REG · Federal Taxation of Entities · 6 practice questions
Current E&P Deficit: Proration to the Distribution Date
When full-year current E&P is negative, reduce positive beginning accumulated E&P by the loss accrued through the distribution date. Below: a timeline showing how a ratable loss limits the dividend portion of a July 1 cash distribution.
Try one first
Hint
Determine how much of the $90,000 current-year E&P loss had accrued by July 1 (ratable proration). Subtract that from beginning accumulated E&P to find E&P available for dividend treatment, then apply the ordering rules: dividend → return of capital (basis reduction) → capital gain.
Answer C. Because the current-year E&P loss accrued ratably, half of the $90,000 deficit (i.e., $45,000) is treated as having arisen by the July 1 distribution date. Subtracting $45,000 from beginning accumulated E&P ($120,000) yields $75,000 of E&P available for dividend treatment; the first $75,000 of the $150,000 distribution is therefore a dividend. The remaining $75,000 reduces the shareholder's $20,000 basis (return of capital), and the excess $55,000 is taxed as capital gain.
Why not A: This is tempting because it uses beginning accumulated E&P of $120,000 as if no portion of the Year 1 loss had accrued by the distribution date. That ignores ratable proration (half of the $90,000 loss, $45,000, had reduced E&P by July 1); if you incorrectly omit that reduction you would treat $120,000 as dividend and then apply basis reduction to the remainder.
Why not B: This result comes from netting the entire $90,000 Year 1 loss against beginning accumulated E&P (120,000 − 90,000 = 30,000) before considering the midyear distribution. That is incorrect here because the loss accrued ratably and only the portion that had arisen by July 1 (half of $90,000) reduces available E&P for the distribution.
Why not D: Although this correctly identifies $75,000 as dividendable E&P, it incorrectly skips the required distribution ordering. After the dividend portion, any excess distribution must first reduce the shareholder's stock basis (return of capital) before any remaining amount is treated as capital gain.
The timeline
- January 1, Year 1Lakeview begins with $120,000 of accumulated E&P.
Lakeview is a calendar-year C corporation. It makes only one nonliquidating cash distribution, with no other transactions affecting E&P.
- January through June, Year 1Half of the ratable annual E&P deficit accrues.
The full-year current E&P deficit is $90,000. The portion through July 1 is $90,000 × 6/12 = $45,000.
- July 1, Year 1, before paymentDetermine E&P available on the distribution date.
$120,000 beginning accumulated E&P − $45,000 accrued deficit = $75,000 available for dividend treatment.
- July 1, Year 1, paymentLakeview pays a $150,000 cash distribution.
Of the $150,000 distribution, $75,000 is a dividend and $75,000 is a nondividend distribution.
Key points
- Remember: Subtract the loss through the payment date, not the entire year's loss.
- A current-year deficit does not automatically make the entire distribution a nondividend distribution.
- The cash payment amount alone does not determine the dividend amount.
How the exam traps you
- Using the full $120,000 beginning accumulated E&P as the dividend amount. Subtract the $45,000 loss accrued through July 1, leaving $75,000.
- Subtracting the entire $90,000 annual deficit for the July 1 payment. Use half the ratable annual deficit because the payment occurs at midyear.
Question 2
Hint
Determine how much of the distribution is a dividend by netting current and accumulated E&P at the distribution date, then apply stock basis to the remainder.
Answer D. Net E&P at the distribution date equals accumulated E&P ($100,000) less the current-year deficit ($60,000) = $40,000, so $40,000 of the $80,000 distribution is a dividend. The remaining $40,000 is a nondividend distribution that first reduces Lane's $25,000 stock basis to zero, leaving $15,000 of the distribution treated as capital gain. Therefore Lane recognizes $15,000 of capital gain.
Why not A: This assumes the entire $80,000 is a dividend because of the beginning accumulated E&P, ignoring the Year 1 current-year deficit which must be netted against accumulated E&P. Only $40,000 is dividend; some of the distribution falls below dividend treatment.
Why not B: This assumes the current-year deficit eliminates dividend treatment and then subtracts Lane's $25,000 basis from the full $80,000 distribution. In fact, net E&P is still positive $40,000, which is dividend income before any basis recovery and capital-gain computation.
Why not C: This reflects treating the entire $40,000 nondividend portion as capital gain. Under the distribution ordering rules, amounts in excess of E&P first reduce stock basis ($25,000 here), and only the remaining $15,000 becomes capital gain.
Question 3
Hint
Work through the distribution in layers: first determine the dividend portion from E&P, then apply stock basis, and only then determine any capital gain.
Answer B. Because the only distribution occurred at year-end, the $20,000 current-year E&P deficit offsets accumulated E&P, leaving net E&P of $20,000 (a dividend). That $20,000 is treated as dividend, the next $25,000 of the distribution reduces Reed's stock basis, and the remaining $55,000 ($100,000 - $20,000 - $25,000) is capital gain.
Why not A: This reflects treating the entire $40,000 beginning accumulated E&P as dividend (ignoring the $20,000 current-year deficit). If the deficit is ignored, the dividend would be $40,000, leaving $60,000 to apply to basis and gain (yielding $35,000 gain after the $25,000 basis reduction).
Why not C: This comes from skipping dividend treatment entirely and treating the excess over basis as capital gain: $100,000 - $25,000 basis = $75,000. That ignores that distributions are dividends to the extent of E&P before basis reduction.
Why not D: This reflects netting E&P to $20,000 but then treating the entire remainder ($100,000 - $20,000 = $80,000) as capital gain without first reducing shareholder basis by $25,000. In a nonliquidating distribution, basis is reduced before any capital gain is recognized.
Question 4
Hint
First compute the earnings and profits available on the actual distribution date, not at year-end. Then apply the distribution ordering rules: dividend first, basis recovery second, gain last.
Answer A. Available E&P on July 1 equals beginning accumulated E&P ($80,000) reduced by the portion of the current-year deficit accrued through July 1 (one-half of $50,000 = $25,000), yielding $55,000 of E&P that is a dividend. The $90,000 distribution exceeds that dividend amount by $35,000; $20,000 of that excess is a return of capital that reduces the shareholder's stock basis to zero, and the remaining $15,000 is capital gain.
Why not B: Tempting if a student uses beginning accumulated E&P without reducing it for the prorated portion of the current-year deficit through the midyear distribution date. Because the deficit arose ratably, half of it ($25,000) had already reduced available E&P by July 1, so dividend treatment cannot be $80,000.
Why not C: This reflects the error of netting the entire $50,000 current-year deficit against accumulated E&P before allocating a midyear distribution. For a July 1 distribution with a ratable deficit, only the portion accrued through that date should reduce available E&P, so the dividend portion is $55,000, not $30,000.
Why not D: Although this choice correctly computes the dividend portion, it treats more of the excess distribution as return of capital than the shareholder's basis allows. The shareholder's basis was only $20,000, so any distribution in excess of that and the dividend portion produces capital gain.
Question 5
Hint
First determine how much accumulated E&P is available on the distribution date, taking into account the current-year deficit only through that date. Then apply stock basis to any excess distribution.
Answer D. Because the current-year E&P deficit accrued ratably, half of the $36,000 deficit (i.e., $18,000) applies through the July 1 distribution date and reduces beginning accumulated E&P of $90,000 to $72,000 available for dividend treatment. The $80,000 distribution is a dividend to the extent of that $72,000; the $8,000 excess is a nondividend distribution that reduces the shareholder's $25,000 stock basis, so no capital gain is recognized.
Why not A: Although this gets the dividend amount right, it treats the excess as immediate capital gain rather than a return of capital. Nondividend distributions first reduce the shareholder's stock basis, and only after basis is reduced to zero would any excess be treated as gain.
Why not B: This answer mistakenly applies the entire $36,000 current-year deficit against accumulated E&P (yielding $54,000) instead of only the portion accrued through the July 1 distribution date. Using the full-year deficit would be appropriate only if the distribution occurred at year-end (or if the deficit did not accrue ratably).
Why not C: This choice ignores the effect of the current-year deficit through the distribution date and treats the full distribution as a dividend, overlooking the ratable reduction of accumulated E&P that leaves only $72,000 available for dividend treatment.
Question 6
Hint
Determine the amount of E&P available on the distribution date first. Then apply the shareholder distribution ordering rules: dividend, return of capital to basis, then capital gain.
Answer C. Compute E&P available on the distribution date: beginning accumulated E&P of $60,000 is reduced by the $30,000 current-year E&P deficit, leaving $30,000 of E&P. The first $30,000 of the $90,000 distribution is thus a dividend. The next $20,000 reduces the shareholder's stock basis to zero, and the remaining $40,000 is treated as capital gain.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates may focus on the beginning accumulated E&P and ignore current-year results. It is wrong here because the distribution occurs on December 31, so the full $30,000 current-year E&P deficit must be reflected, reducing E&P available for dividend treatment to $30,000.
Why not B: This reflects a partial-rule error: while amounts beyond E&P are not dividends, the shareholder recovers basis before recognizing gain. After the $30,000 dividend portion, the next $20,000 is a return of capital that reduces the shareholder's $20,000 basis to zero, not immediate capital gain.
Why not D: This overemphasizes the current-year deficit and ignores accumulated E&P. Even with a negative current-year E&P, accumulated E&P remains and, after reducing it by the current-year deficit, $30,000 of E&P is available to support dividend treatment.
Common questions
How do you prorate a current E&P deficit for a July 1 distribution?
For the ratable loss in this example, use half the annual deficit. Half of $90,000 is $45,000, which reduces beginning accumulated E&P.
Why not subtract the full-year E&P deficit from accumulated E&P?
The July 1 distribution uses the deficit accrued through that date. Subtracting the full $90,000 would incorrectly include losses arising after the payment.
Can a corporation pay a dividend when current E&P is negative?
Yes. Lakeview still has $75,000 of positive accumulated E&P after the accrued loss, so $75,000 of its cash distribution is a dividend.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on C Corporations (taxation and dividends and capital gains), worked step by step.
Schedule M-1 & Taxable Income | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on C Corporations (taxation and dividends and capital gains)
- C Corporation Distributions: Dividend, Basis, or Capital Gain
- Allocate Current E&P Across Multiple Distributions
- Beginning E&P Deficit: Allocating Current E&P to Dividends
- DRD Taxable Income Limit and NOL Exception
- CAMT Calculation: 15% of AFSI and Total Tax
- Section 351 Cash Boot: How Much Gain Is Recognized?
All C Corporations (taxation and dividends and capital gains) practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.