REG · Federal Taxation of Entities · 6 practice questions
Beginning E&P Deficit: Allocating Current E&P to Dividends
A beginning accumulated E&P deficit does not offset positive current E&P when determining dividends. Below: a worked example showing how to allocate current E&P proportionally between cash distributions.
Try one first
Hint
Determine how the corporation's positive current-year E&P is allocated among all Year 1 distributions before applying the return-of-capital and basis rules; do not net the opening deficit against current-year E&P first.
Answer B. Current-year E&P of $120,000 is allocated across the total Year 1 distributions ($150,000), so the June 30 distribution's dividend portion is $90,000 × (120,000/150,000) = $72,000. The remaining $18,000 of that $90,000 payment is a nontaxable return of capital that reduces Lane's stock basis from $20,000 to $2,000 (20,000 − 18,000 = 2,000). No capital gain arises. (A beginning accumulated E&P deficit does not reduce the amount of current-year E&P allocable to distributions.)
Why not A: Tempting because it reflects netting the $40,000 beginning E&P deficit against current-year E&P before allocation; that understates the current-year E&P available for distributions. When current-year E&P is positive it is allocated to the year's distributions without first being reduced by a prior accumulated deficit, so the dividend portion is $72,000, not $48,000.
Why not C: This treats the entire June payment as a dividend, but with multiple distributions the current-year E&P is apportioned across the year's distributions; only 80% of the June 30 payment is dividend here.
Why not D: This reflects an incorrect midyear apportionment or netting approach that both understates the dividend portion and overstates the capital-gain portion; the correct allocation yields a $72,000 dividend and an $18,000 return of capital (no gain).
Worked example
Birch Corp., a calendar-year C corporation, begins Year 1 with a $140,000 accumulated E&P deficit. Its full-year current E&P, determined without reduction for distributions, is $100,000. Birch makes nonliquidating cash distributions to its sole individual shareholder of $80,000 in May and $120,000 in November. There are no other distributions. How much of November's distribution is dividend income?
| 1 | Total annual distributions$80,000 + $120,000 | $200,000 |
| 2 | Dividend percentage$100,000 ÷ $200,000 | 50% |
| 3 | November dividend income$120,000 × 50% | $60,000 |
November’s $120,000 distribution includes $60,000 of dividend income: $120,000 × ($100,000 ÷ $200,000). The beginning $140,000 accumulated E&P deficit does not reduce that dividend amount.
Check: November represents 60% of annual distributions, so it receives 60% of the $100,000 current E&P, or $60,000.
Key points
- Use full-year current E&P, determined without reduction for distributions.
- Include every distribution for the year in the allocation denominator.
- Apply the same dividend percentage to each distribution, regardless of payment date.
How the exam traps you
- Subtracting the $140,000 beginning deficit from current E&P and reporting no dividend. Keep the beginning deficit separate. Allocate the full $100,000 of positive current E&P.
- Giving the first distribution priority, leaving only $20,000 of current E&P for November. Allocate proportionally, not chronologically. November receives $60,000 of current E&P.
Question 2
Hint
First compute the corporation's recognized gain and how it affects Year 1 current E&P; then determine how much of the $90,000 distribution can be a dividend given E&P and the year-end timing.
Answer D. Under IRC §311(b) a corporation recognizes gain on a nonliquidating distribution of appreciated property equal to FMV less adjusted basis ($90,000 − $40,000 = $50,000). That recognized gain is included in Year 1 current E&P, increasing current E&P from $20,000 to $70,000. Because the distribution was made on the last day of the tax year, the full positive current-year E&P is applied to characterize the distribution; $70,000 is dividend income to the shareholder under IRC §316, and the remaining $20,000 is a return of capital reducing stock basis.
Why not A: This is tempting if one assumes only the pre-distribution current E&P ($20,000) is available for the distribution; however, the gain recognized under §311(b) increases current-year E&P and is included for a year-end distribution, so the dividend amount is larger than $20,000.
Why not B: This reflects the common error of netting the post-gain current-year E&P ($70,000) against the beginning-of-year accumulated E&P deficit ($60,000) to arrive at only $10,000 of distributable E&P. For a distribution on the last day of the year, the recognized gain is part of current-year E&P and the positive current-year E&P is applied to characterize the distribution before treating the accumulated deficit as offset in other computations.
Why not C: This assumes the entire fair market value distributed is dividend income, but dividend treatment is limited to E&P. After recognizing the gain, Cedar's current-year E&P is $70,000, so only $70,000 can be treated as a dividend; the remainder is a return of capital.
Question 3
Hint
Determine the corporate-level consequence first (Sec. 311(b)), recompute current E&P at the distribution date, then apply the Sec. 301 ordering rules to classify the shareholder-level receipt.
Answer D. Under Sec. 311(b), a corporation generally recognizes gain on a nonliquidating distribution of appreciated property equal to FMV less adjusted basis: 90,000 − 20,000 = 70,000. Adding that $70,000 to pre-distribution current E&P (−10,000) yields current E&P of +60,000 at the distribution date. Under the Sec. 301 ordering rules, the $100,000 distribution is dividend to the extent of the $60,000 positive current E&P, then reduces Reed's $15,000 stock basis, and the remaining $25,000 is treated as capital gain.
Why not A: Tempting because a student might (incorrectly) conclude the corporation does not recognize gain on a nonliquidating property distribution and therefore the entire $100,000 is applied to the shareholder's basis and then capital gain. This is incorrect because Sec. 311(b) generally requires recognition of the built‑in gain by the corporation on the distributed property.
Why not B: Tempting because it reflects netting the $60,000 positive current E&P against the $25,000 accumulated E&P deficit to arrive at $35,000 of dividend. That netting is not correct for determining the dividend portion when current E&P is positive at the distribution date; the positive current E&P is applied first and is not reduced by a prior accumulated deficit under the Sec. 301 ordering rules.
Why not C: Tempting because one might assume that recognizing the corporate gain makes the whole $100,000 distribution a dividend. However, dividend treatment is limited to available E&P at the distribution date ($60,000 here); the excess reduces basis and then results in shareholder capital gain.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on two steps: how positive current E&P is allocated when there are multiple distributions during the year, and what happens to any nondividend portion after considering the shareholder's remaining stock basis.
Answer B. Current E&P of $120,000 is allocated ratably to the year's distributions because current E&P is positive, so the December 31 distribution's dividend portion is (110/160) × $120,000 = $82,500. The nondividend portion of the December distribution is $27,500; after the June distribution Dana's basis was reduced to $17,500 (initial $30,000 less the $12,500 nondividend portion of the June distribution), so $17,500 is a return of capital and the remaining $10,000 is a taxable capital gain.
Why not A: This treats current E&P as being used up in chronological order (giving the June distribution full current E&P first), which is incorrect; when current E&P is positive and total distributions exceed it, current E&P is allocated ratably among the distributions.
Why not C: This effectively nets the $20,000 accumulated E&P deficit against current E&P and then applies distributions in sequence; that netting or chronological approach is not the correct rule when current E&P is positive and must be allocated ratably.
Why not D: This correctly computes the dividend portion but omits the basis-recovery step: the nondividend portion first reduces Dana's remaining stock basis ($17,500) and only the excess over basis ($10,000) is treated as capital gain.
Question 5
Hint
Use the ordering rules for a nonliquidating cash distribution: earnings and profits first, then basis recovery, then gain. Be careful not to automatically offset positive current E&P with a beginning accumulated E&P deficit.
Answer A. Nonliquidating corporate distributions are taxed in this order: dividend to the extent of earnings and profits, return of capital (nontaxable) up to the shareholder's stock basis, and then capital gain on any excess. Bluebird had $12,000 of current-year E&P available for the Dec. 31 distribution even though beginning accumulated E&P was a $20,000 deficit; therefore $12,000 is dividend. The remaining $18,000 reduces Lee's $10,000 basis to zero ($10,000 return of capital) and the final $8,000 is capital gain.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates often net current-year E&P against a prior accumulated E&P deficit. However, current-year E&P is allocated to distributions during the year, so the positive $12,000 current E&P produces dividend treatment even though accumulated E&P began the year negative.
Why not C: Overstates the dividend portion. A distribution is a dividend only to the extent of E&P available for that distribution; Bluebird had only $12,000 of current-year E&P to support dividend treatment, not the full $30,000.
Why not D: Fails to apply the basis-recovery rule. Distributions in excess of E&P first reduce the shareholder's stock basis (a nontaxable return of capital) before any capital gain is recognized; here $10,000 of the excess is return of capital and only $8,000 is gain.
Question 6
Hint
Apply the sequence for classifying nonliquidating distributions: current-year E&P allocation to distributions during the year, then accumulated E&P, then return of capital and gain.
Answer A. For nonliquidating distributions, current-year E&P is allocated to distributions made during that year before considering accumulated E&P or stock basis. Falcon's current E&P of $70,000 exceeds the total distributions of $60,000, so the entire amount is treated as dividend income to the shareholder despite the beginning accumulated E&P deficit.
Why not B: Tempting because many candidates assume a beginning accumulated deficit must be eliminated before current-year E&P can fund dividends. Wrong because current-year E&P is applied to distributions made during the year and is not first reduced by a beginning accumulated deficit for that allocation; here $70,000 of current E&P covers the $60,000 distributed.
Why not C: Tempting because a negative accumulated E&P can suggest no capacity for dividends. Wrong because positive current-year E&P can produce dividend treatment even when accumulated E&P is negative; the beginning deficit does not automatically prevent dividends if current-year E&P is sufficient.
Why not D: Tempting because basis matters for nondividend distributions. Wrong because the ordering is dividend (to the extent of E&P) first, then return of capital to the extent of basis, and then gain; since current-year E&P covers the distributions, basis is not reduced and no capital gain arises.
Common questions
Can a C corporation pay a dividend with a beginning accumulated E&P deficit?
Yes. Positive current E&P supports dividend treatment despite the beginning deficit. Here, the $140,000 beginning deficit does not offset the $100,000 of current E&P.
How do you allocate current E&P when distributions exceed it?
Divide current E&P by total annual distributions, then multiply each distribution by that percentage. Here, $100,000 divided by $200,000 makes each distribution 50% dividend.
Does the first distribution use up current E&P before later distributions?
No. Current E&P is allocated proportionally among the year's distributions. The earlier $80,000 payment does not receive priority over November's $120,000 payment.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on C Corporations (taxation and dividends and capital gains), worked step by step.
Schedule M-1 & Taxable Income | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on C Corporations (taxation and dividends and capital gains)
- C Corporation Distributions: Dividend, Basis, or Capital Gain
- Allocate Current E&P Across Multiple Distributions
- Current E&P Deficit: Proration to the Distribution Date
- DRD Taxable Income Limit and NOL Exception
- CAMT Calculation: 15% of AFSI and Total Tax
- Section 351 Cash Boot: How Much Gain Is Recognized?
All C Corporations (taxation and dividends and capital gains) practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.