PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 6 practice questions

AUD Attribute Sampling: Do Missing Documents Count as Deviations?

A missing selected item is a control deviation when no suitable alternative procedure can establish that the required control operated. Below, compare audit responses to missing approval evidence in a voucher sample.

The ruleIf a selected item cannot be tested and no suitable alternative procedure can establish whether the control operated, count it as a deviation. Validating the transaction does not prove the control operated.

Try one first

During Year 2, an auditor tests a control requiring a purchasing manager's documented approval on each voucher package before payment. The auditor uses a nonstatistical attribute sample of 60 voucher packages to support a planned low assessed level of control risk. The tolerable deviation rate is 6%, and the expected deviation rate is 1%. Of the 60 selected items, 58 packages show the required approval and no other exceptions. Two selected packages cannot be located. The underlying purchases and cash disbursements can be substantiated from other records, but no suitable alternative procedures can determine whether the approval control actually operated for those two items. Management says the missing files resulted from a scanning problem and asks the auditor to replace the two selections with other randomly chosen items. Which response is required?
Hint

Separate evidence that the transaction occurred from evidence that the specific control operated on the selected sample item.

What should you do?

The situation

At Cedar Co., every payment requires documented purchasing manager approval before release. An auditor selects 60 Year 2 voucher packages to test that control. Of these, 58 show timely approval; two cannot be located. Other records substantiate both purchases and payments, but no suitable alternative procedures can establish whether approval occurred. Management blames a scanning problem and requests replacement selections.

  1. Count both missing packages as deviations and reevaluate planned control reliance.

    Best Neither payment validity nor a scanning explanation establishes that the required approval occurred before payment.

  2. Replace the two missing packages with randomly selected packages.

    Wrong Replacement hides untestable original selections instead of accounting for them as deviations.

  3. Exclude the missing packages and evaluate only the 58 available packages.

    Wrong Dropping selected items removes potentially unfavorable evidence and understates the sample's deviations.

  4. Treat the missing packages as compliant because the purchases and payments were substantiated.

    Wrong Valid transactions do not establish that the required approval control operated.

  5. Conclude immediately that the approval control is ineffective.

    Wrong The auditor must evaluate the deviations and remaining sample evidence before deciding whether planned reliance is supported.

Key points

  • Remember: An untestable selected item counts as a deviation when no suitable alternative procedure can establish that the control operated.
  • The tested attribute is approval before payment, not whether the purchase was legitimate.
  • Both missing selections remain in the 60-item sample; they are not removed from the denominator.

How the exam traps you

  • Replace missing packages to preserve the sample size. Account for the original selections. Count them as deviations when suitable alternative procedures cannot establish control operation.
  • Exclude missing packages because they cannot be examined. Keep them in the sample evaluation. Removing them discards potentially unfavorable evidence.
  • Treat valid purchases and payments as proof of approval. Look for evidence that the required approval occurred before payment, not merely that the transaction was valid.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

While testing controls over cash disbursements, an auditor used nonstatistical sampling to select 40 vouchers from the Year 1 population. After completing the test, the auditor discovered that the sampling frame excluded all vouchers processed during the last week of Year 1, so those items had no chance of being selected. All 40 sampled vouchers showed no deviations. Which conclusion is best?
Hint

Ask whether the problem comes from the natural uncertainty of using a sample or from the way the sample was designed and performed.

Question 3

In testing the operating effectiveness of a control that requires credit department approval before shipment, an auditor planned to rely on the control and therefore set a tolerable deviation rate of 5% and an expected deviation rate of 1%. From a representative nonstatistical sample of 75 sales orders, the auditor initially noted three exceptions. After follow-up, two were determined not to be true deviations because electronic approval logs showed timely approval even though the paper files were incomplete. The remaining item involved a shipment that exceeded the customer's credit limit after a sales vice president instructed staff to bypass the approval step; no compensating control was identified. Assuming the sample is otherwise representative, what is the most appropriate consequence of these results?
Hint

Do not evaluate a test-of-controls sample using the deviation percentage alone. Ask whether the one true deviation says something qualitatively important about how the control can fail.

Question 4

An auditor plans a statistical test of controls to rely on a controller-review control that is designed to operate only for manual, nonrecurring journal entries over $25,000. For the planned level of reliance, the auditor determined that 60 relevant items would be needed if the population were properly defined. By mistake, the auditor's data extract included all posted journal entries for Year 2, including automated recurring entries and manual entries of $25,000 or less, and then selected a simple random sample of 75 items from that full extract. Of the 75 items selected, only 42 were journal entries for which the control was designed to operate. None of those 42 lacked the controller's approval. The other 33 selected items were outside the control's scope and, as expected, did not show the controller's approval. Assume no other control is being tested, the control objective is limited to this approval control, and nothing in the sample suggests fraud or management override. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
Hint

Focus first on whether the sampled population matches the control being tested, and only then ask whether the amount of relevant evidence is sufficient.

Question 5

An auditor uses attribute sampling to test a control requiring supervisor approval of credit memos over $10,000. From a sample drawn across Year 2, the auditor finds 2 control deviations, and both occurred in December after the client converted to a new workflow system. The auditor's sampling evaluation indicates that, if the sample is representative of the full year, the computed upper deviation rate would still be below the tolerable deviation rate. Assume December credit memos are significant to year-end assertions, the 2 items are actual control deviations, and no compensating controls or additional December procedures have been tested. Which factor should govern whether the auditor may rely on this sample to support control reliance for the entire year?
Hint

Do not stop at the overall sampled rate. Ask whether the sample result can fairly be extended to the period for which reliance is intended.

Question 6

An auditor is performing a nonstatistical test of controls over cash disbursements by inspecting 60 vouchers for evidence of required supervisor approval. One of the selected vouchers cannot be located, and no alternative evidence is available to determine whether the approval control operated for that item. What is the correct treatment of this sample item?
Hint

Focus on how auditors handle a selected sample item in a test of controls when the planned procedure and any alternative procedures cannot be performed.

Drill all 125 Sampling Techniques questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does a missing voucher count as a control deviation?

Yes, if no suitable alternative procedure can establish that the required approval occurred before payment. Reliable alternative evidence of timely approval could prevent the missing document from being a deviation.

Can an auditor replace a missing sample item?

Not to avoid a deviation when the item is subject to the control and suitable alternative procedures cannot establish that it operated. Keep the original selection in the evaluation.

Does a missing voucher automatically mean the control is ineffective?

No. Count the untestable item as a deviation, then evaluate the sample results to determine whether planned reliance remains supported.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sampling Techniques, worked step by step.

AUD Simulation: Attribute Sampling, Deviations and Upper Limit on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Sampling Techniques

All Sampling Techniques practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.