AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 6 practice questions
Substantive Sampling: Anomalies and Upper Misstatement Limits
A supported anomaly is excluded from projection, but its uncorrected amount still counts when comparing sampling results with tolerable misstatement. Follow the steps to combine a monetary-unit sampling upper limit with an anomaly and decide whether more testing is needed.
Try one first
Hint
For substantive sampling, ask what amount the auditor compares to tolerable misstatement at evaluation time, not what amount was used only at planning time.
Answer D. The auditor must consider both the projected misstatement and the allowance for sampling risk when evaluating the sampled population. Here, $96,000 + $34,000 = $130,000, which exceeds the tolerable misstatement of $120,000, so additional procedures (for example, expanding testing or obtaining a management adjustment) are required before accepting the population at the planned assurance level.
Why not A: Tempting because the projected misstatement by itself is below the tolerance, but incorrect: the auditor must also add the allowance for sampling risk to the projected amount when deciding acceptability.
Why not B: Incorrect because expected misstatement is a planning input used to design the sample; the acceptance decision is based on tolerable misstatement and the evaluated sample results (including sampling risk), not solely on the planning expectation.
Why not C: This distractor misapplies the evaluation threshold to raw sample totals. Substantive-sampling results are projected to the population and evaluated together with sampling risk, not judged solely on the unprojected sample dollar totals.
Step by step
- Identify the population and tolerance
An auditor uses monetary-unit sampling (MUS) to test inventory for overstatement, with tolerable misstatement of $35,000. The sample contains a $12,000 conversion duplicate that management has not corrected.
- Support the anomaly conclusion
Additional procedures establish a high degree of certainty that the $12,000 conversion error is not representative. Identifying its cause alone would not support exclusion from projection.
- Project only representative errors
Project representative misstatements to the inventory population sampled. Exclude the supported $12,000 anomaly from that projection, not from the final evaluation.
- Use the statistical upper limit
Statistical evaluation of the non-anomalous portion produces a $24,000 upper misstatement limit. It already includes the allowance for sampling risk.
- Add the uncorrected anomaly
Keep the uncorrected $12,000 anomaly at its actual amount. The amount to compare is $24,000 + $12,000 = $36,000.
- Compare with tolerable misstatement
The $36,000 total exceeds the $35,000 tolerable misstatement. The sample does not support accepting the inventory population at the planned assurance level.
- Obtain more evidence
Expand the sample or perform alternative substantive procedures before concluding. Exceeding tolerance does not establish that inventory is misstated by exactly $36,000.
Key points
- Remember: Excluding an anomaly from projection does not exclude its actual amount from the final evaluation.
- An upper misstatement limit already includes sampling risk; do not add the allowance again.
- Exceeding tolerable misstatement signals insufficient assurance, not proof that the balance is misstated by the upper-limit amount.
How the exam traps you
- Compare only the $24,000 upper limit with $35,000. Include the uncorrected $12,000 anomaly: $36,000 exceeds $35,000.
- Project the conversion duplicate because every sample error must be projected. A supported anomaly is evaluated at its actual amount rather than projected.
- Treat $36,000 as a confirmed misstatement requiring that exact adjustment. The total includes sampling risk; obtain more evidence before concluding.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on the rare anomaly exception in audit sampling and what still happens to an uncorrected anomalous misstatement after it is excluded from projection.
Answer A. AU-C 530 allows an auditor, in rare circumstances, to exclude an identified misstatement from projection when the auditor obtains a high degree of certainty that the misstatement is not representative of the population. The auditor's targeted follow-up procedures here support treating the duplicated invoice as an anomaly. Nonetheless, if management does not correct the duplicate, the auditor must still consider its effect separately when evaluating overall misstatement while projecting nonanomalous errors such as the $1,200 pricing error.
Why not B: This distractor correctly invokes the anomaly idea and additional testing, which makes it tempting. It is wrong because even if an anomaly is excluded from the projection, an uncorrected anomalous misstatement cannot be ignored entirely; the auditor must consider its effect separately in the overall evaluation of misstatements.
Why not C: This option reflects the general rule that sample misstatements are projected, making it plausible. It is incorrect because it ignores the anomaly exception: when an auditor obtains a high degree of certainty that a misstatement is not representative, that particular item need not be projected.
Why not D: This choice overstates the required response. Finding a single system-generated duplicate does not automatically invalidate the sample if the auditor performs appropriate follow-up and isolates the issue to a one-time event; discarding and redrawing the sample is not required here. Whether management records a correction does not determine whether a sampled misstatement is projected to the population.
Question 3
Hint
Under MUS, compare both the projected misstatement and the upper limit to tolerable misstatement; recall which comparison governs whether sampling risk requires more work.
Answer B. Under MUS the auditor must consider sampling risk by comparing the upper limit of misstatement to tolerable misstatement. Although the point projection ($25,000) is below tolerable misstatement, the 95% upper limit ($45,000) exceeds it; therefore the auditor should obtain additional evidence (for example, expand the sample or perform other substantive procedures) before accepting the balance.
Why not A: This is tempting because the sample's point estimate is below tolerable misstatement, but it is incorrect: MUS requires attention to the upper limit (which reflects sampling risk). The upper limit ($45,000) exceeds tolerable misstatement, so accepting based on the point estimate alone would ignore sampling risk.
Why not C: Tempting because the projected misstatement suggests a specific adjustment amount; however, the projection is an estimate subject to sampling risk. Because the upper limit exceeds tolerable misstatement, the auditor should first obtain more persuasive evidence rather than immediately require an adjustment based solely on the projection.
Why not D: This is tempting since the upper limit exceeds tolerable misstatement, indicating a potential material misstatement. However, issuing a modified opinion requires substantive evidence of an actual material misstatement (and consideration of management's response and pervasiveness). The appropriate immediate step is to perform additional procedures to resolve the sampling uncertainty.
Question 4
Hint
Separate the general rule for projecting sample misstatements from the narrow exception for a supported anomaly.
Answer D. Ordinary misstatements identified in a sample should be projected to the population being sampled. However, when the auditor obtains sufficient evidence that a particular misstatement is an anomaly and not representative of the rest of the population, that item need not be projected; it should instead be evaluated separately. The anomaly still must be considered in the auditor's overall evaluation of uncorrected misstatements and their effect on the audit opinion.
Why not A: This answer relies on the default rule that sample misstatements are projected to the population. It is tempting but incorrect here because the auditor obtained a high degree of certainty that the $42,000 error resulted from a one-time conversion failure and is not representative; such an anomaly can be evaluated separately rather than projected.
Why not B: Although the anomaly need not be projected if it is not representative, it is not irrelevant. The auditor must still consider the isolated misstatement's effect on the audit, including whether the uncorrected amount is material or requires disclosure or further action.
Why not C: This distractor confuses stratification/100% testing of large-dollar items with the sampling of the remaining population. Projecting sample misstatements is still required for the sampled portion; testing large items 100% does not eliminate sampling risk in the remainder.
Question 5
Hint
Separate the population into strata before doing any math. Ask which misstatements are projected and which are already known.
Answer C. The sampled stratum has a $18,000 overstatement ($360,000 recorded less $342,000 audited), which is 5% of the sampled recorded amount. Using ratio projection, the best estimate for that stratum is 5% of $3,600,000, or $180,000. The $84,000 misstatement in the 100%-examined stratum is a known misstatement and is added separately rather than projected, yielding a total estimated misstatement of $264,000.
Why not A: This equals the ratio-projected estimate for the sampled stratum only (5% of $3,600,000). It is tempting but incorrect because it ignores the $84,000 known overstatement discovered in the 100%-examined stratum, which must be added separately.
Why not B: This is what you get if you incorrectly apply the 5% misstatement rate to the entire receivables population of $4,800,000 (5% of $4,800,000 = $240,000). That is wrong because the projection applies only to the sampled stratum ($3,600,000); the 100%-examined stratum is not projected.
Why not D: This results from projecting 5% over the entire population (240,000) and then adding the $84,000 known misstatement, which double counts the fully examined stratum. Once a stratum is tested 100%, its misstatements are treated as known and should not be included in the projection base.
Question 6
Hint
In statistical substantive sampling, do not compare only the projected misstatement to tolerable misstatement. Ask what measure reflects the remaining uncertainty from sampling risk.
Answer B. The auditor must consider sampling risk as well as the projected misstatement. The upper misstatement limit of $118,000 exceeds tolerable misstatement of $100,000, so the sample does not provide sufficient assurance to accept the stratum. The auditor should obtain additional evidence (expand the sample or perform alternative substantive procedures) and, if management still refuses to address the potential population misstatement, consider the effect on the audit opinion.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates often stop at the projected misstatement. It is wrong because the projected amount alone ignores sampling risk; the auditor must consider the upper misstatement limit, and here that limit exceeds tolerable misstatement, so acceptance is not supported.
Why not C: This appeals to the notion that only known errors should be adjusted. It is incorrect because auditors do use projected misstatements, along with their upper bounds reflecting sampling risk, to evaluate whether a population is acceptably stated; ignoring projections would defeat the purpose of sampling.
Why not D: This is attractive because the upper misstatement limit exceeds tolerable misstatement. However, the upper limit is a confidence-bound, not a definitive measurement of actual booked misstatement. The auditor should obtain further evidence or request management correction based on substantive findings before compelling recording of the full upper-limit amount.
Common questions
How are anomalous misstatements treated in audit sampling?
Exclude an anomaly from projection only after additional procedures provide a high degree of certainty it is not representative. The uncorrected $12,000 still enters the final evaluation.
Does the MUS upper misstatement limit include sampling risk?
Yes. The $24,000 upper limit already includes the allowance for sampling risk, so add only the separately evaluated $12,000 anomaly, not another allowance.
When do substantive sampling results require more testing?
Here, the $24,000 upper limit plus the $12,000 anomaly totals $36,000, exceeding $35,000. Expand testing or perform alternative substantive procedures before accepting the population.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sampling Techniques, worked step by step.
AUD Simulation: Attribute Sampling, Deviations and Upper Limit on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Sampling Techniques
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.