PracticeREGFree practice exam

REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 9 practice questions

AICPA Confidentiality: When Is Client Consent Not Required?

Confidential client information requires specific client consent unless a recognized AICPA Code exception applies. Sort requests for Orion Co.'s confidential audit records, assuming no client consent and no other law changes the result.

The ruleWithout specific client consent, disclosure is permitted for authorized peer review, AICPA ethics or state board investigations, validly issued and enforceable legal process, or necessary litigation defense. Limit disclosure to what the exception permits or requires.

Try one first

A member in public practice has not obtained any specific client consent to disclose confidential client information. During one week the member receives four authentic requests relating to the same client: 1. A written request from the client's successor CPA for prior-year depreciation schedules to assist in transitioning the engagement. 2. An oral request from an IRS revenue agent for copies of the member's workpapers; no summons, subpoena, court order, or taxpayer authorization has been issued. 3. A document request from an authorized peer reviewer in connection with the firm's peer review. 4. A formal written inquiry from the investigative or disciplinary division of the state board of accountancy regarding a complaint against the member. Assume no more restrictive state law applies and the client objects to any disclosure not permitted by the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct. Under the AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule, which of these disclosures may the member make without the client's specific consent?
Hint

Separate the Code's narrow exceptions (peer review and state board investigations) from requests that typically require client consent or formal compulsory process.

Sort it

Permitted without consent

The proposed disclosure fits a recognized exception and stays within its scope.

Not permitted without consent

The proposed disclosure lacks an exception or exceeds the exception's scope.

ItemGoes to
Orion's bank requests audit schedules, citing a loan covenant but providing no client authorization.Not permitted without consentThe covenant binds Orion and its bank. It does not itself authorize the CPA to disclose confidential records.
An authorized AICPA peer reviewer requests selected Orion workpapers for the firm's peer review.Permitted without consentAuthorized peer review is a recognized exception. Provide only records needed for that review.
Orion's prospective successor CPA requests prior-year schedules to establish opening balances.Not permitted without consentA successor CPA's professional need does not replace Orion's specific consent.
A validly issued, enforceable subpoena requires selected Orion workpapers, despite Orion's objection.Permitted without consentThe enforceable subpoena permits disclosure of the specified records. Orion's objection does not eliminate that exception.
An IRS agent informally emails for Orion workpapers without a summons, subpoena, or other legal authority.Not permitted without consentThe agent's government position does not turn an informal request into enforceable legal process.
The AICPA Professional Ethics Division requests relevant Orion documents during an investigation of the CPA.Permitted without consentResponding to an authorized AICPA ethics investigation is a recognized exception.
A subpoena requests selected Orion records, but the court has stayed production.Not permitted without consentThe subpoena is not currently enforceable. Formal issuance alone does not authorize disclosure now.
The state board of accountancy's disciplinary division requests Orion records relevant to its investigation of the CPA.Permitted without consentA state board investigation is a recognized exception. Limit the response to relevant records.
The CPA gives retained legal counsel necessary Orion records to defend against Orion's written threat of litigation.Permitted without consentNecessary disclosure to counsel for defense against threatened litigation is permitted. A lawsuit need not already be filed.
A prospective Orion investor signs a nondisclosure agreement and requests confidential audit schedules.Not permitted without consentThe investor's promise of confidentiality does not substitute for Orion's specific consent.
A valid, enforceable court order requires production of specified Orion engagement records.Permitted without consentCompliance with enforceable legal process permits the required disclosure, limited to the specified records.
Orion's bank requests confidential workpapers that belong to the CPA firm rather than Orion.Not permitted without consentFirm ownership changes nothing. Confidential client information remains protected regardless of who owns the workpapers.
The CPA proposes sending Orion's entire file under an enforceable subpoena requiring only selected schedules.Not permitted without consentThe subpoena permits the required schedules, not the entire file. Unrelated confidential records remain protected.

Key points

  • Remember: A requester's need is not permission; match the disclosure to a named exception.
  • Test each proposed disclosure separately, even when requesters want identical documents.
  • A subpoena must be enforceable now; formal issuance alone is not enough.
  • An exception permits a limited disclosure, not unrestricted access to the client file.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating a loan covenant or successor CPA's professional need as client consent. Obtain specific client consent unless a separate exception authorizes disclosure.
  • Treating every IRS request or issued subpoena as legal authority. An informal IRS email is insufficient; a stayed subpoena is not currently enforceable.
  • Sending the entire file because the CPA owns it or a subpoena covers selected records. Ownership does not authorize disclosure; an enforceable subpoena permits production only within its scope.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Stone & Co., a CPA firm, performed monthly bookkeeping for Quartz Corp. and began preparing Quartz's Year 1 federal and state income tax returns, which are still on extension. Quartz terminates Stone before the returns are filed and still owes substantial fees. Quartz asks Stone for: (1) the original bank statements and vendor invoices Quartz previously gave Stone, (2) the year‑end trial balance and adjusting journal entries Stone prepared that are not otherwise reflected in Quartz's books and that the successor accountant needs to file the returns, and (3) Stone's internal research memorandum analyzing uncertain state nexus positions. Assume no state law, regulation, or engagement‑term provision requires release of internal firm work product or otherwise changes the default AICPA Code result. Which response best complies with the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct?
Hint

First classify each requested item (client‑provided record, member‑prepared compliance record, or internal firm work product), then apply the AICPA Code rules about returning records and withholding for unpaid fees.

Question 3

Lane, a CPA in public practice, obtained confidential client information while performing services for River Co. River has not given Lane permission to disclose that information. Assume no law requires disclosure unless stated in the facts. Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, in which situation may Lane disclose River's confidential client information without River's consent?
Hint

Focus on whether the Code provides a specific exception to confidentiality, not on whether the third party has a strong business reason for asking.

Question 4

Nelson, CPA, performs compilation and tax services for Harbor Co. Harbor has not given Nelson permission to disclose any of Harbor's confidential information. Assume each request below is genuine, properly documented, and limited to relevant records, and assume no law other than the AICPA Code changes the result. Nelson receives these requests for Harbor information: 1. Harbor's prospective lender asks for Harbor's draft financial statements and tax return to evaluate a loan application. 2. Harbor's successor CPA asks Nelson for prior-year working papers and tax return details. 3. Nelson's firm is undergoing an AICPA-authorized peer review, and the reviewer asks for selected Harbor engagement documentation. 4. A court issues a valid, enforceable subpoena requiring specified Harbor records. Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, which requests may Nelson satisfy without Harbor's specific consent?
Hint

Identify which requesters match the AICPA Code's explicit confidentiality exceptions (for example, AICPA-authorized peer review or compliance with a valid subpoena) rather than assuming a business or successor relationship alone permits disclosure.

Question 5

Allen, a CPA in public practice, audited Holt Co. in Year 2. Assume no client consent has been obtained, no state law imposes stricter confidentiality requirements, and each request is limited to the documents described. Allen receives four unrelated requests for Holt confidential client information: (1) Holt's commercial lender asks Allen to send specified audit workpapers, stating Holt's loan agreement requires Holt to cooperate with lender requests; (2) Allen is served with a validly issued, enforceable subpoena requiring production of specified Holt documents in litigation between Holt's shareholders; (3) a reviewer operating under an AICPA-approved peer review program requests access to the Holt engagement file as part of Allen's firm's peer review; and (4) an industry trade association asks Allen to describe Holt-specific inventory-control problems for a benchmarking study, promising not to publish Holt's name. Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, for which of these requests may Allen disclose the information without Holt's consent?
Hint

Match each request to the AICPA Code's explicit exceptions to the confidential client information rule (e.g., legally enforceable subpoena, authorized AICPA peer review); third-party business or research requests generally require client consent.

Question 6

While preparing a business client's tax return, CPA Lee learns that the client plans to close several locations. Before any public announcement, Lee tells another client about the planned closures to discuss possible market opportunities. The business client did not consent to the disclosure, and assume no subpoena, peer review, ethics investigation, or other specific exception applies. Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, what is the primary issue?
Hint

Focus on the rule that most directly addresses sharing client information learned during professional services.

Question 7

Lopez, CPA, is in public practice and previously completed an audit for Cedar Co. Cedar has not authorized any disclosure of confidential client information. Assume no law or court order requires disclosure unless stated in the facts. Lopez receives the following unrelated requests regarding Cedar: 1. Cedar's prospective successor auditor asks Lopez about disagreements with management and requests selected workpaper excerpts. 2. Lopez's firm is undergoing an AICPA-authorized peer review, and the reviewer requests access to portions of the Cedar engagement file. 3. A state tax examiner telephones Lopez and asks for Cedar's supporting schedules, but no subpoena, summons, or other enforceable legal demand has been issued. Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, what is the most appropriate response?
Hint

Start with the general confidentiality rule, then test each request separately for a recognized AICPA exception rather than treating all three requests the same.

Question 8

Parker, a CPA in public practice, completed an individual tax engagement for Diaz. Diaz later asked Parker to provide items from the engagement file. Assume no state law, court order, or written agreement imposes obligations beyond the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, the engagement is complete, all fees for that engagement have been paid, and Diaz does not otherwise have access to the depreciation schedule or the completed return. The file contains: (1) Diaz's original Forms W-2 and 1099 that Diaz gave Parker, (2) a depreciation schedule Parker prepared that is not otherwise available in Diaz's records, (3) the completed Form 1040 and supporting schedules Parker prepared for filing, and (4) Parker's internal tax research memo and review notes. Which of the following is the best conclusion under the AICPA Code?
Hint

Classify each requested item before deciding: client-provided records, member-prepared records, work product, or working papers.

Question 9

Grant, a CPA in public practice, performed consulting services for Blue Co. and has confidential client financial information in the engagement files. Blue has not authorized any disclosure. Assume no law or regulation requires disclosure other than the court order described below. Later, all of the following occur: (1) Blue's bank asks Grant to confirm figures from Blue's internal forecasts for a loan renewal, (2) a state court issues a validly issued and enforceable subpoena requiring specified engagement documents, (3) another CPA firm considering whether to accept Blue as a client asks Grant about Blue's business practices, and (4) Grant's firm is undergoing an AICPA-authorized peer review and the reviewer requests access to the Blue engagement files. Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Sort the requests into two groups: specific Code-based exceptions to confidentiality and requests that may seem reasonable but still require client permission.

Drill all 94 AICPA Code of Professional Conduct questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can a CPA disclose client information for peer review without consent?

Yes. An authorized AICPA peer review permits disclosure of relevant engagement records without specific client consent. That exception does not authorize disclosure to unrelated requesters.

Can a CPA share workpapers with a successor CPA or bank without client consent?

A routine request from either generally requires specific client consent. A loan covenant, professional need, or the firm's ownership of workpapers does not replace that consent.

Can a CPA comply with a subpoena if the client refuses consent?

Yes, if the subpoena is validly issued and enforceable and no other legal restriction prevents compliance. Produce only the required records; a subpoena with production stayed by the court does not currently qualify.

Watch it solved

A full CPA REG task-based simulation on AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, worked step by step.

Independence & Covered Members | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice REG like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on AICPA Code of Professional Conduct

All AICPA Code of Professional Conduct practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.