REG · Federal Taxation of Entities · 6 practice questions
Section 351 Cash Boot: How Much Gain Is Recognized?
In a qualifying Section 351 exchange, recognized gain is the lesser of realized gain or cash boot received. Below, follow Wells's equipment transfer through a decision tree to separate realized gain from recognized gain.
Try one first
Hint
When a §351 transferor receives stock plus boot (cash or non-stock property), gain is recognized but capped, at the LESSER of the transferor's realized gain or the boot received.
Answer C. §351's nonrecognition rule applies as long as the transferor group is in control of the corporation immediately after the exchange. If a transferor receives 'boot', anything other than stock (cash, other property, or short-term debt), gain is recognized to the extent of the lesser of (i) the transferor's realized gain or (ii) the fair market value of the boot received. Wells's realized gain is $300,000 FMV received − $180,000 adjusted basis = $120,000. The boot received is $50,000 cash. The recognized gain equals the lesser, which is $50,000. Wells's basis in the stock received = property basis ($180,000) − boot received ($50,000) + gain recognized ($50,000) = $180,000.
Why not A: §351 nonrecognition does NOT shelter cash boot. The 'no gain or loss' rule applies only to the property-for-stock portion of the exchange; cash boot triggers gain recognition up to the boot amount. Treating cash as a return of capital ignores the boot rule of §351(b).
Why not B: Boot caps the recognized gain at the lesser of realized gain or boot, it does not 'pile on' to realized gain. The full $120,000 realized gain would only be recognized if boot equaled or exceeded that amount, but here boot is only $50,000, limiting the gain accordingly.
Why not D: There is no allocation rule that reduces the cash boot by the proportion of basis to total consideration. The recognized gain is straightforward: lesser of realized gain or boot. Apportioning basis to the boot is not how §351(b) operates.
Decide it in order
T1Wells transfers equipment worth $300,000 with a $180,000 adjusted basis for $250,000 of stock and $50,000 cash. The exchange otherwise qualifies under Section 351: control is satisfied, and no liabilities are assumed. Does total consideration exceed adjusted basis?
YesGo to T2NoNo realized gain means no gain is recognized under the cash-boot rule.T2Wells's realized gain is $300,000 minus $180,000, or $120,000. Did Wells receive cash boot?
YesGo to T3NoWithout cash boot, this otherwise qualifying stock-only exchange produces no recognized gain.T3Is Wells's $120,000 realized gain at least the $50,000 cash boot received?
YesRecognize $50,000, the cash boot. Do not recognize the full $120,000 or reduce the boot by an allocated portion of basis.NoRecognize only the realized gain. Cash boot cannot trigger gain beyond the gain realized.
Key points
- Remember: Cash boot caps recognized gain; it does not make the entire realized gain taxable.
- Realized gain uses total consideration, including both stock and cash.
- Receiving cash does not make the entire exchange taxable.
How the exam traps you
- Recognizing the full $120,000 realized gain because Wells receives cash. Limit recognized gain to the $50,000 cash boot.
- Recognizing no gain because the exchange qualifies under Section 351. Section 351 does not shelter the cash boot from gain recognition.
- Reducing the $50,000 boot by an allocated portion of equipment basis. Compare total realized gain with cash boot. Do not allocate basis to reduce the boot.
Question 2
Hint
§351 isn't limited to corporate formations. A transferor can contribute property to an EXISTING controlled corporation in a §351 transaction, as long as the control test is met immediately after the transfer.
Answer A. §351 nonrecognition applies whenever (1) one or more persons transfer property to a corporation in exchange for stock, AND (2) the transferor group is in control (≥80%) of the corporation immediately after the exchange. There is no requirement that the corporation be newly formed. A subsequent contribution to a controlled corporation qualifies for §351 nonrecognition just as the initial incorporation did, provided both elements are met. Reyes is the sole shareholder before and after the contribution; the 80% control test is satisfied at 100%. Reyes contributes property in exchange for stock with no boot. Result: §351 applies, and Reyes recognizes $0 gain. The corporation takes a carryover basis of $80,000 in the equipment under §362(a).
Why not B: §351 contains no limitation to initial formations. The Code's text refers to 'transfers' to a controlled corporation, which encompasses both initial incorporations and later capital contributions. This is a frequent area of confusion, but the rule is settled: §351 applies to both.
Why not C: §118 applied to capital contributions (specifically by non-shareholders or governmental entities) before TCJA changes, but the analysis here is governed by §351, not §118. The §351 nonrecognition framework is the controlling rule for shareholder-to-controlled-corporation transfers, including subsequent contributions. Reyes recognizes no gain under §351.
Why not D: The control test for §351 is applied looking at all owners of the corporation immediately after the exchange. Reyes owns 100% of Reyes Inc. before and after, so the control test is straightforwardly satisfied. The issuance of new stock to Reyes does not 'dilute' Reyes's interest because Reyes is the sole shareholder.
Question 3
Hint
§351 allows the transferor group to receive multiple classes of stock, common, preferred, voting, non-voting. The one exception is 'nonqualified preferred stock' under §351(g), which has debt-like features and is treated as boot. Plain preferred is fine.
Answer A. §351 nonrecognition applies to exchanges of property for STOCK in a controlled corporation. The Code does not limit the qualifying stock to a single class, common, preferred, voting, non-voting, and combinations are all permitted. The one exception is §351(g)'s 'nonqualified preferred stock' (NQPS): preferred stock with debt-like features (such as mandatory redemption within 20 years, holder-put rights, dividend rate tied to interest rates) is treated as boot for §351 purposes. The facts here specify that Mosaic's preferred is plain preferred, NOT NQPS. Marsh and Reed together own 100% of every class of Mosaic stock immediately after the exchange (well above the 80% control threshold), and only stock is received in exchange for property, no boot. §351 fully applies, and both transferors recognize $0 gain.
Why not B: Plain preferred stock is not boot under §351, only nonqualified preferred stock under §351(g) is. The facts explicitly rule out §351(g) NQPS treatment, so Marsh's receipt of preferred stock is fully eligible for §351 nonrecognition.
Why not C: Multiple classes of stock are explicitly permitted in §351 transactions; this is a common method of allocating economic interests among transferors. The §351 control test requires 80% of the total combined voting power AND 80% of all other classes of stock (each tested separately), both tests are met here at 100%.
Why not D: Even if preferred stock issued in §351 raised concerns about boot characterization, that would not selectively disqualify §351 for one transferor while preserving it for the other. The §351 control test is applied to the transferor group as a whole. The premise of this answer (that issuing preferred stock disqualifies §351 for the recipient) is also wrong, see Answer B explanation.
Question 4
Hint
Cash-method receivables contributed in §351 are tax-free at contribution (no assignment-of-income trigger). The receivables RETAIN their ordinary-income character, and the corporation reports ordinary income as the receivables are collected, using the same $0 basis the transferor had.
Answer D. When a cash-method taxpayer contributes zero-basis accounts receivable to a corporation in a §351 exchange, two related rules apply. First, §351 provides nonrecognition at the moment of contribution, the assignment-of-income doctrine generally does NOT trigger immediate income for the transferor in a properly structured §351 (Hempt Bros., Inc. v. United States). Second, under §362(a), the corporation takes a carryover basis ($0 here, since Bowman had $0 basis) AND inherits the character of the income. When the corporation collects the receivables, it recognizes ordinary income (the character of the underlying earnings activity) equal to the amount collected ($80,000), with no offsetting basis. The income is taxed at the corporate level rather than at Bowman's individual level.
Why not A: The Hempt Bros. case and IRS practice confirm that the assignment-of-income doctrine does not override §351's nonrecognition rules in a properly structured incorporation transaction. Bowman is not taxed on the receivables at the moment of contribution, the corporation is taxed when it collects them.
Why not B: The receivables retain their character. Bowman generated them in the ordinary course of a consulting practice, so they would have produced ordinary income for Bowman; under §351's character-preservation principle, the corporation likewise recognizes ordinary income on collection, not capital gain.
Why not C: A §351 contribution is not a gift. The transferor receives stock in exchange for the contributed property, which is consideration; the corporation acquires the assets through an exchange, not a gratuitous transfer. The receivables produce taxable income on collection under §61.
Question 5
Hint
§357(c)(3) carves out from 'liabilities' any debt that the transferor would have been able to deduct if paid. Cash-method trade accounts payable are the classic example, excluded from the §357(c) excess-liability-over-basis test.
Answer C. §357(c) generally treats the excess of total liabilities assumed over the total adjusted basis of property transferred as recognized gain. However, §357(c)(3) carves out from the definition of 'liabilities' any obligation that the transferor would have been allowed to deduct if paid. The classic example is a cash-method taxpayer's trade accounts payable: these have not yet been deducted (cash-method = deduct when paid), and the transferor would have been entitled to a deduction if the obligation were paid. Allowing them to count as 'liabilities' under §357(c) would create an artificial gain where there is no economic substance, the corporation will simply step into the obligation and gets the deduction when paid. Lopez's calculation: liabilities for §357(c) purposes = $30,000 mortgage (the AP is excluded under §357(c)(3)) versus $50,000 basis. $30,000 < $50,000, so no §357(c) gain is recognized.
Why not A: §357(c)(3) explicitly excludes accounts payable that would have been deductible by the transferor if paid. Including the AP inflates the liabilities figure and incorrectly triggers §357(c) gain.
Why not B: §357(c) does not exclude secured debt; in fact, the mortgage is precisely the type of liability that §357(c) is designed to test. The exclusion in §357(c)(3) is for deductible-if-paid items (e.g., trade payables of a cash-method taxpayer), not secured debt.
Why not D: §357(a) generally states that assumed liabilities are not boot for §351 purposes (no immediate gain), but §357(c) is a different rule that imposes gain when liabilities exceed basis. The §357(a) and §357(c) rules coexist: §357(a) governs the boot question, and §357(c) imposes a separate excess-over-basis gain.
Question 6
Hint
Two questions help: which transferors count toward the 80% control test, and which do not? And separately, what happens to a transferor whose only contribution is services?
Answer A. Under §351, a transferor of property who receives stock recognizes no gain or loss if the transferor group is in 'control' of the corporation immediately after the exchange. 'Control' means owning at least 80% of the total combined voting power and at least 80% of all other classes of stock. A person who receives stock in exchange solely for services is not treated as a transferor, and that person's stock is not counted toward the 80% test. Adam contributed property and received 90 of 100 shares (90% of total outstanding stock), which exceeds the 80% threshold; §351 applies and Adam recognizes no gain. Beth received stock for services and is taxed on the $20,000 fair market value as ordinary compensation income.
Why not B: Tempting because a services-for-stock issue can feel disqualifying. However, §351 disqualification only occurs if the property-transferor group fails the 80% control test, Beth's status as a services-only recipient does not by itself defeat §351 for Adam, and Adam still owns 90% of the total outstanding stock.
Why not C: A person whose only consideration is services is not a §351 transferor at all and does not qualify for nonrecognition. The fair market value of the stock received for services is currently includible in income as compensation.
Why not D: This misapplies the 80% test. Beth's service-stock is not excluded from the corporation's total outstanding shares, those shares are issued and remain outstanding. Adam owns 90 of 100 shares, which is 90% of total outstanding stock and easily exceeds the 80% threshold; the control test is met.
Common questions
How is cash boot taxed in a Section 351 exchange?
Recognized gain equals the lesser of realized gain or cash boot received. Wells recognizes $50,000 because the cash boot is less than the $120,000 realized gain.
How do you calculate realized gain in a Section 351 exchange?
Subtract adjusted basis from total consideration received. Wells receives $250,000 of stock plus $50,000 cash, so realized gain is $300,000 minus $180,000, or $120,000.
Does receiving cash make the entire Section 351 exchange taxable?
No. With the control requirement satisfied and no liabilities assumed, Wells's cash boot triggers $50,000 of recognized gain, not the full $120,000 realized gain.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on C Corporations (taxation and dividends and capital gains), worked step by step.
Schedule M-1 & Taxable Income | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on C Corporations (taxation and dividends and capital gains)
- C Corporation Distributions: Dividend, Basis, or Capital Gain
- Allocate Current E&P Across Multiple Distributions
- Beginning E&P Deficit: Allocating Current E&P to Dividends
- Current E&P Deficit: Proration to the Distribution Date
- DRD Taxable Income Limit and NOL Exception
- CAMT Calculation: 15% of AFSI and Total Tax
All C Corporations (taxation and dividends and capital gains) practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.