REG · Business Law · 6 practice questions
First to File or Perfect: Priority Between Secured Parties
Between conflicting perfected security interests, priority generally goes to the first to file or perfect if filing or perfection remains continuous. Follow one equipment timeline, then change only Bank A's filing date to see priority flip.
Try one first
Hint
Separate attachment, perfection, and priority. Then ask which date Article 9 uses when both creditors ultimately have perfected security interests.
Answer C. Under UCC Article 9, priority between conflicting perfected security interests is determined by the earlier of filing or perfection. First Bank's financing statement was filed on March 2 (earlier than Second Bank's March 7 filing), and when First Bank later attached on March 10 its priority relates back to the earlier filing date. Thus First Bank has priority even though Second Bank perfected before First Bank attached.
Why not A: Attachment makes a security interest enforceable against the debtor, which is why this choice is tempting, but priority between competing perfected interests turns on the earlier of filing or perfection, not merely who attached first.
Why not B: This distractor is attractive because Second Bank perfected (by filing) before First Bank actually attached/perfected, but First Bank's earlier financing-statement filing (March 2) establishes an earlier priority date when First Bank later attached, so Second Bank is junior.
Why not D: Although First Bank is the correct winner, the reasoning here is flawed: filing alone does not perfect before attachment. First Bank was not perfected until value was given and attachment occurred on March 10; its priority, however, relates back to the March 2 filing once attachment occurred.
The timeline
- March 1Original: Bank A files a financing statement covering Apex's equipment.
Apex owns the equipment throughout. All filings are authorized and remain effective. Neither lender takes possession. No special priority rule applies.
- March 5In both versions, Rival lends Apex money and obtains an authenticated security agreement covering the same equipment.
Rival's security interest attaches. It is not yet perfected because Rival has not filed.
- March 6In both versions, Rival files its financing statement.
Rival becomes perfected. Its priority date is March 6 in both versions.
- March 7Alternate only: Bank A files today instead of March 1.
Only Bank A's authorized filing date changes. Bank A still has not given value or obtained a security agreement.
- March 10In both versions, Bank A lends Apex money and obtains an authenticated security agreement covering the equipment.
Bank A's interest now attaches and becomes perfected. Filing earlier did not itself cause attachment or perfection.
- After March 10Compare priority now that both security interests are perfected.
Original: Bank A wins with its March 1 filing. Alternate: Rival wins with its March 6 filing, before Bank A's March 7 filing.
Key points
- Remember: First to file can beat first to perfect once both interests are perfected.
- Authorized filing may occur before the loan and authenticated security agreement.
- Keep filing or perfection continuous to preserve the earlier priority date.
How the exam traps you
- Choosing Rival in the original because it perfected first. Bank A's March 1 filing controls once Bank A attaches and perfects.
- Treating Bank A as perfected when it files. Bank A cannot perfect until its interest attaches on March 10.
- Keeping Bank A first after moving its filing to March 7. Rival's March 6 filing now comes first, so Rival wins.
Question 2
Hint
Work in order: first determine when Metro Bank's interest attached, then determine when it became perfected, and only then compare that timing to when Supplier became a lien creditor.
Answer D. Metro Bank gave value on January 2 and had an authenticated security agreement covering after-acquired equipment. The security interest attached when Orion obtained rights in the machine on January 8; because Metro Bank had already filed on January 3, that filing became effective to perfect the interest at attachment. Supplier became a lien creditor on January 10, after Metro Bank was perfected, so Metro Bank's perfected security interest has priority.
Why not A: While lien creditors defeat unperfected security interests, they do not automatically defeat prior perfected interests. Because Metro Bank's interest was perfected at attachment on January 8 and Supplier became a lien creditor on January 10, Metro Bank's perfected interest prevails.
Why not B: This is tempting because students may think filing before ownership is meaningless. Under Article 9, a financing statement filed before attachment can become effective later; an early filing becomes effective to perfect when the security interest attaches (as occurred here on January 8).
Why not C: This distractor relies on the mistaken idea that each new asset needs a separate amendment. A properly drafted after-acquired property clause (here covering equipment now owned or later acquired) covers later-acquired equipment, so the security interest attached automatically when Orion obtained rights in the machine.
Question 3
Hint
Separate the timing of attachment from the timing of filing, then apply the general priority rule for conflicting perfected security interests.
Answer D. Under Article 9, priority among conflicting perfected security interests is determined by who first files or first perfects. A financing statement validly filed before attachment can establish the earlier priority date once the security interest later attaches and perfection is achieved. Here A filed on April 1 before B's April 7 filing, so A's earlier filing gives A priority once A's interest attached and was perfected.
Why not A: Although both parties ended up perfected, Article 9 does not treat that as a tie, priority is allocated by who filed or perfected first. Because A's effective filing predates B's, A ranks first.
Why not B: This is tempting because B attached and perfected earlier in real time, but priority between perfected security interests goes to the party first to file or perfect. A's earlier valid filing (April 1) controls once A's interest attached and was perfected.
Why not C: This plays on the mistaken idea that filings before attachment are irrelevant. In fact, a financing statement may be filed before attachment and, if effective, will give the filer the earlier priority date once the security interest attaches and is perfected.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on the Article 9 rule for conflicting perfected security interests in the same collateral: compare the governing priority dates, not just the date each interest attached.
Answer A. Under UCC Article 9, conflicting perfected security interests in the same collateral are ranked by the earlier of the time of filing or the time of perfection. A financing statement may be filed before attachment; when the security interest later attaches, the earlier filing date is used for priority purposes. Because Bank filed on January 5 (earlier than FinanceCo's January 16 filing), Bank has priority once its interest attached on January 20.
Why not B: Tempting because FinanceCo authenticated (attached) on January 15, but attachment alone does not trump an earlier filing. Priority is determined by the earlier of filing or perfection; FinanceCo's perfection occurred on its January 16 filing, which is later than Bank's January 5 filing.
Why not C: This misstates Article 9. A financing statement can be filed before attachment and will establish the earlier priority date once the security interest later attaches and is perfected, so Bank's January 5 filing controls when its interest attached on January 20.
Why not D: Article 9 does not split priority equally when multiple perfected security interests exist. Instead, it applies a rule based on the earlier of filing or perfection; here Bank's earlier filing gives it priority.
Question 5
Hint
Separate filing from attachment first, then compare the date the judicial lien arose with the date Bank first had an enforceable security interest.
Answer C. A financing statement may be filed before attachment, but perfection does not occur until the security interest attaches (attachment requires debtor's authentication and value). Bank's interest did not attach and become perfected until March 15. Because Judgment Creditor became a lien creditor on March 10, before Bank's interest attached/perfected, the judgment lien has priority.
Why not A: Tempting because of the first-to-file idea, but filing alone (before attachment) does not create a perfected security interest. Without attachment and value, the filing could not defeat a lien creditor that arose in the interim.
Why not B: Attractive because debtor ownership is one attachment element, but attachment also requires an authenticated security agreement (or possession/control or other satisfaction of attachment) and value. Those were missing until March 15, so perfection did not exist on March 10.
Why not D: This overextends the relation-back idea. While a prior filing can be effective once the security interest later attaches, it does not eliminate the lien creditor's priority when the lien arose before attachment/perfection in the interim.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the timeline for attachment from the timeline for filing. Ask what facts were in place on the date of the sheriff's levy.
Answer D. Attachment requires value, debtor rights in the collateral, and an authenticated security agreement (unless the secured party has possession or control). Although First Bank filed on January 5 and advanced value on January 20, Delta did not authenticate the security agreement until January 25, so the interest had not attached or been perfected by the January 22 levy. A security interest cannot be perfected before it has attached, so the judgment creditor's lien that arose on January 22 has priority.
Why not A: Tempting because filing occurred early, but filing alone does not create an enforceable security interest. Perfection depends on attachment plus the perfection act; on January 22 the interest had not yet attached, so filing by itself did not give priority over the judgment creditor.
Why not B: This mixes up the attachment requirements: giving value is one element, but without the debtor's authenticated security agreement (or the secured party's possession/control), the interest does not attach. Delta did not authenticate until January 25, so attachment had not occurred on January 20 or by the January 22 levy.
Why not C: Although a financing statement filed before attachment can later support priority against competing secured parties when the interest subsequently attaches, that relation-back does not defeat a lien creditor who became such (by levy) before attachment and perfection existed. Because the levy occurred on January 22, the judgment creditor's priority was already established.
Common questions
Does the first lender to perfect always have priority?
No. In the original timeline, Rival perfects first on March 6, but Bank A wins once both interests are perfected because Bank A filed on March 1.
Can a financing statement be filed before attachment?
Yes, an authorized financing statement may be filed before attachment. Bank A's early filing can establish its priority date, but Bank A does not become perfected until attachment on March 10.
Who has priority if Bank A files on March 7 instead?
Rival wins because its March 6 filing and perfection precede Bank A's March 7 filing. Bank A still attaches and perfects on March 10.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Sales and Secured Transactions
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.