REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 6 practice questions
AICPA Independence: Nonattest Services for Attest Clients
For an attest client, a CPA may propose entries, but management must decide and approve them with qualified client oversight. Below, judge responses to a controller vacancy and a CEO's offer to sign an acknowledgment.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the tasks that are management decisions from those that are assistance, then ask whether the client has designated a suitably knowledgeable person to oversee the work and accept responsibility.
Answer C. Selecting and approving journal entries are management functions the auditor may not assume. Under the AICPA Code, certain nonattest services are allowed only if management accepts responsibility and designates a suitably knowledgeable person to oversee the service; because Arbor has no such designee, Lane must decline as described.
Why not A: Tempting because private companies can obtain some nonattest assistance and the CEO offered to sign an acknowledgment; however, a CEO signature alone does not replace the Code requirement that management designate a suitably knowledgeable person to oversee and accept responsibility, and the auditor still may not assume management duties.
Why not B: Tempting because documentation and safeguards reduce threats, but this fails because safeguards cannot cure the auditor performing management functions; selecting and approving entries remains a management responsibility that the auditor may not take on.
Why not D: Tempting because preparing a draft trial balance may seem like permissible assistance, but approving entries for posting is a management act; without a designated, suitably knowledgeable client representative to oversee and accept responsibility, approving postings would be impermissible.
What should you do?
The situation
Lane & Co. audits Arbor, a private company. Arbor's controller resigns before year-end. Arbor asks Lane to propose adjusting entries, decide which to record, and approve them for posting. The CEO will sign an acknowledgment but lacks the skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee the work. No other qualified designee is available. What should Lane do to remain independent?
Decline as requested; propose entries only with qualified client oversight and client approval.
Best Lane may propose entries, but cannot select or approve them. Arbor also needs qualified oversight, not merely a signature.
Accept because the CEO's signed acknowledgment assigns responsibility to Arbor.
Wrong A signature does not replace qualified oversight or allow Lane to make management's entry decisions.
Propose entries and approve posting, but let the CEO choose which entries to record.
Wrong Approving entries is a management responsibility. Having the CEO select entries does not cure the missing qualified oversight.
Accept if a separate partner reviews Lane's entry selections and approvals.
Wrong Partner review cannot make management decisions permissible or replace Arbor's qualified designee.
Decline because proposing adjusting entries for an audit client always impairs independence.
Wrong Proposals can be permitted. Here, the problems are Lane making management decisions and Arbor lacking qualified oversight.
Key points
- Remember: Proposing an entry is help; deciding whether to record it is management.
- A controller vacancy does not transfer management's decision-making authority to the audit firm.
- The designee needs enough skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee the service, not to perform it.
How the exam traps you
- Treating the CEO's acknowledgment as qualified oversight. Require a designee with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience who can oversee and evaluate the work.
- Using partner review to justify selecting or approving entries. Leave entry selection and approval with the client; safeguards do not permit the firm to assume management responsibilities.
- Rejecting all proposed-entry assistance as an independence violation. Proposing entries can be permitted when qualified client oversight and management responsibility remain in place.
Question 2
Hint
Recall the member-in-business sequence: use internal escalation channels to the next appropriate level before considering resignation or external disclosure.
Answer D. A member in business should not knowingly be associated with financial information the member believes is misleading. When company policy provides an internal escalation route, the member should raise the issue to the next appropriate level (such as the audit committee) and avoid issuing statements she believes are misleading while it is unresolved. Resignation or external disclosure are subsequent or exceptional steps if escalation fails or if there is a legal or regulatory obligation to disclose.
Why not A: Tempting because it focuses on the small quantitative size, but incorrect: qualitative factors (for example, the covenant effect) can make an omission material, and the Code expects internal escalation rather than acquiescing to instructions that would associate the member with potentially misleading information.
Why not B: Resignation may be appropriate if a serious issue remains unresolved, but it is premature here because company policy provides an escalation route beyond the CFO that Rena should use before resigning.
Why not C: Attractive because it appears to protect external users, but incorrect as the immediate next step: a member in business should follow employer escalation channels first and generally should not make direct external disclosures unless internal channels fail or a legal/regulatory duty requires it.
Question 3
Hint
Decide which tasks are bookkeeping/nonattest services that can be overseen by the client and which require the auditor to execute or authorize client transactions.
Answer D. The AICPA permits certain nonattest services (like posting entries or reconciliations) when the client designates a qualified overseer and accepts responsibility. However, the firm must not assume management responsibilities for an attest client; executing client transactions (such as releasing vendor payments) is a management function and therefore impairs independence.
Why not A: Tempting because client oversight and acceptance of responsibility can make bookkeeping-type services permissible. Wrong because that safeguard does not permit the firm to execute transactions (authorize or release payments), which is a management function that impairs independence.
Why not B: Tempting because limiting the firm's discretion and requiring client authorization can reduce threats. Wrong because actually executing disbursements, even on instruction, involves carrying out client transactions and thus constitutes a management responsibility that impairs independence.
Why not C: Tempting because bookkeeping can create self-review threats. Wrong because the Code allows bookkeeping and reconciliations if the client provides appropriate oversight and accepts responsibility; the stem supplies those safeguards, so the real independence problem is the payment-release task.
Question 4
Hint
Separate services that may be allowed with safeguards from decisions that management itself must make.
Answer B. Under the AICPA Code, certain nonattest services for a nonissuer audit client can be performed without impairing independence, but the client must assume management responsibilities. Drafting financial statements and proposing entries may be allowed, yet the auditor cannot decide which entries the client should record. Once Harbor is asked to make that decision, it is effectively performing a management function, so independence is impaired.
Why not A: This is tempting because the first two services listed can often be performed for a nonissuer attest client without impairing independence. But the option ignores the additional fact that Harbor is also being asked to decide which entries should be recorded. Signed letters do not cure the problem if the firm is actually taking over management's decision-making role.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to candidates who overgeneralize bookkeeping restrictions or confuse AICPA rules with stricter settings outside this fact pattern. For a privately held nonissuer, preparing financial statements does not automatically impair independence if the required safeguards are met and management retains responsibility. The impairment here comes from deciding for the client, not from financial statement drafting by itself.
Why not D: This is tempting because the AICPA Code does require the client to designate someone to oversee nonattest services. However, designation alone is not enough; management must be able to evaluate the service and make the key decisions. If the controller relies on Harbor's judgment about which entries to post, Harbor is still assuming a management responsibility.
Question 5
Hint
Distinguish tasks that are preparatory or processing under management direction from the one that requires management to make a recognition decision.
Answer B. Under the AICPA Code, nonattest services may be provided to an attest client if management designates an appropriate individual to oversee the services, evaluates their adequacy and results, and accepts responsibility, and the firm does not assume management functions. Preparing schedules using client-selected policies, posting entries after management approves classifications and entries, and drafting financial statements from the client's trial balance are preparatory or processing tasks and are permissible when management retains responsibility. Deciding which obligations to accrue is a management judgment about recognition and would constitute assuming a management function, impairing independence.
Why not A: This is tempting because bookkeeping services often raise independence concerns, but the AICPA Code does not categorically prohibit all such services; the key is whether management retains responsibility and the firm refrains from making management decisions.
Why not C: This lure rests on the required safeguard of a designated, competent individual, but it is incorrect because that safeguard does not permit the firm to perform services that amount to management functions (for example, deciding which liabilities to record).
Why not D: This misclassifies the tasks: posting entries and drafting financial statements can be permissible preparatory/processing tasks when management approves and accepts responsibility; by contrast, selecting which obligations to accrue involves management judgment about recognition.
Question 6
Hint
Ask whether the CPA would be making or authorizing management decisions (assumption of management authority) versus performing tasks under management's supervision.
Answer B. Independence is impaired when a CPA assumes management responsibilities. Authorizing and recording journal entries on the client's behalf constitutes making management decisions and exercising authority reserved for management, which impairs independence under the AICPA Code. A client's written agreement to oversee services does not permit the CPA to perform management functions.
Why not A: This option tempts because preparing adjustments involves accounting judgment, but it is permitted when management reviews, approves, and accepts responsibility. Here the controller's review and approval keep the decision and responsibility with management, so Lane is assisting rather than assuming management responsibility.
Why not C: Reconciliations require professional care and may appear decision‑oriented, yet they are permitted when management oversees, evaluates, and accepts responsibility for the results. The controller's review indicates that Lane is performing an assistive function rather than replacing management.
Why not D: Posting entries can seem like taking over accounting, but bookkeeping and posting are allowed if the client prepares and approves source documents and management retains responsibility. Because Rock's personnel prepared and approved the documents, Lane is executing tasks under management direction, not making management decisions.
Common questions
Can an auditor propose adjusting journal entries for an audit client?
Yes, if the client provides qualified oversight, evaluates the work, and accepts responsibility. Management must decide which entries to record and approve them.
Does a signed management acknowledgment preserve independence for nonattest services?
Not by itself. A signature cannot replace qualified client oversight or allow the CPA to select or approve entries for management.
Must the client's designee know how to prepare the journal entries?
The designee need not be able to perform the service. The designee must have suitable skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee it and evaluate its adequacy and results.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, worked step by step.
Independence & Covered Members | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on AICPA Code of Professional Conduct
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.