PracticeBARFree practice exam

BAR · Business Analysis · 6 practice questions

Financial Leverage Effects on ROE, EPS, and Risk

Debt-funded buybacks raise financial risk, but higher ROE does not guarantee higher EPS. Sort all-equity Larsen's changes: $20 million equity, 1 million shares, $2 million EBIT, 25% tax; borrow $8 million at 8% to repurchase $40 shares.

The ruleWith operations unchanged, replacing equity with debt increases financial leverage and financial risk, not business risk. ROE and EPS depend on how interest reduces net income relative to the reductions in equity and shares.

Try one first

North Co. plans to issue additional long-term debt and use all of the proceeds to repurchase common stock. Assume the transaction does not change the company's operating assets or operating income, book-value equity remains positive after the repurchase, and taxes and transaction costs are ignored. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Focus on what changes in the financing mix, not whether operating assets change.

Sort it

Increases

After Larsen completes the borrowing and repurchase, the amount, ratio, or risk is higher.

Decreases

After Larsen completes the borrowing and repurchase, the amount or per-share result is lower.

Unchanged

The financing swap alone does not change this operating measure or asset total.

ItemGoes to
ROE: 7.5% to 8.5%IncreasesBefore: $1.5 million ÷ $20 million. After: $1.02 million ÷ $12 million. Equity shrinks proportionately more than net income.
Operating income: $2 millionUnchangedOperations stay the same. Interest reduces income below EBIT, not EBIT itself.
EPS: $1.50 to $1.275DecreasesBefore: $1.5 million ÷ 1 million shares. After: $1.02 million ÷ 800,000 shares.
Debt-to-equity ratio: 0% to 66.7%IncreasesDebt rises to $8 million while equity falls to $12 million. Both changes push the ratio upward.
Common shares outstanding: 1 million to 800,000DecreasesThe $8 million repurchase at $40 per share retires 200,000 shares.
Business riskUnchangedThe financing swap does not change operations or fixed operating costs. Interest creates financial risk instead.
Annual interest expense: $0 to $640,000IncreasesThe new fixed financing charge equals $8 million × 8%.
Book equity: $20 million to $12 millionDecreasesThe repurchase reduces equity by $8 million, leaving a smaller cushion to absorb losses.
Debt as a percentage of debt plus equity: 0% to 40%IncreasesAfter the swap, debt is $8 million and total debt plus equity remains $20 million.
Net income: $1.5 million to $1.02 millionDecreasesBefore: $2 million × 75%. After: ($2 million − $640,000) × 75%. Interest lowers earnings despite the tax savings.
Total assets after the completed transactionUnchangedBorrowing adds $8 million of cash, then the repurchase uses that same $8 million.
Financial risk and EPS sensitivity to operating incomeIncreasesFixed interest leaves less earnings cushion. Fewer shares make each dollar change in after-tax operating income produce a larger EPS change.
Long-term debt: $0 to $8 millionIncreasesLarsen replaces part of its equity financing with borrowing rather than adding operating assets.

Key points

  • Remember: ROE and EPS use different denominators, so this buyback raises ROE while lowering EPS.
  • The repurchase reduces book equity dollar-for-dollar: equity falls 40%, while shares fall only 20%.
  • Borrowing and immediately spending the proceeds on shares leaves total assets unchanged.
  • Fixed interest must be paid even when operating income falls.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating interest as a fixed operating cost. Interest is a financing cost. Financial risk rises; operating leverage and business risk do not change.
  • Assuming fewer shares guarantee higher EPS. Net income falls 32%, more than the 20% decline in shares, so EPS falls.
  • Assuming lower net income forces ROE down. Equity falls 40%, more than the 32% decline in net income, so ROE rises.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Company U (unlevered) and Company L (levered) have identical operations and total assets of $1,000. Company U is financed entirely with equity ($1,000). Company L is financed with $500 of debt and $500 of equity. Both companies expect EBIT of $200 in Year 1. The interest rate on debt is 5% (pre-tax). The corporate tax rate is 21%. All else equal, which statement is correct?
Hint

Compute net income for each firm and then divide by the equity amount; also compare whether EBIT/Assets (20%) is greater than the interest rate (5%) to judge the direction of leverage's effect on ROE.

Question 3

Redwood Co. is currently financed entirely with common equity. Management is considering issuing long-term debt and using the proceeds to repurchase a portion of its common shares. Assume Redwood's total assets and operations would otherwise remain unchanged, and expected operating income is sufficient to cover interest. Which conclusion is best supported about the effect on Redwood's capital structure?
Hint

Focus on how replacing common equity with debt changes fixed financing obligations and the volatility borne by common shareholders.

Question 4

Lake Co. has a relatively low debt-to-equity ratio compared with its industry. Management wants to increase financial leverage without changing total assets and believes the company's return on assets will remain higher than the after-tax cost of additional borrowing. Which action best supports that objective?
Hint

Focus on which transaction replaces equity with debt while leaving the asset base about the same.

Question 5

Pine Co. is deciding how to finance a new distribution system. The system is expected to earn a return greater than Pine's after-tax cost of long-term debt. Pine can either issue debt or issue additional common stock. Assume the project's operating income will be positive and sufficient to cover any related interest expense, and ignore market-price effects and transaction costs. If Pine chooses debt financing instead of issuing common stock, which is the most appropriate conclusion?
Hint

Separate operating effects from financing effects. Ask which type of leverage changes when a company substitutes debt for common stock.

Question 6

Pine Co. currently has a conservative mix of debt and equity. Management is considering issuing long-term debt and using the proceeds to repurchase common stock because interest rates are favorable. Assume the transaction would not change Pine's operations or total assets. In evaluating this proposal, what is the primary capital-structure issue?
Hint

Ask what changes immediately when equity is replaced with debt: the company’s operations, or its fixed financing commitments?

Drill all 113 Capital structure questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can ROE rise while EPS falls after a debt-funded buyback?

Yes. Larsen's ROE rises from 7.5% to 8.5%, while EPS falls from $1.50 to $1.275. Equity shrinks proportionately more than net income, but shares do not.

Does replacing equity with debt increase business risk?

Not when operations remain unchanged. Larsen adds fixed interest, which increases financial risk without changing the risk of its operations.

Why does a debt-funded share repurchase increase EPS sensitivity?

Fixed interest leaves less income for common shareholders, and the repurchase leaves fewer shares. With fewer shares, each dollar change in after-tax operating income produces a larger EPS change.

Practice BAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Capital structure

All Capital structure practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.