REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 7 practice questions
Section 1231 vs. 1245 vs. 1250: Classify Business Assets
An asset can be Section 1231 property and also Section 1245 or 1250 property. Below, sort North's assets by use, holding period, and property type to see how the classifications overlap.
Try one first
Hint
Ask two questions: is the asset business-use property held more than 1 year, and is it depreciable?
Answer C. Land used in a trade or business and held more than 1 year is Section 1231 property. But land is not Section 1245 property and is not Section 1250 property because those categories apply to depreciable property, and land is not depreciable.
Why not A: This choice comes from treating all business-use property as Section 1245 property. Section 1245 covers depreciable personal property and certain other depreciable property, not nondepreciable land.
Why not B: This choice comes from assuming all real property used in a business is Section 1250 property. Section 1250 is limited to depreciable real property, so unimproved land does not fit.
Why not D: This choice comes from assuming land is always a capital asset. Property used in a trade or business is excluded from capital asset treatment and can be Section 1231 property when held more than 1 year.
Sort it
Business-use depreciable personal property or amortizable Section 197 intangibles held more than one year.
Business-use depreciable real property, other than Section 1245 property, held more than one year.
Business-use nondepreciable land held more than one year.
Fails the business-use or holding-period test, or is inventory; Section 1245 or 1250 may still apply.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| North's depreciable packaging machine used in its business and held three years. | Section 1231 and Section 1245Business use and the holding period establish Section 1231 eligibility. Depreciable personal property also falls under Section 1245. |
| North's unimproved land used as a business storage yard and held four years. | Section 1231 onlyLong-held business land qualifies under Section 1231. It is not depreciable, so neither Section 1245 nor Section 1250 applies. |
| North's depreciable warehouse building used in its business and held three years. | Section 1231 and Section 1250The building meets Section 1231's business-use and holding-period tests. Its depreciable real property classification also places it under Section 1250. |
| North's depreciable delivery truck used in its business and held 10 months. | Outside Section 1231The truck remains Section 1245 property, but 10 months does not satisfy Section 1231's holding-period test. |
| North's purchased goodwill, amortized under Section 197, used in its business, and held three years. | Section 1231 and Section 1245Amortizable Section 197 goodwill is Section 1245 property. Business use and the three-year holding period also qualify it under Section 1231. |
| North's vacant land held solely for investment appreciation for four years. | Outside Section 1231Investment land is a capital asset, not business-use property. A long holding period alone does not establish Section 1231 eligibility. |
| North's depreciable asphalt parking lot used in its business and held three years. Ignore Section 179 and bonus depreciation. | Section 1231 and Section 1250Unlike underlying land, the parking lot is depreciable real property. Its business use and holding period also qualify it under Section 1231. |
| North's finished cabinets held primarily for sale to customers for three years. | Outside Section 1231Inventory is specifically excluded from Section 1231, even when held in a business for more than one year. |
| North's truck used solely for personal family errands and held three years. | Outside Section 1231Personal use fails the business-use test. The truck is also not depreciable Section 1245 property in North's hands. |
| North's depreciable warehouse building used in its business and held 10 months. | Outside Section 1231The building remains Section 1250 property, but its short holding period prevents Section 1231 classification. |
Key points
- Remember: Section 1231 eligibility and Section 1245 or 1250 classification are separate tests, so an asset can satisfy both.
- Investment property fails the business-use test. Inventory held primarily for sale to customers is specifically excluded from Section 1231.
- Business land can qualify under Section 1231 without being depreciable, so it falls outside Sections 1245 and 1250.
How the exam traps you
- Treating all business real estate as Section 1250 property. Separate nondepreciable land from depreciable real property. North's business land is Section 1231 property only.
- Calling every business delivery truck Section 1231 property, regardless of holding period. North's delivery truck held 10 months remains Section 1245 property but fails the Section 1231 holding-period test.
- Treating Section 1245 or 1250 classification as a reason to exclude an asset from Section 1231. North's long-held business machine and warehouse each carry both classifications.
Question 2
Hint
Ask whether the asset was used in the business or held primarily for sale to customers.
Answer A. Inventory is excluded from section 1231 even when the business held it longer than one year. Property held primarily for sale to customers produces ordinary gain or loss instead. The other assets are business-use property that can fall within section 1231.
Why not B: A candidate may assume frequently replaced vehicles produce ordinary gain automatically. Delivery vans used in the business are depreciable business property, so they can receive section 1231 treatment if held more than one year.
Why not C: A common mistake is to treat equipment only as section 1245 property and therefore outside section 1231. Depreciable personal property used in the business and held more than one year is still section 1231 property, with any section 1245 recapture handled separately.
Why not D: A candidate may think a building belongs only under section 1250. Real property used in the business and held more than one year is section 1231 property, and section 1250 only governs the recapture aspect.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on the nature of the improvement itself, not on who owns the underlying building or lease.
Answer B. Leasehold improvements that become part of a building, such as permanent walls, ceilings, and built-in plumbing, are generally section 1250 property. The tenant does not need to own the entire building for the improvement itself to be depreciable real property.
Why not A: This answer comes from treating all tenant-installed assets as personal property. It fails because permanent build-outs that become part of a building are real property, so they are classified under section 1250 rather than section 1245.
Why not C: This answer assumes ownership of the whole building is required for section 1250 treatment. It fails because a taxpayer can own and depreciate leasehold improvements separately, and those improvements can still be section 1250 property.
Why not D: This answer confuses a physical improvement with a lease-related intangible. It fails because the build-out is a tangible structural improvement, not an amortizable section 197 intangible.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on whether the installed piping serves the building generally or directly serves production equipment.
Answer A. Section 1250 property is depreciable real property that is not Section 1245 property. Fire-suppression piping serving the building generally is a structural component of the building, so it remains Section 1250 property. Piping dedicated to production tanks, assembly tools, or mixing equipment is treated as Section 1245 property because it serves equipment or manufacturing processes.
Why not B: Compressed-air piping can look like a permanent part of the facility. It fails because it serves assembly tools directly, so it is Section 1245 property.
Why not C: Chemical-feed piping can be mistaken for real property because it is installed in the facility. It fails because piping serving mixing equipment is production-related Section 1245 property.
Why not D: Process-water piping can be mistaken for ordinary plumbing. It fails because the facts tie the piping to production tanks, making it Section 1245 property rather than a building structural component.
Question 5
Hint
Identify whether the holder has tangible personal property of a character subject to depreciation.
Answer A. A pickup truck used in a trade or business is tangible personal property subject to depreciation. That makes it Section 1245 property to the holder. The classification depends on the holder's use, not just the truck's physical form.
Why not B: Treating dealer inventory as business property produces this answer. Inventory held primarily for sale to customers is not depreciable property in the holder's hands, so it is not Section 1245 property.
Why not C: Focusing only on the truck's tangible personal form produces this answer. Personal-use property is not property of a character subject to depreciation, so it is not Section 1245 property.
Why not D: Treating any tangible personal investment asset as Section 1245 property produces this answer. Property stored solely for appreciation is not depreciable property in the holder's hands.
Question 6
Hint
For livestock used in the business, start with the purpose, then apply the species-specific holding period.
Answer D. Livestock held for breeding or dairy purposes can be Section 1231 property if held long enough. Cattle and horses must be held 24 months or more, while other livestock must be held 12 months or more. The dairy cow qualifies because it is cattle used in the business and held 26 months.
Why not A: This answer comes from using the correct business purpose but stopping one month short on the holding period. Other livestock must be held at least 12 months.
Why not B: This answer comes from treating any breeding animal as automatically qualifying. Sheep are other livestock, so the animal must be held at least 12 months.
Why not C: This answer comes from recognizing the breeding purpose but missing the longer holding period for cattle. A bull is cattle, so it must be held at least 24 months to be Section 1231 property.
Question 7
Hint
Check both how the real property is used and whether it was held longer than one year.
Answer A. Section 1231 includes real property used in a trade or business and held for more than one year. A warehouse used in the taxpayer's business for 18 months meets both requirements. The other properties fail because they are investment property, inventory, or held too briefly.
Why not B: This choice comes from assuming all long-held real estate qualifies. Land held for investment is a capital asset, not property used in a trade or business, so it is not Section 1231 property.
Why not C: This choice comes from focusing only on business use. Section 1231 requires the property to be held for more than one year, and 10 months is not enough.
Why not D: This choice comes from focusing only on the long holding period. Property held primarily for sale to customers is inventory, which is excluded from Section 1231.
Common questions
Can property be both Section 1231 and Section 1245?
Yes. North's depreciable business machine held three years is Section 1231 property and Section 1245 property. These labels answer separate classification questions.
Is business land Section 1231 or Section 1250 property?
North's business land held four years is Section 1231 property, but not Section 1250 property. Land is not depreciable.
Is a business truck held less than one year Section 1245 property?
Yes. North's depreciable delivery truck held 10 months is Section 1245 property. It is not Section 1231 property because that classification requires a holding period exceeding one year.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Section 1231, 1245 and 1250 property, worked step by step.
Section 1231 Netting and Depreciation Recapture | CPA REG TBS on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Section 1231, 1245 and 1250 property
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.