PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 7 practice questions

MUS vs. Classical Variables vs. Attribute Sampling

Use attribute sampling for deviation rates, MUS for positive-dollar overstatement testing, and classical variables for two-sided monetary estimates. Below: a side-by-side comparison showing how the objective and receivable balances change the choice.

The ruleUse attribute sampling for control deviation rates and MUS for overstatement testing of recorded positive dollars. Choose classical variables for a two-sided dollar estimate or one monetary sample covering zero and credit balances.

Try one first

An auditor plans substantive testing of Year 2 accounts receivable (A/R). The A/R subsidiary ledger has 12,000 customer accounts totaling $20,000,000; about 150 large accounts represent roughly 60% of the total. Approximately 8% of customer accounts have credit (negative) balances. The auditor's objective is to estimate the total dollar misstatement (net of overstatements and understatements) in the recorded A/R balance and to detect material misstatements in individual accounts. The auditor proposes using monetary-unit sampling (MUS) with a sample of 200 monetary units. What is the primary issue the auditor should consider regarding the proposed use of MUS in this situation?
Hint

Focus on whether the sampling method can select credit/negative balances and whether the auditor's objective requires measuring both overstatements and understatements.

Side by side

Attribute samplingMonetary-unit sampling (MUS/PPS)Classical variables sampling
Receivables questionHow often are required invoice approvals missing?Are recorded receivables overstated?What is the dollar misstatement, considering both directions?
Estimate soughtControl deviation rate.Monetary overstatement.Dollar misstatement, including overstatements and understatements.
What gets sampledInvoices selected for a yes/no approval check.Recorded positive dollars; inspect the related invoice or account.Invoice or account items.
Treatment of large balancesDollar size does not determine selection weight for the approval-rate estimate.Larger recorded balances have a greater chance of selection.May stratify or test large balances separately.
Best-fit error patternMissing approvals measured as a proportion of invoices.Low-frequency overstatements concentrated in large balances.Two-sided errors or many small errors unrelated to item size.
Zero and credit balancesDollar sign does not change the yes/no approval check.Test separately; ordinary positive-dollar MUS does not appropriately cover them.Can include them in the monetary estimate.
Supported conclusionEstimates the population's missing-approval rate, not dollar misstatement.Supports a monetary-overstatement conclusion, not an approval deviation-rate estimate.Estimates population dollar misstatement in either direction.

Key points

  • Remember: Ask 'a rate or dollars?' first; then check whether the dollar population fits MUS.
  • Checking approval is yes/no, but counting exceptions in a dollar-weighted sample does not estimate the invoice deviation rate.
  • Zero or credit balances can be tested separately if MUS is used only for the positive-balance portion.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating exceptions from a MUS sample as an invoice approval deviation rate. Use attribute sampling to estimate the missing-approval rate.
  • Choosing MUS for the entire population just because a few receivables dominate the total. For one two-sided dollar estimate including zero and credit balances, use classical variables.

6 more, each from a different angle

0 of 6 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

As audit manager for Year 1, you plan substantive testing of accounts payable to search for unrecorded liabilities (i.e., understatement of liabilities). The population consists of many small vendor invoices (12,000 items) and several credit memos/zero balances. You want a statistical sampling approach that provides a quantifiable measure of sampling risk and is appropriate for detecting monetary understatement. Which sampling technique is most appropriate?
Hint

Decide first whether the objective is to detect overstatement or understatement and whether the population contains many small, zero, or negative monetary amounts; then pick the sampling method that can estimate dollar misstatements in that context.

Question 3

An audit team is testing the operating effectiveness of a control that requires sales invoices to be authorized before shipment. The auditors selected 75 invoices using a method that gave larger invoices a higher probability of selection (selection probability proportional to dollar amount). Which classification best describes the sampling technique used and its appropriateness for estimating the control's deviation rate?
Hint

Decide whether selection probabilities varied by invoice dollar amount and whether the method is intended to estimate monetary misstatement or an attribute (deviation) rate.

Question 4

In planning a statistical substantive test of details for inventory pricing, an auditor will examine all individually significant line items separately and sample only the remaining 3,600 line items. For that remaining population, all recorded amounts are positive, book values still vary widely, and prior audits indicate that any misstatements tend to be roughly proportional to the recorded amounts rather than a fairly constant dollar amount per item. The auditor wants the sample to support an estimate of total dollar misstatement in either direction for the sampled population, not just overstatement risk. Which sampling technique is most appropriate?
Hint

Do not stop at 'positive balances' or 'wide variation.' Focus on what relationship the stem gives between book amounts and likely audited amounts, and whether the auditor wants an overstatement-focused method or a two-sided dollar estimate.

Question 5

An auditor is designing two samples for Year 1. One sample will be used to determine how often purchase orders lacked the required approval signature. The other sample will be used to estimate the amount of overstatement in inventory pricing. Which factor should primarily govern whether the auditor uses attribute sampling or variables sampling for each test?
Hint

Focus on what the auditor wants the sample to measure, not on factors that mainly change sample size.

Question 6

An auditor is testing the operating effectiveness of a control requiring supervisor approval on cash disbursement vouchers. The auditor wants to estimate the rate of vouchers in the population that are missing the required approval, not the dollar amount of any misstatement. Assuming the auditor wants to use a representative audit sample, which sampling technique is most appropriate?
Hint

Focus on the audit objective: Is the auditor trying to estimate a dollar misstatement or the frequency of a control deviation?

Question 7

An auditor is designing a substantive test of accounts receivable. The population contains a small number of very large customer balances and many small balances. The auditor's primary issue is selecting a sampling approach that gives larger-dollar items a greater chance of being selected without separately stratifying the population. Which sampling technique is most appropriate?
Hint

Focus on whether the sampling unit is the customer account or the individual dollar.

Drill all 125 Sampling Techniques questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What is the difference between attribute sampling and MUS?

Attribute sampling estimates the rate of invoices missing approval. MUS weights selection by recorded dollars and supports conclusions about monetary overstatement.

When should I use classical variables sampling instead of MUS?

Use classical variables when you need a two-sided dollar estimate or one monetary sample covering positive, zero, and credit balances. Skewness alone does not override those needs.

Is MUS appropriate for a highly skewed population?

Yes, when balances are positive and overstatement risk is concentrated in large items. Larger recorded balances receive a greater chance of selection.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sampling Techniques, worked step by step.

AUD Simulation: Attribute Sampling, Deviations and Upper Limit on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Sampling Techniques

All Sampling Techniques practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.