BAR · Business Analysis · 8 practice questions
Classify Risk Responses
Classify a risk response by whether it reduces exposure, shifts financial consequences, accepts exposure, or stops the activity. Below, sort Pine's possible responses to a supplier shutdown by what each action changes.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on whether the company is keeping the activity, reducing the exposure, shifting the risk, or eliminating the activity entirely.
Answer C. Pine is taking steps that lower the likelihood and/or impact of a supplier disruption (qualifying a second supplier and holding buffer inventory). Those are internal actions to reduce exposure while continuing the activity, so the response is risk reduction (mitigation) rather than transfer, acceptance, or avoidance.
Why not A: Acceptance means knowingly retaining the risk without taking meaningful steps to reduce its likelihood or impact. Because Pine actively changed its operations to reduce exposure, the response is not pure acceptance.
Why not B: Transfer involves shifting the financial consequences or responsibility to another party (for example, insurance or contractual risk transfer). Pine retained responsibility and used operational measures instead of shifting the risk externally.
Why not D: Avoidance requires eliminating the risky activity (for example, discontinuing the product line or stopping reliance on the supplier). Pine continued the product and modified sourcing, so it did not avoid the risk.
Sort it
Does the action lower the likelihood or operational impact of disruption while production continues?
Does the action shift covered financial consequences to another party?
Does Pine retain the exposure without further action to reduce or transfer it?
Does Pine stop the activity that creates the exposure?
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Pine makes one product using a single supplier's critical part. To address shutdown risk, it qualifies a backup supplier. | MitigationThe backup supplier can keep production running if the primary supplier shuts down. |
| Pine buys business interruption insurance covering part of its losses from a supplier shutdown. | Transfer/shareThe insurer bears covered financial losses. The policy does not prevent the supplier shutdown. |
| Pine continues production unchanged and deliberately retains the supplier-shutdown exposure without taking action. | AcceptancePine knowingly keeps the exposure without reducing it or shifting financial consequences. |
| Pine holds backup inventory of the critical part to use during a supplier shutdown. | MitigationBackup inventory cushions the production impact. It does not stop the supplier's factory from shutting down. |
| Pine permanently discontinues the product that requires the supplier's critical part. | AvoidanceStopping the product eliminates Pine's production exposure to disruption of that part. |
| Pine buys supplier-disruption insurance with a deductible. | Transfer/shareThe insurer pays covered losses above the deductible. The deductible is exposure Pine retains. |
| Pine negotiates priority deliveries from its current supplier to reduce interruptions in critical-part deliveries. | MitigationPriority deliveries reduce supply interruptions rather than assigning Pine's financial losses to another party. |
| Pine approves a qualified second supplier and splits purchases between both vendors. | MitigationDiversifying supply lowers disruption impact. It reduces the remaining exposure rather than transferring financial consequences. |
| Pine decides the supplier-shutdown exposure is within its tolerance and proceeds without an additional response. | AcceptanceManagement deliberately tolerates the exposure instead of adding protection. |
| Pine obtains an enforceable indemnity requiring another party to reimburse specified losses from a supplier shutdown. | Transfer/shareThe indemnity assigns specified financial consequences to another party rather than preventing the shutdown. |
| Pine qualifies a backup supplier and holds critical-part inventory while continuing the product line. | MitigationBoth actions help production withstand a supplier shutdown. Neither stops the activity or transfers financial losses. |
Key points
- Remember: Ask what changes: the disruption, who pays, nothing, or the activity itself.
- Continuing production does not automatically mean acceptance; Pine may continue while mitigating or transferring exposure.
- Insurance can shift covered losses without preventing a supplier shutdown or keeping production running.
How the exam traps you
- Calling a second supplier risk sharing because two vendors are involved. A backup supplier helps production continue. That reduces disruption impact rather than transferring financial consequences.
- Calling insurance mitigation because it makes a shutdown less costly for Pine. Insurance shifts covered financial losses to an insurer. It does not prevent the supplier shutdown.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the pre-control amount, the post-control amount, and the board's acceptable limit before choosing the term.
Answer A. Residual risk is the risk that remains after management has taken actions to reduce or respond to the original exposure. Here, the company reduced the expected annual loss from $500,000 to $80,000 through control activities, so $80,000 is the remaining exposure. The $500,000 amount is the pre-control exposure, not the post-control amount.
Why not B: This is tempting because inherent risk and residual risk both describe exposure levels. However, inherent risk is the exposure before any risk response or control is applied. In this fact pattern, the inherent risk is the original $500,000 expected annual loss, not the reduced $80,000 amount.
Why not C: Risk appetite is a broader, strategic statement of how much risk an organization is willing to accept overall; it is not the measured remaining exposure from a specific risk after controls. The question asks for the classification of the $80,000 amount itself, which is a measured remaining exposure.
Why not D: This is a realistic distractor because the board set a specific maximum acceptable exposure of $100,000. That board limit is a tolerance or threshold (what is acceptable), while the $80,000 is the actual risk remaining after controls. Tolerance describes allowable limits; residual risk describes what remains.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on what encryption at rest actually prevents versus what it cannot prevent, who controls the keys and whether the processor needs plaintext for routine processing are critical.
Answer A. Encryption at rest prevents unauthorized access to stored data only when attackers or insiders cannot obtain the plaintext. If PayrollCo controls the keys and routinely decrypts data for staff use, employees (or attackers who obtain those credentials/keys) can access plaintext, defeating the planned mitigation. The other options either address post-event remedies (B), external access controls (C), or describe a stronger arrangement that preserves encryption effectiveness (D).
Why not B: Tempting because contracts impose consequences and encourage response, but contractual remedies do not prevent technical exposure of plaintext by vendor staff and therefore do not materially weaken the need for effective key control.
Why not C: These controls reduce the risk of external or credential-based attacks, but they do not stop PayrollCo employees from legitimately decrypting and accessing plaintext, so they do not negate the specific limitation of encryption at rest.
Why not D: This option strengthens rather than weakens the mitigation: if Alpha controls the keys and PayrollCo only processes tokenized data without decrypting PII, encryption at rest remains effective against internal disclosure.
Question 4
Hint
Decide whether the actions are preventive (controls), financial (transfer), eliminative (avoidance), or passive (acceptance).
Answer A. Management implemented preventive controls (email filtering, MFA, training, incident response), which reduce likelihood and impact, this is risk mitigation. They also purchased insurance, but the $150,000 per-incident deductible means the company retains residual exposure, so the overall approach is mitigation combined with partial transfer rather than pure transfer, avoidance, or acceptance.
Why not B: This distractor tempts because the company did buy cyber-insurance, which does transfer financial risk. It fails because the $150,000 deductible leaves the company with material residual exposure and the firm also applied preventive controls, so the approach is not a pure transfer.
Why not C: This option tempts because exiting risky markets is the textbook avoidance strategy. It fails here because the company continued operating in those regions and instead implemented controls and insurance rather than eliminating the exposure.
Why not D: This choice tempts because accepting risk means choosing to bear it. It fails because the company implemented multiple controls and purchased insurance, so it did not simply accept the risk with no action.
Question 5
Hint
Identify whether the response mainly accepts, reduces, transfers, or eliminates risk. Backup arrangements usually lower residual risk, but they rarely make risk disappear.
Answer B. Contracting a second qualified provider and regularly testing failover are mitigation actions that lower both the chance of a prolonged outage and its potential severity. Residual risk remains because failover may fail or both providers could be affected, but overall the company's outage risk is reduced.
Why not A: This is tempting because some outage risk remains, but acceptance means taking no meaningful action. Here management actively implemented redundancy and tested failover, which are mitigation steps that reduce risk rather than leaving it unchanged.
Why not C: Redundancy reduces risk but does not eliminate it completely. Failovers can fail, both providers could be impacted by a common event, or switching may introduce delays, so the risk is reduced but not eradicated.
Why not D: Using an external provider does not transfer the business consequences of an outage away from the company. The company still bears operational and customer-impact risk even when a vendor is involved, so the risk is mitigated but not transferred.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the risk that exists before management acts from the risk that remains after management responds.
Answer A. Inherent risk is the level of risk that exists before management takes any action. Residual risk is the risk remaining after management's responses, such as controls or risk transfer. Here, the insurance and shipment controls are responses that reduce the residual risk but do not change the pre-response inherent risk.
Why not B: This is tempting because actions that reduce exposure might seem to lower all measures of risk. However, inherent risk is defined as the risk measured before any responses; management's actions affect residual risk, not the pre-response inherent risk.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the fact that the threat still exists, but it ignores that residual risk explicitly describes the risk after responses. Controls and insurance change the remaining exposure even if the underlying hazard is not fully removed.
Why not D: This is a common shortcut mistake: insurance transfers financial consequences but does not eliminate all remaining risk (for example, deductibles, claim disputes, operational disruption, or reputational harm). Therefore residual risk is reduced but not eliminated.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on what management did with the underlying activity: did it keep the activity, stop it, shift it to another party, or keep it but add controls?
Answer B. Management implemented controls (cameras, tighter access, increased cycle counts) to reduce the likelihood and/or impact of theft while continuing the operation. That is risk reduction, commonly called mitigation. The stem rules out transfer (no insurance or outsourcing) and avoidance (the activity continues).
Why not A: Tempting because the company still has some residual exposure, but acceptance implies choosing to tolerate the risk without taking meaningful steps to reduce it. Here management clearly added controls to lower the risk.
Why not C: Plausible if one focuses on preventing theft, but avoidance means eliminating the activity that creates the risk (e.g., closing the distribution center). Management kept the operation and instead added controls.
Why not D: Some may associate any external control with transfer, but transfer shifts financial consequences to another party (insurance, outsourcing, hedging). The stem explicitly says no insurance or outsourcing was used.
Question 8
Hint
Ask whether the action lowers the chance of the bad event or mainly shifts part of the financial loss to someone else.
Answer C. Buying insurance shifts part of the financial consequence of a breach to another party (the insurer). That is a classic transfer or sharing of the financial impact, the company still faces the underlying likelihood of a breach but has shifted some of the potential loss to the insurer.
Why not A: Tempting because the retailer continues operating and remains exposed, but acceptance means deliberately retaining the risk without taking action to shift or mitigate it. Purchasing insurance is an active step that transfers part of the loss, so it is not pure acceptance.
Why not B: Avoidance would require eliminating the activity that creates the risk (for example, shutting down the online store). Here the retailer continues the activity and instead buys insurance to handle potential losses, so it has not avoided the risk.
Why not D: Reducing risk means lowering the likelihood of a breach or limiting its severity through controls or process changes. The fact pattern says the retailer did not change security procedures, so buying insurance changes the financial outcome rather than reducing the event's likelihood.
Common questions
What are the four risk responses on the CPA exam?
Mitigation reduces likelihood or impact. Transfer shifts financial consequences, acceptance retains exposure without further action, and avoidance stops the activity creating the exposure.
Is adding a second supplier mitigation or risk sharing?
It is mitigation when the second supplier helps keep production running. Using two suppliers does not itself transfer financial consequences.
Does continuing a risky activity mean risk acceptance?
No. Pine can continue production while adding backup inventory or buying insurance. Acceptance means continuing without further action to reduce or transfer the exposure.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Risk management
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.