AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 6 practice questions
AUD Attribute Sampling: Do Missing Documents Count as Deviations?
A missing selected item is a control deviation when no suitable alternative procedure can establish that the required control operated. Below, compare audit responses to missing approval evidence in a voucher sample.
Try one first
Hint
Separate evidence that the transaction occurred from evidence that the specific control operated on the selected sample item.
Answer D. If the auditor cannot perform the planned control test on a selected item and no suitable alternative procedures can provide evidence about whether the control operated, that selected item must be treated as a deviation. The auditor should not replace selected items after selection because replacement would bias the sample; instead, the auditor treats the missing items as deviations and reassesses whether the sample still supports the planned level of reliance or whether additional testing is required.
Why not A: Tempting because replacement preserves sample size, but incorrect: once items are selected they must be accounted for. Replacing selections distorts the sample and masks the effect of missing evidence; if no alternative procedures can determine whether the control operated, the auditor must treat the items as deviations.
Why not B: This confuses substantive evidence about the validity of transactions with evidence that a specific control was applied. Proof that transactions occurred does not demonstrate that the purchasing manager's approval control was performed on the selected items.
Why not C: Attractive because the remaining items are clean, but wrong: excluding selected items ignores the fact that the test of controls requires evidence that the control operated on each selected item. Without that evidence (and without suitable alternative procedures), the items cannot simply be omitted and must be treated as deviations.
What should you do?
The situation
At Cedar Co., every payment requires documented purchasing manager approval before release. An auditor selects 60 Year 2 voucher packages to test that control. Of these, 58 show timely approval; two cannot be located. Other records substantiate both purchases and payments, but no suitable alternative procedures can establish whether approval occurred. Management blames a scanning problem and requests replacement selections.
Count both missing packages as deviations and reevaluate planned control reliance.
Best Neither payment validity nor a scanning explanation establishes that the required approval occurred before payment.
Replace the two missing packages with randomly selected packages.
Wrong Replacement hides untestable original selections instead of accounting for them as deviations.
Exclude the missing packages and evaluate only the 58 available packages.
Wrong Dropping selected items removes potentially unfavorable evidence and understates the sample's deviations.
Treat the missing packages as compliant because the purchases and payments were substantiated.
Wrong Valid transactions do not establish that the required approval control operated.
Conclude immediately that the approval control is ineffective.
Wrong The auditor must evaluate the deviations and remaining sample evidence before deciding whether planned reliance is supported.
Key points
- Remember: An untestable selected item counts as a deviation when no suitable alternative procedure can establish that the control operated.
- The tested attribute is approval before payment, not whether the purchase was legitimate.
- Both missing selections remain in the 60-item sample; they are not removed from the denominator.
How the exam traps you
- Replace missing packages to preserve the sample size. Account for the original selections. Count them as deviations when suitable alternative procedures cannot establish control operation.
- Exclude missing packages because they cannot be examined. Keep them in the sample evaluation. Removing them discards potentially unfavorable evidence.
- Treat valid purchases and payments as proof of approval. Look for evidence that the required approval occurred before payment, not merely that the transaction was valid.
Question 2
Hint
Ask whether the problem comes from the natural uncertainty of using a sample or from the way the sample was designed and performed.
Answer C. Nonsampling risk includes errors in designing or performing the sampling procedure, such as using an incomplete sampling frame. Because vouchers from the last week were excluded, the sample was not drawn from the full population the auditor intended to test. Therefore the sample results cannot reliably support a conclusion about the entire Year 1 population, even though the selected items had no deviations.
Why not A: Tempting because sampling risk involves the chance that a properly selected sample is not representative. However, the core problem here is a flawed sampling frame (a design/performance error), which is categorized as nonsampling risk rather than sampling risk.
Why not B: Tempting because students often focus on sample results. Clean results do not correct a deficient sampling frame; if some population items had no chance of selection, the auditor cannot generalize those clean results to the full population.
Why not D: Tempting because materiality matters, but the problem is population coverage. Excluding a portion of the population without justification undermines the sampling conclusion regardless of whether individual excluded items appear material.
Question 3
Hint
Do not evaluate a test-of-controls sample using the deviation percentage alone. Ask whether the one true deviation says something qualitatively important about how the control can fail.
Answer C. When evaluating a sample for tests of controls, the auditor considers not only the deviation rate but also the nature and cause of deviations. A deliberate bypass of the control by senior personnel is qualitatively more serious than a routine clerical lapse and may undermine reliance on the control for the planned purpose. Therefore, even with only 1 true deviation in 75 items, the auditor may need to increase assessed control risk and modify substantive procedures.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates often anchor on the numerical comparison of observed deviation rate to tolerable deviation rate. It is wrong because tests of controls are not evaluated on rate alone; the nature of the deviation matters. An override that defeats the control's purpose can impair reliance even when the sample deviation rate appears low.
Why not B: This distractor appeals to the idea that more sampling is always the next step when results are uncomfortable. It is wrong because auditing standards do not require automatic sample expansion whenever a deviation is found. If the deviation's nature already indicates a serious weakness in the control's operation, the consequence may be reduced reliance rather than mechanically adding more items.
Why not D: This is tempting because management override does have broader fraud and governance implications. But it is still relevant to whether the control operated effectively for the transactions tested. The override should inform both the sampling evaluation and any additional fraud-related or communication responsibilities.
Question 4
Hint
Focus first on whether the sampled population matches the control being tested, and only then ask whether the amount of relevant evidence is sufficient.
Answer C. Sampling for a test of controls must be based on a population that matches the control's intended scope. Because the auditor's extract was overbroad, only 42 in-scope items were obtained, fewer than the 60 needed for the planned level of reliance. The auditor should redefine the population to the appropriate in-scope entries and obtain additional sample evidence (for example, by redrawing from the correct population or extending the sample) before concluding on operating effectiveness.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates sometimes count anything selected that lacks the control attribute as an exception. It is wrong here because those 33 items were not subject to the control; treating them as deviations would test the wrong population and misstate the control's effectiveness.
Why not B: This is tempting because zero deviations in the observed in-scope items is favorable. However, it is incorrect because the auditor did not obtain the planned amount of in-scope evidence required for the intended level of reliance, so additional work is necessary to support the conclusion.
Why not D: This distractor appeals because it attempts to salvage the existing work. It is incorrect because the auditor drew the sample from the wrong population and obtained fewer in-scope items than planned; simply discarding out-of-scope items does not address the need to test a properly defined population and to obtain the required amount of relevant evidence.
Question 5
Hint
Do not stop at the overall sampled rate. Ask whether the sample result can fairly be extended to the period for which reliance is intended.
Answer A. Comparing the sampled (or upper) deviation rate to tolerable deviation assumes the sample is representative of the period for which reliance is intended. Because both deviations are clustered in December after a workflow conversion and December is significant to year-end assertions, the auditor must first assess whether the control operated consistently during the relevant period before projecting a full-year conclusion.
Why not B: This is tempting because comparing the upper deviation rate to tolerable deviation is the normal sampling-evaluation step. However, that comparison only supports reliance if the sample can legitimately be projected to the period in question; clustered deviations after a system change raise representativeness concerns first.
Why not C: This distractor lures candidates who conflate substantive materiality with control testing. In attribute sampling of controls, the key issue is the rate and pattern of deviations (and their timing), not the dollar size of the sampled items when deciding whether the sample supports control reliance.
Why not D: Expected deviation rate is a planning input that influences sample size. While exceeding expected deviations may indicate problems with the sampling plan, the pivotal issue here is the concentration of deviations in a specific, significant period after a system change, which undermines projecting the sample result to the full year.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on how auditors handle a selected sample item in a test of controls when the planned procedure and any alternative procedures cannot be performed.
Answer A. If the auditor cannot examine a selected item and no alternative procedures are available, the auditor ordinarily treats the missing item as a deviation because there is no evidence the control operated for that item. Treating it as a deviation prevents overstating control effectiveness based on unsupported assumptions when evaluating the sample.
Why not B: This is tempting because unusable items might seem removable, but excluding the item biases the sample by discarding potentially unfavorable evidence; without alternative procedures, the item should be treated as a deviation.
Why not C: Replacing a selected item after discovering evidence is unavailable undermines the integrity of the original sample selection and can mask the fact that the auditor lacks evidence about the originally selected item.
Why not D: A missing document can be important, but one deviation does not automatically prove the control is ineffective; the auditor should evaluate the number and nature of deviations in the entire sample against tolerable deviation criteria before reaching a final conclusion.
Common questions
Does a missing voucher count as a control deviation?
Yes, if no suitable alternative procedure can establish that the required approval occurred before payment. Reliable alternative evidence of timely approval could prevent the missing document from being a deviation.
Can an auditor replace a missing sample item?
Not to avoid a deviation when the item is subject to the control and suitable alternative procedures cannot establish that it operated. Keep the original selection in the evaluation.
Does a missing voucher automatically mean the control is ineffective?
No. Count the untestable item as a deviation, then evaluate the sample results to determine whether planned reliance remains supported.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sampling Techniques, worked step by step.
AUD Simulation: Attribute Sampling, Deviations and Upper Limit on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Sampling Techniques
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.