REG · Business Law · 6 practice questions
PMSI Priority: Equipment vs. Inventory Timing
Equipment PMSIs allow perfection within 20 days after possession; inventory PMSIs require perfection at possession and authenticated notice received beforehand. Compare Delta's press under both uses, then isolate the inventory filing deadline.
Try one first
Hint
First decide whether the press is equipment or inventory; then apply the PMSI priority rule that corresponds to that collateral class (timing for filing versus any authenticated-notice requirement).
Answer A. Machine Seller took a purchase-money security interest by selling the press on credit and retaining a security interest to secure the unpaid price, and the press qualifies as equipment given its agreed use. Under Article 9, a PMSI in equipment has priority over an earlier conflicting security interest if it is perfected at the time the debtor receives possession or within 20 days thereafter. Machine Seller filed a financing statement on April 25, which is within 20 days after Delta received possession on April 12, so Seller's PMSI defeats Regional Bank's earlier-filed interest as to the press.
Why not B: This is tempting because of the general first-to-file rule, but it overlooks the PMSI superpriority exception for equipment: a properly perfected PMSI in equipment can take priority over an earlier filing when perfected at possession or within 20 days thereafter.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the notice requirement that applies to PMSIs in inventory. For PMSIs in equipment, however, priority is achieved by timely perfection (at possession or within 20 days after), not by advance authenticated notice to prior secured parties.
Why not D: This is a stricter timing rule than Article 9 requires for equipment. While some contexts require pre-possession perfection, a PMSI in equipment is permitted to be perfected within 20 days after the debtor receives possession and still obtain superpriority; Seller met that timing here.
Side by side
| Equipment: press used in manufacturing | Inventory: press held for resale | |
|---|---|---|
| Delta's intended use: the only changed fact | Delta will use the press in manufacturing. | Delta will hold the press for resale. |
| Bank's earlier lien | Bank filed March 1; its valid lien covers all existing and after-acquired equipment and inventory. | Bank filed March 1; its valid lien covers all existing and after-acquired equipment and inventory. |
| Seller's credit sale | Seller sells the press on credit April 10 and retains a PMSI securing the unpaid price. | Seller sells the press on credit April 10 and retains a PMSI securing the unpaid price. |
| Possession and perfection | Delta receives the press April 12. Seller properly files and perfects April 25. | Delta receives the press April 12. Seller properly files and perfects April 25. |
| Perfection deadline for superpriority | At possession or within 20 days afterward: no later than May 2. | At possession on April 12. No post-possession grace period. |
| Notice requirement and actual notice | Seller gives no notice. Equipment PMSI superpriority requires none. | Seller gives no notice. Bank must receive authenticated PMSI notice describing the inventory before April 12 possession. |
| Priority in the press | Seller wins: April 25 perfection is within 20 days after possession. | Bank wins: Seller perfected after possession and gave no notice. |
| Inventory timing test: change only notice | No equipment variation; advance notice is not required. | Same facts, except Bank received proper authenticated PMSI notice on April 11. Seller still files April 25. Bank wins: perfection came after April 12 possession; inventory has no 20-day grace period. |
Key points
- Remember: Notice cannot cure late inventory perfection, and timely filing cannot cure missing inventory notice.
- Changing Delta's intended use changes the priority test without changing the press or Bank's lien.
- Seller's credit sale creates a PMSI, but PMSI status alone does not guarantee first priority.
How the exam traps you
- Giving inventory the equipment PMSI's 20-day grace period. In the notice-corrected inventory test, Bank wins because Seller's April 25 filing follows Delta's April 12 possession.
- Requiring advance notice for an equipment PMSI. Equipment needs no advance notice. Seller's April 25 perfection is timely, so Seller wins despite giving no notice.
Question 2
Hint
For PMSI in inventory, do not stop after asking whether the creditor filed before possession. Check whether every superpriority condition was met, then decide whether ordinary first-to-file priority controls.
Answer A. A PMSI in inventory obtains superpriority over a prior perfected inventory lender only if the PMSI holder perfects before the debtor receives possession and also sends the required authenticated notice to the earlier secured party before possession. Supplier filed before possession (good) but failed to send the required notice, so it did not obtain inventory-PMSI superpriority. Priority therefore falls back to the ordinary first-to-file-or-perfect rule, under which City Bank prevails in both the remaining inventory and the identifiable cash proceeds.
Why not B: This choice plays on the separate analysis for proceeds. While proceeds require tracing and separate priority analysis, a properly established inventory PMSI superpriority can extend to identifiable cash proceeds. Supplier loses here not because proceeds are excluded but because it never satisfied the notice requirement needed to obtain superpriority at all.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the memorized timing rule for inventory PMSIs (must be perfected before possession). But for inventory PMSIs, timely perfection alone is not enough; the PMSI holder must also give authenticated notice to a conflicting secured party, which Supplier failed to do here.
Why not D: This distractor leans on the intuition that purchase-money character follows into proceeds. But purchase-money status alone does not displace a prior perfected inventory lender. Without meeting the special inventory-PMSI conditions (notably prior notice), Supplier cannot leapfrog City Bank for the inventory or the identifiable cash proceeds.
Question 3
Hint
Start with the general first-to-file rule, then ask whether Article 9 gives special priority to a creditor who financed the debtor's purchase of equipment.
Answer B. Under Article 9, a PMSI in equipment has priority over a prior perfected security interest if the PMSI is perfected when the debtor receives possession or within 20 days thereafter. Seller financed Ridge's purchase of the laser cutter and filed on March 15, which is within 20 days of Ridge's March 1 receipt. Therefore Seller's properly perfected PMSI in the equipment takes priority over Bank's earlier-filed after-acquired equipment lien.
Why not A: This appeals to the general first-to-file rule, and Bank's filing did cover after-acquired equipment. However, the PMSI superpriority for equipment (when perfected at receipt or within 20 days) displaces the general rule here, so Bank's earlier filing loses to Seller's timely perfected PMSI.
Why not C: This overgeneralizes automatic perfection. Automatic perfection of a PMSI applies in some consumer-goods situations, not for commercial equipment. Seller wins here because it filed within the 20-day window, not because perfection was automatic upon delivery.
Why not D: Attachment is necessary but not dispositive for priority. Bank's interest did attach as after-acquired collateral, but Seller's PMSI was perfected within the 20-day statutory window and therefore has priority under Article 9.
Question 4
Hint
First determine whether the ovens are inventory or equipment based on intended use; then apply the PMSI priority rule that corresponds (inventory: pre-possession authenticated notice; equipment: perfection within 20 days after possession).
Answer A. Classify the collateral first: Bistro bought the ovens to use in its restaurants, so they are equipment. Under Article 9, a seller's PMSI in equipment can obtain superpriority over an earlier perfected conflicting security interest if the PMSI is perfected within 20 days after the debtor receives possession. Kitchen Supply filed 13 days after Bistro received the ovens, so it satisfied the 20-day perfection requirement and therefore has priority; the inventory pre-possession notice rule does not apply to equipment PMSIs.
Why not B: This distractor is tempting because candidates may conflate the inventory rule with equipment; however, only a PMSI in inventory requires an authenticated notice to earlier secured parties before the debtor receives possession. That pre-possession notice requirement does not apply to a PMSI in equipment.
Why not C: This appeals to the general first-to-file-or-perfect and after-acquired property concepts, which are often correct, but it ignores the statutory PMSI exception: for equipment, a PMSI can obtain priority by being perfected within 20 days after possession, so perfection before possession is not required in that context.
Why not D: This traps candidates who think the earlier secured party's knowledge is an extra element. Actual knowledge by the earlier secured party is not an additional requirement for a PMSI in equipment to obtain superpriority; the controlling condition for equipment is timely perfection within the 20-day window.
Question 5
Hint
Decide in order: (1) did and when did the bank's security interest attach to the copier? (2) was the April 2 financing statement effective to perfect the interest at that time?
Answer C. The security agreement's after-acquired equipment clause covers the copier, and First Bank had given value and an authenticated security agreement on April 1, so the security interest attached when OfficeCo obtained rights in the copier on April 10. Under Article 9, a financing statement filed before attachment becomes effective to perfect when the interest attaches; because First Bank filed on April 2, the interest was perfected upon attachment (April 10) and therefore had priority over the judgment lien that arose on April 12.
Why not A: Tempting because students often think each newly acquired asset requires a fresh advance to be covered. But with an authenticated security agreement that includes an after-acquired-collateral clause and an existing advance, no new value at the moment of acquisition is required for the earlier security interest to attach to the copier.
Why not B: Tempting because of a timing confusion about filing and attachment. However, Article 9 permits filing before attachment; the financing statement becomes effective to perfect the security interest when the interest attaches, so First Bank's April 2 filing perfected the interest upon attachment on April 10.
Why not D: Tempting to students who think after-acquired items require updating the filing. But a correct generic description such as 'equipment' covers later-acquired equipment, so no post-acquisition amendment was necessary to perfect First Bank's interest in this copier.
Question 6
Hint
Analyze equipment and inventory PMSIs separately and compare the dates of possession, filing (perfection), and when Bank actually received Supplier's notice.
Answer A. Under UCC 9-324, an equipment PMSI can prevail over an earlier-filed security interest if perfected (here, by filing a financing statement) within 20 days after the debtor receives possession. Supplier filed on June 10, which is within 20 days of CafeCo's June 1 possession, so Supplier's PMSI in the espresso machine has superpriority. Inventory PMSIs require perfection by the time the debtor receives possession and that the holder of the earlier security interest receive authenticated notice before possession; Supplier's filing and Bank's receipt of notice occurred after June 1, so Supplier did not meet the inventory timing requirements and Bank remains senior in the mugs.
Why not B: Tempting because Supplier filed soon after delivery and sent notice, but inventory PMSIs require perfection and receipt-of-notice before the debtor receives possession. Here both the filing and Bank's receipt of notice occurred after possession, so Supplier cannot obtain superpriority in the mugs.
Why not C: Attractive under the first-to-file-or-perfect default rule, but PMSI rules are an exception. Because Supplier perfected the equipment PMSI within 20 days after possession, Supplier's PMSI prevails in the espresso machine despite Bank's earlier filing.
Why not D: This reverses the statutory distinctions: equipment PMSIs benefit from the 20-day grace period for perfection after possession, while inventory PMSIs require perfection and notice before possession. In this fact pattern, only the equipment PMSI met its timing requirement.
Common questions
What is the 20-day PMSI rule for equipment?
An equipment PMSI can defeat an earlier lien if perfected at possession or within 20 days afterward. Delta receives the press April 12, making May 2 the deadline; Seller's April 25 filing qualifies.
Does an inventory PMSI require notice before delivery?
Bank must receive authenticated PMSI notice describing the inventory before Delta receives possession. Seller's failure to give notice defeats inventory superpriority even if Seller files on time.
Does timely inventory PMSI notice excuse filing after delivery?
No. Even if Bank receives proper notice April 11, Seller's April 25 filing is too late because Delta receives possession April 12.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Sales and Secured Transactions
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.