REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 7 practice questions
AICPA Commissions: Compilation Rules
A lender-use compilation does not bar a vendor commission if the report discloses lack of independence; separate written commission disclosure is still required. Below, sort changes to one payroll-vendor recommendation as permitted or prohibited.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the two clients by engagement type, then ask whether disclosure merely accompanies a permitted commission or whether the Code flatly prohibits the commission.
Answer D. The AICPA Code prohibits accepting a commission for a client for whom the member performs a review engagement, so Parker may not accept the commission for Blue Co. For compilation engagements expected to be used by third parties, commissions are prohibited only when the compilation report does not disclose lack of independence. Because Green Co.'s compilation report will disclose Parker's lack of independence and Parker would disclose any commission to the client, accepting the commission for Green Co. is permitted.
Why not A: This reverses the applicable rules. A commission is prohibited for the review client (Blue Co.) regardless of disclosure; Green Co.'s compilation permits a commission because the compilation report will disclose lack of independence.
Why not B: This choice overlooks the flat prohibition in the Code on accepting commissions for clients for whom the member performs review engagements. Disclosure does not permit commissions for a review client, so Blue Co. remains prohibited even if Parker disclosed the commission.
Why not C: This overgeneralizes the rule. While commissions are prohibited for review clients and for certain compilation clients when third-party use is expected and lack of independence is not disclosed, here Green Co.'s compilation report will disclose lack of independence, so a commission for Green is permitted if disclosed.
Sort it
Both disclosure requirements are met, and no firm audit, review, or examination of Pine's prospective financial information blocks the commission.
Either disclosure requirement fails, or the firm also audits or reviews Pine's statements or examines Pine's prospective financial information.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Lane's CPA firm compiles Pine Co.'s statements for a lender. The report discloses lack of independence. A payroll vendor offers Lane a commission if Pine buys its service. Lane discloses the commission to Pine in writing before recommending it. The firm provides Pine no other services. No stricter rules or other ethical issues apply. May Lane accept the commission? | PermittedThe report discloses lack of independence, Pine receives timely written commission disclosure, and no prohibited firm engagement exists. |
| Same facts, except the compilation report omits the lack-of-independence disclosure. May Lane accept the commission? | ProhibitedFor lender-use statements, the report must disclose lack of independence; commission disclosure alone is insufficient. |
| Same facts, except Lane gives Pine written commission disclosure when making the recommendation, not beforehand. May Lane accept the commission? | PermittedDisclosure at the recommendation is timely; moving it from beforehand to that moment does not change eligibility. |
| Same facts, except another partner at Lane's firm also performs a review of Pine's financial statements. May Lane accept the commission? | ProhibitedThe firm's review bars the commission even though another partner performs it. |
| Same facts, except Lane discloses the commission to Pine only orally. May Lane accept the commission? | ProhibitedOral disclosure does not satisfy the written commission disclosure requirement. |
| Same facts, except lack of independence is disclosed only in a separate letter, not the compilation report. May Lane accept the commission? | ProhibitedA separate letter does not replace the required lack-of-independence disclosure in the compilation report. |
| Same facts, except Lane's firm also audits Pine's annual financial statements. May Lane accept the commission? | ProhibitedThe firm's audit bars the commission despite both disclosures. |
| Same facts, except Pine receives the written commission disclosure but gives no written consent. May Lane accept the commission? | PermittedMissing written consent does not change eligibility; the commission rule requires disclosure, not separate written consent. |
| Same facts, except Lane first discloses the commission to Pine in writing after making the recommendation. May Lane accept the commission? | ProhibitedWritten commission disclosure must occur before or when the recommendation is made. |
| Same facts, except Lane sends the written commission disclosure only to Pine's lender, not to Pine. May Lane accept the commission? | ProhibitedThe required commission disclosure must reach Pine, the client; disclosure only to the lender is insufficient. |
| Same facts, except Lane's firm also performs an examination of Pine's prospective financial information. May Lane accept the commission? | ProhibitedThe firm's examination of prospective financial information bars the commission despite the compilation report's disclosure. |
Key points
- Remember: For a lender-use compilation, the report's lack-of-independence disclosure removes the compilation-based commission ban.
- Written commission disclosure must reach the client before or when the recommendation is made.
- The commission rule requires disclosure, not separate written client consent.
- Check services performed by the entire firm, not just the partner receiving the commission.
How the exam traps you
- Treating every compilation for bank use as a commission ban. Check whether the compilation report discloses lack of independence.
- Treating the report's independence disclosure as disclosure of the commission. Separately disclose the commission to Pine in writing before or when recommending the vendor.
- Ignoring a review performed by another partner. A review by Lane's firm bars Lane's commission for that client.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the rules for tax return preparation, tax authority representation, and commissions, and watch for any disclosure requirement.
Answer D. The AICPA Code prohibits contingent fees for preparing original tax returns, preparing amended returns that claim a refund, or preparing claims for refund. However, contingent fees are permitted for representation of a client before a taxing authority (such as an IRS examination), provided no separate attest-service prohibitions apply. Because Rivera's firm provides only tax services to X and does not perform attest services for X, option B is permitted.
Why not A: This is tempting because the firm does not perform attest services, but the AICPA Code specifically prohibits contingent fees for preparing an original tax return, so this arrangement is impermissible.
Why not B: Preparing an amended return that claims a refund is treated as tax-return preparation; the AICPA Code prohibits contingent fees for such amended returns. The contingent-fee exception applies to representation before a taxing authority, not to preparing the amended return itself.
Why not C: Commissions may be permissible when no prohibited attest relationship exists, but the member must disclose receipt of the commission to the client. Failing to disclose the commission makes this arrangement impermissible.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on which fact in the stem triggers the AICPA commission prohibition: disclosure, service subject, timing of payment, or the type/timing of the engagement.
Answer A. The AICPA Code prohibits a member in public practice from receiving a commission for recommending or referring products or services to a client for whom the member or the member's firm performs an attest engagement, including a review. Because Allen made the recommendation while performing the review, receiving a commission is prohibited. Preparing the client's tax return, disclosure, or a later payment does not cure that prohibition.
Why not B: This distractor tempts by focusing on the service's subject matter. It fails because the rule turns on whether the member is performing an attest engagement for the client, not on whether the third-party product or service relates directly to the financial statement subject matter.
Why not C: This is tempting because disclosure/consent can address conflicts in non-attest contexts. It is wrong because the Code's commission prohibition applies when the member is performing an attest engagement for the client; disclosure or client consent does not make the commission permissible in that situation.
Why not D: This is tempting because timing can matter, if both recommendation and payment occur after an attest engagement ends, commissions may be permissible. It is wrong here because Allen made the recommendation while the review was in progress; a later payment does not cure the prohibition triggered by recommending during the attest engagement.
Question 4
Hint
Separate the issue into two steps: first decide whether the compilation engagement makes commissions impermissible, then ask what disclosure the Code requires if the commission is allowed.
Answer C. The AICPA prohibits commissions for certain attest situations and for compilations expected to be used by third parties when the compilation report does not disclose lack of independence. Here, Lee's compilation report expressly disclosed lack of independence, so the commission is not automatically barred. However, when a member receives or expects to receive a commission for a referral, the member must disclose that fact in writing to the client.
Why not A: This is too broad. The commission prohibition for compilations applies when third‑party use is expected and the compilation report does not disclose lack of independence. Because lack of independence was disclosed here, the blanket prohibition in this choice is incorrect.
Why not B: Who pays the commission is not the controlling factor. The Code requires that a member disclose in writing to the client when the member receives or expects to receive a commission for a referral, even if the payment comes from a third‑party vendor.
Why not D: This overstates the rule. Third‑party use is relevant, but the prohibition applies only when the compilation report does not disclose lack of independence. Because Lee's report expressly disclosed lack of independence, commissions are not automatically barred in this situation.
Question 5
Hint
Identify which specific services actually trigger the AICPA commission prohibition, then consider whether a separate disclosure rule still applies.
Answer D. The AICPA commission prohibition applies in limited circumstances for certain attest-type services (for example when a compilation is intended for third-party use and the compilation report does not disclose lack of independence). Here, Lark's compilation report expressly discloses lack of independence, so that compilation does not bar the commission. Preparing the client's original tax return does not, by itself, prohibit receiving a commission. However, permitted commissions must be disclosed to the client.
Why not A: This overgeneralizes the rule. The prohibition applies only in specific circumstances (e.g., certain attest engagements or compilations intended for third-party use when lack of independence is not disclosed). Because Lark's compilation disclosed lack of independence, the blunt prohibition in this option is incorrect.
Why not B: Preparing an original tax return does not automatically bar a CPA from receiving a commission. This distractor confuses commission rules with other tax-practice restrictions (such as some contingent-fee limitations) that are separate issues.
Why not C: This incorrectly treats the lack-of-independence disclosure as substituting for the separate client disclosure required when a commission is received. The two disclosures are distinct under the AICPA rules.
Question 6
Hint
Evaluate the commission rule separately for each client based on the service Mason performs. Disclosure matters, but first decide whether the Code permits a commission at all.
Answer B. The AICPA Code permits commissions in many nonattest situations with required disclosure. Review engagements are attest services for which acceptance of commissions is prohibited, so Beta Co. is barred. Alpha is a nonattest client (bookkeeping and tax), and the commission for Gamma is permitted because the compilation report will expressly disclose lack of independence.
Why not A: This choice overgeneralizes by excluding Gamma. A compilation client can be the subject of commissions if the CPA discloses lack of independence in the compilation report, which the stem says Mason will do.
Why not C: This distractor incorrectly assumes disclosure cures all conflicts. For a review engagement (an attest service), the Code prohibits acceptance of commissions regardless of disclosure, so Beta Co.'s commission is not allowed.
Why not D: This is an overbroad ethics intuition. The AICPA Code does not impose a blanket ban on commissions; it permits them in many nonattest situations (with required disclosure) and allows them for compilations when lack of independence is disclosed.
Question 7
Hint
Identify exactly which services make commissions prohibited under the AICPA Code, and do not ignore the significance of the compilation report's independence disclosure.
Answer D. Under the AICPA Code, commissions are prohibited for certain attest-type services (for example, audits, reviews, and examinations of prospective financial information) and in limited compilation circumstances. A compilation that discloses lack of independence does not trigger the commission prohibition. Because Jordan provides bookkeeping and tax return preparation (nonattest services) and a compilation that expressly discloses nonindependence, the commission is permitted if the commission is disclosed to the client.
Why not A: Candidates may recall that compilations appear on prohibition lists, but the prohibition applies in specific circumstances; a compilation that expressly discloses lack of independence does not by itself bar accepting commissions.
Why not B: This is tempting because some ethics rules require formal client acknowledgement in other contexts, but the controlling AICPA commission rule focuses on disclosure of the commission rather than requiring prior written client consent in this scenario.
Why not C: This distractor confuses commissions with other fee restrictions. Preparing tax returns alone does not automatically prohibit accepting commissions under the AICPA commission rule.
Common questions
Can a CPA accept a commission for a compilation client?
For a lender-use compilation, yes, if the report discloses lack of independence and the CPA timely discloses the commission in writing. A firm audit, review, or examination of the client's prospective financial information still bars it.
Does disclosing lack of independence also disclose the commission?
No. Lane must separately disclose the commission to Pine in writing before or when making the recommendation.
Does the client have to give written consent to a permitted commission?
No separate written consent is required under the commission rule in these facts. Written commission disclosure is still required.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, worked step by step.
Independence & Covered Members | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on AICPA Code of Professional Conduct
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.