BAR · Business Analysis · 10 practice questions
Debt vs. Equity: EPS and the EBIT Indifference Point
Debt produces higher EPS above the EBIT-EPS indifference point, but lower EPS below it. Below, compare a debt-financed repurchase with remaining all-equity, then change one fact at a time.
Try one first
Hint
Compare EPS under both capital structures at each EBIT level, or find the EBIT-EPS indifference point first.
Answer C. Before the recap, EPS = EBIT*(1−tax rate)/1,000,000 = $2,400,000*0.75/1,000,000 = $1.80 and $1,800,000*0.75/1,000,000 = $1.35. After issuing $6,000,000 at 10% (interest = $600,000) and reducing shares to 700,000, EPS = (EBIT−600,000)*(1−0.25)/700,000 ≈ $1.93 at $2,400,000 EBIT and ≈ $1.29 at $1,800,000 EBIT. Thus the recap raises EPS when EBIT is high enough but lowers EPS in the downside case, the classic effect of increased financial leverage.
Why not A: This distractor focuses only on the numerator; when EBIT is sufficiently high the reduction in shares can more than offset the interest cost, increasing EPS (as happens at $2.4M EBIT).
Why not B: This is tempting because interest is tax-deductible and share count falls, but the fixed interest charge can outweigh the share-reduction benefit when EBIT is lower; in the $1.8M downside case the levered EPS falls.
Why not D: This is tempting if a candidate confuses operating performance with per-share metrics. Financing changes interest and shares outstanding, which change EPS even when EBIT itself doesn't change.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Northgate has no debt and 1,000,000 common shares. It expects annual EBIT of $3,000,000. Plan D issues $6,000,000 of 10% debt at the year's start and repurchases 300,000 shares. Plan E remains all-equity. The tax rate is 25%. There are no preferred dividends or issuance costs, and financing does not change EBIT.
Answer: Plan D EPS is $2.57; Plan E EPS is $2.25. Indifference EBIT is $2,000,000.
Annual interest is $600,000, and Plan D leaves 700,000 shares. Set up Plan D EPS = (EBIT − $600,000) × 75% ÷ 700,000 and Plan E EPS = EBIT × 75% ÷ 1,000,000. At $3,000,000 EBIT, these produce $2.57 and $2.25. Setting them equal and canceling 75% gives EBIT − $600,000 = 0.7 × EBIT, so indifference EBIT is $2,000,000. Northgate also takes on a fixed annual interest obligation of $600,000, increasing financial risk despite the higher expected EPS. The $1,800,000 EBIT variation illustrates the downside: debt-plan EPS falls below all-equity EPS.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Annual EBIT falls to $1,800,000.
Answer: Plan D EPS is $1.29; Plan E EPS is $1.35. All-equity produces higher EPS.
Debt EPS = $1,200,000 × 75% ÷ 700,000. Equity EPS = $1,800,000 × 75% ÷ 1,000,000. EBIT is below the $2,000,000 indifference point.
Change 2Annual EBIT falls to $2,000,000.
Answer: Both plans produce EPS of $1.50.
Debt EPS = $1,400,000 × 75% ÷ 700,000. Equity EPS = $2,000,000 × 75% ÷ 1,000,000. This is the indifference point.
Change 3The proposed debt’s interest rate rises from 10% to 15%.
Answer: Both plans produce EPS of $2.25 at $3,000,000 EBIT. Indifference EBIT rises to $3,000,000.
Interest rises to $900,000. Debt EPS = $2,100,000 × 75% ÷ 700,000 = $2.25. Higher interest raises the EBIT needed for debt to win.
Key points
- Remember: Debt reduces the share count, but fixed interest means fewer shares do not guarantee higher EPS.
- Use 700,000 shares after Northgate’s repurchase, not the original 1,000,000.
- With no preferred dividends and identical tax rates, the common tax factor cancels when solving for indifference EBIT.
- Northgate’s fixed interest obligation increases financial risk even when its expected EPS rises.
How the exam traps you
- Compare total net income instead of EPS. Divide each plan’s income by its own share count.
- Use the original share count after the repurchase. Subtract the 300,000 repurchased shares before calculating debt-plan EPS.
- Subtract after-tax interest inside an EPS formula that already applies taxes. Subtract pretax interest from EBIT, then multiply by 75%.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer A. Correct. Debt EPS is $1,800,000 × 75% ÷ 700,000; equity EPS is $2,400,000 × 75% ÷ 1,000,000.
Why not B: Wrong. $1.35 uses the original 1,000,000 shares for the debt plan.
Why not C: Wrong. Unchanged EBIT does not make EPS equal; interest and share counts differ.
Why not D: Wrong. $2.57 uses 700,000 shares but ignores the $600,000 interest expense.
Question 2
Answer B. Correct. Debt EPS is $900,000 ÷ 700,000; equity EPS is $1,350,000 ÷ 1,000,000.
Why not A: Wrong. These are the results at $2,400,000 EBIT.
Why not C: Wrong. The debt plan cannot ignore interest and the repurchase.
Why not D: Wrong. Debt EPS ignores interest: $1,800,000 × 75% ÷ 700,000.
Question 3
Answer C. Correct. Both plans produce $1.50 EPS at the $2,000,000 indifference EBIT.
Why not A: Wrong. $1.05 divides debt-plan income by the original share count.
Why not B: Wrong. $2.14 ignores debt interest.
Why not D: Wrong. Both amounts omit income taxes.
Question 4
Answer D. Correct. Debt interest is $900,000, making debt EPS equal to equity EPS at $3,000,000 EBIT.
Why not A: Wrong. $2.57 still uses the original 10% interest rate.
Why not B: Wrong. $1.58 divides debt-plan income by 1,000,000 shares instead of 700,000.
Why not C: Wrong. Both amounts omit income taxes.
Question 2
| Plan | Description |
|---|---|
| Plan D | Issue $12,000,000 of 7% bonds at par |
| Plan C | Issue common stock at $12 per share |
Hint
First find how many new shares would be issued under the stock plan, then compare EPS formulas for the two plans before deciding whether expected EBIT is above or below the indifference point.
Answer A. Under Plan D, annual interest is $840,000, and under Plan C the company would issue 1,000,000 new shares, for a total of 3,000,000 shares outstanding. Setting EPS equal: ((EBIT - 840,000)(1 - 0.25)) / 2,000,000 = (EBIT(1 - 0.25)) / 3,000,000, which simplifies to an indifference EBIT of $2,520,000 because the common tax factor cancels. Since expected EBIT of $3,600,000 is above that level, debt produces higher EPS; at the downside EBIT of $1,800,000, the common-stock plan yields higher EPS and avoids the additional fixed-charge risk.
Why not B: This reflects the common mistake of subtracting after-tax interest (840,000 × (1 − 0.25) = 630,000) when forming the indifference equation; that yields the incorrect 1,890,000 figure. For indifference the corporate tax factor cancels, so the correct indifference point is $2,520,000 and at $1,800,000 common equity gives higher EPS.
Why not C: This overstates the effect of taxes. EPS indifference analysis remains meaningful for a taxable company: debt can increase EPS when EBIT is above the indifference point, so debt is not categorically inferior for EPS reasons.
Why not D: Tax shields and dilution both matter, but they do not neatly cancel here. At expected EBIT, Plan D EPS is $1.035 while Plan C EPS is $0.90, so the plans are not equivalent at the expected EBIT, only at the computed indifference point of $2,520,000 would they be equal.
Question 3
Hint
Do not start with EPS. First test each financing plan against the stated debt-to-total-capital ceiling, then compare EPS only among the plans that survive.
Answer A. Apply the firm's policy first: the all-debt plan would produce post-financing debt of $56M on total capital of $100M (56%), exceeding the 50% ceiling, so it is ineligible. Among the remaining plans compute EPS: under the $12M debt/$8M equity plan interest = 36*8% + 12*9% = $3.96M, EBT = 12.00 - 3.96 = $8.04M, net income = $8.04M*(1-0.25) = $6.03M, shares = 2.2 + (8/20) = 2.6M, EPS ≈ $6.03M/2.6M ≈ $2.32. That EPS exceeds the EPS under Options B and D, so the $12M debt/$8M equity plan is selected.
Why not B: This clearly satisfies the debt ceiling (debt stays at $36M, total capital $100M, debt ratio 36%), but it issues the most shares (1.0M new shares → 3.2M total), keeping interest at $2.88M. That yields EBT = 12.00 - 2.88 = $9.12M, net income = $6.84M, and EPS ≈ $6.84M/3.2M ≈ $2.14, which is lower than the $12M debt/$8M equity plan.
Why not C: Tempting because all-debt financing avoids dilution and can raise EPS via the interest tax shield; if allowed, all-debt financing would yield high EPS (interest = 2.88 + 1.80 = $4.68M, net income ≈ $5.49M, EPS ≈ $5.49/2.2 ≈ $2.50). However, it violates management's explicit leverage policy: post-financing debt-to-total-capital would be 56%, above the 50% limit, so it is not an allowable choice.
Why not D: Also within the debt ceiling (post-debt $44M on $100M total capital = 44%), but it issues more shares than the $12M debt/$8M equity plan while only modestly reducing interest. Interest = 2.88 + 0.72 = $3.60M, EBT = 12.00 - 3.60 = $8.40M, net income = $6.30M, shares = 2.2 + 0.6 = 2.8M, EPS ≈ $6.30M/2.8M ≈ $2.25, which is below the $12M debt/$8M equity plan's EPS.
Question 4
Hint
Set up common EPS under each financing plan first, then compare them. Watch the difference between tax-deductible interest and non-tax-deductible preferred dividends.
Answer B. Under the debt plan interest = 8% of $12,000,000 = $960,000, so net income available to common = (EBIT - 960,000) * 0.75 - 300,000, giving EPS_debt = (0.75EBIT - 1,020,000) / 600,000. Under the equity plan EPS_equity = (0.75EBIT - 300,000) / 1,000,000. Setting the two EPS formulas equal and solving for EBIT yields $2,800,000. Above this EBIT the debt plan produces higher EPS.
Why not A: This stems from mishandling after-tax interest or incorrectly letting taxes 'cancel' while also mishandling preferred dividends; it understates the required EBIT because preferred dividends remain a fixed after-tax deduction.
Why not C: This results from incorrectly treating preferred dividends as tax-deductible (reducing them for taxes). Preferred dividends are paid from after-tax income and should not be tax-adjusted.
Why not D: This appears when interest is treated correctly but preferred dividends are (incorrectly) ignored as irrelevant because they exist under both plans; they still matter because the common-share denominator changes.
Question 5
Hint
Compute Year 1 net income under each alternative (include interest and taxes), then divide by the resulting shares outstanding to compare EPS.
Answer D. Under debt: EBIT = $4,150,000; interest = $60,000, so taxable income = $4,090,000, taxes = $858,900, net income = $3,231,100, and EPS = $3.2311 (3,231,100 / 1,000,000). Under equity: EBIT = $4,150,000, taxes = $871,500, net income = $3,278,500, and EPS = $2.9805 (3,278,500 / 1,100,000). Debt yields the higher Year 1 EPS because interest is tax-deductible and there is no share dilution.
Why not A: This mixes a correct numeric point (debt raises EPS here) with a normative claim about shareholder preference and risk that the stem does not support; the question asks only for the best-supported conclusion about Year 1 EPS.
Why not B: Tempting because total net income is indeed larger under equity ($3,278,500) than under debt ($3,231,100), but EPS uses per-share income; dividing by 1,100,000 shares yields $2.9805, which is lower than the debt EPS of $3.2311.
Why not C: Incorrect: the increase in net income from equity financing does not fully offset the 100,000-share dilution in Year 1; EPS differ (3.2311 with debt vs 2.9805 with equity).
Question 6
Hint
Compute EPS under each financing plan first, then separately ask which plan creates fixed financing obligations.
Answer D. Under the bond plan, interest expense is 8% of $5,000,000 = $400,000, so earnings available to common shareholders are $900,000 - $400,000 = $500,000 and EPS = $500,000 / 1,000,000 = $0.50. Under the stock plan, no interest is paid, so EPS = $900,000 / 1,500,000 = $0.60. Therefore the bond plan yields lower EPS at the stated EBIT and increases financial risk because interest is a fixed obligation.
Why not A: This distractor plays on the idea that debt avoids dilution and can boost EPS, but it is wrong here because the interest burden reduces earnings enough that EPS falls. Also, debt does not lower financial risk; fixed interest payments increase financial (leverage) risk.
Why not B: This is a common trap: higher leverage can increase EPS if EBIT is sufficiently large, but at the given EBIT the interest expense reduces EPS (bond-plan EPS = $0.50 vs. stock-plan EPS = $0.60). The increased financial risk part is correct, but the EPS conclusion is not.
Why not C: While the EPS part is correct in this fact pattern, the claim that financial risk is lower is incorrect. Issuing bonds increases leverage and creates fixed interest payments, which raises financial risk rather than lowering it.
Common questions
How do you calculate the EBIT-EPS indifference point?
Set debt-plan EPS equal to all-equity EPS and solve for EBIT. For Northgate at 10% interest, the equation gives $2,000,000.
Does the tax rate affect the EBIT-EPS indifference point?
Not in Northgate’s comparison. Both plans use the same tax rate and have no preferred dividends, so the common tax factor cancels.
Why can a debt-financed repurchase lower EPS?
The share count falls, but interest reduces earnings available to those shares. At Northgate’s $1,800,000 EBIT, the interest burden outweighs the smaller denominator.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Capital structure
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.