REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 6 practice questions
Section 1245 Installment Sale: Recapture and Gross Profit
Section 1245 depreciation recapture is ordinary income in the sale year, even if no cash is received. Below, follow an equipment sale from total gain through the gross profit percentage and each year's recognized gain.
Try one first
Hint
First compute total gain and total depreciation taken. Then determine which portion an installment sale cannot defer.
Answer C. Total gain is $150,000, calculated as $260,000 selling price less $110,000 adjusted basis. Section 1245 recapture equals the lesser of depreciation taken, $90,000, or total gain, $150,000. That recapture is recognized in full in the year of sale, even though the rest of the gain may be reported under the installment method.
Why not A: This comes from spreading the entire $150,000 gain over the four equal payments. That fails because Section 1245 recapture is not deferred under the installment method and must be recognized immediately.
Why not B: This treats the entire gain as depreciation recapture. That fails because Section 1245 recapture is limited to the depreciation taken, which is $90,000; the remaining $60,000 is not recapture.
Why not D: This treats the first year's cash collection as the maximum gain recognized in Year 1. That fails because depreciation recapture is recognized in full in the year of sale, even if it exceeds the cash collected that year.
Step by step
- Read the sale terms
N Corp sells Section 1245 equipment for $100,000, receiving $40,000 in Year 1 and $60,000 in Year 2. The equipment cost $40,000 and has $20,000 of depreciation and a $20,000 adjusted basis; assume installment reporting, no debt or selling expenses, and ignore interest.
- Calculate total gain
Total gain is $100,000 selling price minus $20,000 adjusted basis, or $80,000. This is the gain to split between recapture and installment reporting.
- Recognize recapture immediately
Section 1245 recapture is the lesser of $80,000 total gain or $20,000 depreciation, so recognize $20,000 as ordinary income in Year 1. This amount is recognized even if no cash is collected.
- Calculate the gross profit percentage
Installment-sale basis is $20,000 adjusted basis plus $20,000 recapture recognized upfront, or $40,000; installment gross profit is $100,000 selling price minus $40,000 installment-sale basis, or $60,000. Divide $60,000 by the $100,000 contract price to get 60%.
- Calculate Year 1 recognized gain
Year 1 installment gain is $40,000 principal collected × 60%, or $24,000. Add $20,000 recapture for total Year 1 recognized gain of $44,000.
- Calculate Year 2 recognized gain
Year 2 installment gain is $60,000 principal collected × 60%, or $36,000, with no additional depreciation recapture.
Key points
- Remember: Split the gain before applying the payment percentage; recapture never waits for cash.
- The $40,000 installment-sale basis includes both adjusted basis and recapture already recognized.
- Year 1 recognized gain can exceed the cash received.
How the exam traps you
- Applying the installment percentage to the entire $80,000 gain. Remove the $20,000 recapture first. Only $60,000 enters installment gross profit.
- Limiting Year 1 recognized gain to the $40,000 payment. Recognize $20,000 recapture plus $24,000 installment gain, totaling $44,000.
Question 2
Hint
For section 1245, first ask whether a gift causes current recapture or shifts that potential to the transferee.
Answer A. A gift is an exception to current section 1245 recapture. The donor does not recognize ordinary income when the property is transferred by gift. Instead, the donee preserves the donor's section 1245 recapture potential for a later taxable disposition.
Why not B: This treats the gift like a basis step-up event. A gift of section 1245 property does not erase prior depreciation recapture potential or give the donee an FMV basis for this purpose.
Why not C: This treats the gift like a taxable sale with recognized gain. Because the donor does not recognize gain on the gift, there is no current section 1245 ordinary income to recapture.
Why not D: This assumes every disposition triggers immediate section 1245 recapture. Gifts are specifically excluded from current recapture, even though the donee generally carries over the recapture potential.
Question 3
Hint
Compute the usual Section 1245 outcome first, then consider whether selling depreciable property to a related person changes any remaining gain.
Answer B. The machinery is Section 1245 property, and the buyer is Lena's wholly owned corporation, so this is a related-party sale of depreciable property. Section 1239 causes the entire recognized gain to be ordinary income, not just the amount that would otherwise be recaptured under Section 1245. Lena therefore reports the full $90,000 as ordinary income.
Why not A: This comes from applying the normal Section 1245 recapture rule and stopping there. That would be correct for an unrelated-party sale, but the related-party rule converts the remaining $30,000 to ordinary income too.
Why not C: This ignores depreciation recapture and the related-party ordinary-income rule. A gain on business machinery is not entirely Section 1231 gain when depreciation has been taken, especially when sold to a related party.
Why not D: This reverses the recapture logic by treating only the excess gain as ordinary. For Section 1245 property, ordinary income recapture is limited by depreciation taken, and the related-party rule then prevents any leftover gain from being Section 1231 gain.
Question 4
Hint
Use the beneficiary's fair value basis at death, then identify whose depreciation reduced that basis afterward.
Answer D. Property acquired from a decedent generally takes a new basis equal to fair value at death. The decedent's predeath depreciation does not carry over into the beneficiary's section 1245 recapture calculation. Jordan's gain is $60,000, but only Jordan's own $10,000 depreciation is recaptured as ordinary income.
Why not A: This treats inherited property as permanently exempt from section 1245 recapture. Death prevents recapture to the decedent, but the beneficiary's own post-death depreciation can still be recaptured on sale.
Why not B: This answer carries over the decedent's $60,000 depreciation and then limits recapture to the $60,000 gain. Because Jordan received a fair value basis at death, the decedent's depreciation does not create recapture for Jordan.
Why not C: This adds the decedent's $60,000 depreciation to Jordan's $10,000 depreciation. That fails because inherited property receives a new basis at death, so only Jordan's own depreciation is relevant here.
Question 5
Hint
First determine how much gain the shareholder recognizes when stock and a small amount of cash are received, then apply the recapture rule to that recognized gain.
Answer D. The exchange qualifies for nonrecognition treatment except for the cash received. Ava's realized gain is $50,000, but recognized gain is limited to the $10,000 boot. Because the equipment is Section 1245 property, the recognized gain is treated as ordinary income to the extent of prior depreciation, so the full $10,000 is ordinary income.
Why not A: This comes from using the full realized gain as current recapture. That fails because Section 1245 recharacterizes recognized gain, but it does not override the boot limitation on how much gain is recognized in this controlled-corporation transfer.
Why not B: This comes from treating the transfer as fully tax-free because Ava controlled the corporation after the exchange. That fails because the $10,000 cash received is boot, which creates recognized gain up to that amount.
Why not C: This comes from assuming all prior depreciation is immediately recaptured. That fails because ordinary income cannot exceed the gain recognized in the exchange, and only $10,000 is recognized here.
Question 6
Hint
Find the gain recognized after the Sec. 1033 reinvestment, then compare that amount with prior depreciation.
Answer A. The realized gain is $50,000, but only $20,000 is recognized because $80,000 of the $100,000 proceeds was reinvested in qualifying replacement property. The machine is Sec. 1245 property, and prior depreciation of $30,000 creates recapture potential greater than the recognized gain. Therefore, all $20,000 recognized in Year 1 is ordinary income, with no Section 1231 gain recognized.
Why not B: This treats the recognized gain as if involuntary conversion character rules go straight to Section 1231. For Sec. 1245 property, recognized gain is recaptured as ordinary income first, up to the depreciation previously allowed or allowable.
Why not C: This uses the full realized gain and ignores the Sec. 1033 deferral. Because the taxpayer replaced part of the converted property value, only the unreinvested proceeds create recognized gain in Year 1.
Why not D: This comes from treating all prior depreciation as automatically recaptured. Recapture cannot exceed the gain actually recognized in the conversion year, which is only $20,000 after the Sec. 1033 election.
Common questions
Can Section 1245 recapture be deferred on an installment sale?
No. The example's $20,000 recapture is ordinary income in Year 1, even if the buyer pays no cash that year.
How do you calculate the gross profit percentage after recapture?
Subtract recapture from total gain, then divide by contract price. Here, ($80,000 minus $20,000) divided by $100,000 equals 60%.
Why is recapture added to installment-sale basis?
It removes gain already recognized from the installment calculation. Here, $20,000 adjusted basis plus $20,000 recapture gives a $40,000 installment-sale basis.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Section 1231, 1245 and 1250 property, worked step by step.
Section 1231 Netting and Depreciation Recapture | CPA REG TBS on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Section 1231, 1245 and 1250 property
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.