PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 6 practice questions

Substantive Sampling: Anomalies and Upper Misstatement Limits

A supported anomaly is excluded from projection, but its uncorrected amount still counts when comparing sampling results with tolerable misstatement. Follow the steps to combine a monetary-unit sampling upper limit with an anomaly and decide whether more testing is needed.

The ruleProject representative misstatements; exclude an anomaly from projection only with a high degree of certainty it is nonrepresentative. Compare the remaining population's statistical upper limit plus the uncorrected anomaly with tolerable misstatement.

Try one first

During a substantive test of details of inventory pricing, an auditor uses sampling to evaluate a population with tolerable misstatement of $120,000. The auditor's evaluation of the sample results yields a projected misstatement of $96,000 and an allowance for sampling risk of $34,000. Assume none of the detected misstatements is considered anomalous, management has not recorded any adjustment, and the auditor is evaluating only this sampled population. Which circumstance has occurred that should trigger additional audit action before the auditor accepts the population at the planned assurance level?
Hint

For substantive sampling, ask what amount the auditor compares to tolerable misstatement at evaluation time, not what amount was used only at planning time.

Step by step

  1. Identify the population and tolerance

    An auditor uses monetary-unit sampling (MUS) to test inventory for overstatement, with tolerable misstatement of $35,000. The sample contains a $12,000 conversion duplicate that management has not corrected.

  2. Support the anomaly conclusion

    Additional procedures establish a high degree of certainty that the $12,000 conversion error is not representative. Identifying its cause alone would not support exclusion from projection.

  3. Project only representative errors

    Project representative misstatements to the inventory population sampled. Exclude the supported $12,000 anomaly from that projection, not from the final evaluation.

  4. Use the statistical upper limit

    Statistical evaluation of the non-anomalous portion produces a $24,000 upper misstatement limit. It already includes the allowance for sampling risk.

  5. Add the uncorrected anomaly

    Keep the uncorrected $12,000 anomaly at its actual amount. The amount to compare is $24,000 + $12,000 = $36,000.

  6. Compare with tolerable misstatement

    The $36,000 total exceeds the $35,000 tolerable misstatement. The sample does not support accepting the inventory population at the planned assurance level.

  7. Obtain more evidence

    Expand the sample or perform alternative substantive procedures before concluding. Exceeding tolerance does not establish that inventory is misstated by exactly $36,000.

Key points

  • Remember: Excluding an anomaly from projection does not exclude its actual amount from the final evaluation.
  • An upper misstatement limit already includes sampling risk; do not add the allowance again.
  • Exceeding tolerable misstatement signals insufficient assurance, not proof that the balance is misstated by the upper-limit amount.

How the exam traps you

  • Compare only the $24,000 upper limit with $35,000. Include the uncorrected $12,000 anomaly: $36,000 exceeds $35,000.
  • Project the conversion duplicate because every sample error must be projected. A supported anomaly is evaluated at its actual amount rather than projected.
  • Treat $36,000 as a confirmed misstatement requiring that exact adjustment. The total includes sampling risk; obtain more evidence before concluding.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

While performing a substantive test of details over Year 2 recorded sales, an auditor selects a nonstatistical sample from a population of 4,800 invoices. In the sample, one invoice overstates revenue by $24,000 because a one-time system restart during a conversion duplicated that invoice. The auditor inspects all invoices created during the restart window, reviews the related system logs, and finds no other duplicates or similar errors. A second sampled invoice is understated by $1,200 because of an ordinary pricing-key error, and nothing indicates that error was isolated. Management does not record either adjustment. Under AU-C 530, which conclusion is most appropriate when evaluating the sample results?
Hint

Focus on the rare anomaly exception in audit sampling and what still happens to an uncorrected anomalous misstatement after it is excluded from projection.

Question 3

An auditor is testing the Year 2 accounts receivable balance (population total $2,000,000) for overstatement using monetary‑unit sampling (MUS) at a 95% confidence level. The auditor set tolerable misstatement at $40,000 and selected a sample of 100 monetary units. Sample results project a misstatement of $25,000, and the 95% upper limit of misstatement (to allow for sampling risk) is $45,000. What is the auditor's most appropriate response?
Hint

Under MUS, compare both the projected misstatement and the upper limit to tolerable misstatement; recall which comparison governs whether sampling risk requires more work.

Question 4

An auditor uses nonstatistical sampling in a test of details of revenue transactions. All invoices over $75,000 were examined 100%; the remaining population of 3,600 invoices totaling $2.1 million was subject to sampling. In a sample from the remaining population, the auditor found ordinary overstatements totaling $9,000 and one additional $42,000 overstatement caused by a one-time system-conversion failure affecting a single identified processing batch. The auditor extended procedures to the entire affected batch, confirmed no other invoices outside that batch were affected, and obtained a high degree of certainty that the $42,000 item is not representative of the remaining population. Assuming the misstatement is uncorrected, what is the correct treatment when evaluating the sample results?
Hint

Separate the general rule for projecting sample misstatements from the narrow exception for a supported anomaly.

Question 5

During a Year 2 audit of accounts receivable, an auditor stratifies the population for a test of details as follows: 12 individually significant customer balances with a total recorded amount of $1,200,000 are examined 100%, and the remaining 1,760 balances with a total recorded amount of $3,600,000 are tested using nonstatistical sampling. In the 100%-examined stratum, one balance is found to be overstated by $84,000. In the sampled stratum, the auditor selects balances with a total recorded amount of $360,000 and determines an audited amount of $342,000. Assume the auditor uses ratio projection for the sampled stratum, does not offset misstatements across strata, and is asking only for the best estimate of total misstatement before any separate allowance for sampling risk. Which amount should the auditor most appropriately use?
Hint

Separate the population into strata before doing any math. Ask which misstatements are projected and which are already known.

Question 6

In a Year 2 audit of accounts receivable, the auditor uses statistical monetary-unit sampling on a stratum of recorded receivables that was not individually tested. For this sampled stratum, tolerable misstatement is $100,000 and expected misstatement was $20,000. The sample produces one detected overstatement, which results in a projected misstatement of $54,000 and an upper misstatement limit of $118,000 at the planned confidence level. The misstatement does not appear to be an isolated anomaly, and no other substantive procedures were performed on this stratum. Management says it will correct only specifically identified errors, not any projection-based amount. What is the auditor's best action?
Hint

In statistical substantive sampling, do not compare only the projected misstatement to tolerable misstatement. Ask what measure reflects the remaining uncertainty from sampling risk.

Drill all 125 Sampling Techniques questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

How are anomalous misstatements treated in audit sampling?

Exclude an anomaly from projection only after additional procedures provide a high degree of certainty it is not representative. The uncorrected $12,000 still enters the final evaluation.

Does the MUS upper misstatement limit include sampling risk?

Yes. The $24,000 upper limit already includes the allowance for sampling risk, so add only the separately evaluated $12,000 anomaly, not another allowance.

When do substantive sampling results require more testing?

Here, the $24,000 upper limit plus the $12,000 anomaly totals $36,000, exceeding $35,000. Expand testing or perform alternative substantive procedures before accepting the population.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sampling Techniques, worked step by step.

AUD Simulation: Attribute Sampling, Deviations and Upper Limit on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Sampling Techniques

All Sampling Techniques practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.