REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 6 practice questions
Section 1231 Netting: Casualty and Theft Ordering
Net qualifying casualty and theft items first; a net loss stays outside Section 1231 netting, while a net gain joins it. Below, follow North's results from separate casualty netting to final tax character.
Try one first
Hint
Net involuntary conversion items together before combining the remaining business sale and exchange results.
Answer D. Casualty and theft items are netted first. The $8,000 casualty gain and $23,000 casualty loss produce a $15,000 net casualty loss, which is ordinary. The sale and exchange items are then netted separately, producing a $25,000 net Section 1231 gain from the $31,000 gain and $6,000 loss.
Why not A: This comes from netting all four items together in one bucket. That fails because casualty gains and losses must be netted first, and a net casualty loss is treated as ordinary rather than included in the Section 1231 pool.
Why not B: This correctly nets the sale and exchange items but ignores the casualty gain when computing the ordinary loss. The $8,000 casualty gain reduces the $23,000 casualty loss, so only $15,000 is ordinary.
Why not C: This treats the casualty gain as Section 1231 and the casualty loss as fully ordinary without first offsetting them. The rule requires netting the casualty items against each other first, leaving only a $15,000 ordinary loss.
Step by step
- Set the assumptions
North's assets are used in its business and held more than one year. All amounts are after any required depreciation recapture, and North has no nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses from the prior five years.
- Net casualty and theft items first
North has an $8,000 casualty gain on warehouse equipment and a $23,000 casualty loss on a different machine. The casualty net is $8,000 minus $23,000, or a $15,000 loss.
- Keep the casualty loss outside
The $15,000 net casualty loss is ordinary and stays outside Section 1231 netting. A net casualty/theft gain would instead join the other Section 1231 items.
- Net the remaining sale items
North also has a $31,000 gain on business land and a $6,000 loss on business equipment. These sale items produce a $25,000 net Section 1231 gain.
- Report the two results separately
North reports a $15,000 ordinary casualty loss and a separate $25,000 net Section 1231 gain, treated as long-term capital gain under the stated assumptions.
Key points
- Remember: A net casualty/theft loss stays out of the Section 1231 pool, even when sale gains exceed it.
- The $8,000 casualty gain reduces the ordinary casualty loss; it does not increase the separate sale gain.
- A positive total across all assets does not eliminate the separate ordinary casualty loss.
How the exam traps you
- Combine all four amounts into one $10,000 Section 1231 gain. Net casualties first: keep the $15,000 ordinary loss separate from the $25,000 Section 1231 gain.
- Report the full $23,000 casualty loss as ordinary. Offset the $8,000 casualty gain first, leaving a $15,000 ordinary casualty loss.
- Add the $8,000 casualty gain to sales for a $33,000 Section 1231 gain. Keep both casualty amounts together for the initial casualty netting test.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on the character assigned after all Sec. 1231 items are netted and no lookback recapture applies.
Answer B. With no nonrecaptured Sec. 1231 losses, a final net Sec. 1231 gain is treated as long-term capital gain. A final net Sec. 1231 loss is treated as an ordinary loss. That mismatch favors taxpayers because gains may receive capital gain treatment, while losses avoid capital loss limitations.
Why not A: This applies ordinary treatment symmetrically. Sec. 1231 does not make a final net gain ordinary when no lookback recapture applies; the gain receives long-term capital treatment.
Why not C: This applies capital treatment symmetrically. Sec. 1231 does not make a final net loss a capital loss; the final net loss receives ordinary treatment.
Why not D: This reverses the Sec. 1231 character rule. Net gains are not ordinary merely because the assets were used in a business, and final net losses are not capital losses.
Question 3
Hint
First determine the year's net Section 1231 result, then apply the rule for a net gain when no prior-year loss recapture remains.
Answer D. A net Section 1231 gain is treated as long-term capital gain when there are no nonrecaptured net Section 1231 losses to recapture. Because the only Section 1231 item is a gain, the net result is a gain, so the full $48,000 receives long-term capital gain treatment.
Why not A: This comes from remembering that some Section 1231 results are ordinary after netting, but applying that to the wrong direction. Only a net Section 1231 loss becomes ordinary loss, and these facts produce a net gain.
Why not B: This comes from ignoring the Section 1231 rule or using the wrong holding-period result. The land was held more than one year, and a net Section 1231 gain is treated as long-term, not short-term, capital gain.
Why not C: This comes from treating all gains on business assets as ordinary or confusing Section 1231 with recapture rules. Here the asset is land, and the facts rule out prior-year Section 1231 loss recapture, so the net gain is not ordinary income.
Question 4
Hint
Compute adjusted basis first, then ask whether the sale produced gain or loss before considering any Section 1250 layer.
Answer C. The warehouse's adjusted basis is $450,000, so selling it for $410,000 creates a $40,000 loss. Because there is no gain, neither Section 1250 recapture nor unrecaptured Section 1250 gain applies. A depreciable building used in a trade or business and held more than one year is Section 1231 property, so the loss is a Section 1231 loss.
Why not A: This comes from assuming prior depreciation automatically creates recapture. Section 1250 recapture applies only when there is recognized gain, and this sale produced a loss instead.
Why not B: This treats the warehouse like an investment capital asset. Because it was used in the business and held more than one year, it is Section 1231 property, so its loss is not a capital loss.
Why not D: This mistake focuses on the prior depreciation but skips the gain requirement. Unrecaptured Section 1250 gain is a portion of gain on the sale of depreciated real property, not a rule that applies when the property is sold at a loss.
Question 5
Hint
Net every current-year Section 1231 gain and loss first, then determine how the net result is characterized.
Answer D. Section 1231 gains and losses are first netted for the year. Here, the $25,000 gain offsets part of the combined $75,000 losses, producing a $50,000 net Section 1231 loss. A net Section 1231 loss is treated as an ordinary loss, so ordinary income decreases by $50,000.
Why not A: This comes from adding the two losses and ignoring the $25,000 gain. The gain reduces the net loss before determining the effect on ordinary income.
Why not B: This results from netting the $60,000 loss against the $25,000 gain and ignoring the additional $15,000 loss. All Section 1231 items for the year must be included in the netting process.
Why not C: This comes from using only the gain amount. Section 1231 requires netting all current-year Section 1231 gains and losses, not isolating the gain.
Question 6
Hint
Separate ordinary recapture first, then determine the net Section 1231 result before applying any prior-loss lookback.
Answer D. Depreciation recapture is determined first and is treated as ordinary income before any Section 1231 netting. The remaining Section 1231 gains and losses are then netted. If that net result is a gain, the Section 1231 lookback rule recharacterizes it as ordinary income to the extent of prior nonrecaptured Section 1231 losses, and only the balance goes to Schedule D as long-term capital gain.
Why not A: This answer assumes the lookback rule applies before knowing the current year's net Section 1231 result. The lookback rule can be applied only after the remaining Section 1231 gains and losses have been netted.
Why not B: This answer treats Schedule D as the immediate destination after Section 1231 netting. Any recapture and any Section 1231 lookback recharacterization must be handled before any remaining gain is reported as long-term capital gain.
Why not C: This answer comes from treating recapture as part of the later netting process. Recapture does not wait until after Section 1231 netting; it is pulled out first as ordinary income on the affected assets.
Common questions
Do casualty and theft losses enter Section 1231 netting?
Net qualifying casualty and theft gains and losses first. If that produces a net loss, it is ordinary and stays outside Section 1231 netting.
What happens to a net casualty or theft gain under Section 1231?
A net casualty/theft gain joins the other Section 1231 gains and losses. Unlike a net casualty/theft loss, it does not stay in a separate ordinary bucket.
Can an ordinary casualty loss and a Section 1231 gain occur in the same year?
Yes. North has a $15,000 ordinary casualty loss and a separate $25,000 net Section 1231 gain because the casualty loss stays outside the sale netting.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Section 1231, 1245 and 1250 property, worked step by step.
Section 1231 Netting and Depreciation Recapture | CPA REG TBS on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Section 1231, 1245 and 1250 property
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.