REG · Federal Taxation of Entities · 9 practice questions
C Corporation Distributions: Dividend, Basis, or Capital Gain
A nonliquidating C corporation cash distribution is a dividend to the extent of E&P, then a return of capital up to stock basis, then capital gain. Below: a step-by-step example showing where each portion of the cash goes.
Try one first
Hint
Use the standard ordering rule for a nonliquidating C corporation distribution: earnings and profits first, then stock basis, then gain.
Answer C. Apply the ordering rule for a nonliquidating C corporation distribution: dividends to the extent of earnings and profits, then return of capital up to the shareholder's basis, and any excess is capital gain. Maple has $60,000 of E&P, so $60,000 is dividend income; the next $25,000 reduces the shareholder's basis to zero and is a tax-free return of capital. The remaining $15,000 ($100,000 - $60,000 - $25,000) is recognized as capital gain.
Why not A: Tempting because corporate distributions are often dividends, but dividend treatment is limited to available E&P. Maple has only $60,000 of E&P, so the remaining $40,000 cannot be treated as dividend income.
Why not B: This distractor jumps to recovering basis and recognizing gain without first applying the E&P rule. The correct sequence requires treating the first $60,000 as dividend income because Maple has $60,000 of E&P.
Why not D: This correctly identifies the dividend portion but ignores basis recovery. After the $60,000 dividend, the shareholder recovers $25,000 of basis tax-free, leaving $15,000 as capital gain, not $40,000.
Step by step
- Identify the distribution and basis
Maple C Corp makes its only distribution of the year: $90,000 cash in a nonliquidating transaction to its sole individual shareholder. Current E&P is $20,000, accumulated E&P is $50,000, and stock basis is $15,000; the stock is a capital asset, and there are no other E&P adjustments.
- Find available E&P
Both E&P balances are positive, so add them: $20,000 current + $50,000 accumulated = $70,000. Do not ignore accumulated E&P.
- Allocate the dividend first
The dividend is the smaller of the $90,000 distribution or $70,000 available E&P: $70,000. This leaves $20,000 to test against stock basis.
- Recover stock basis next
The tax-free return of capital is the smaller of the $20,000 remainder or $15,000 stock basis: $15,000. That reduces stock basis to zero; the dividend portion does not reduce basis.
- Recognize the remaining capital gain
After basis recovery, $20,000 − $15,000 = $5,000 remains. That amount is capital gain on the distribution date, even though the shareholder did not sell the stock.
- Check the allocation
E&P and basis together absorb $85,000: $70,000 as a dividend and $15,000 as return of capital. The $90,000 payment exceeds that total by $5,000, confirming the capital gain.
Key points
- Remember: E&P determines the dividend; stock basis determines how much of the nondividend portion is tax-free.
- When current and accumulated E&P are both positive, include both in the dividend limit.
- The dividend portion does not reduce the shareholder's stock basis.
- Excess over both E&P and basis creates gain now, without a stock sale.
How the exam traps you
- Use only current E&P and report a $20,000 dividend. Include the $50,000 accumulated E&P too. The dividend is $70,000.
- Treat the entire $20,000 excess over E&P as capital gain. Recover the $15,000 stock basis first. Only $5,000 is capital gain.
- Treat all $20,000 above E&P as a tax-free return of capital. Return of capital stops at the $15,000 basis. Basis cannot fall below zero.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on the tax-specific measure used for C corporation distributions, not the shareholder-level basis rule or a financial statement concept.
Answer C. For a nonliquidating distribution by a C corporation, dividend treatment is governed by the corporation's earnings and profits (E&P). A distribution is a dividend to the extent of current and accumulated E&P; only after E&P is exhausted does any excess reduce the shareholder's stock basis (a return of capital) and then become capital gain. E&P is a tax concept distinct from GAAP retained earnings and can differ from taxable income because of timing and permanent differences.
Why not A: Retained earnings is a GAAP/book measure and may differ substantially from tax E&P. Dividend characterization for federal tax purposes uses tax E&P, not book retained earnings, so this choice is a book-tax confusion trap.
Why not B: Basis is relevant to the tax treatment of distributions, but only after the corporation's E&P has been fully used. If the distribution exceeds E&P, it reduces the shareholder's stock basis (return of capital) and any amount in excess of basis is taxed as capital gain.
Why not D: Taxable income for the current year is not the controlling measure because E&P incorporates tax adjustments and timing differences that can make it differ from taxable income; dividend treatment depends on E&P, not merely current-year taxable income.
Question 3
Hint
Apply the distribution rules in order: E&P first, then basis recovery, then capital gain.
Answer A. A nonliquidating corporate distribution is a dividend to the extent of available E&P. Lake's available E&P = $30,000 current + $40,000 accumulated = $70,000, so $70,000 is dividend income. The remaining $70,000 reduces Dana's $50,000 stock basis (return of capital) and the excess $20,000 is recognized as capital gain.
Why not B: This treats only current E&P as the dividend portion and ignores accumulated E&P; for a single nonliquidating distribution both current and accumulated E&P are used to determine the dividend amount.
Why not C: Although it recognizes the correct $70,000 dividend, it ignores the basis limitation: the remaining $70,000 can only reduce stock basis of $50,000, so $20,000 must be capital gain.
Why not D: This skips the intermediate basis-recovery step; amounts in excess of E&P reduce shareholder basis first, and only the portion exceeding basis is treated as capital gain.
Question 4
Hint
Separate the corporation-level tax result from the shareholder-level distribution result, and focus on the role of earnings and profits.
Answer A. A C corporation is a separate taxable entity, so Oak recognizes the $60,000 gain on the sale of the land at the corporate level. The subsequent nonliquidating cash distribution does not eliminate the corporation's taxable gain; because Oak has sufficient current and accumulated earnings and profits, the distribution is treated as a dividend to the shareholder and is taxable to the individual.
Why not B: This distractor confuses corporate taxation with pass-through treatment. A C corporation cannot avoid recognizing gain merely by distributing the proceeds; the corporation still includes the gain in its taxable income. The shareholder dividend characterization is correct only because E&P is sufficient, but the corporate tax still applies.
Why not C: This choice lures students who try to 'trace' the cash source. For nonliquidating distributions from a C corporation, shareholder tax treatment depends on earnings and profits, not the origin of the cash. With sufficient E&P, the distribution is a dividend, not a return of capital.
Why not D: This plays on the individual preference for long-term capital gains. C corporations generally do not receive a special lower tax rate for capital gains; such gains are taxed at the corporate tax rate as part of corporate taxable income. The shareholder result would still be dividend income if E&P is sufficient.
Question 5
Hint
Think in layers: dividend to the extent of E&P, then return of capital reduces shareholder basis, then gain for any excess, ask which numeric value ends the return-of-capital layer.
Answer A. A nonliquidating distribution is a dividend to the extent of earnings and profits (here $90,000). The remaining $60,000 is applied next as a return of capital to reduce Ava's stock basis ($40,000); only the excess over basis is recognized as capital gain. Thus whether any of the $60,000 is capital gain is governed by Ava's stock basis (here $60,000 − $40,000 = $20,000 of capital gain).
Why not B: Tempting because candidates often conflate corporate taxable income with distributable amounts. However, taxable income ($130,000) is not the tax metric that determines whether the post-dividend portion becomes return of capital or gain; after applying E&P the shareholder's basis controls recognition of gain.
Why not C: Tempting because the holding period determines whether a recognized gain is long-term or short-term. But it does not determine whether any gain is recognized in the first place, recognition here depends on whether the remainder after the dividend exceeds the shareholder's basis.
Why not D: Tempting because book retained earnings can look similar to distributable earnings on the face of the balance sheet. In practice GAAP retained earnings are a book measure; tax classification uses E&P (here $90,000), and any excess over basis is determined by the shareholder's basis, not the corporation's book retained earnings.
Question 6
Hint
Classify the distribution in order: first by earnings and profits, then by stock basis, then any remainder.
Answer B. Distributions from a C corporation are dividends to the extent of current and accumulated E&P. Pine has $40,000 of current E&P, so $40,000 is dividend income. The remaining $10,000 reduces Lee's stock basis ($6,000) tax-free, and the excess $4,000 is treated as capital gain on sale or exchange of the stock.
Why not A: Tempting because shareholders often think all cash from a corporation is a dividend, but dividend treatment is limited to available E&P. Only $40,000 is supported by E&P here, so the full $50,000 cannot be dividend income.
Why not C: This is incorrect and somewhat arbitrary: it misstates the dividend portion (E&P limits dividend to $40,000) and ignores the required basis-reduction step before recognizing gain. After the $40,000 dividend, basis must be reduced before any capital gain.
Why not D: This correctly limits dividend treatment to E&P but is wrong because it treats the entire excess as gain without first reducing Lee's $6,000 stock basis. Only $4,000 of the excess becomes capital gain.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on the tax ordering rules for a nonliquidating C corporation distribution: determine the dividend portion using E&P before considering stock basis.
Answer C. A nonliquidating distribution from a C corporation is treated as a dividend only to the extent of current and accumulated earnings and profits. Here, Falcon has $30,000 of total positive E&P available, so $30,000 of the $70,000 distribution is dividend income. The remaining $40,000 is not a dividend; it reduces the shareholder's stock basis from $50,000 to $10,000, so no capital gain is recognized.
Why not A: This distractor plays on the fact that stock basis matters in distribution questions. However, basis does not determine the dividend portion first. E&P determines the dividend portion; only after E&P is applied does any remaining distribution reduce basis and potentially create gain.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates often shortcut C corporation distributions as 'dividends.' But a nonliquidating distribution is a dividend only to the extent of E&P. Once E&P is exhausted, the distribution is treated next as a return of capital up to the shareholder's basis, not automatically as additional dividend income.
Why not D: This is a realistic mistake because retained earnings sounds similar to earnings and profits. But book retained earnings is an accounting concept; for tax purposes dividend treatment is governed by tax E&P. High retained earnings alone does not make the full distribution taxable as a dividend.
Question 8
Hint
Work through the distribution in layers: earnings and profits first, then stock basis, then gain.
Answer B. A nonliquidating distribution from a C corporation is a dividend to the extent of the corporation's earnings and profits. Lark's available E&P is $50,000 (accumulated) + $90,000 (current) = $140,000, so $140,000 is dividend income. The remaining $50,000 reduces Nia's $30,000 stock basis to zero, and the $20,000 excess is recognized as capital gain.
Why not A: This is tempting if the student uses only current-year E&P. Because both accumulated and current E&P are positive, the dividend portion is the sum ($140,000), not just current E&P ($90,000).
Why not C: This correctly identifies the $140,000 dividend portion but incorrectly applies the remainder. Basis can only be reduced to zero; the $50,000 nondividend portion first reduces the $30,000 basis to zero, and the $20,000 excess becomes gain.
Why not D: Overbroad. Dividend treatment is limited to available E&P; distributions in excess of E&P are a return of capital (reducing basis) and, if in excess of basis, are treated as gain.
Question 9
Hint
Work through the distribution in order: earnings and profits first, then basis recovery, then any remaining excess.
Answer B. A nonliquidating distribution by a C corporation is a dividend to the extent of current and accumulated earnings and profits. Pine has total E&P of $40,000, so $40,000 of the $55,000 is dividend income. The remaining $15,000 reduces Reed's $8,000 stock basis to zero, and the excess $7,000 is recognized as capital gain.
Why not A: This answer incorrectly uses only the current-year E&P and ignores the $10,000 of accumulated E&P; total dividend treatment here is $40,000, not $30,000.
Why not C: This correctly limits dividends to $40,000 but incorrectly treats the entire $15,000 excess as a nontaxable return of capital. Basis can only be reduced to zero ($8,000), so the remaining $7,000 must be treated as gain.
Why not D: This overstates dividend treatment. Dividend treatment is limited to the amount of earnings and profits (here $40,000), so only $40,000 can be dividend income.
Common questions
Do you apply E&P or stock basis first to a C corporation distribution?
Apply E&P first. Maple's $70,000 of E&P determines the dividend before the remaining $20,000 is tested against stock basis.
Does a C corporation cash dividend reduce stock basis?
The dividend portion does not reduce basis. In this example, only the $15,000 return of capital reduces the shareholder's stock basis.
When does a C corporation distribution become capital gain?
Capital gain arises when the nondividend portion exceeds stock basis. Maple's $20,000 nondividend portion exceeds the $15,000 basis, creating $5,000 of capital gain when distributed.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on C Corporations (taxation and dividends and capital gains), worked step by step.
Schedule M-1 & Taxable Income | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on C Corporations (taxation and dividends and capital gains)
- Allocate Current E&P Across Multiple Distributions
- Beginning E&P Deficit: Allocating Current E&P to Dividends
- Current E&P Deficit: Proration to the Distribution Date
- DRD Taxable Income Limit and NOL Exception
- CAMT Calculation: 15% of AFSI and Total Tax
- Section 351 Cash Boot: How Much Gain Is Recognized?
All C Corporations (taxation and dividends and capital gains) practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.