AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 6 practice questions
Attribute Sampling Sample Size: Deviation Rates and Risk
For tests of controls, sample size rises when tolerable deviation falls, expected deviation rises, or acceptable overreliance risk falls. Below, compare one credit memo approval plan as each input changes.
Try one first
Hint
For tests of controls, ask which factors make the auditor need more assurance or expect more deviations before selecting the sample.
Answer C. In attribute sampling for tests of controls, sample size increases when the auditor wants more assurance, can tolerate fewer deviations, and expects more deviations in the population. A low acceptable risk of assessing control risk too low means the auditor wants greater confidence. A low tolerable deviation rate and a high expected deviation rate also push the required sample size upward.
Why not A: The low tolerable deviation rate would tend to increase sample size, but a high acceptable risk means the auditor is willing to accept less assurance (reducing sample size) and the low expected deviation rate also reduces sample size, so overall this is smaller than option A.
Why not B: While a low acceptable risk increases sample size, a high tolerable deviation rate (the auditor can accept more deviations) and a low expected deviation rate both reduce the needed sample. Together they make this combination require fewer samples than option A.
Why not D: Although a high expected deviation rate increases sample size, both a high acceptable risk and a high tolerable deviation rate act to reduce the required sample. That combination does not produce the largest sample compared with option A.
Numbers to know
| Base plan: tolerable deviationTest supervisor approval of credit memos. Expected deviation is 2%, acceptable risk of assessing control risk too low is 10%, and the large, similar population has 8,000 items. Each change below starts from this base. | 6% |
| Lower tolerable deviationPlanned sample size increases. The auditor accepts fewer deviations, with expected deviation and acceptable risk unchanged. | 6% to 3% |
| Higher tolerable deviationPlanned sample size generally decreases. The auditor can accept more deviations. | 6% to 9% |
| Higher expected deviationPlanned sample size increases. More expected deviations make it harder to support reliance within the unchanged 6% tolerable rate. | 2% to 4% |
| Lower expected deviationPlanned sample size generally decreases. Fewer deviations are expected, while tolerable deviation and acceptable risk remain unchanged. | 2% to 1% |
| Lower acceptable overreliance riskPlanned sample size increases. Lower acceptable risk means the auditor requires greater assurance. | 10% to 5% |
| Smaller population that remains largePopulation size usually has little effect here. This tempting change does not justify a proportionate reduction in the sample. | 8,000 to 6,000 items |
| Expected deviation approaches tolerable deviationWith tolerable deviation still 6%, the gap narrows to 1 percentage point. Sample size increases, and reliance may require an impractically large sample. | 2% to 5% |
Key points
- Remember: Less tolerance, more expected deviations, or less acceptable risk means a larger sample.
- Risk of overreliance is also called risk of assessing control risk too low.
- The rates below are planning assumptions, not universal thresholds or prescribed sample sizes.
How the exam traps you
- Treating a higher tolerable deviation rate as a reason to test more. A higher tolerable rate relaxes the limit and generally reduces the sample.
- Reading lower acceptable risk as evidence that the control is stronger. It means the auditor wants more assurance, so the sample increases.
- Letting population size dominate the plan. For a large, similar population, focus on deviation rates and acceptable overreliance risk.
Question 2
Hint
Ask which change makes the auditor less willing to accept control deviations without expanding testing.
Answer B. A lower tolerable deviation rate means the auditor will accept fewer control deviations before concluding the control is ineffective. To provide that higher level of assurance, the auditor generally needs a larger sample. In attribute sampling, sample size increases when tolerable deviation decreases, when expected deviation increases, or when acceptable sampling risk decreases.
Why not A: Increasing the tolerable deviation rate makes the auditor willing to accept more deviations in the population, so less evidence is needed and the required sample size generally decreases.
Why not C: Accepting a higher risk of assessing control risk too low means the auditor tolerates more sampling risk and therefore needs less evidence; increasing this acceptable risk generally reduces required sample size (lowering it would increase sample size).
Why not D: Expecting fewer deviations in the population (a lower expected deviation rate) reduces the amount of evidence needed, so the sample size would typically decrease rather than increase.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on the main factors that drive attribute sample size: desired assurance, tolerable deviation, and expected deviation.
Answer A. Requiring a greater level of assurance means the auditor accepts less sampling risk and therefore needs more evidence, which increases the attribute sample size. Other key inputs are tolerable deviation (a lower tolerable deviation increases sample size) and expected deviation (a higher expected deviation increases sample size); given the stem's assumption that population size is not the primary driver, greater assurance is the change that most clearly raises sample size.
Why not B: Expected deviation affects sample size directionally: expecting fewer deviations reduces the amount of evidence needed, so sample size tends to decrease. If expected deviation were higher, sample size would increase.
Why not C: This may seem tempting because tolerable deviation is a sampling input, but a higher tolerable deviation means the auditor will accept more deviations and therefore needs less evidence. It is a lower tolerable deviation that would increase the required sample size.
Why not D: When the population is already sufficiently large, further increases in population size have minimal effect on attribute sample size. The stem explicitly tells you not to treat population size as the primary driver.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on which planning change means the auditor wants stronger support from the sample, not just a different population.
Answer B. Reducing the acceptable risk of overreliance means the auditor wants greater assurance (less sampling risk) before relying on the control. To achieve that higher confidence, the planned sample size must increase, so lowering acceptable risk from 10% to 5% triggers a larger sample.
Why not A: Increasing the tolerable deviation rate means the auditor is willing to accept a higher actual deviation in the population; that makes the test less stringent and typically reduces the required sample size, so this change would not increase the sample.
Why not C: If the auditor expects fewer deviations, less evidence is needed to support reliance on the control, so the planned sample size generally decreases rather than increases.
Why not D: For large populations, attribute-sampling sample size is driven mainly by tolerable deviation, expected deviation, and desired confidence; halving a large population usually has minimal effect and would not be the primary trigger to increase sample size.
Question 5
Hint
For tests of controls, ask which change makes the auditor want more assurance from the sample before relying on the control.
Answer C. Decreasing the acceptable risk of overreliance means the auditor requires more assurance that the control is effective; to obtain that higher assurance the auditor generally increases the sample size. In attribute sampling for tests of controls, sample size also increases when expected deviation increases or when tolerable deviation decreases.
Why not A: This is tempting if a student focuses on the word "deviation," but increasing the tolerable deviation rate means the auditor is willing to accept a higher rate of control failures, so less precision is needed and the required sample size generally decreases.
Why not B: If the auditor expects fewer deviations, the control is expected to perform better and fewer sample items are usually needed to achieve the same level of assurance, so sample size generally decreases.
Why not D: The selection method (systematic vs. random) affects how items are chosen but does not, by itself, change the statistical sample size requirement when either method yields a representative sample.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on which factor changes the amount of assurance the auditor wants from the sample, not just the size of the population.
Answer C. Lowering the acceptable risk of assessing control risk too low (ARACR) means the auditor requires more assurance that the control is operating effectively. Requiring more assurance increases the sample size so the auditor can be more confident in the sample result. Therefore, lowering ARACR generally requires a larger sample.
Why not A: If the auditor expects fewer deviations in the population, the anticipated number of exceptions is lower and the required sample size is reduced because less testing is needed to achieve the same level of assurance.
Why not B: Increasing the tolerable deviation rate means the auditor can accept more deviations and still rely on the control; allowing more deviations reduces, not increases, the required sample size.
Why not D: Once the population is reasonably large, increases in population size have little effect on sample size for attribute sampling; sample size is driven mainly by desired assurance and tolerable/expected deviation rates.
Common questions
Does a lower tolerable deviation rate increase sample size?
Yes. Reducing tolerable deviation from 6% to 3% requires a larger planned sample when expected deviation and acceptable risk stay unchanged.
How does risk of assessing control risk too low affect sample size?
Lower acceptable risk requires more assurance and a larger sample. Reducing acceptable risk from 10% to 5% increases planned sample size when other inputs stay unchanged.
What happens when expected deviation is close to tolerable deviation?
At 5% expected deviation and 6% tolerable deviation, only 1 percentage point separates the rates. That leaves little room for sampling risk, so supporting reliance may require an impractically large sample.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sampling Techniques, worked step by step.
AUD Simulation: Attribute Sampling, Deviations and Upper Limit on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Sampling Techniques
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.