BAR · Business Analysis · 6 practice questions
Financial Leverage Effects on ROE, EPS, and Risk
Debt-funded buybacks raise financial risk, but higher ROE does not guarantee higher EPS. Sort all-equity Larsen's changes: $20 million equity, 1 million shares, $2 million EBIT, 25% tax; borrow $8 million at 8% to repurchase $40 shares.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on what changes in the financing mix, not whether operating assets change.
Answer A. Replacing equity with debt increases the proportion of debt in the capital structure, so financial leverage rises. With higher fixed interest expense and less equity cushion, earnings available to common shareholders become more sensitive to changes in operating income.
Why not B: This confuses the asset base with the financing mix. Financial leverage depends on the relative amounts of debt and equity; substituting debt for equity increases leverage even if operating assets do not change.
Why not C: Business risk refers to volatility of operating income from core operations; the stem says operating assets and operating income are unchanged. Adding debt raises financial risk to shareholders through fixed interest obligations, but does not change the company's underlying business risk in this scenario.
Why not D: Equal dollar increases in debt and decreases in equity do not cancel in a ratio: the numerator increases while the denominator decreases, so the debt-to-equity ratio rises (often substantially). That arithmetic shortcut is incorrect.
Sort it
After Larsen completes the borrowing and repurchase, the amount, ratio, or risk is higher.
After Larsen completes the borrowing and repurchase, the amount or per-share result is lower.
The financing swap alone does not change this operating measure or asset total.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| ROE: 7.5% to 8.5% | IncreasesBefore: $1.5 million ÷ $20 million. After: $1.02 million ÷ $12 million. Equity shrinks proportionately more than net income. |
| Operating income: $2 million | UnchangedOperations stay the same. Interest reduces income below EBIT, not EBIT itself. |
| EPS: $1.50 to $1.275 | DecreasesBefore: $1.5 million ÷ 1 million shares. After: $1.02 million ÷ 800,000 shares. |
| Debt-to-equity ratio: 0% to 66.7% | IncreasesDebt rises to $8 million while equity falls to $12 million. Both changes push the ratio upward. |
| Common shares outstanding: 1 million to 800,000 | DecreasesThe $8 million repurchase at $40 per share retires 200,000 shares. |
| Business risk | UnchangedThe financing swap does not change operations or fixed operating costs. Interest creates financial risk instead. |
| Annual interest expense: $0 to $640,000 | IncreasesThe new fixed financing charge equals $8 million × 8%. |
| Book equity: $20 million to $12 million | DecreasesThe repurchase reduces equity by $8 million, leaving a smaller cushion to absorb losses. |
| Debt as a percentage of debt plus equity: 0% to 40% | IncreasesAfter the swap, debt is $8 million and total debt plus equity remains $20 million. |
| Net income: $1.5 million to $1.02 million | DecreasesBefore: $2 million × 75%. After: ($2 million − $640,000) × 75%. Interest lowers earnings despite the tax savings. |
| Total assets after the completed transaction | UnchangedBorrowing adds $8 million of cash, then the repurchase uses that same $8 million. |
| Financial risk and EPS sensitivity to operating income | IncreasesFixed interest leaves less earnings cushion. Fewer shares make each dollar change in after-tax operating income produce a larger EPS change. |
| Long-term debt: $0 to $8 million | IncreasesLarsen replaces part of its equity financing with borrowing rather than adding operating assets. |
Key points
- Remember: ROE and EPS use different denominators, so this buyback raises ROE while lowering EPS.
- The repurchase reduces book equity dollar-for-dollar: equity falls 40%, while shares fall only 20%.
- Borrowing and immediately spending the proceeds on shares leaves total assets unchanged.
- Fixed interest must be paid even when operating income falls.
How the exam traps you
- Treating interest as a fixed operating cost. Interest is a financing cost. Financial risk rises; operating leverage and business risk do not change.
- Assuming fewer shares guarantee higher EPS. Net income falls 32%, more than the 20% decline in shares, so EPS falls.
- Assuming lower net income forces ROE down. Equity falls 40%, more than the 32% decline in net income, so ROE rises.
Question 2
Hint
Compute net income for each firm and then divide by the equity amount; also compare whether EBIT/Assets (20%) is greater than the interest rate (5%) to judge the direction of leverage's effect on ROE.
Answer D. Company U: net income = 200 × (1 − 0.21) = 158, so ROE = 158/1,000 = 15.8%. Company L: interest = 500 × 0.05 = 25, taxable income = 175, net income = 175 × (1 − 0.21) = 138.25, so ROE = 138.25/500 = 27.65%. Leverage raises ROE here because equity is smaller, and it increases financial risk due to fixed interest obligations.
Why not A: The interest tax shield lowers taxes but interest also reduces pre-tax income. In this example the levered firm's after-tax income (138.25) is actually lower than the unlevered firm's (158), so net income is not higher.
Why not B: Plausible trap: interest does reduce net income, but ROE divides net income by equity. With less equity in the capital structure, ROE can increase even when net income falls (as shown numerically).
Why not C: Some mistakenly assume leverage doesn't change ROE or that cheap debt always lowers WACC. Here ROE changes because the equity base changes, and WACC's direction depends on the increased required return on equity; the blanket claims are incorrect.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on how replacing common equity with debt changes fixed financing obligations and the volatility borne by common shareholders.
Answer A. Replacing part of equity with debt increases financial leverage because the company is adding fixed-interest financing to its capital structure. If operating income remains strong, less equity supporting the business can increase return on equity. However, debt also raises financial risk because interest must be paid even when earnings decline.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates may focus on the share repurchase and assume the company somehow has less capital at risk. But the fact pattern says total assets and operations remain unchanged, so the issue is not less capital overall. The key change is the mix of financing, and using more debt increases, not decreases, financial leverage.
Why not C: This choice is attractive if a candidate mixes up business risk and financial risk. Business risk comes from the company's operations and remains tied to the nature of its sales, costs, and industry conditions. Changing from equity to debt financing does not reduce operating uncertainty; it increases financial risk by adding fixed payment obligations.
Why not D: This distractor sounds plausible because fixed costs can seem stabilizing, but the effect is the opposite. Adding fixed interest causes earnings available to common shareholders to swing more as operating income changes. Debt financing generally makes EPS and ROE more sensitive to changes in operating income, not less sensitive.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on which transaction replaces equity with debt while leaving the asset base about the same.
Answer A. Replacing equity with debt increases financial leverage because debt rises while shareholders' equity falls. Using borrowed funds to repurchase stock leaves total assets roughly unchanged (cash rises then falls by the repurchase amount). If ROA exceeds the after-tax cost of the new debt, the transaction will increase return on equity.
Why not B: This reduces debt and increases equity, which decreases financial leverage, the opposite of the stated objective. It also leaves assets roughly unchanged but does not increase leverage.
Why not C: Issuing stock increases equity and holding the cash increases total assets, so leverage (debt relative to equity) falls and the asset base changes, violating the requirement to keep total assets unchanged.
Why not D: Paying down debt reduces leverage because debt falls while equity (retained earnings) remains the same; using cash to reduce liabilities also reduces total assets, contrary to the objective of leaving assets unchanged.
Question 5
Hint
Separate operating effects from financing effects. Ask which type of leverage changes when a company substitutes debt for common stock.
Answer A. Choosing debt instead of issuing additional common stock raises financial leverage by adding fixed financing obligations (interest). If the project returns exceed the after-tax cost of debt, equity holders can earn a higher return (ROE) because debt magnifies returns to equity. However, required interest payments increase financial risk because they must be paid regardless of business performance.
Why not B: This is tempting because both operating and financial leverage involve fixed costs, but operating leverage arises from fixed operating costs (e.g., depreciation, fixed wages). Interest is a financing cost, so substituting debt changes financial leverage, not operating leverage.
Why not C: While debt often has a lower after-tax cost than equity, adding debt creates fixed obligations (interest) that increase financial risk. Lower cost does not eliminate the increased risk from mandatory payments.
Why not D: Financing choice does affect income available to equity holders because interest must be paid before earnings are available to shareholders. If project returns exceed debt cost, ROE can increase under debt financing; if not, ROE can fall.
Question 6
Hint
Ask what changes immediately when equity is replaced with debt: the company’s operations, or its fixed financing commitments?
Answer A. Capital structure concerns the mix of debt and equity financing. Replacing equity with debt increases fixed financing obligations and therefore raises financial leverage, leaving less equity to absorb operating losses or unexpected costs. The core issue is this tradeoff between potentially higher returns and increased financial risk.
Why not B: This distractor overgeneralizes: debt is often cheaper than equity and interest is tax-deductible, but WACC does not automatically decline as leverage increases. Beyond certain leverage levels, higher financial risk raises required returns (especially the cost of equity), which can prevent WACC from falling further.
Why not C: This confuses business risk with financial risk. Business risk comes from operations (sales volatility, cost structure) and is unchanged by this transaction per the fact pattern. Increasing debt changes financing risk, not the firm's underlying business risk.
Why not D: Reducing shares outstanding can affect metrics like EPS but does not eliminate financing risk. Issuing debt adds fixed obligations (interest and principal) that increase pressure on cash flows and can raise the risk of financial distress.
Common questions
Can ROE rise while EPS falls after a debt-funded buyback?
Yes. Larsen's ROE rises from 7.5% to 8.5%, while EPS falls from $1.50 to $1.275. Equity shrinks proportionately more than net income, but shares do not.
Does replacing equity with debt increase business risk?
Not when operations remain unchanged. Larsen adds fixed interest, which increases financial risk without changing the risk of its operations.
Why does a debt-funded share repurchase increase EPS sensitivity?
Fixed interest leaves less income for common shareholders, and the repurchase leaves fewer shares. With fewer shares, each dollar change in after-tax operating income produces a larger EPS change.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Capital structure
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.