PracticeREGFree practice exam

REG · Business Law · 6 practice questions

PMSI Priority: Equipment vs. Inventory Timing

Equipment PMSIs allow perfection within 20 days after possession; inventory PMSIs require perfection at possession and authenticated notice received beforehand. Compare Delta's press under both uses, then isolate the inventory filing deadline.

The ruleEquipment PMSIs beat earlier liens if perfected at possession or within 20 days afterward. Inventory PMSIs require perfection at possession and earlier filers' receipt of authenticated PMSI notice describing the inventory before possession.

Try one first

On March 1, Year 1, Regional Bank filed a financing statement covering "all existing and after-acquired equipment" of Delta Co. On April 10, Year 1, Machine Seller sold Delta a new industrial press on credit, retained a security interest in that press to secure the unpaid price, and Delta agreed the press would be used solely in Delta's manufacturing operations. Delta received possession of the press on April 12, Year 1. Machine Seller filed a financing statement covering the press on April 25, Year 1. Delta later defaulted while still owning the press. Assume no certificate-of-title statute applies and no other facts affect priority. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

First decide whether the press is equipment or inventory; then apply the PMSI priority rule that corresponds to that collateral class (timing for filing versus any authenticated-notice requirement).

Side by side

Equipment: press used in manufacturingInventory: press held for resale
Delta's intended use: the only changed factDelta will use the press in manufacturing.Delta will hold the press for resale.
Bank's earlier lienBank filed March 1; its valid lien covers all existing and after-acquired equipment and inventory.Bank filed March 1; its valid lien covers all existing and after-acquired equipment and inventory.
Seller's credit saleSeller sells the press on credit April 10 and retains a PMSI securing the unpaid price.Seller sells the press on credit April 10 and retains a PMSI securing the unpaid price.
Possession and perfectionDelta receives the press April 12. Seller properly files and perfects April 25.Delta receives the press April 12. Seller properly files and perfects April 25.
Perfection deadline for superpriorityAt possession or within 20 days afterward: no later than May 2.At possession on April 12. No post-possession grace period.
Notice requirement and actual noticeSeller gives no notice. Equipment PMSI superpriority requires none.Seller gives no notice. Bank must receive authenticated PMSI notice describing the inventory before April 12 possession.
Priority in the pressSeller wins: April 25 perfection is within 20 days after possession.Bank wins: Seller perfected after possession and gave no notice.
Inventory timing test: change only noticeNo equipment variation; advance notice is not required.Same facts, except Bank received proper authenticated PMSI notice on April 11. Seller still files April 25. Bank wins: perfection came after April 12 possession; inventory has no 20-day grace period.

Key points

  • Remember: Notice cannot cure late inventory perfection, and timely filing cannot cure missing inventory notice.
  • Changing Delta's intended use changes the priority test without changing the press or Bank's lien.
  • Seller's credit sale creates a PMSI, but PMSI status alone does not guarantee first priority.

How the exam traps you

  • Giving inventory the equipment PMSI's 20-day grace period. In the notice-corrected inventory test, Bank wins because Seller's April 25 filing follows Delta's April 12 possession.
  • Requiring advance notice for an equipment PMSI. Equipment needs no advance notice. Seller's April 25 perfection is timely, so Seller wins despite giving no notice.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

City Bank already has an attached and perfected security interest in all of RetailCo's existing and after-acquired inventory and proceeds. Supplier later sold 200 tablets to RetailCo on credit and took a purchase-money security interest in those tablets as inventory. Supplier filed a proper financing statement before RetailCo received possession of the tablets, but Supplier did not send City Bank any authenticated notice of its PMSI. RetailCo then sold some of the tablets to customers in the ordinary course and deposited the sales receipts into a separate account, where the cash proceeds remained identifiable. RetailCo defaulted while still holding the remaining tablets. Assume Article 9 applies, there is no bankruptcy filing, and all other enforceability requirements are satisfied. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

For PMSI in inventory, do not stop after asking whether the creditor filed before possession. Check whether every superpriority condition was met, then decide whether ordinary first-to-file priority controls.

Question 3

On January 5, Year 1, Bank loaned Ridge Tools, LLC money. Ridge signed a security agreement granting Bank a security interest in all existing and after-acquired equipment, and Bank properly filed a financing statement that same day. On March 1, Year 1, Seller sold Ridge a laser cutter on credit for use in Ridge's business. Ridge received possession of the laser cutter on March 1. Seller retained a purchase-money security interest in the laser cutter and properly filed a financing statement on March 15, Year 1. Assume the laser cutter is equipment, not inventory or consumer goods, and both filings were otherwise effective. If Ridge defaults, what is the correct treatment of priority in the laser cutter?
Hint

Start with the general first-to-file rule, then ask whether Article 9 gives special priority to a creditor who financed the debtor's purchase of equipment.

Question 4

Metro Bank filed a financing statement on January 5, Year 1, covering Bistro LLC's existing and after-acquired equipment and inventory. On April 1, Year 1, Kitchen Supply sold three commercial ovens to Bistro on credit and retained a purchase-money security interest in the ovens. Bistro purchased the ovens for use in preparing food in its restaurants and not for resale. Bistro received possession of the ovens on April 2, Year 1. Kitchen Supply filed a financing statement covering the ovens on April 15, Year 1, and did not send any notice to Metro Bank. Assume Article 9 applies, all filings are otherwise proper, and no consumer-goods exception applies. Which statement is best supported regarding priority in the ovens?
Hint

First determine whether the ovens are inventory or equipment based on intended use; then apply the PMSI priority rule that corresponds (inventory: pre-possession authenticated notice; equipment: perfection within 20 days after possession).

Question 5

On April 1, First Bank loaned OfficeCo $100,000. On that date, OfficeCo authenticated a security agreement granting First Bank a security interest in "all existing and after-acquired equipment." On April 2, First Bank filed a proper financing statement in the correct filing office describing the collateral as equipment. On April 10, OfficeCo purchased a copier for use in its main office (the copier is business equipment) and took delivery. The seller did not retain or perfect any security interest in the copier. On April 12, a judgment creditor caused the sheriff to levy on the copier, becoming a lien creditor on that date. Assume the copier is not subject to any certificate-of-title statute. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Decide in order: (1) did and when did the bank's security interest attach to the copier? (2) was the April 2 financing statement effective to perfect the interest at that time?

Question 6

Bank filed a financing statement on January 5, Year 1 covering all existing and after-acquired inventory and equipment of CafeCo. On June 1, Supplier sold CafeCo (1) a commercial espresso machine to be used in CafeCo's operations (equipment) and (2) coffee mugs that CafeCo would hold for resale (inventory), taking a purchase-money security interest in both items. CafeCo received possession of both items on June 1. Supplier filed a financing statement covering both items on June 10. Supplier sent Bank an authenticated notice of its claimed purchase-money security interest on June 3; Bank received that notice on June 4. Assume both security interests otherwise attached, and no buyer or lien-creditor issues are involved. Under UCC 9-324, an inventory PMSI has superpriority only if the PMSI is perfected by the time the debtor receives possession and the holder of the earlier security interest receives authenticated notice before the debtor receives possession; an equipment PMSI has superpriority if the PMSI is perfected within 20 days after the debtor receives possession. Which conclusion is most accurate regarding priority between Supplier and Bank?
Hint

Analyze equipment and inventory PMSIs separately and compare the dates of possession, filing (perfection), and when Bank actually received Supplier's notice.

Drill all 103 Sales and Secured Transactions questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What is the 20-day PMSI rule for equipment?

An equipment PMSI can defeat an earlier lien if perfected at possession or within 20 days afterward. Delta receives the press April 12, making May 2 the deadline; Seller's April 25 filing qualifies.

Does an inventory PMSI require notice before delivery?

Bank must receive authenticated PMSI notice describing the inventory before Delta receives possession. Seller's failure to give notice defeats inventory superpriority even if Seller files on time.

Does timely inventory PMSI notice excuse filing after delivery?

No. Even if Bank receives proper notice April 11, Seller's April 25 filing is too late because Delta receives possession April 12.

Practice REG like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Sales and Secured Transactions

All Sales and Secured Transactions practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.