BAR · Business Analysis · 6 practice questions
Residual Risk Score: Likelihood × Impact and Risk Appetite
Calculate residual risk using likelihood and impact after existing controls, then compare the product with management's stated cutoff. Below: a worked calculation showing when to accept and monitor the remaining risk.
Try one first
Hint
Do not look only at the largest loss or the highest probability. Use the exact prioritization method stated in the question.
Answer D. Expected annual loss = probability × estimated loss. Supplier disruption expected loss = 0.10 × $900,000 = $90,000, which is higher than billing error ($72,000), inventory shrinkage ($75,000), and product liability ($70,000). Because management ranks solely by expected annual loss, supplier disruption should be prioritized first.
Why not A: This choice is plausible because it is moderate on both probability and loss, and some candidates may make an arithmetic error. Its expected loss is 0.25 × $300,000 = $75,000, which is still below the supplier disruption expected loss of $90,000.
Why not B: This is tempting because it has the highest probability (40%); candidates often focus on frequency. However, its expected loss is 0.40 × $180,000 = $72,000, which is less than the supplier disruption expected loss of $90,000, so it is not the top priority under the stated method.
Why not C: This is tempting because it has the largest single-event loss ($1,400,000) and candidates may overweight severity. But its expected loss is only 0.05 × $1,400,000 = $70,000, which is lower than supplier disruption's $90,000 under the given ranking method.
Worked example
Cedar Manufacturing rates vendor delivery risk on a 1 to 5 scale. Inherent likelihood and impact are both 5. Existing controls reduce likelihood to 2 and impact to 4. Management requires additional action for residual scores of 10 or greater and accepts lower scores with periodic monitoring. No regulatory requirement overrides this policy.
| 1 | Calculate the inherent baseline5 × 5 = 25 | 25 |
| 2 | Calculate the residual score2 × 4 = 8 | 8 |
| 3 | Apply the action cutoff8 < 10 | Within appetite |
Cedar should accept the residual vendor delivery risk and continue periodic monitoring because its score of 8 is below 10.
Check: 10 ÷ 4 = 2.5, so a whole-number likelihood of at least 3 would trigger action; the current likelihood is only 2.
Key points
- The 1 to 5 ratings are scores, not probabilities or dollar losses.
- An acceptable residual score does not mean the risk is eliminated.
- Acceptable scores depend on management's stated policy, not a universal cutoff.
How the exam traps you
- Using the inherent score of 25 to require more action. Existing controls already reduce the exposure. Compare the residual score of 8 with the cutoff.
- Multiplying residual likelihood 2 by inherent impact 5 to get 10. Use both post-control ratings: 2 × 4 = 8.
Question 2
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Routine sales-tax filing errors (60% probability) | $20,000 estimated loss |
| Shutdown of Pine's only supplier of a key component (15% probability) | $800,000 estimated loss |
| Short-term raw material price increases (70% probability) | $30,000 estimated loss |
| Employee travel-card misuse (40% probability) | $5,000 estimated loss |
Hint
Do not choose the highest likelihood automatically. Apply the prioritization method stated in the stem to each risk.
Answer C. The supplier shutdown has the highest expected annual financial exposure: 15% × $800,000 = $120,000. The other risks have lower expected values: sales-tax filing errors = $12,000, raw material price increases = $21,000, and travel-card misuse = $2,000. Because management is prioritizing only on this basis, the supplier concentration risk is the primary issue.
Why not A: This choice is tempting because the likelihood is high (60%), but expected exposure = 60% × $20,000 = $12,000, which is much lower than the supplier shutdown's $120,000. The question requires using likelihood × impact, not probability alone.
Why not B: Although this risk has the highest likelihood (70%), its expected exposure = 70% × $30,000 = $21,000, still well below $120,000 for the supplier shutdown. Candidates who focus only on frequency may be misled.
Why not D: Fraud-related items can seem urgent, but the expected exposure here is only 40% × $5,000 = $2,000, the lowest of the four. Under the stated prioritization method, it is not the primary issue.
Question 3
Hint
Consider which risk remains most significant after accounting for the controls noted and the apparent strength/evidence of those controls, focus on the largest remaining exposure.
Answer C. Compare the residual (post-control) scores: payments vendor = 3 × 4 = 12; data-center outage = 2 × 3 = 6; privacy noncompliance = 2 × 3 = 6; customer concentration = 1 × 4 = 4. The payments-vendor residual is highest, and the vendor lacks evidence of adequate controls (no SOC 2 and processes full card data), so management should prioritize mitigating that residual cybersecurity risk. Prioritization should follow remaining exposure after current controls, not solely inherent scores or single-factor impact.
Why not A: This distractor is attractive because regulatory failures feel severe and the inherent score equals 12. It confuses inherent and residual risk: the partially implemented privacy program reduces the residual to 2 × 3 = 6, so the current residual exposure is lower than the payments-vendor residual of 12. Effective prioritization here follows the remaining risk after controls.
Why not B: This is tempting because an outage has very high impact and the DR site is not fully implemented, so it appears urgent. However, the assessment's residual score after existing controls is 6, which is lower than the payments-vendor residual of 12. The distractor arises from focusing on inherent impact or an incomplete control plan rather than the current residual exposure.
Why not D: This is tempting because losing a >50% customer would be catastrophic, prompting a focus on worst-case impact. However, the assessment assigns a low likelihood and a residual score of 4, making it a lower near-term priority than the vendor cyber risk. Strategic actions such as diversification remain important but do not change the current highest residual exposure.
Question 4
Hint
Compute the new residual scores for each proposed measure and compare them to the <= 8 threshold; remember that insurance transfers financial loss but does not necessarily reduce the operational impact used in the risk score.
Answer A. Implementing the advanced intrusion detection reduces Risk 1's residual score from 10 to 5, bringing it below the company's appetite (<= 8). Risk 2 is already at 8, so no further action is required. The $180,000 cost fits within the $200,000 budget and therefore this option is the most direct way to bring both critical risks within appetite this year.
Why not B: This option is tempting because it addresses supplier risk and buys financial protection for cyber losses while staying within budget. It is incorrect because the stem specifies insurance does not reduce the operational likelihood×impact score used for appetite, the cyber residual remains 10 and still exceeds the <=8 requirement.
Why not C: Doing nothing preserves cash but fails the company's stated appetite requirement: Risk 1 remains at 10, which is above the <=8 threshold, so the firm would not meet its policy by taking no action.
Why not D: This reduces the supplier risk but leaves the cyber risk above appetite. Holding the $80,000 as contingency may be prudent, but it does not address the unacceptable cyber residual of 10, so the overall appetite condition is not met.
Question 5
Hint
Compute the residual score after existing controls and compare it to the firm's unacceptable threshold before weighing the cost or disruption of further actions.
Answer D. Compute the residual score after existing controls: likelihood 2 × impact 3 = 6, which is below management's unacceptable threshold of 9. There is no regulatory requirement to eliminate the risk and management's protocol is to periodically review residual risks that are within appetite. Given the high ongoing cost of the proposed control ($400,000/year) and the fact the risk is currently within the firm's appetite, the proportionate response is to accept the residual risk and monitor it rather than immediately incur the additional cost or take disruptive action.
Why not A: Avoidance would eliminate the risk but is overly drastic and likely disruptive. Immediate termination is disproportionate when the residual risk is within appetite and can be managed through periodic monitoring.
Why not B: This is tempting because dual-sourcing would further lower the score to 2, but it is disproportionate here: the residual score is already acceptable (6 < 9), there is no regulatory mandate, and the control carries a substantial $400,000 annual cost absent other supporting factors.
Why not C: Transferring risk by purchasing insurance may appear prudent, but it would add ongoing cost and complexity. Because the residual risk is already within the firm's stated appetite and there is no requirement to transfer, insurance is not the most appropriate next step based on the facts given.
Question 6
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Data migration errors: 50% probability; estimated first-year cost | $250,000 |
| User adoption resistance (productivity losses + timeline delays): 70% probability; estimated first-year cost | $200,000 |
| Regulatory compliance shortfall (audit-trail requirements): 10% probability; estimated first-year cost | $1,000,000 |
| Third-party payment gateway downtime during cutover: 30% probability; estimated first-year cost | $400,000 |
Hint
Compute probability × estimated first‑year cost for each listed risk and compare results; remember the committee asked for prioritization by expected first‑year financial exposure, not by maximum possible loss alone.
Answer B. Compute expected first‑year exposure for each risk: Data migration = 0.50 × $250,000 = $125,000; User adoption = 0.70 × $200,000 = $140,000; Regulatory = 0.10 × $1,000,000 = $100,000; Third‑party = 0.30 × $400,000 = $120,000. The steering committee asked to prioritize by expected first‑year financial exposure, so the user adoption resistance risk (expected $140,000) is the highest and should be flagged.
Why not A: Tempting because the per‑incident cost is substantial, but its expected first‑year exposure (0.50 × $250,000 = $125,000) is lower than the user adoption risk, so it is not the highest under the committee's requested metric.
Why not C: Attractive because the maximum loss is largest and regulatory failures can be severe, but with only a 10% probability the expected first‑year exposure (0.10 × $1,000,000 = $100,000) is lower than user adoption; the committee specified expected exposure rather than maximum possible loss.
Why not D: Plausible since downtime could affect revenue, but its expected first‑year exposure (0.30 × $400,000 = $120,000) is still below the user adoption risk, so it is not the single highest-priority risk by the requested metric.
Common questions
How do you calculate a residual risk score?
Multiply likelihood after existing controls by impact after existing controls. Here, 2 × 4 = 8.
What is the difference between inherent and residual risk scores?
Inherent risk is measured before controls; residual risk remains after controls. Here, the inherent score is 25, but the residual score used for the decision is 8.
When can management accept a residual risk?
Under this policy, management accepts and monitors a score below 10. A score of exactly 10 requires additional action because the cutoff includes 10.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Risk management
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.