency or bankruptcy risk; the firm must first be able to service the debt safely.
Why not D: Stock-price trends can affect the timing or attractiveness of an equity issuance, which makes this plausibly relevant. Market movements do not determine whether the company can prudently take on permanent fixed obligations; repayment capacity and interest coverage are the more fundamental considerations.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on which financing choice adds permanent capital while improving, not worsening, leverage.
Answer D. Issuing common stock raises permanent capital without adding required interest or principal obligations. By increasing equity, it improves the debt-to-equity ratio and reduces financial leverage, so it best meets the stated goal of lowering financial risk.
Why not A: Repurchases can boost earnings per share and return capital to shareholders, which may be tempting, but they reduce the equity base. That typically increases leverage (worsening the debt-to-equity ratio), the opposite of the board's stated goal.
Why not B: Tempting because 10-year bonds provide long-term funding and may seem 'permanent' and cheaper than equity; however, they increase debt and fixed interest obligations, which raises leverage and works against the objective of reducing financial risk.
Why not C: This provides quick financing but adds short-term debt and refinancing/liquidity risk. It does not increase equity, so it does not strengthen the capital structure or improve the debt-to-equity ratio.
Question 6
Hint
Compute post-transaction interest expense and compare interest coverage under normal vs. downturn EBIT; consider whether expected distress costs outweigh tax and agency benefits.
Answer B. Although additional debt creates a larger tax-deductible interest expense, the projected severe downturn EBIT (~$3 million) would be far below the post-transaction interest expense ($8.5 million), yielding interest coverage well below 1. That large increase in fixed obligations materially raises the likelihood and expected cost of financial distress. Therefore, the primary issue for the board is the substantially higher financial distress risk; tax shields and agency benefits are secondary considerations.
Why not A: Higher debt does increase deductible interest and potential tax savings, which is appealing, but this benefit is outweighed here by the solvency risk: in a severe downturn the company's EBIT would be well below interest obligations, making distress the dominant concern.
Why not C: Leverage can discipline management by reducing free cash flow, which is a valid benefit, but this is a secondary effect. The immediate and larger issue is that the proposed debt raises fixed interest obligations enough to markedly increase insolvency risk in a downturn.
Why not D: Substituting debt can lower WACC when bankruptcy costs are small, but that conclusion assumes limited default risk. Given the firm's earnings volatility and the demonstrated drop in coverage in a downturn, default and distress costs could increase the firm's expected cost of capital instead of lowering it.
Common questions
What matters most when choosing debt or equity financing?
Start with cash available to cover total required debt payments through downturns. Lark's $2 million cannot cover $3 million, so the debt option fails that test.
Why not choose debt if interest is tax-deductible?
The tax benefit does not eliminate required payments. Lark's downside cash shortfall and assets with little resale value make financial distress the more important concern.
Should a company use debt to avoid ownership dilution?
Only if it can safely support the fixed payments. Lark should accept dilution rather than add debt it cannot reliably service.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Capital structure
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.