AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 6 practice questions
A/R Sampling: MUS, Large Items, and Zero or Credit Balances
For A/R overstatement testing with few expected misstatements, separate large debits and zero or credit balances before applying MUS. Below, sort Cedar's balances into full examination, MUS, or separate procedures.
Try one first
Hint
Decide which sampling method targets large-dollar overstatements efficiently and then consider how zero or negative balances are treated by that method.
Answer C. Monetary‑unit sampling (MUS/PPS) is efficient for detecting overstatements when misstatements are expected to be rare and concentrated in larger balances because selection probability is proportional to size. However, MUS does not properly include zero or negative balances, so those 200 nonpositive accounts must be handled separately (for example, by 100% inspection or by a classical variables procedure). Stratifying the population and applying MUS only to positive balances preserves efficiency while ensuring all accounts are adequately tested.
Why not A: Tempting because MUS targets large-dollar items where overstatements are likely, but it is incorrect here: MUS cannot properly include zero or negative balances, so applying it to the entire population 'without special handling' would mishandle those 200 accounts and could bias the auditor's conclusions.
Why not B: Classical variables sampling can handle zero and negative balances and gives an unbiased monetary estimate, but when misstatements are expected to be infrequent and concentrated in large items, classical variables sampling is generally less efficient (requiring larger sample sizes) than MUS for detecting overstatement.
Why not D: Control (attribute) sampling assesses the operating effectiveness of controls, not directly the monetary amount of account balance misstatements. Inferring monetary overstatement from control exception rates would not provide direct substantive evidence about A/R balances and is therefore inappropriate as the primary substantive-sampling approach here.
Sort it
Debit balance above Cedar's $40,000 cutoff: examine the entire account balance.
Positive debit balance of $40,000 or less: retain in Cedar's MUS selection frame.
Zero or credit balance: use separate targeted procedures, classical variables sampling, or 100% examination.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Customer A: $50,000 debit balance | 100% examinationThe debit exceeds Cedar's cutoff, so examine it separately rather than leaving its selection to MUS. |
| Customer B: $0 balance | Separate zero/credit testingNo positive monetary units exist to select. A larger MUS sample cannot cover this account. |
| Customer C: $40,000 debit balance | MUS remainderThe cutoff says above $40,000, not $40,000 or more. This positive balance stays in the MUS frame. |
| Customer D: $60,000 credit balance | Separate zero/credit testingIts size does not make it a large debit. The credit balance needs separate procedures. |
| Customer E: $10,000 debit balance | MUS remainderIt is positive and below the cutoff. MUS fits Cedar's overstatement objective and expectation of few misstatements. |
| Customer F: $80,000 debit balance | 100% examinationThis debit exceeds the planning cutoff. Test the whole balance outside the MUS remainder. |
| Customer G: $1,000 credit balance | Separate zero/credit testingA small credit still needs separate testing. Small size does not make it eligible for positive-dollar MUS. |
| Customer H: $1,000 debit balance | MUS remainderTesting the large debits does not cover this smaller balance. Retain it in the positive-dollar selection frame. |
| Customer I: $60,000 debit balance | 100% examinationUnlike the $60,000 credit, this is a debit above the cutoff. Examine it fully. |
| Customer J: $30,000 debit balance | MUS remainderIt is a remaining positive balance below Cedar's cutoff, so it is eligible for MUS selection. |
| Customer K: $40,000 credit balance | Separate zero/credit testingThe debit cutoff does not govern credit balances. Handle this account separately from MUS. |
| Customer L: $100,000 debit balance | 100% examinationThe balance exceeds Cedar's cutoff. Full examination removes it from the population sampled with MUS. |
Key points
- Remember: A large credit balance still belongs outside MUS; the debit cutoff does not apply to credits.
- $40,000 is Cedar's chosen planning cutoff, not a required audit threshold.
- Full examination of large debits does not replace testing the remaining balances.
How the exam traps you
- Increasing the MUS sample to cover zero balances. Zero balances have no positive monetary units to select. Test them separately.
- Sending a large credit balance to the large-debit stratum. The cutoff covers debits only. Test credit balances separately, regardless of their size.
- Testing only debit balances above $40,000. Keep smaller debits in the MUS frame and test zero and credit balances separately.
Question 2
Hint
Consider how creating more homogeneous strata affects within‑stratum variance and how total estimator variance determines sample size for a target precision.
Answer D. Stratification groups similar‑value items so within‑stratum variances are lower than the overall population variance. With appropriate allocation across strata (for example, Neyman allocation), the overall variance of the estimator falls, so achieving a specified precision typically requires a smaller total sample, especially when the population is highly skewed.
Why not A: This confuses the benefits of MUS (which targets large dollar items) with the general statistical benefit of stratification. Stratification reduces within‑stratum variance and can improve efficiency under classical variables sampling as well; MUS is not a prerequisite for stratification to help.
Why not B: This is tempting because drawing separate samples appears to multiply work. It fails because sample‑size requirements are driven by variance and precision, not by the count of strata; reduced within‑stratum variance and efficient allocation usually lower the sum of observations needed. Only inefficient allocation or poorly chosen tiny strata could make the total sample larger.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the idea that stratification is merely organizational. It is partly true only when stratification does not create more homogeneous groups; however, effective stratification does change the variance structure used in sample‑size formulas and therefore typically affects precision and required sample size.
Question 3
Hint
Classify each group separately before labeling the overall approach. Ask whether probability theory is being used and whether any group was selected for a special purpose rather than to support a conclusion about a population.
Answer A. AU-C 530 permits stratification and distinguishes statistical from nonstatistical sampling. Testing all invoices above the threshold is 100% examination (not sampling), the random selection without using probability theory is nonstatistical audit sampling, and the last-business-day invoices inspected solely for cutoff are a targeted non-sampling procedure. Thus the three groups should be classified separately as described in option B.
Why not B: This is tempting because random selection is often associated with statistical sampling. However, statistical sampling requires both random selection and the use of probability theory to measure sampling risk; the stem states probability theory will not be used. Also the 100% and targeted cutoff procedures are not statistical sampling.
Why not C: Dual-purpose sampling typically refers to using the same sample to test controls and to perform substantive procedures. Here the auditor used separate groups for separate objectives (100% large-item testing, a sampled stratum, and a separate cutoff test), so the approach is not dual-purpose sampling.
Why not D: This distractor relies on the incorrect idea that all items must have identical selection probability. AU-C 530 allows stratification and 100% testing of certain strata; the sampled stratum can still be audit sampling even though other items were examined separately or selected for targeted non-sampling procedures.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on how MUS selects items: what is the sampling unit, and what happens when the recorded population includes balances that do not consist of positive monetary units?
Answer C. MUS (PPS) selects positive monetary units with selection probability proportional to recorded amounts; negative (credit) balances are not valid positive sampling units. Netting credits against debits reduces the recorded population amount used to compute sample size, which typically reduces the sample size, and it also means the credit balances are not given appropriate sampling coverage. Therefore the design understates required sample size and leaves credit balances untested.
Why not A: This is tempting because netting might appear to reduce overstatement risk, but the problem is the sampling population definition. Without a right of offset, netting changes the measurement basis, can reduce sample size, and fails to provide appropriate sampling coverage for the credit balances.
Why not B: This distractor uses technical-sounding language, but it is incorrect: negative balances do not receive disproportionate weight. Including credits by netting decreases the population total and thus typically decreases, not increases, the sample size; the real issue is invalid population definition and omitted coverage.
Why not D: A later evaluation does not cure a defective sampling design. If credit balances are not part of the positive-unit population, they had no chance to be selected; that selection-stage defect cannot be fixed solely by post hoc consideration.
Question 5
Hint
Remember that monetary‑unit sampling selects monetary units (dollar amounts) and cannot select zero or negative balances, consider whether the excluded subset could conceal material misstatements and what procedures would address that gap.
Answer C. MUS selects monetary units and cannot select zero or negative balances, so a sizable group of excluded credit memos/negative accounts can create a limiting condition, particularly given management's history of post‑period credits. The auditor must perform additional substantive procedures or use an alternative sampling approach targeted at the excluded zero/negative accounts before relying on the MUS conclusion. After testing that subset, the auditor can properly reassess whether AR is materially misstated.
Why not A: Tempting because the numeric MUS result (upper bound < tolerable) suggests acceptability. Wrong because it ignores that MUS could not select the 160 zero/negative accounts; excluding a potentially significant subset is a limiting condition that must be addressed before accepting the MUS result.
Why not B: Tempting because increasing sample size normally improves precision. Wrong because MUS still cannot select zero or negative balances (they contain no monetary units), so expanding MUS does not test the excluded subset; alternate procedures or sampling are required for those accounts.
Why not D: Tempting because zero/negative balances may appear immaterial by amount. Wrong because materiality is influenced by the number and nature of excluded items and the history of post‑period credits; the excluded accounts could indicate higher risk and therefore must be tested rather than disregarded.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on what the auditor does to the population before choosing the sampled items.
Answer C. This is stratified sampling because the auditor intentionally divides the population into subgroups (strata) based on a relevant characteristic, here, dollar balance, and then tests separately. Auditors frequently isolate large-dollar items (sometimes selecting them with certainty) and sample the remaining stratum. The defining feature is the preselection division into strata before sampling.
Why not A: Systematic sampling involves picking every nth item after a random start. The stem does not describe an every-nth selection procedure; it describes dividing the population by size first, which is stratification rather than systematic selection.
Why not B: Block sampling selects contiguous or adjacent items (for example, a sequence of invoices) rather than grouping by a characteristic like dollar amount. The grouping in the stem is by balance size, not by physical or chronological adjacency, so block sampling is incorrect.
Why not D: Haphazard sampling is an unstructured, nonstatistical selection made without a formal pattern. The auditor's deliberate split by balance size is a structured approach (stratification), not an unplanned haphazard selection.
Common questions
Why use MUS to test accounts receivable for overstatement?
MUS gives larger positive balances higher selection probabilities and is efficient when few misstatements are expected. Those conditions support MUS for Cedar's positive-balance remainder after the large debits are removed.
Can MUS select zero or negative accounts receivable balances?
Standard positive-dollar MUS does not give these balances appropriate selection coverage. Cedar tests them separately using targeted procedures, classical variables sampling, or 100% examination.
Does a $40,000 receivable require 100% examination?
Not under Cedar's cutoff, which applies only above $40,000. A $40,000 debit stays in the MUS remainder; a $40,000 credit receives separate procedures.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sampling Techniques, worked step by step.
AUD Simulation: Attribute Sampling, Deviations and Upper Limit on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Sampling Techniques
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.