REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 6 practice questions
AICPA Independence: Covered Members and Financial Interests
A covered member's direct financial interest in an attest client impairs independence, even when immaterial. Sort Pine's Harbor holdings by covered-member status, interest type, and timing.
Try one first
Hint
First decide whether Pine is a covered member under the AICPA independence rules, then consider whether materiality matters for that type of financial interest.
Answer B. Under the AICPA Code, a partner in the office in which the lead attest engagement partner primarily practices is a covered member for that attest client. A covered member may not hold a direct financial interest in the attest client, even if the amount is small or immaterial. Because Pine is a covered member and personally owns Harbor stock, independence is impaired.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates often recall the engagement-team rule first. However, the covered member definition is broader than just those assigned to the engagement; a partner in the same office as the lead engagement partner can be a covered member and thus is subject to the direct-ownership prohibition.
Why not C: Tempting because materiality matters in many contexts. For a covered member, though, any direct financial interest in an attest client, regardless of size, impairs independence. Immateriality does not cure a prohibited direct ownership interest.
Why not D: Tempting because ability to influence is one route to being a covered member. But Pine already meets a separate criterion for covered-member status (partner in the same office as the lead engagement partner), so the direct ownership itself impairs independence even though Pine does not participate in the audit.
Sort it
A covered member or the member's immediate family holds a direct or material indirect Harbor interest during a required independence period, without an exception.
Pine is not covered, or the covered member's Harbor interest is indirect and immaterial.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Base case: Moss audits Harbor's Year 2 financial statements under the AICPA Code. Pine, a tax partner in the office where the lead engagement partner primarily practices, has no Harbor services, audit role, or influence. Pine personally owns $100 of Harbor stock throughout Year 2 and the audit engagement. The holding is immaterial to Pine. Assume no exceptions apply. | Independence impairedPine is covered because of same-office partner status. Any direct Harbor interest is prohibited, even an immaterial $100 holding. |
| Same facts, except Pine's $100 Harbor interest is indirect through a diversified mutual fund whose investment decisions Pine cannot control. | No impairment from this interestPine remains covered, but the Harbor interest is indirect and immaterial. Materiality matters for indirect interests. |
| Same facts, except Pine's spouse, rather than Pine, personally owns the Harbor shares. | Independence impairedMoving ownership to a spouse does not help; a covered member's immediate-family direct interest also impairs independence. |
| Same facts, except Pine is a staff accountant rather than a tax partner. The office and lack of Harbor services, audit role, or influence remain unchanged. | No impairment from this interestSharing the lead engagement partner's office does not, by itself, make a staff accountant a covered member. |
| Same facts, except in the staff-accountant case, Pine is assigned to Harbor's audit team. | Independence impairedMembership on the attest engagement team makes Pine covered, so the $100 direct holding is prohibited. |
| Same facts, except Pine holds the $100 of Harbor stock for only two days during the audit engagement, then sells it. | Independence impairedA quick sale does not erase the impairment that arose when Pine acquired the prohibited direct interest. |
| Same facts, except Pine is a tax manager rather than a tax partner. Pine remains in the same office and provides no Harbor services. | No impairment from this interestSame-office status alone covers partners, not managers. Pine has no audit role, influence, or nonattest-service hours that otherwise make Pine covered. |
| Same facts, except the Harbor interest in the immaterial-indirect-interest case is material to Pine. | Independence impairedA covered member's material indirect financial interest impairs independence. Changing materiality flips the answer for this indirect interest. |
| Same facts, except in the 12-hour tax-manager case below, Pine is a senior associate rather than a manager. The service hours remain unchanged. | No impairment from this interestThe more-than-10-hour nonattest-services category covers partners and managers, not senior associates. Pine has no other covered-member role. |
| Same facts, except Pine discloses the $100 direct holding to Moss and Harbor. | Independence impairedDisclosure does not cure a covered member's prohibited direct financial interest. |
| Same facts, except in the tax-manager case, Pine provides 12 Harbor tax-service hours during Year 2: eight before audit work begins and four while the audit is underway. | Independence impairedAll 12 fiscal-year hours count. More than 10 makes Pine covered; counting only four hours during audit work would incorrectly avoid impairment. |
| Same facts, except in the tax-manager case with no Harbor services, Pine is in a position to influence Harbor's audit. | Independence impairedThe ability to influence the attest engagement makes Pine covered despite providing no Harbor tax services. |
Key points
- Remember: First test covered-member status; then any direct interest impairs independence, even $100.
- A partner in the lead engagement partner's primary office is covered without serving the client.
- A spouse's direct interest counts too; personal ownership by the covered member is not required.
- For partners and managers, count nonattest-service hours across the client's fiscal year, not just during audit work.
How the exam traps you
- Treating Pine's lack of audit work as proof Pine is not covered. Test same-office partner status first; no client service is required.
- Allowing the $100 direct holding because it is immaterial or disclosed. Neither size nor disclosure permits a covered member's direct interest.
- Counting only the four tax-service hours performed while the audit is underway. Count all 12 fiscal-year hours; the manager exceeds the more-than-10-hour threshold.
Question 2
Hint
For an AICPA review, think about whether independence applies only when the engagement starts, only to the financial statement period, or to both.
Answer C. Under the AICPA Code, independence for an attest engagement such as a review must be maintained both for the period covered by the financial statements and for the professional engagement period. Therefore Lake must be independent for the year ended December 31, 20X5, and throughout the review engagement. The fact that permitted nonattest services were provided under a compliant arrangement does not eliminate the independence requirement for the review.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates often focus on the period after acceptance, but this choice is incomplete: AICPA independence for a review also covers the financial statement period itself.
Why not B: This is plausible, independence must cover the financial statement period, but it is incomplete because independence must also be maintained during the professional engagement period.
Why not D: This distractor confuses permitted nonattest services with an independence exemption. A review is an attest service, so independence is required even if certain nonattest services were provided under a compliant arrangement.
Question 3
Hint
Focus first on who is a covered member under the AICPA independence rules, not just on who owns the stock.
Answer D. Under the AICPA Code, covered members include partners in the office in which the lead engagement partner primarily practices. A covered member may not hold any direct financial interest in an attest client, so this partner's ownership of Fox stock impairs independence even though the partner is not assigned to the engagement.
Why not A: A fully retired former partner with no continuing role and only fixed retirement payments is generally not treated as a covered member; therefore that former partner's ownership does not impair independence based on the facts given.
Why not B: Direct ownership by a covered member would impair independence, but the staff accountant described is in a different office and has no role on the engagement and therefore is not a covered member on these facts; their ownership alone does not impair independence.
Why not C: An outside specialist hired for an unrelated client is not a covered member with respect to Fox; absent facts showing the specialist is part of Hill's Fox engagement or otherwise a covered person, that ownership does not impair Hill's independence.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on whether a review engagement requires independence and whose financial interests are treated as relevant to a covered member.
Answer B. A review is an attest engagement and therefore requires independence. Under the AICPA Code, a covered member is not independent if the member's immediate family (including a spouse) has a direct financial interest in the attest client. Because Pat's spouse holds a direct financial interest in Orion, Pat's independence is impaired.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates often associate financial-interest rules with materiality, but a covered member's immediate family having a direct financial interest in an attest client impairs independence regardless of materiality.
Why not C: This distractor overlooks attribution: the AICPA independence rules treat certain immediate-family interests as the covered member's, so Pat's lack of personal ownership does not avoid the impairment.
Why not D: Although conflicts of interest are relevant under the Code, the more specific and controlling issue here is an independence impairment caused by a covered member's immediate family holding a direct financial interest in the attest client.
Question 5
Hint
First decide who counts as a covered member or immediate family, then separate direct financial interests from indirect ones.
Answer C. This is the only fact pattern that does not impair independence. A covered member may hold an immaterial indirect financial interest in an attest client through a diversified mutual fund when the member cannot control the fund's investment decisions. The other choices involve immediate family employment in a key position or direct financial interests by covered members or immediate family, which impair independence.
Why not A: Tempting if focusing only on the CPA, but a spouse is immediate family; immediate family employment in a key position (controller) at the attest client impairs independence.
Why not B: A partner who provides significant nonattest services to an attest client is treated as a covered member; a direct financial interest by a covered member impairs independence even if the holding is small.
Why not D: A dependent child is immediate family. Direct financial interests of immediate family are attributed to the covered member and impair independence regardless of the dollar amount.
Question 6
Hint
First determine whether Omar is a covered member under the AICPA Code. Then ask whether materiality matters for the type of financial interest described.
Answer B. Under the AICPA independence rules, a partner in the office in which the lead attest engagement partner primarily practices is a covered member, even if that partner is not on the engagement team. A covered member's direct financial interest in an attest client impairs independence. Materiality does not rescue a direct financial interest held by a covered member.
Why not A: This is tempting because many candidates focus only on the engagement team or those who can influence the engagement. However, the AICPA Code defines covered members more broadly, and it includes a partner in the office where the lead attest engagement partner primarily practices. Because Omar falls into that category, his direct ownership impairs independence.
Why not C: This distractor is attractive because materiality does matter for some indirect financial interest questions. But for a covered member's direct financial interest in an attest client, materiality is not the test. Any direct financial interest by a covered member impairs independence.
Why not D: This choice picks up a real covered-member category: certain partners or managers who provide substantial nonattest services to a client can become covered members. But that is not the only way someone becomes a covered member. Omar is already a covered member because he is a partner in the same office as the lead attest engagement partner, so the nonattest-service hours threshold is irrelevant here.
Common questions
Who is a covered member under AICPA independence rules?
Covered members include engagement-team members, people able to influence the engagement, and partners in the office where the lead partner primarily practices. Partners and managers providing more than 10 nonattest-service hours during the client's fiscal year are also covered.
Does an immaterial financial interest impair AICPA independence?
An immaterial direct interest held by a covered member or the member's spouse impairs independence. An immaterial indirect interest through the diversified mutual fund does not.
When must AICPA independence be maintained?
Absent an applicable exception, independence must cover both the financial statement period and the professional engagement period. Pine's quick sale during the engagement does not erase the impairment.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, worked step by step.
Independence & Covered Members | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on AICPA Code of Professional Conduct
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.