REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 6 practice questions
Section 1245 Recapture: Ordinary Income vs. Section 1231 Gain
Section 1245 ordinary income equals the lesser of recognized gain or depreciation allowed or allowable. Below: a worked equipment sale and free practice separating ordinary recapture from the remaining Section 1231 gain.
Try one first
Hint
For Section 1245 property sold at a gain, compare total gain with depreciation taken, then classify any excess separately.
Answer D. Section 1245 recaptures as ordinary income the lesser of total gain or depreciation allowed or allowable. The total gain is $50,000, and depreciation claimed was $40,000, so $40,000 is recaptured as ordinary income. The remaining $10,000, representing the amount realized above original cost, is Section 1231 gain.
Why not A: This answer comes from assuming all gain on depreciable personal property is recaptured. Section 1245 recapture is capped at depreciation allowed or allowable, which is $40,000 here, not the full $50,000 gain.
Why not B: This answer comes from ignoring Section 1245 recapture and treating the entire gain under Section 1231. For depreciable personal property, gain is first recharacterized as ordinary income up to prior depreciation.
Why not C: This answer comes from treating only the amount above original cost as ordinary income. That reverses the rule. The excess above original cost is the part that remains Section 1231 after depreciation is recaptured.
Worked example
Cedar Co. sells business equipment held for three years for $100,000 cash. The equipment cost $80,000, and depreciation allowed or allowable totals $30,000. There are no selling costs. Compute Section 1245 ordinary income and the remaining Section 1231 gain before netting.
| 1 | Adjusted basis$80,000 cost − $30,000 depreciation | $50,000 |
| 2 | Total recognized gain$100,000 amount realized − $50,000 adjusted basis | $50,000 |
| 3 | Section 1245 ordinary incomeLesser of $50,000 gain or $30,000 depreciation | $30,000 |
| 4 | Remaining Section 1231 gain$50,000 total gain − $30,000 ordinary recapture | $20,000 |
Cedar recognizes $30,000 of ordinary income under Section 1245 and $20,000 of Section 1231 gain before netting.
Check: Shortcut: $100,000 proceeds − $80,000 original cost = $20,000 of Section 1231 gain; the $30,000 depreciation recovery is ordinary income.
Key points
- Recapture changes the gain's character, not the equipment's adjusted basis.
- Holding equipment more than one year does not protect the depreciation portion from ordinary income treatment.
- Remove ordinary recapture before Section 1231 netting.
How the exam traps you
- Treating the entire $50,000 gain as ordinary income. Recapture cannot exceed the $30,000 of depreciation.
- Treating the entire $50,000 gain as Section 1231 gain. First remove $30,000 of Section 1245 ordinary income.
- Calling the $20,000 above original cost ordinary income. Reverse that split: depreciation is recaptured first; appreciation above original cost is the remaining Section 1231 gain.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the basis used to measure gain from the rule that characterizes that gain.
Answer D. Section 1245 recapture changes the character of recognized gain, generally from Section 1231 gain to ordinary income. It does not increase or decrease the asset's adjusted basis. Rivera should still use the $54,000 adjusted basis for the sale computation.
Why not A: This subtracts the recapture amount from adjusted basis. That treats recapture like an additional basis reduction, but depreciation has already been reflected in adjusted basis.
Why not B: This adds the recapture amount back to adjusted basis. Recapture may convert gain to ordinary income, but it does not restore basis in the asset.
Why not C: This uses the recapture amount as though it were the asset's basis. The recapture amount is a character amount, not the adjusted basis used in computing gain.
Question 3
Hint
For a sold Section 197 intangible, compare total gain with total amortization allowed or allowable.
Answer D. A purchased customer list is a Section 197 intangible, and gain on its sale is subject to Section 1245 recapture to the extent of amortization allowed or allowable. Maple claimed six years of amortization, or $120,000, leaving an adjusted basis of $180,000. The sale produced a $160,000 gain, so ordinary income is the lesser of gain or prior amortization, which is $120,000.
Why not A: This comes from treating the entire gain as ordinary because the asset was amortized. Recapture is limited to prior amortization, so only $120,000 is ordinary income even though total gain is $160,000.
Why not B: This comes from choosing the gain left after recapture instead of the recaptured ordinary portion. The remaining $40,000 is the excess gain after $120,000 of recapture, not the ordinary income amount.
Why not C: This usually comes from counting only five years of amortization. Because the asset was bought on January 1, Year 1 and sold on December 31, Year 6, six full years of amortization were allowed, totaling $120,000.
Question 4
Hint
First determine whether the disposition produced gain or loss, then apply the Section 1231 treatment for that result.
Answer B. The sale produced a loss because the $30,000 amount realized is less than the $50,000 adjusted basis. Section 1245 recapture applies only when there is gain. Because this business asset was held more than one year and there were no other Section 1231 items, the Section 1231 loss is treated as ordinary.
Why not A: This comes from assuming Section 1245 governs every disposition of depreciable personal property. Section 1245 recharacterizes gain as ordinary to the extent of prior depreciation, but it does not recharacterize a loss.
Why not C: This comes from treating the equipment like a capital asset held more than one year. Business equipment used in operations is Section 1231 property, not a capital asset.
Why not D: This comes from thinking all Section 1231 results receive capital treatment. Net Section 1231 gains may receive long-term capital treatment, but net Section 1231 losses are ordinary.
Question 5
Hint
First compute adjusted basis and amount realized. Then determine how much of the gain is recharacterized before assigning the character of any remainder.
Answer C. Adjusted basis = $90,000 − $50,000 = $40,000. Amount realized = $100,000 − $3,000 = $97,000, so total gain = $97,000 − $40,000 = $57,000. Sec. 1245 recaptures ordinary income to the extent of depreciation taken (up to the gain), so $50,000 is ordinary under Sec. 1245 and the remaining $7,000 is Sec. 1231 gain.
Why not A: Tempting because depreciable personal property can generate ordinary recapture, but Sec. 1245 ordinary income is limited to the lesser of depreciation taken and the total gain. Depreciation taken was $50,000, so only $50,000 can be ordinary.
Why not B: This reflects forgetting selling commissions: using $100,000 without subtracting the $3,000 selling expense gives a $60,000 total gain (leaving $10,000 after $50,000 recapture). Selling commissions reduce amount realized, so the actual excess over recapture is $7,000.
Why not D: Although business property held more than one year can produce Sec. 1231 gain, Sec. 1245 requires recapture of depreciation as ordinary income first. That makes $50,000 ordinary rather than all $57,000 Sec. 1231.
Question 6
Hint
For Section 1245 property, compute total gain first, then separate depreciation recapture from any remaining gain.
Answer A. The equipment is depreciable property used in a trade or business and was held more than one year, so any gain not recaptured can be section 1231 gain. Delta's adjusted basis is $50,000, producing total gain of $70,000. Section 1245 recaptures depreciation as ordinary income up to $40,000, leaving $30,000 treated as section 1231 gain.
Why not B: This treats all gain on Section 1245 property as ordinary income. Section 1245 recaptures gain as ordinary only to the extent of depreciation taken, so gain above that amount can be section 1231 gain.
Why not C: This treats the entire realized gain as section 1231 gain. The portion equal to prior depreciation is recaptured as ordinary income before any excess is treated as section 1231 gain.
Why not D: This selects the accumulated depreciation amount. That amount is ordinary income under Section 1245 recapture, not the remaining section 1231 gain.
Common questions
How do you calculate Section 1245 depreciation recapture?
Subtract adjusted basis from the amount realized. Ordinary recapture is the lesser of that gain or depreciation allowed or allowable: here, $30,000.
Is gain above original cost Section 1231 gain?
For this business equipment held more than one year, yes. The $20,000 above original cost remains Section 1231 gain after depreciation recapture, before Section 1231 netting.
Does Section 1245 recapture change adjusted basis?
No. Depreciation already reduced basis to $50,000. Recapture splits the $50,000 gain by character without changing basis again.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Section 1231, 1245 and 1250 property, worked step by step.
Section 1231 Netting and Depreciation Recapture | CPA REG TBS on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Section 1231, 1245 and 1250 property
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.