REG · Business Law · 6 practice questions
Security Interest Perfection: Filing vs. Deposit Account Control
Filing perfects ordinary inventory, equipment, and receivables, but a deposit account pledged as original collateral requires control. Sort Delta LLC's collateral by method below, assuming attachment and no possession.
Try one first
Hint
Identify which collateral type has a special perfection rule under Article 9, then determine the usual method for the other collateral.
Answer C. Inventory is generally perfected by filing a financing statement under Article 9. A deposit account (as original collateral) cannot be perfected by filing; it is perfected by control. Because Commerce is not the depositary bank, it must obtain control of the deposit account (for example, by an account-control agreement with Metro Bank), while filing perfects the inventory.
Why not A: Filing perfects many Article 9 collateral types, including inventory, so this is tempting. However, a deposit account as original collateral is a special category that is perfected by control, not by filing; filing alone would leave the deposit-account interest unperfected.
Why not B: This correctly recognizes that the deposit account requires control. But attachment alone does not perfect an ordinary security interest in inventory; the inventory still requires a proper perfection step (typically filing).
Why not D: Possession can perfect certain goods, so this may seem plausible for inventory, but the stem specifies Commerce wants to perfect without taking possession. More importantly, filing does not perfect a deposit account as original collateral, so the deposit-account interest would remain unperfected.
Sort it
Is the collateral ordinary inventory, equipment, or accounts receivable that Delta retains? File a financing statement.
Is the collateral a deposit account pledged as original collateral? Obtain control; filing does not perfect it.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Delta's merchandise inventory, kept for sale. | FilingFiling perfects the inventory interest while Delta keeps the goods. |
| Delta's operating checking account at another bank, pledged as original collateral. | ControlThe collateral is a deposit account. Bank needs control, not a financing statement. |
| Delta's office computers, retained for business use. | FilingThese computers are ordinary equipment. Filing perfects the interest without interrupting Delta's use. |
| Delta's customer accounts receivable, documented by invoices. | FilingThe collateral is the right to payment. Filing perfects the interest in the accounts receivable. |
| Delta's payroll deposit account, expressly listed in Bank's filed financing statement. | ControlExpressly naming the deposit account does not make filing effective. Bank still needs control. |
| Delta's savings deposit account; the account bank received notice but agreed to nothing. | ControlNotice alone is not control. A qualifying control agreement would provide the required method. |
| Delta's ordinary manufacturing equipment; Bank has only an authenticated security agreement. | FilingAttachment is assumed, but the security agreement alone does not perfect the equipment interest. Bank must file. |
| Delta's business checking account, covered by a signed three-party agreement requiring Bank's instructions to be followed without Delta's further consent. | ControlThe agreement establishes control. Bank does not need a UCC-1 filing to perfect this deposit-account interest. |
| Delta's raw materials held for production. | FilingRaw materials are inventory even before they become finished goods. Filing perfects the interest. |
| Delta's business deposit account; Bank has only an authenticated security agreement. | ControlAttachment does not complete perfection. Unlike ordinary equipment, this collateral requires control rather than filing. |
Key points
- Remember: File for ordinary inventory, equipment, and receivables; obtain control for a deposit account pledged as original collateral.
- An authenticated security agreement does not, by itself, perfect an interest in these assets.
- Filing lets Delta retain its inventory and continue using its equipment.
- Notice to the account bank is not the same as control.
How the exam traps you
- Listing the deposit account in a financing statement and treating it as perfected. Obtain control of the deposit account. Filing does not perfect it.
- Treating the authenticated security agreement as the final perfection step. Separate attachment from perfection. File for ordinary business collateral; obtain control for the deposit account.
- Sending notice to the account bank instead of obtaining control. Use a control agreement requiring the account bank to follow Bank's instructions without Delta's further consent.
Question 2
Hint
For a registered organization, first identify which jurisdiction determines the debtor's location for filing purposes, then consider how long a filing from the old jurisdiction remains effective after that location changes.
Answer B. For a registered organization, the relevant filing jurisdiction is the debtor's state of organization, not the debtor's headquarters or the location of the collateral. When Delta converted and became organized only under Texas law, the Delaware filing remained effective only for a limited transitional period. To preserve continuous perfection in the existing collateral, North Bank must file a financing statement in Texas within the four‑month temporary period following the change of the debtor's jurisdiction.
Why not A: A continuation statement extends the life of a filing in the original jurisdiction but does not prevent loss of perfection caused by the debtor's change of location to a new state once the Article 9 temporary period expires.
Why not C: For a registered organization the relevant filing location is the state of organization, not the chief executive office. Amending the Delaware financing statement to update an address will not substitute for filing in the debtor's new state of organization.
Why not D: Although the original filing has not yet reached its lapse date, its effectiveness after the debtor changes its state of organization is only temporary. If North Bank fails to refile in Texas before the transitional period ends, it risks losing perfection in the existing collateral.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on the type of collateral first. Then ask which perfection method Article 9 normally uses for that collateral type.
Answer A. Accounts receivable are intangible rights to payment and, under Article 9, are normally perfected by filing a financing statement. Metro already has attachment (value given, an authenticated security agreement, and debtor rights in the collateral), so the additional step required to perfect against third parties is filing the UCC-1 in the proper office for Apex's location.
Why not B: This is tempting because invoices relate to the receivables and students may equate possession with perfection. However, accounts receivable are intangible rights; mere possession of paperwork evidencing those accounts does not perfect a security interest in the accounts themselves (possession is a perfection method for tangible chattel paper or negotiable instruments, not for ordinary accounts).
Why not C: Control is the correct perfection method for deposit accounts, and collections often end up in a bank account, which makes this tempting. But Metro's collateral is accounts receivable, not the deposit account; control of the deposit account would perfect a security interest in that account, not in the underlying receivables.
Why not D: This choice confuses attachment with perfection. Attachment makes the security interest enforceable against the debtor, but it does not generally perfect the interest against third parties. Ordinary accounts receivable are not automatically perfected.
Question 4
Hint
Separate the analysis into two steps: first ask whether the security interest attached, then ask whether the method used was a valid way to perfect each specific type of collateral.
Answer C. Attachment is met for both assets because Harbor gave value, Mesa had rights in the collateral, and Mesa authenticated a security agreement describing the collateral. A properly filed financing statement normally perfects a security interest in inventory. By contrast, a security interest in an original deposit account is generally perfected only by control (e.g., a control agreement or the secured party being the bank's customer), and Harbor did not obtain control, so the deposit account interest remains unperfected.
Why not A: Tempting because filing is the common method to perfect many Article 9 collateral types; incorrect because deposit accounts are a key exception and are generally perfected only by control, not merely by filing.
Why not B: This overgeneralizes the rule for deposit accounts. Inventory is normally perfected by filing a financing statement, so possession or control is not required to perfect inventory.
Why not D: Incorrect: Article 9 requires a description that reasonably identifies the collateral, but it does not mandate an account number. The description of Mesa's existing operating deposit account at Valley Bank is sufficient for attachment; the problem is lack of perfection (control), not lack of attachment.
Question 5
Hint
Treat each collateral type separately and ask whether filing works for both, or whether one of them requires a different perfection method.
Answer D. Equipment (tangible, non-title goods) is typically perfected by filing a UCC financing statement when no certificate-of-title statute applies. A deposit account used as original collateral is an exception: it is perfected by control, not by filing. Because Lender is not the bank holding the account, obtaining control (for example, via a control agreement with City Bank) is necessary for perfection of the deposit account, while filing perfects the equipment.
Why not A: Filing will perfect the equipment but does not perfect a deposit account that is original collateral. Deposit accounts require control, so this choice would leave the deposit account unperfected.
Why not B: A signed security agreement (with attachment) establishes the security interest but does not by itself perfect a deposit account. Filing does not perfect deposit accounts, so this approach would leave the deposit account unperfected.
Why not C: Notice to the bank is not the same as control. Unless the bank agrees to a control arrangement, the secured party becomes the bank's customer on the account, or the secured party otherwise obtains control, the deposit account remains unperfected despite notice.
Question 6
Hint
First decide whether the security interest attached, then separately ask whether it was perfected. The debtor's use of the goods matters.
Answer D. The security interest attached because Bank gave value, Delta had rights in the servers, and Delta authenticated a security agreement describing the collateral. The servers are business equipment, not consumer goods; a PMSI in equipment is not automatically perfected by attachment, filing a financing statement is generally required to perfect it.
Why not A: This is tempting because some students recall that certain PMSIs receive automatic perfection. However, automatic perfection typically applies to PMSIs in consumer goods, not to equipment used in a business; here, the servers are equipment, so automatic perfection does not apply.
Why not B: Possession can be a method of perfection for some types of collateral, which makes this distractor plausible. But perfection of equipment is commonly achieved by filing; the facts state Bank did not file and do not indicate Bank took possession, so the interest is attached but unperfected under these facts.
Why not C: This confuses attachment with perfection. Filing generally perfects the interest against third parties, but failure to file does not make the security interest unenforceable between the debtor and secured party once it has attached.
Common questions
Can a UCC-1 perfect a security interest in a deposit account?
No. A deposit account pledged as original collateral requires control, even if the financing statement expressly lists it.
Does a signed security agreement perfect inventory or equipment?
Not by itself. Assuming attachment and no possession, file a financing statement to perfect an interest in ordinary inventory or equipment.
What does control of a deposit account mean?
One method is a control agreement among Delta, Bank, and the account bank. The account bank agrees to follow Bank's instructions about the funds without Delta's further consent.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Sales and Secured Transactions
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.