REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 9 practice questions
AICPA Confidentiality: When Is Client Consent Not Required?
Confidential client information requires specific client consent unless a recognized AICPA Code exception applies. Sort requests for Orion Co.'s confidential audit records, assuming no client consent and no other law changes the result.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the Code's narrow exceptions (peer review and state board investigations) from requests that typically require client consent or formal compulsory process.
Answer B. The AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule prohibits disclosure without client consent except for limited, specified exceptions. Those exceptions include disclosure to authorized peer reviewers in connection with peer reviews and to state boards (including their investigative/disciplinary divisions) in connection with investigations or disciplinary proceedings. A successor CPA's request ordinarily requires the client's authorization, and an IRS revenue agent's informal oral request, absent a summons, subpoena, court order, or the taxpayer's authorization, does not fall within the Code's exceptions.
Why not A: This is tempting because successor accountants commonly request information for transitions, but under the Code a successor CPA generally needs the client's consent unless another exception applies; Item 1 therefore cannot be disclosed without client authorization in the facts given.
Why not C: This choice overgeneralizes government authority access: an informal oral request from an IRS agent without compulsory process (summons/subpoena/court order) or taxpayer authorization is not an exception under the Code, so Item 2 is not disclosable on these facts.
Why not D: This assumes a broad permission for professional or regulatory requests; however, the Code's exceptions are specific, neither a successor CPA request nor an informal IRS oral request alone authorizes disclosure without client consent.
Sort it
The proposed disclosure fits a recognized exception and stays within its scope.
The proposed disclosure lacks an exception or exceeds the exception's scope.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Orion's bank requests audit schedules, citing a loan covenant but providing no client authorization. | Not permitted without consentThe covenant binds Orion and its bank. It does not itself authorize the CPA to disclose confidential records. |
| An authorized AICPA peer reviewer requests selected Orion workpapers for the firm's peer review. | Permitted without consentAuthorized peer review is a recognized exception. Provide only records needed for that review. |
| Orion's prospective successor CPA requests prior-year schedules to establish opening balances. | Not permitted without consentA successor CPA's professional need does not replace Orion's specific consent. |
| A validly issued, enforceable subpoena requires selected Orion workpapers, despite Orion's objection. | Permitted without consentThe enforceable subpoena permits disclosure of the specified records. Orion's objection does not eliminate that exception. |
| An IRS agent informally emails for Orion workpapers without a summons, subpoena, or other legal authority. | Not permitted without consentThe agent's government position does not turn an informal request into enforceable legal process. |
| The AICPA Professional Ethics Division requests relevant Orion documents during an investigation of the CPA. | Permitted without consentResponding to an authorized AICPA ethics investigation is a recognized exception. |
| A subpoena requests selected Orion records, but the court has stayed production. | Not permitted without consentThe subpoena is not currently enforceable. Formal issuance alone does not authorize disclosure now. |
| The state board of accountancy's disciplinary division requests Orion records relevant to its investigation of the CPA. | Permitted without consentA state board investigation is a recognized exception. Limit the response to relevant records. |
| The CPA gives retained legal counsel necessary Orion records to defend against Orion's written threat of litigation. | Permitted without consentNecessary disclosure to counsel for defense against threatened litigation is permitted. A lawsuit need not already be filed. |
| A prospective Orion investor signs a nondisclosure agreement and requests confidential audit schedules. | Not permitted without consentThe investor's promise of confidentiality does not substitute for Orion's specific consent. |
| A valid, enforceable court order requires production of specified Orion engagement records. | Permitted without consentCompliance with enforceable legal process permits the required disclosure, limited to the specified records. |
| Orion's bank requests confidential workpapers that belong to the CPA firm rather than Orion. | Not permitted without consentFirm ownership changes nothing. Confidential client information remains protected regardless of who owns the workpapers. |
| The CPA proposes sending Orion's entire file under an enforceable subpoena requiring only selected schedules. | Not permitted without consentThe subpoena permits the required schedules, not the entire file. Unrelated confidential records remain protected. |
Key points
- Remember: A requester's need is not permission; match the disclosure to a named exception.
- Test each proposed disclosure separately, even when requesters want identical documents.
- A subpoena must be enforceable now; formal issuance alone is not enough.
- An exception permits a limited disclosure, not unrestricted access to the client file.
How the exam traps you
- Treating a loan covenant or successor CPA's professional need as client consent. Obtain specific client consent unless a separate exception authorizes disclosure.
- Treating every IRS request or issued subpoena as legal authority. An informal IRS email is insufficient; a stayed subpoena is not currently enforceable.
- Sending the entire file because the CPA owns it or a subpoena covers selected records. Ownership does not authorize disclosure; an enforceable subpoena permits production only within its scope.
Question 2
Hint
First classify each requested item (client‑provided record, member‑prepared compliance record, or internal firm work product), then apply the AICPA Code rules about returning records and withholding for unpaid fees.
Answer A. Under the AICPA Code, records the client originally provided (item 1) must be returned regardless of unpaid fees. Member‑prepared records that the client cannot otherwise obtain and that are necessary for legal or tax filing obligations (item 2) should be furnished even if fees are unpaid. Internal firm work product (item 3), such as an internal research memorandum, generally may be withheld unless law, regulation, or a prior agreement requires release.
Why not B: This choice is tempting because unpaid fees often justify withholding; however, member‑prepared records needed for the client to meet filing obligations are an exception and should be provided despite overdue fees.
Why not C: Attractive if one focuses solely on authorship, but creating a document does not permit withholding when the document is necessary for the client to comply with legal or tax filing obligations.
Why not D: Appeals to a broad fairness intuition, but the Code distinguishes internal work product from client records and generally allows withholding of internal memoranda absent a legal, regulatory, or contractual requirement to release them.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on whether the Code provides a specific exception to confidentiality, not on whether the third party has a strong business reason for asking.
Answer B. Under the AICPA Code, a member should not disclose confidential client information without the client's specific consent. A recognized exception permits disclosure when required to comply with a validly issued and enforceable subpoena or summons. Requests based solely on a third party's business need or an NDA do not satisfy the Code's exception.
Why not A: This is tempting because the lender's need seems legitimate, but the Code does not allow disclosure for a third party's business purposes without client consent or a specific exception such as a subpoena.
Why not C: An investor's confidentiality agreement does not substitute for the client's consent; the Code requires the client's permission or a recognized exception before disclosure.
Why not D: Even if disclosure might help preserve a vendor relationship, the supplier is an outside party and economic importance alone does not override the confidentiality rule without client consent or a specific Code exception.
Question 4
Hint
Identify which requesters match the AICPA Code's explicit confidentiality exceptions (for example, AICPA-authorized peer review or compliance with a valid subpoena) rather than assuming a business or successor relationship alone permits disclosure.
Answer C. The AICPA confidentiality rule prohibits disclosure of client information without the client's specific consent. The Code expressly permits disclosure for an AICPA-authorized peer review and to comply with a valid, enforceable subpoena. Requests from a prospective lender or a successor CPA are third-party disclosures that are not authorized by those exceptions, so only requests 3 and 4 may be satisfied.
Why not A: A lender often requests financials and tax returns, which makes this distractor attractive. But a prospective lender is an outside party, and disclosure to a lender requires the client's specific consent, it's not covered by the peer-review or subpoena exceptions.
Why not B: This is tempting because predecessor-successor communications and transfer of working papers commonly occur in practice. However, the AICPA confidentiality rule does not permit releasing a client's confidential information to a successor CPA without the client's consent; including request 2 is therefore not allowed.
Why not D: This appeals to those who recall the subpoena exception but underestimate other Code exceptions. While a subpoena permits disclosure, the AICPA Code also authorizes disclosure for an AICPA-authorized peer review, so omitting request 3 makes this choice incorrect.
Question 5
Hint
Match each request to the AICPA Code's explicit exceptions to the confidential client information rule (e.g., legally enforceable subpoena, authorized AICPA peer review); third-party business or research requests generally require client consent.
Answer C. The AICPA Code's confidential client information rule permits disclosure without client consent only in limited circumstances, including compliance with a validly issued, enforceable subpoena and authorized access for an AICPA-approved peer review of the firm's engagements. A lender's contractual agreement with the client is an arrangement between the lender and the client and does not itself authorize the CPA to disclose the client's confidential workpapers. A trade association's request, even with a promise not to name the client, is not a Code exception absent client consent or a separate legal compulsion.
Why not A: This is tempting because a subpoena (request 2) is a recognized exception; however, a lender's contractual right (request 1) exists between the lender and the client and does not authorize the CPA to disclose confidential client information without client consent or legal compulsion.
Why not B: Attractive if the candidate recognizes the subpoena and peer review exceptions but overextends them: a benchmarking request by a trade association (request 4), even with a confidentiality promise, is not an AICPA Code exception and requires client consent.
Why not D: This option correctly includes the subpoena and peer review exceptions but incorrectly adds the lender request. The lender's contractual arrangement does not relieve the CPA of the Code's confidentiality requirement absent client authorization or a legal requirement.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on the rule that most directly addresses sharing client information learned during professional services.
Answer C. Lee disclosed confidential information obtained during a client engagement without the client's consent. Under the AICPA Code, members generally must not disclose confidential client information except with specific client consent or when a recognized exception applies; the stem rules those exceptions out. Therefore the primary issue is a breach of the Confidential Client Information Rule.
Why not A: While the behavior could be viewed as unprofessional, 'acts discreditable' is a broader category. The Code specifically addresses unauthorized disclosure of client information under the confidentiality provisions, making that the more precise issue.
Why not B: This is tempting because Lee used one client's information in a way that could benefit another client, which might seem to implicate integrity or objectivity. However, the facts most directly describe an unauthorized disclosure of client information, which is governed by the confidentiality rule rather than the integrity and objectivity rule.
Why not D: The General Standards Rule focuses on competence, due professional care, planning/supervision, and obtaining sufficient relevant data, not on disclosure of confidential information. The central problem here is the unauthorized sharing of client information.
Question 7
Hint
Start with the general confidentiality rule, then test each request separately for a recognized AICPA exception rather than treating all three requests the same.
Answer A. Under the AICPA confidentiality rule, a member generally may not disclose confidential client information without the client's specific consent. Recognized exceptions include disclosures required by law (e.g., a valid subpoena or summons) and disclosures in connection with professional practice reviews (such as an AICPA-authorized peer review). A successor auditor's request does not by itself waive confidentiality, and an informal government request without an enforceable demand is not a sufficient exception.
Why not B: Tempting because predecessor-successor communications are common in practice, but the AICPA confidentiality rule requires client consent before disclosing confidential workpapers or details to a successor auditor; peer review is an independent exception but successor requests alone are not.
Why not C: Tempting because a tax examiner sounds official, but the facts state there is no subpoena, summons, or other enforceable legal demand; absent such a legal requirement, disclosure is not permitted under the confidentiality rule. Item 2 remains the permitted exception.
Why not D: This reflects the general confidentiality rule and is attractive, but it is incorrect because the Code includes specific exceptions (for example, disclosures to an authorized peer reviewer) that allow item 2 without client consent.
Question 8
Hint
Classify each requested item before deciding: client-provided records, member-prepared records, work product, or working papers.
Answer C. Under the AICPA Code, client‑provided records must be returned. Member‑prepared records that form part of the client's records and are not otherwise available (the depreciation schedule here) must be provided once the engagement is complete and fees are paid. The completed tax return and supporting schedules are client work product and must be provided. Internal research memos and review notes are working papers and generally remain the CPA's property absent law, regulation, or agreement to the contrary.
Why not A: This is tempting because client‑provided documents must be returned, but it is incomplete: member‑prepared records that are part of the client's records and not otherwise available (e.g., the depreciation schedule) and the completed return must also be provided under the stated facts.
Why not B: This distractor correctly treats the completed return as deliverable but errs by treating the depreciation schedule as retainable. Because the depreciation schedule was prepared for the client and is not otherwise available to the client, it is part of the client's records and should be provided.
Why not D: Although payment and completion support providing client records and member‑prepared client work product, internal tax research memos and review notes are working papers that generally remain the CPA's property absent a law, regulation, or agreement requiring disclosure.
Question 9
Hint
Sort the requests into two groups: specific Code-based exceptions to confidentiality and requests that may seem reasonable but still require client permission.
Answer A. Under the AICPA confidential client information rule, a member generally may not disclose client information without the client's specific consent. Two recognized exceptions present here are compliance with a validly issued and enforceable subpoena and disclosure in connection with an AICPA-authorized peer review of the member's practice. A bank's request and a prospective successor firm's inquiry do not, by themselves, override the confidentiality rule.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates often remember the subpoena exception but overlook that peer review is also a permitted disclosure under the AICPA Code. It is wrong because the Code allows disclosure of client information in connection with an authorized peer review even without client consent.
Why not C: This choice is attractive if a candidate assumes a lender's business need is enough to permit disclosure. It is wrong because there is no general AICPA exception for a bank's legitimate business purpose, while a validly issued and enforceable subpoena is a recognized exception.
Why not D: This distractor plays on the common misconception that another CPA firm may receive client information simply because it is bound by professional standards. It is wrong because a prospective successor firm's inquiry still requires client consent unless some separate exception applies, which the stem does not provide.
Common questions
Can a CPA disclose client information for peer review without consent?
Yes. An authorized AICPA peer review permits disclosure of relevant engagement records without specific client consent. That exception does not authorize disclosure to unrelated requesters.
Can a CPA share workpapers with a successor CPA or bank without client consent?
A routine request from either generally requires specific client consent. A loan covenant, professional need, or the firm's ownership of workpapers does not replace that consent.
Can a CPA comply with a subpoena if the client refuses consent?
Yes, if the subpoena is validly issued and enforceable and no other legal restriction prevents compliance. Produce only the required records; a subpoena with production stayed by the court does not currently qualify.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, worked step by step.
Independence & Covered Members | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on AICPA Code of Professional Conduct
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.